- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes HiBT, a learned-symbolic framework for hierarchical robot task planning. HiBT predicts hierarchical concepts from task instructions and symbolic states. It then retrieves planning templates and uses predefined rules to repair action dependencies. And the resulting plan is compiled into a Behavior Tree (BT). The BT coordinates subtask execution and condition checking, while a fixed VLA handles low-level actions.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses long-horizon robotic task planning, particularly the preservation of action dependencies and execution constraints. The proposed framework provides a structured approach to task planning and execution.
- The authors conduct relatively comprehensive ablation studies to demonstrate the effectiveness of their proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
- The comparisons with existing methods are rather limited. LLM-BT is the only external baseline, and it is evaluated only with Qwen2.5. The authors should also cite the original paper in the experimental setup, so readers can clearly identify which method is being compared.
- Some tables need further clarification. For example, I could not clearly understand the color-coding scheme in Table 4, and the authors should explain it more explicitly. Additionally, some text in Table 14 appears to have formatting issues.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors include more comparisons with existing methods?
- Have the authors considered how HiBT could adapt to incremental tasks?
7 comments
A Sincere Note of Appreciation
Dear Reviewer 1sFr,
We are grateful for your recognition of the importance of preserving action dependencies in long-horizon planning and for your constructive suggestions on comparisons and presentation. We hope the added experiments and revised explanations make the evidence easier to assess.
If we have satisfactorily addressed your concerns, may we kindly ask you to consider a more positive rating and, where justified by the clarifications, a higher confidence in your assessment? We would also be glad to answer any follow-up questions, whether about the new comparisons, incremental updates, or details of the revised paper.
Regarding external baselines, my original concern remains unresolved. A paper should not rely primarily on comparisons with its own variants. The authors have already cited several relevant studies, including LLM-BT (ICRA 2024), BTGenBot (IROS 2024), LLM-as-BT-Planner (ICRA 2025), and Integrating Intent Understanding and Optimal Behavior Planning for Behavior Tree Generation from Human Instructions (IJCAI 2024). However, the only external baseline is LLM-BT, evaluated solely with Qwen2.5. I would expect comparisons with multiple existing, complete end-to-end robotic task-planning methods on the same tasks, rather than mainly component-level ablations or classical planning algorithms. Without such comparisons, I do not believe this paper meets ICLR standards.
This concern is adequately addressed will determine whether I lower my rating to 1 or raise it to 3. Please include external Comparison Experiment.
Dear Reviewer 1sFr,
Thank you for recognizing the importance of preserving action dependencies and execution constraints. We have expanded the experimental comparisons, clarified the tables, and added an evaluation of state-consistent incremental goal updates.
1. Additional planning comparison and LLM-BT identification
The four-backbone evaluation covers Direct BT, ActionSeq, and HiBT, while LLM-BT is evaluated with Qwen2.5. We now explicitly cite the original LLM-BT paper (Zhou et al., ICRA 2024) in the experimental setup.
We additionally evaluated three standard search configurations using Pyperplan 2.1: BFS, A* with hmax, and greedy best-first search with FF. All use the same assembly states, goals, 11 action schemas, and 10 predicates. All three achieve 60/60 symbolic goal success and 60/60 success after shared BT compilation. Each returned action is independently validated against the original transition model. PDDL problems, generated plans, and validation records are provided in Appendix K.1.
These results establish classical search as a strong solution when the symbolic domain is fully specified. Our objective is complementary: HiBT learns a task-conditioned hierarchical interface and connects it to dependency-aware BT synthesis, rather than claiming an advantage over classical search in this fully specified symbolic setting.
2. Table clarification
Table 4 now explicitly states that the pale blue-gray shading only groups rows and does not encode significance or a numerical scale. Boldface identifies the full HiBT configuration, and the reported intervals are Wilson 95% confidence intervals.
We also revised the column widths, headers, and alignment in Table 14 and verified the rendered layout.
3. Incremental goal updates
We added a state-consistent goal-update adapter for mid-execution changes. At an action boundary, it snapshots the current symbolic state, grounds the new goal using the existing domain rules, closes its dependencies, and compiles a replacement BT.
We evaluated 1,388 goal replacements across action boundaries in 60 saved task traces. Candidate replacement goals are drawn from the assembly constraints and hand–tool holding goals. Of these, 1,167 were not already satisfied at the update point.
The comparison shows that updating dependencies from the current state is important: reusing the original tree or original state does not account for actions already completed and changes in hand/tool occupancy. The median symbolic update time is 0.104 ms, excluding Predictor inference.
This evaluation isolates symbolic goal-update realization with fixed Predictor outputs; it does not claim general adaptation to unseen domains or newly introduced action schemas.
Revision locations: Section 4.2 (LLM-BT citation), Tables 4 and 14 (clarification and formatting), Section 4.6 and Appendix K.3 (incremental goal updates), and Appendix K.1 (classical planning comparison).
Thank you again for your constructive feedback. We believe these additions provide a clearer account of HiBT's scope and its relationship to existing planning approaches.