acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

DualFront: What Must Hold and What Must Come First for Long-Horizon LLM Agents

Abstract

Long-horizon interactive tasks require LLM agents to satisfy long-term objectives while adhering to immediate execution constraints. Existing paradigms enhance decision-making through planning, memory management, or state tracking. However, these mechanisms often fail to explicitly couple goal fulfillment with execution readiness. Incoherent state updates lead to state drift—a misalignment where the agent's context diverges from the current task state, resulting in actions that either deviate from remaining requirements or violate current preconditions. We propose DualFront, a state-adaptation framework that synchronizes agent reasoning through dual dynamic frontiers driven by interaction evidence. The goal frontier identifies a goal condition to establish or verify (What Must Hold), while the execution frontier identifies a prerequisite state to address first (What Must Come First). By jointly updating these frontiers from shared evidence, DualFront ensures that execution preparation remains structurally aligned with the current task state. As a plug-and-play guidance layer, DualFront is compatible with various agent architectures, including ReAct, Plan-and-Execute, and Reflexion. Evaluations across three interactive environments show that DualFront improves macro-averaged success rates by up to 15.78 percentage points while reducing average LLM calls per episode by 9.47%. Trajectory analysis further reveals a reduction in execution mismatch rates. These results demonstrate that DualFront improves task completion and call efficiency across agent paradigms, while better aligning actions with current execution conditions.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM Agent, Long-Horizon Tasks, State Adaptation, Goal-Execution Alignment

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 32%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.50 over 4 reviews, above 68% of the others.
Reviewer_SP7eOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies state drift in long-horizon LLM agents, where the agent’s internal decision context gradually becomes inconsistent with the actual task state. The authors identify two types of misalignment: goal-state misalignment, where agents fail to track remaining requirements, and execution-state misalignment, where agents attempt actions without satisfying necessary prerequisites.

To address this issue, the authors propose dualfront, a state-adaptation framework that maintains two dynamic frontiers. The goal frontier answers what must hold by tracking remaining task requirements, while the execution frontier answers what must come first by identifying prerequisite states needed before advancing.

These frontiers are updated from public interaction evidence and provide additional guidance to existing agent architectures without modifyin their decision loop or requiring extra LLM calls. Experiments on PDDL, alfworld, and scienceworld with multiple agent paradigms show that dualfront improves task success and progress while reducing execution mismatch, LLM calls, and token consumption.

Critical strengths

The main strength of this paper is the clear identification of two different failure modes in long-horizon agents. Instead of treating agent failure as a general planning problem, the paper separates goal tracking errors from execution readiness errors. This provides a more precise analysis of why agents repeatedly perform invalid or redundant actions.

The proposed dualfront framework has a practical advantage because it can be integrated with existing agent paradigms. The authors demonstrate compatibility with act, react, plan-and-execute, and reflexion, without changing the underlying agent decision process or requiring additional LLM calls. This makes the method easier to apply compared with approaches that require retraining or modifying the base model

The experimental evaluation is relatively comprehensive. The authors evaluate across PDDL, alfWorld, and ScienceWorld, covering different types of interactive tasks. The improvements are consistent across multiple agent paradigms, with macro-average success rate improved and progress rate improved

Critical weaknesses

The main concern is the technical novelty of the proposed framework. Although the paper identifies an important failure mode in long-horizon agents, several components of dualfront are closely connected to existing ideas in task decomposition, symbolic planning, state tracking, and dependency reasoning. The authors need to more clearly explain what new capability is enabled by maintaining separate goal and execution frontiers, rather than viewing the method as a combination of existing goal tracking and prerequisite reasoning modules.

Another concern is the dependency on environment-specific structures. The construction of goal frontier and execution frontier requires goal parsing rules and dependency schemas, which may be feasible in structured benchmarks but could become a bottleneck in open-ended environments. It is unclear how much manual effort is required when adapting dualfront to a new domain, and whether the framework can maintain its advantages when task structure is incomplete or noisy.

The current evaluation mainly focuses on structured interactive environments such as PDDL, ALFWorld, and ScienceWorld. While these benchmarks are appropriate for studying long-horizon reasoning, they may not fully represent the challenges faced by real-world agents, where goals are ambiguous, dependencies are not explicitly available, and state information may be incomplete. More evidence in less structured settings would strengthen the generality of the claims.

The smaller-backbone test contains a direct counterexample to uniform gains: Qwen2.5-14B on ALFWorld-Act falls from 54.48% to 51.49% success and raises rejection from 31.58% to 35.45%. The positive 32B main results remain, but model-robustness wording should be qualified and this failure mode explained.

The paper demonstrates improvements across several agent backbones, but it remains unclear which part of dualfront contributes most to the gains. In particular, it is not fully separated whether the improvement comes from the additional information provided to the agent, the specific frontier representation, or the dependency-based execution guidance. A more detailed analysis of the source of improvement would make the contribution easier to evaluate.

Questions for authors

Please address the concerns raised in the critical weaknesses, especially regarding the novelty of dualfront, the dependency on environment-specific structures, and the generalization ability beyond structured benchmarks.

If the authors can address my concerns in the rebuttal, I would consider increasing my positive assessment and rating

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

We clarify DualFront’s novelty in coordinating goal and execution frontiers and explain its environment-specific adaptation requirements. New WebShop experiments, component ablations, and mechanism comparisons provide further evidence on generalization and the sources of performance gains. Relevant manuscript revisions are marked in blue.

We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and constructive feedback. We have updated the manuscript PDF on OpenReview, with the relevant changes marked in blue. Below, we address your comments and questions point by point and indicate the corresponding revision locations in each response.

Q. Please respond to the above concerns about DualFront’s novelty, environment-dependent structures, generalization across less structured settings, and the source of performance improvements.

Novelty of DualFront. The core novelty of DualFront lies not in introducing another state-tracking mechanism, but in quantitatively identifying two distinct sources of state drift in long-horizon tasks: goal mismatch and execution mismatch. Existing planning, memory, state-tracking, and workflow-based approaches often maintain a unified task state, without explicitly distinguishing remaining task requirements from the execution conditions needed to satisfy them, or modeling their underlying dependencies. To address this limitation, DualFront introduces two dynamically coordinated frontiers: the Goal Frontier, representing remaining task requirements, and the Execution Frontier, representing the conditions that must be established or verified to advance these requirements. Both frontiers are jointly updated using publicly observable interaction evidence, maintaining explicit goal-execution dependencies. This coordination enables agents to adjust their execution focus as tasks progress, realign execution conditions when goals change, and reopen previously satisfied goals when their satisfaction is invalidated. By explicitly linking remaining goals, current execution states, and subsequent decisions, DualFront provides continuous goal-execution coordination without additional LLM calls or modifications to the original decision loop.

Dependence on Environment-Specific Structures. Integrating an agent into a new interactive environment typically requires some degree of interface and semantic adaptation, and DualFront likewise relies on publicly available task requirements and action semantics. However, DualFront does not require complete, manually designed execution workflows for specific tasks. Instead, it uses existing task requirements and action semantics as the basis for a lightweight structuring process that explicitly extracts goal constraints and local action dependencies, from which the goal program and execution dependencies are constructed. The key idea is to establish relationships between goals and execution conditions using semantic information already available in the environment, rather than requiring predefined task execution paths.

To evaluate its applicability beyond structured environments, we conducted additional experiments on the semi-structured WebShop benchmark, which involves searching, browsing, selecting product specifications, and purchasing. We divided the complete task set into development, validation, and test subsets. On the held-out test set, DualFront improved SR from 34.44% to 39.07% (+4.63 percentage points) and average reward from 0.6101 to 0.6627, while reducing average LLM calls and total token consumption by 3.13% and 5.18%, respectively (Section 4.6, Page 10; Appendix D.2, Page 25-26 ). These results provide evidence of DualFront's applicability to less structured interactive environments with low inference overhead.

Performance Degradation on the 14B Model We acknowledge that overall improvements do not guarantee gains under every model configuration.. We reexamined 134 paired execution trajectories. Analysis of suggests that the agent sometimes failed to translate state guidance into the necessary execution preparations. This indicates that DualFront's effectiveness also depends on the underlying model's ability to follow such guidance. We have accordingly refined our claims regarding cross-model robustness to explicitly acknowledge this limitation.

Ablation Analysis We added component ablations and mechanism-level comparisons(Section 4.4, Page 8) to evaluate DualFront's components and their coordination. Taken together, these ablations provide complementary evidence at different levels: component ablations demonstrate the necessity of both the Goal Frontier and Execution Frontier ; comparisons with controllers using identical knowledge further isolate the contributions of dynamic frontier selection and coordinated updates; and goal-reopening experiments validate the mechanism's effectiveness when previously satisfied goals become invalidated. Furthermore, the performance degradation observed when structured execution dependencies are removed or goal structures are weakened indicates that the interdependencies between the two types of states are fundamental to DualFront's effectiveness.

We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful feedback. We hope our responses and revisions adequately resolve your concerns, and we welcome any further question.

Reviewer_BM5aOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

DualFront is a training-free state-adaptation layer for long-horizon LLM agents. The target failure is state drift: actions that the environment accepts but that do not serve a remaining goal, and actions that violate the preconditions of a goal that is still relevant.

On the AgentBoard splits of PDDL, ALFWorld, and ScienceWorld, and on Act, ReAct, Plan-and-Execute, and Reflexion, Qwen2.5-32B macro-averaged success rises from 41.44% to 52.00% and progress from 63.12% to 70.35%, in all 12 environment–paradigm cells. Pooled LLM calls fall by 9.47% and input tokens by 7.23%. On PDDL, a four-way ablation attributes most of the gain to the execution frontier, and offline replay reduces execution-mismatch rate from 17.89% to 14.62% and accepted state-revisit rate from 21.52% to 16.68%.

Critical strengths
  1. The failure is measured before a method is proposed. Rejection grows with depth and with stagnation, accepted actions need not advance unmet goals, and a memory-style agent does not remove the late-stage rejection pattern. That supports the design target: reassess what must still hold, and check what must hold before it can be attempted.

  2. The ablation separates the two frontiers, including a harmful intermediate. On PDDL, a static compiled hint yields +2.50 pp success. Adding only the goal frontier adds about two further points of success and loses progress. Adding the execution frontier reaches 35.42% success and 58.91% progress and cuts execution mismatch by 5.39 pp relative to the goal-only variant. The Barman replay agrees: the baseline satisfies a shot goal, pours the ingredient away, and never restores it; DualFront switches to the next open shot and first establishes the holding precondition.

  3. The wrapper is tested as a wrapper. The same injection is applied to four control loops with no extra LLM call. Guidance averages 26.07 tokens, while pooled calls, actions, and input tokens still fall.

  4. Satisfaction is typed, and the update rules are explicit. Empty evidence is kept distinct from counterevidence. current-state atoms can return to the candidate set after revocation. SEQUENCE opens only the first unsatisfied child, and CONDITIONAL opens neither branch while the guard is unknown. Algorithm 1 also states the sticky rule: keep the previous frontier while it remains a candidate.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The operative knowledge is hand-specified and not inspectable. The execution frontier is an environment-specific schema plus parsed entity bindings. No schema, coverage count, or rate of empty or wrong guidance is reported, so the frontier rule and a hand-written domain model are not separable.

  2. The local frontier misses cross-goal damage. In Barman, an accepted pour falsifies an already true goal atom. DualFront notices this only after counterevidence, and the sticky rule keeps the current frontier until it leaves the candidate set.

Questions for authors
  1. Please add the dependency schemas, at least one per PDDL domain and per ALFWorld and ScienceWorld task family, and report the fraction of steps with empty guidance, a parser failure, or a frontier you would judge wrong.

  2. On ALFWorld–ReAct, rejection rises from 10.49% to 17.42% while success also rises (Table 2). Are the added rejections precondition failures, bad arguments, or the agent acting against the hint?

  3. Do you have a trace where the execution frontier recommends a state that falsifies another current-state atom?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

We added dependency schemas, guidance-coverage and state-verification results, and a simple-controller comparison to examine contributions beyond domain knowledge. We also provide a Blocksworld trace demonstrating goal invalidation, reopening, and recovery, and clarify how it differs from the Barman example.

We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and constructive feedback. We have updated the manuscript PDF on OpenReview, with the relevant changes marked in blue. Below, we address your comments and questions point by point and indicate the corresponding revision locations in each response.

Q1. Please add the dependency schemas,and report the fraction of steps with empty guidance, a parser failure, or a frontier you would judge wrong. How can the contribution of domain knowledge be distinguished from that of the dual-frontier mechanism?

A1. Thank you for this suggestion. Deploying an agent in a new environment often requires environment-specific adaptation. DualFront uses lightweight adapters built on public goal specifications and action semantics to make implicit goal and prerequisite relations explicit. In Appendix B.1-B.2 (Page 18-20), we provide details of goal parsing, representative goal relations, and dependency schemas, and explain how they are instantiated with public observations to select the frontiers. Appendix B.4(Page 23) further reports compilation records, guidance coverage, and state-verification results for Qwen2.5-32B-Instruct under ReAct.

\text{Environment} & \text{Full compilation} & \text{Nonempty guidance} & \text{Goal-state} & \text{Execution-state} \\\\ & \text{records/tasks} & \text{coverage (\\%)} & \text{verification} & \text{verification} \\\\ & & & \text{error rate (\\%)} & \text{error rate (\\%)} \\\\ \hline \text{PDDL} & 60/60 & 100.00 & 0.00 & 6.08 \\\\ \text{ALFWorld} & 134/134 & 100.00 & 0.00 & 1.07 \\\\ \text{ScienceWorld} & 90/90 & 98.92 & 0.68 & 0.28 \end{array}$$ To further distinguish the contribution of the control mechanism from that of domain knowledge (**Section 4.4, Page 8**), we include a simple-controller comparison in the revised manuscript. Averaged across the four agent paradigms on PDDL, full DualFront outperforms the simple controller by 4.17 percentage points in success rate and 5.06 percentage points in progress rate. These results provide additional evidence for the effectiveness of DualFront’s guidance organization and selection mechanism. **Q2.** On ALFWorld–ReAct, rejection rises from 10.49% to 17.42% while success also rises (Table 2). Are the added rejections precondition failures, bad arguments, or the agent acting against the hint? **A2.** Thank you for highlighting this observation. We examined 134 pairs of original trajectories and conducted an offline diagnosis using the environment rules and initial states. A major contributor to the increased rejections was repeated observation loops in a small number of tasks: the agent repeatedly issued examine before reaching the receptacle to be inspected, violating the location precondition. Persistent state guidance did not help the agent escape these loops.Six cleaning tasks exhausted the 30-step budget in this manner, accumulating 180 rejections. The baseline completed five of these tasks with only 34 rejections in total. Across all tasks, however, 17 outcomes changed from failure to success and nine from success to failure, yielding an overall increase in success rate. These results show that task-level gains can coexist with degraded execution in a subset of trajectories; state guidance does not yet guarantee the elimination of repeated invalid actions. **Q3.** Do you have a trace where the execution frontier recommends a state that falsifies another current-state atom? **A3.** Yes, such a case occurs in Blocksworld P&E instance 020, which requires both ON(b2,b1) and ON(b3,b2) to hold. At step 8, the agent established ON(b3,b2), while the goal frontier remained focused on ON(b2,b1). To enable moving b2, the execution frontier subsequently selected CLEAR(b2) as a prerequisite. At step 11, the agent executed unstack b3 b2, invalidating the previously satisfied goal ON(b3,b2). Upon receiving public counterevidence, DualFront returned this goal to the candidate set. Frontier retention does not suspend state updates, but it can delay goal switching: the system first completed ON(b2,b1) at step 14, then restored ON(b3,b2) during steps 15–16, successfully completing the task. We also clarify that, in the Barman example, the action that poured out the ingredient and invalidated a satisfied goal occurred in the baseline trajectory. DualFront switched to the next goal after satisfaction, and this invalidation did not occur. Thus, the Barman example illustrates goal switching after satisfaction, while the Blocksworld example additionally demonstrates detection, reopening, and actual recovery following goal invalidation. We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful feedback. We hope our responses and revisions adequately resolve your concerns, and we welcome any further question.
Reviewer_yr8cOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

DualFront is a layer of programmatic guidance for interactive LLM agents. It compiles a task to a goal program, monitoring satisfaction/unsatisfaction/unknownness of goal conditions, and what's-currently-required vs what's-previously-satisfied. At each step, the goal that's left is chosen, and its environment-specific prerequisite graph is instantiated. A second frontier chooses a prerequisite to establish or check. This short instruction is tacked on to the base agent input (no auxiliary LLM call).

Evaluations (60 PDDL, 134 ALFWorld, 90 ScienceWorld tasks; 4 agent impls; 2 Qwen2.5 sizes; default budget of 30 environment actions) show (using Qwen2.5-32B) a mean increase in success of 10.57 percentage points, and a 9.47% decrease in pooled mean LLM calls. Validation (PDDL component ablations; offline trajectory analysis; action-budget and guidance-frequency experiments; Qwen2.5-14B replication). (Sections 3-4; Tables 1-3 and 11; Appendix C.1.)

Critical strengths

The success and progress are better (in all 12 combinations of environment-paradigm) with 32B backbone. For 14B results, success is better in 11 out of 12 combinations, while progress is better in all 12 combinations. In the paired settings the main prompting, decoding, action budget and termination decisions are kept the same. Further they also count total calls and input/output tokens (and don't equate no auxiliary calls with no cost) -- e.g. the pooled input tokens per episode drop from 44.44k to 41.23k per episode in spite of additional guidance, this is a strong evidence that the full guidance layer is helpful in tested settings. (Tables 1-2 & 11-12, Appendix C.1)

Critical weaknesses

Core contribution to coordination is not de-coupled from environment-specific knowledge driving the guidance.

As described in Appendices B.1-B.2, the environment specific goal parsers, rule-based extraction of observation / evidence, and environment/goal-relation-specific prerequisite schemas that dictate what is needed for the task, if it has been accomplished, and what should be done next, are key sources of task knowledge. While interfaces to these are presented in the submission, there is no concrete rule/schema inventory, nor construction/validation protocol, nor enough info on coverage/error to evaluate the effort required for reproducibility/adaptation.

The ablation in Table 3 (cumulative) fails to help here, as in the static case, structured goals are given, in the goal-frontier case dynamic guidance of goals is given, and in the full case we get schema-derived prerequisite knowledge as well. So the 7.50 point jump in success when adding the execution frontier is not only giving more info, but changing how this info is retrieved. This doesn't demonstrate the benefit of two frontier coordination over a more simplistic controller given the same parsed state + prerequisite knowledge. The difference here is particularly important since even just the goal-frontier jump is just 2.08 success points and has a -2.86 drop in progress.

We need to see a case where the state representation and dependency knowledge is kept the same, and the controller just made more simplistic to make the case for the methodology contribution as claimed. It would also be good to directly test the unique (non-monotonic update) used here as e.g. the Barman case is more about DualFront avoiding invalidation, rather than it sensing and correcting a goal that was previously achieved and later turned out to be false. (Table 3; Appendix A.4 - Table 7; Appendices B.1-B.2 - pp. 16-18).

Questions for authors

Clarification - adapted construction and coverage. How are the goal parsers/evidence rules and dependency schemas built and validated? Their concrete forms? Which tasks/trajectories are involved in this process? Are the rules fixed before evaluation? What are the compilation/guidance-coverage and state/goal-verification error rates for each environment?

Additional evidence needed for the existing claim - mechanism attribution. Can we still see performance benefits from DualFront over a naive controller with the same parsed public state, dependency schema, and goal structures, and under the same action budget and guidance size? Furthermore, if we fixed the status of goals (i.e. permanently successful instead of resetting on counterevidence), what differences would we observe? These would more directly isolate the claimed mechanisms of coordination and non-monotonicity.

Clarification - baseline activation/calling. Why does PDDL Plan-and-Execute seem to only call plan at the start and PDDL Reflexion seem to not call reflect? For both baselines, please report the exact conditions under which reflex/replanning happens and the overall number of calls, and explain how these fit with the call accounting in Table 2 and the description of the PDDL implementation.

Additional evidence needed for the existing claim - relevant comparison. Can we compare DualFront with StateAct for the same backbone and action budget? For HiAgent (the already reproduced one), what do these performance results (success, progress, cost) look like? For the main performance differences and ablations please also add error bars from paired task-level uncertainty estimates, taking reuse of the same tasks across paradigms into account.

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

We clarify how goal parsers, evidence rules, and dependency schemas are constructed and integrated before evaluation, and report coverage and state-verification audits across 284 tasks. We also add WebShop generalization experiments and simple-controller, No goal reopening, and EF-only comparisons to examine the roles of guidance selection, non-monotonic goal updates, and coordination between the two frontiers.

We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and constructive feedback. We have updated the manuscript PDF on OpenReview, with the relevant changes marked in blue. Below, we address your comments and questions point by point and indicate the corresponding revision locations in each response.

Q1. How are the goal parsers/evidence rules and dependency schemas built and validated? Their concrete forms? Which tasks/trajectories are involved in this process? Are the rules fixed before evaluation? What are the compilation/guidance-coverage and state/goal-verification error rates for each environment?

A1. Thank you for your valuable feedback. Our goal parsers and dependency schemas are constructed based on the environment’s publicly available task requirements and corresponding action semantics. Adapting to a new environment requires only a lightweight environment adapter built on this basis to make explicit the implicit relationships between goal requirements and local actions. These adapters are integrated into the system before formal evaluation and do not involve trajectory-specific adaptation.We have also added generalization experiments in the semi-structured WebShop environment, partitioning the full task set into development, validation, and test sets. Details are provided in Appendix D.2(Page 25-26).

During online interaction, the evidence-extraction rules convert initial observations and subsequent action feedback into structured facts and event records. We have expanded **Appendix B.1-B.2(Page 18-21)**of the revised manuscript to describe their concrete forms and operational procedures. Regarding coverage and state-judgment errors, Appendix B.4(Page 23) presents an audit of existing trajectories obtained using Qwen2.5-32B-Instruct, ReAct, and full DualFront, covering all 284 evaluation tasks across PDDL, ALFWorld, and ScienceWorld.

\text{Environment} & \text{Full compilation} & \text{Nonempty guidance} & \text{Goal-state} & \text{Execution-state} \\\\ & \text{records/tasks} & \text{coverage (\\%)} & \text{error rate (\\%)} & \text{error rate (\\%)} \\\\ \hline \text{PDDL} & 60/60 & 100.00 & 0.00 & 6.08 \\\\ \text{ALFWorld} & 134/134 & 100.00 & 0.00 & 1.07 \\\\ \text{ScienceWorld} & 90/90 & 98.92 & 0.68 & 0.28 \end{array}$$ **Q2.** What performance gains does DualFront bring compared with a naive controller under the same configuration? Besides, if goal status is fixed as permanently successful rather than reset upon counterevidence, what differences can we observe? **A2.** We thank the reviewer for highlighting the limitations of our original cumulative ablation study in mechanism attribution. We have added a simple-controller comparison under the same knowledge conditions. We also acknowledge that the Barman case primarily illustrates timely goal switching after completion and the preparation of execution prerequisites, without directly demonstrating the detection and restoration of invalidated goals. We therefore retain this case to illustrate coordination between the two frontiers and introduce a No goal reopening comparison to examine the role of non-monotonic goal updates. In addition, we include an EF-only component ablation to further assess the effects of a single frontier. The Simple controller reuses the public-state parsing outputs, goal structure, and dependency knowledge of full DualFront, following a fixed order to select an unfinished goal and its unsatisfied or unknown direct prerequisites. With the same configuration , full DualFront achieves mean SR and PR that are higher by 4.17 and 5.06 percentage points, respectively(**Section 4.4, Page 8**). This provides further evidence for the role of organizing and selecting existing knowledge during online execution. The No goal reopening variant permanently retains the completion label of a current-state goal after its first satisfaction, preventing it from being reopened in response to counterevidence while leaving all other GF/EF control rules and the environment’s success criterion unchanged. Full DualFront exceeds this variant by 2.92 and 3.61 percentage points in mean SR and PR, respectively(**Section 4.4, Page 8**), supporting the overall benefit of continually updating goal-satisfaction states in the evaluated settings. The additional EF-only ablation exhibits a similar pattern of increased SR but decreased PR; detailed results are provided in **Section 4.4(Page 8)** and Table 4. One possible explanation is that single-frontier guidance may emphasize either goal focus or local preparation. In full DualFront, GF selects the current goal and constrains the scope of EF, while EF provides guidance on the prerequisite states needed to advance that goal. This coordination connects goal selection with execution preparation as public feedback arrives, better supporting overall task progress.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

We clarify the replanning and reflection triggers and explain their lack of activation in PDDL . We also add StateAct comparisons using the same backbone and action budget, report HiAgent’s performance and costs, and provide paired task-level bootstrap confidence intervals.

We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and constructive feedback. We have updated the manuscript PDF on OpenReview, with the relevant changes marked in blue. Below, we address your comments and questions point by point and indicate the corresponding revision locations in each response.

Q3. Why does PDDL Plan-and-Execute seem to only call plan at the start and PDDL Reflexion seem to not call reflect? For both baselines, please report the exact conditions under which reflex/replanning happens and the overall number of calls, and explain how these fit with the call accounting in Table 2 and the description of the PDDL implementation.

A3. Thank you for highlighting this issue. We inspected the original request logs and confirmed your observation: in the Qwen2.5-32B PDDL main experiments, P&E performed one initial planning call per task without triggering replanning, while Reflexion did not trigger explicit reflection. The original manuscript did not sufficiently specify the trigger conditions or their observed activation. P&E triggers replanning after three consecutive action rejections or eight consecutive steps satisfying the public-stagnation criterion. Reflexion uses thresholds of three consecutive rejections or four consecutive stagnation steps, with at least four interaction steps between successive reflections. These thresholds are now documented in Appendix C.1. Public stagnation occurs when consecutive normalized observations are identical or consecutive actions are identical; the stagnation counter resets when neither condition holds. The absence of these triggers in PDDL is related to the use of check valid actions. AgentBoard’s PDDL environment exposes this query publicly, and rejection feedback may suggest its use. The query returns the currently available actions and is accepted as a valid environment action. It is equally available to Baseline and DualFront and counts toward the interaction budget. Across the four main-experiment configurations—P&E and Reflexion, each with and without DualFront—we identified 822 rejected actions followed by further interaction. In 818 cases (99.51%), the next action was an accepted check valid actions query; in the remaining four cases, it was an accepted task operation. Rejections were therefore separated by accepted actions, resetting the consecutive-rejection counter. The query and its returned action list also differed from the preceding failed action and rejection feedback, interrupting the public-stagnation count. Step-by-step verification confirmed that neither counter exceeded one at eligible update steps in these four configurations. Consequently, the replanning and reflection thresholds were not reached. These mechanisms were activated in experiments on ALFWorld and ScienceWorld.

Q4. Can we compare DualFront with StateAct for the same backbone and action budget? For HiAgent (the already reproduced one), what do these performance results (success, progress, cost) look like? For the main performance differences and ablations please also add error bars from paired task-level uncertainty estimates, taking reuse of the same tasks across paradigms into account.

A4. Thank you for the suggestion. We have added a comparison with StateAct using the same Qwen2.5-32B-Instruct backbone and 30-step action budget, and reported HiAgent’s performance and costs. These results are presented in Sections 4.2 and 4.3, Tables 1 and 3(Page 7) of the revised manuscript. Performance and cost. With equal weighting across environments and the four paradigms, DualFront achieves an SR/PR of 52.00%/70.35%, compared with the cross-environment macro averages of 45.62%/63.63% for StateAct and 32.64%/49.26% for HiAgent. Averaged across the four DualFront configurations, LLM calls per episode are lower than those of both methods on ALFWorld and ScienceWorld, and the pooled action rejection rate is lower in each of the three environments. However, cost advantages vary by environment: on PDDL, DualFront’s mean call count lies between those of the two methods, while its token consumption is higher than both. Paired uncertainty analysis. We have added 95% confidence intervals for the main performance differences and ablation results in Appendix D.6, Table 21(Page 30). We use 10,000 paired task-level bootstrap resamples, stratified by environment. Results for the same task across methods and paradigms are resampled jointly to preserve pairing and account for dependence arising from task reuse across paradigms.

We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful feedback. We hope our responses and revisions adequately resolve your concerns, and we welcome any further question.

Reviewer_VUd8OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes DualFront, a guidance framework for long-horizon LLM agents. It maintains a goal frontier that identifies a requirement to establish or verify and an execution frontier that identifies a prerequisite to address first. Environment-specific adapters update both frontiers from public interaction feedback and convert them into textual guidance without additional LLM calls. Experiments across three interactive environments and four agent paradigms report improved task performance and lower average inference costs.

Critical strengths
  1. The motivation is reasonable. Distinguishing remaining goal requirements from current execution prerequisites provides a clear basis for addressing state misalignment in long-horizon tasks.
  2. The evaluation covers three environments, four agent paradigms, and two model sizes, with additional ablations, cost measurements, and sensitivity analyses.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The method relies on environment-specific parsing rules and predefined dependency schemas. Applying it to new environments requires additional adaptation, while its generalization to unsupported task types and open-ended settings remains unverified.
  2. The trajectory audit used to motivate the method covers the same task instances as the final evaluation. The paper does not clarify how rule development was separated from testing, leaving open the possibility of adaptation to failure patterns in the evaluation tasks. The results therefore provide limited evidence of generalization beyond these tasks.
  3. The paper lacks task-level success/failure transition statistics and systematic mechanism attribution. It remains unclear how many newly successful tasks benefit specifically from goal-state correction or prerequisite establishment. Aggregate metrics and illustrative cases do not establish this connection.
Questions for authors
  1. Among tasks whose outcomes change after adding DualFront, how many improvements or regressions can trajectory analysis link to goal-state updates or execution-prerequisite guidance?
  2. Could the authors provide a concrete example of how a predefined dependency schema combines with current observations to construct the dependency graph and select the execution frontier, including whether the same schema transfers to other tasks without modification?
  3. Could the authors provide additional representative failure trajectories from the initial audit, showing where goal-state or execution-state misalignment arises?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

We add task-outcome transition statistics, linking improvements and regressions to trajectory evidence on goal-state updates and prerequisite guidance. We also clarify how adapters are constructed. We provide WebShop test-set results with separate development, validation, and test splits.

We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and constructive feedback, and for recognizing the motivation behind DualFront and the breadth of our experimental evaluation. Below, we address the concerns and questions in turn.

Q1. Among tasks whose outcomes change after adding DualFront, how many improvements or regressions can trajectory analysis link to goal-state updates or execution-prerequisite guidance?

A1. Thank you for pointing out the limitations of our task-level analysis. The original submission primarily reported aggregate performance, costs, and representative cases, without sufficiently showing how DualFront affects individual task outcomes. To address this, we have added success/failure transition statistics for the main experiments using Qwen2.5-32B-Instruct (Section 4.2, Table 2, Page 8). We further reviewed all 41 PDDL pairs with changed outcomes. Among the 35 improved pairs, 22 (62.86%) showed paired trajectory evidence associated with goal-state updates and a focus on remaining goals, while 28 (80.00%) showed evidence associated with execution-prerequisite preparation; 15 (42.86%) exhibited both associations. Analysis of the six degraded pairs suggests that limitations in guidance efficiency or deviations of the agent’s actions from the guidance can incur additional action costs, preventing task completion within the given action budget.

\text{Dataset} & \text{Fail}\to\text{success} & \text{Success}\to\text{fail} & \text{Net successes} & \Delta\mathrm{SR}\\;\text{(pp)} \\\\ \hline \text{PDDL }(N=240) & 35 & 6 & +29 & +12.08 \\\\ \text{ALFWorld }(N=536) & 85 & 26 & +59 & +11.01 \\\\ \text{ScienceWorld }(N=360) & 49 & 18 & +31 & +8.61 \end{array}$$ **Regarding environment adaptation and generalization.** For most agent methods, deploying an agent in a new interactive environment typically requires some adaptation to its interfaces and semantics. For our method, DualFront builds on publicly available task requirements and action semantics to explicitly represent goal conditions and local execution dependencies. This constitutes a lightweight environment adaptation process. As interaction proceeds, its two dynamic frontiers use public interaction evidence to coordinate “what must hold” and “what must come first” in light of the current observed state, helping prevent goal-state and execution-state misalignment in long-horizon tasks. In the motivation analysis, we used trajectory analysis to identify misalignment phenomena in long-horizon interactions; we did not tailor our adapters to those trajectories. Instead, the adapters were developed based on public task requirements and action semantics. Nevertheless, we understand that the overlap in task instances between the motivation analysis and the final evaluation limits the evidence these results provide for generalization to unseen tasks. To further separate adaptation development from performance evaluation, we divided the tasks used in the additional WebShop experiment into development, validation, and test sets. All reported WebShop performance results are evaluated on the test set. The details are provided in **Appendix D.2(Page 25-26)**. We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful feedback. We hope our responses and revisions adequately resolve your concerns, and we welcome any further question.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

We provide a step-by-step Gripper example showing how task requirements and public observations instantiate a dependency graph and guide execution-frontier selection. We also add three representative baseline failure trajectories identifying where goal-state and execution-state misalignment arises across different agent paradigms and task domains.

We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and constructive feedback, and for recognizing the motivation behind DualFront and the breadth of our experimental evaluation. Below, we address the concerns and questions in turn.

Q2. Could the authors provide a concrete example of how a predefined dependency schema combines with current observations to construct the dependency graph and select the execution frontier, including whether the same schema transfers to other tasks without modification?

A2. We use the Gripper example in the appendix to illustrate how a predefined dependency schema combines with public observations to construct a dependency graph and select the execution frontier (Appendix B.3, Page 21-22). In Gripper, a robot uses grippers to move balls between rooms. The task goal is: “ball1 is at roomb, ball2 is at roomb, ball3 is at roomb, ball4 is at roomb,” requiring all four balls to be placed in roomb. We extract four goal atoms, g1,…,g4g_1,\ldots,g_4, from the task text, where gi=AT(balli,roomb)g_i=\mathrm{AT}(\texttt{ball}_i,\texttt{roomb}). AT(x,d)\mathrm{AT}(x,d) denotes that object xx is at destination dd. For this type of goal relation, the predefined dependency schema is: {object source known, robot at source, free gripper available} → holding the object → being at the destination while carrying the object → object at the destination. The conditions in braces serve as joint prerequisites. The task text provides the object xx and destination dd, while public observations provide the object's source location, the robot's position, and the gripper states. The system uses this information to bind entities and determine each node's satisfaction status.

In this example, z1z_1 is initially selected as the goal frontier. Public observations confirm that both “ball1” and the robot are in “rooma” and that a free gripper is available, satisfying all prerequisites for holding “ball1”. The controller traverses the dependency graph backward from the goal, stops at satisfied nodes, and selects the execution frontier from pending nodes whose prerequisites are all satisfied. The initial execution frontier is therefore the state of holding “ball1”. After the base agent picks up the ball and feedback confirms that it is held, the execution frontier advances to being at “roomb” while carrying “ball1”, while the goal frontier remains at z1z_1. On arrival, the execution frontier is empty, and guidance focuses on the goal. Only after the agent drops the ball and public feedback confirms “ball1 is at roomb” is z1z_1 marked satisfied; the goal frontier then switches to z2z_2 in this trajectory. The system reuses the same schema, rebinding the object to “ball2”. Since the robot remains in “roomb” while “ball2” is in “rooma”, the new execution frontier first focuses on returning to the object’s source location. All concrete environment actions are generated by the base agent. Thus, the same schema supports dynamic updates as task execution progresses. Across tasks within the same domain, the abstracted goal relations and dependency schemas can be reused.

Q3. Could the authors provide additional representative failure trajectories from the initial audit, showing where goal-state or execution-state misalignment arises?

A3. In addition to the Act–Barman case in Appendix A.4, Table 7 of the original submission, we have added three existing Baseline failure trajectories covering different agent paradigms and task domains. A detailed analysis of goal-state and execution-state misalignment is provided in Appendix A.4. Thank you for suggesting that we include representative failure trajectories. In addition to the Act–Barman case in Appendix A.4, Table 7 of the original manuscript, we now include three additional failure trajectories from existing baseline runs, covering different agent paradigms and task domains. The table below identifies the specific steps at which misalignment occurs. A detailed trajectory analysis is provided in the Barman case in Appendix A.4(Page 17-18).

ParadigmCaseBaseline outcomeMisalignment type and key steps
ReActTyreworld–057Failure (30 steps)Goal-state misalignment: At step 22, the agent retrieves the previously stored “w1”, invalidating a satisfied goal. Execution-state misalignment: At steps 20 and 23, it attempts to jack up another hub without first recovering the jack.
ReflexionBlocksworld–025Failure (30 steps)Execution-state misalignment:From step 6 onward, the agent repeatedly attempts to stack “b1” on “b3” without first removing “b2” from “b3”.
P&EGripper–007Failure (30 steps)Goal-state misalignment: During steps 14–30, the agent repeatedly travels between rooms empty-handed, neglecting the remaining transport goals for “ball3” and “ball4”.

We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful feedback. We hope our responses and revisions adequately resolve your concerns, and we welcome any further question.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.