- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies state drift in long-horizon LLM agents, where the agent’s internal decision context gradually becomes inconsistent with the actual task state. The authors identify two types of misalignment: goal-state misalignment, where agents fail to track remaining requirements, and execution-state misalignment, where agents attempt actions without satisfying necessary prerequisites.
To address this issue, the authors propose dualfront, a state-adaptation framework that maintains two dynamic frontiers. The goal frontier answers what must hold by tracking remaining task requirements, while the execution frontier answers what must come first by identifying prerequisite states needed before advancing.
These frontiers are updated from public interaction evidence and provide additional guidance to existing agent architectures without modifyin their decision loop or requiring extra LLM calls. Experiments on PDDL, alfworld, and scienceworld with multiple agent paradigms show that dualfront improves task success and progress while reducing execution mismatch, LLM calls, and token consumption.
Critical strengths
The main strength of this paper is the clear identification of two different failure modes in long-horizon agents. Instead of treating agent failure as a general planning problem, the paper separates goal tracking errors from execution readiness errors. This provides a more precise analysis of why agents repeatedly perform invalid or redundant actions.
The proposed dualfront framework has a practical advantage because it can be integrated with existing agent paradigms. The authors demonstrate compatibility with act, react, plan-and-execute, and reflexion, without changing the underlying agent decision process or requiring additional LLM calls. This makes the method easier to apply compared with approaches that require retraining or modifying the base model
The experimental evaluation is relatively comprehensive. The authors evaluate across PDDL, alfWorld, and ScienceWorld, covering different types of interactive tasks. The improvements are consistent across multiple agent paradigms, with macro-average success rate improved and progress rate improved
Critical weaknesses
The main concern is the technical novelty of the proposed framework. Although the paper identifies an important failure mode in long-horizon agents, several components of dualfront are closely connected to existing ideas in task decomposition, symbolic planning, state tracking, and dependency reasoning. The authors need to more clearly explain what new capability is enabled by maintaining separate goal and execution frontiers, rather than viewing the method as a combination of existing goal tracking and prerequisite reasoning modules.
Another concern is the dependency on environment-specific structures. The construction of goal frontier and execution frontier requires goal parsing rules and dependency schemas, which may be feasible in structured benchmarks but could become a bottleneck in open-ended environments. It is unclear how much manual effort is required when adapting dualfront to a new domain, and whether the framework can maintain its advantages when task structure is incomplete or noisy.
The current evaluation mainly focuses on structured interactive environments such as PDDL, ALFWorld, and ScienceWorld. While these benchmarks are appropriate for studying long-horizon reasoning, they may not fully represent the challenges faced by real-world agents, where goals are ambiguous, dependencies are not explicitly available, and state information may be incomplete. More evidence in less structured settings would strengthen the generality of the claims.
The smaller-backbone test contains a direct counterexample to uniform gains: Qwen2.5-14B on ALFWorld-Act falls from 54.48% to 51.49% success and raises rejection from 31.58% to 35.45%. The positive 32B main results remain, but model-robustness wording should be qualified and this failure mode explained.
The paper demonstrates improvements across several agent backbones, but it remains unclear which part of dualfront contributes most to the gains. In particular, it is not fully separated whether the improvement comes from the additional information provided to the agent, the specific frontier representation, or the dependency-based execution guidance. A more detailed analysis of the source of improvement would make the contribution easier to evaluate.
Questions for authors
Please address the concerns raised in the critical weaknesses, especially regarding the novelty of dualfront, the dependency on environment-specific structures, and the generalization ability beyond structured benchmarks.
If the authors can address my concerns in the rebuttal, I would consider increasing my positive assessment and rating
We clarify DualFront’s novelty in coordinating goal and execution frontiers and explain its environment-specific adaptation requirements. New WebShop experiments, component ablations, and mechanism comparisons provide further evidence on generalization and the sources of performance gains. Relevant manuscript revisions are marked in blue.
We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and constructive feedback. We have updated the manuscript PDF on OpenReview, with the relevant changes marked in blue. Below, we address your comments and questions point by point and indicate the corresponding revision locations in each response.
Q. Please respond to the above concerns about DualFront’s novelty, environment-dependent structures, generalization across less structured settings, and the source of performance improvements.
Novelty of DualFront. The core novelty of DualFront lies not in introducing another state-tracking mechanism, but in quantitatively identifying two distinct sources of state drift in long-horizon tasks: goal mismatch and execution mismatch. Existing planning, memory, state-tracking, and workflow-based approaches often maintain a unified task state, without explicitly distinguishing remaining task requirements from the execution conditions needed to satisfy them, or modeling their underlying dependencies. To address this limitation, DualFront introduces two dynamically coordinated frontiers: the Goal Frontier, representing remaining task requirements, and the Execution Frontier, representing the conditions that must be established or verified to advance these requirements. Both frontiers are jointly updated using publicly observable interaction evidence, maintaining explicit goal-execution dependencies. This coordination enables agents to adjust their execution focus as tasks progress, realign execution conditions when goals change, and reopen previously satisfied goals when their satisfaction is invalidated. By explicitly linking remaining goals, current execution states, and subsequent decisions, DualFront provides continuous goal-execution coordination without additional LLM calls or modifications to the original decision loop.
Dependence on Environment-Specific Structures. Integrating an agent into a new interactive environment typically requires some degree of interface and semantic adaptation, and DualFront likewise relies on publicly available task requirements and action semantics. However, DualFront does not require complete, manually designed execution workflows for specific tasks. Instead, it uses existing task requirements and action semantics as the basis for a lightweight structuring process that explicitly extracts goal constraints and local action dependencies, from which the goal program and execution dependencies are constructed. The key idea is to establish relationships between goals and execution conditions using semantic information already available in the environment, rather than requiring predefined task execution paths.
To evaluate its applicability beyond structured environments, we conducted additional experiments on the semi-structured WebShop benchmark, which involves searching, browsing, selecting product specifications, and purchasing. We divided the complete task set into development, validation, and test subsets. On the held-out test set, DualFront improved SR from 34.44% to 39.07% (+4.63 percentage points) and average reward from 0.6101 to 0.6627, while reducing average LLM calls and total token consumption by 3.13% and 5.18%, respectively (Section 4.6, Page 10; Appendix D.2, Page 25-26 ). These results provide evidence of DualFront's applicability to less structured interactive environments with low inference overhead.
Performance Degradation on the 14B Model We acknowledge that overall improvements do not guarantee gains under every model configuration.. We reexamined 134 paired execution trajectories. Analysis of suggests that the agent sometimes failed to translate state guidance into the necessary execution preparations. This indicates that DualFront's effectiveness also depends on the underlying model's ability to follow such guidance. We have accordingly refined our claims regarding cross-model robustness to explicitly acknowledge this limitation.
Ablation Analysis We added component ablations and mechanism-level comparisons(Section 4.4, Page 8) to evaluate DualFront's components and their coordination. Taken together, these ablations provide complementary evidence at different levels: component ablations demonstrate the necessity of both the Goal Frontier and Execution Frontier ; comparisons with controllers using identical knowledge further isolate the contributions of dynamic frontier selection and coordinated updates; and goal-reopening experiments validate the mechanism's effectiveness when previously satisfied goals become invalidated. Furthermore, the performance degradation observed when structured execution dependencies are removed or goal structures are weakened indicates that the interdependencies between the two types of states are fundamental to DualFront's effectiveness.
We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful feedback. We hope our responses and revisions adequately resolve your concerns, and we welcome any further question.