1.The core claim of this paper is to trade acceptable accuracy loss for real-time inference on edge devices, but this claim lacks sufficient support. The paper does not explain where the acceleration actually comes from: the proposed layer is structurally more complex than the single-graph vector neuron layer, yet the overall model is faster. The causal link is missing. Furthermore, "lightweight" is presented solely in terms of frame rate, without metrics such as parameter count, FLOPs, or memory footprint to demonstrate whether the model itself is actually lighter. The deployment conditions are also not specified, making the efficiency conclusions difficult to attribute and reproduce. More importantly, the paper provides only a single operating point without showing the accuracy-latency trade-off curve. Therefore, it is impossible to determine whether this point lies on the Pareto frontier or if it outperforms a simply scaled-down version of the prior work.
2.There is no comparison with traditional compression methods. The paper treats architectural design as the sole path to lightweighting, yet it completely fails to compare against traditional compression techniques such as quantization, pruning, distillation, or inference engine optimization. Nor does it specify its own deployment settings. This omission directly undermines the paper's motivation: the starting point is that the prior work cannot run in real-time on edge devices. However, applying standard compression and deployment optimizations to the prior work would typically yield significant acceleration with negligible accuracy loss. If that is sufficient to achieve real-time performance, the accuracy sacrificed for speed in this work becomes unnecessary. The authors might argue that architectural improvements are orthogonal to compression and can be stacked, which is theoretically sound. However, orthogonality must be demonstrated with data from both before and after compression on the same device, rather than by mere assertion. In the absence of such comparisons and model scale metrics, readers cannot judge whether the proposed approach offers a genuine advantage over zero-research-cost engineering methods.
3.The contributions are incremental and minor. The paper provides no analysis beyond ablation studies to explain why the components are effective. Every design choice in the method lacks justification at a principled level, and there is no comparison with alternative approaches of equivalent cost. The argument for equivariance merely checks existing designs rather than serving as a basis for deriving the new design. The ablation section offers mostly narrative, speculative mechanistic explanations for the results, without any direct evidence to support them. Moreover, the ablation study itself lacks multiple runs and variance reporting; many of the observed gaps fall within the range of reasonable noise, which casts doubt on the credibility of the "verification." In terms of novelty, each component is a recombination of existing ideas. The topology prior was already used in the authors' own previous work; the modification here is mainly to make it offline and pair it with empirical constants. Thus, the methodological contribution is an incremental engineering tweak rather than a new design principle.