- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes InfluPose, a category-level pose estimator that complements correspondence reliability with a learned, state-conditioned "geometric influence" field. Concretely, the authors probe a frozen complete-geometry estimator by deleting and refilling M=8 regions, measure the resulting changes in predicted rotation, translation, and size, and blend these finite responses with a dense geometric proxy to form four-channel supervision targets. A partial-cloud predictor is then trained to regress these targets from visible observations, and the predicted influence enters weighted Kabsch initialization and joint pose-and-size refinement, supervised by both direct response losses and the endpoint pose objective. On REAL275 and HouseCat6D, the method achieves the highest strict-pose mAP among compared point-cloud methods.
Critical strengths
++ The authors identify that correspondence reliability does not necessarily imply geometric importance. They design a method to evaluate the influence of each point in the point cloud on the fine-grained components of the predicted pose state, and apply it to point-cloud-based category-level pose estimation, improving performance under stricter evaluation metrics. The motivation is clear, the method design is well aligned with the motivation, and the experimental results validate the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
++ The ablation studies are thorough and well-conducted. In addition, the authors provide the code, which supports reproducibility.
Critical weaknesses
-- While the method performs reasonably well under strict metrics, it falls behind existing methods under more relaxed metrics. What is the reason for this? Could the authors provide analyses on this discrepancy? In addition, could the authors provide an analysis of failure cases?
-- Could the influence-related modules be transferred to other existing methods to improve their performance? This would help demonstrate that the proposed approach is general rather than method-specific.
Questions for authors
See Above
Thank you for the positive assessment and for both questions.
W1. Relaxed thresholds and failure cases
Influence only changes how much each predicted correspondence counts when the pose is solved. When the correspondences are about right, better weights give a more precise pose, which gives us the best mAP at 5° on both benchmarks. When they are incorrect, no weighting can fix them, so the instances above 10° remain. Table R1 compares us with HS-Pose (above us at 10°/5cm) on the same detections.
Table R1. Share of instances within each threshold on the same REAL275 detections, ours vs. HS-Pose (%).
At 5°/2cm we lead on bottle, can, laptop and mug. At 10°/5cm these categories are within 2 points of HS-Pose or above it, and only camera is clearly lower.
The failures are of two kinds. The first is camera. The test cameras differ most from the training shapes, and with ground-truth masks our model puts 99.9% of training cameras within 10° but only 44.8% of test cameras. The second is a mug whose handle is hidden. The handle is the only cue for the rotation about the symmetry axis, and most mug errors above 45° occur when less than a quarter of it is visible.
W2. Transfer to other methods
Yes. On DR-Pose, replacing the final pose fit with our influence-based recovery raises the 5°/2cm AP from 41.29 to 44.75, and most of this gain comes from the learned influence (Table R3).
We keep DR-Pose's released weights frozen and add a small influence head on its features, trained with our regional targets and the loss of Equation 5. We then replace its Umeyama fit with influence-weighted Kabsch and one refinement update. No InfluPose network is used at test time.
Table R3. DR-Pose with the influence-based recovery on REAL275 (AP, %, mean of three RANSAC seeds).
Our run of DR-Pose is within 0.41 points of its published results. The gain holds for all three RANSAC seeds and, as in InfluPose, appears at the strict thresholds.