- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents SAP3D, a spatially adaptive personalization framework for consistent 3D asset editing. Given a source 3D asset, an edited 2D image, and a specified 3D editing region, the method aims to achieve the desired modifications while preserving the unedited parts of the original object. To address the limitations of existing latent preservation methods, particularly for VecSet-based representations where tokens lack fixed spatial locations, the authors propose to personalize the 3D generative model using an asset-specific LoRA. During generation, the LoRA strength is adaptively controlled at the token level using complementary 2D and 3D attention probes, with token assignments dynamically updated throughout the denoising process.
The method is evaluated on Edit3D-Bench using Hunyuan3D 2.1 as the backbone, with comparisons against five existing 3D editing methods. The results demonstrate competitive preservation performance and improved edit fidelity, supported by quantitative evaluations, qualitative comparisons, user studies, and ablation experiments.
Critical strengths
-
Clear problem motivation and analysis of existing methods. The paper provides a well-motivated analysis of the limitations of existing 3D editing methods, particularly the challenges of applying latent preservation strategies to VecSet-based representations. I find the problem formulation convincing, and the authors demonstrate a good understanding of the differences between structured and unstructured latent representations.
-
Thoughtful method design with promising results. The proposed combination of asset-specific personalization and spatially adaptive LoRA control is an interesting approach to balancing edit fidelity and preservation. The overall design is reasonable and reflects the authors' own insights into the problem. The competitive experimental results, particularly in edit fidelity, further support the effectiveness of the framework.
Critical weaknesses
-
High computational cost of per-asset LoRA training. The method requires training a separate LoRA for each 3D asset, which could significantly limit its practical applicability, especially for interactive 3D editing. Although the authors mention up to 5,000 training steps, the actual training time and computational overhead are not reported. I believe this is an important concern, particularly compared with existing training-free methods.
-
Insufficient evidence for the necessity of dynamic localization. While SAP3D achieves the best edit fidelity among the compared methods, its preservation performance is less competitive than that of some baselines. More importantly, the ablation results in Table 3 raise questions about the contribution of the proposed localization mechanism. In particular, fixing the editing region at achieves slightly better edit fidelity on both DINOv2 and CLIP metrics, with nearly identical preservation performance. The authors acknowledge in Appendix C that the benefits of dynamic localization are concentrated on a subset of cases and report qualitative improvements in several examples. However, the current evidence does not sufficiently establish when and why dynamically updating token assignments is necessary, especially given the additional complexity and potential computational overhead. A more systematic per-case analysis would strengthen this central technical contribution.
Questions for authors
-
Computational cost and practical efficiency. Could the authors provide the actual training time required for a per-asset LoRA? More specifically, how long does it take to edit a new 3D asset, including LoRA training and the complete editing pipeline? I think this is important for assessing the practical applicability of the proposed method, especially compared with training-free approaches.
-
Effectiveness of the proposed components. While Table 1 shows improvements in edit fidelity, the preservation results are less competitive. More importantly, in Table 3, the benefits of the localization components appear relatively limited, and the fixed-region variant even achieves slightly better edit fidelity than the full method. Could the authors further explain these results and provide stronger evidence for the effectiveness and necessity of dynamic localization?
-
Core novelty and technical contribution. Given the relatively limited gains from the localization components in Table 3, I am somewhat concerned about the significance of the technical novelty. Could the authors clarify what they consider the most important technical contribution of this work, beyond combining per-asset LoRA personalization with attention-based localization? At present, I am not fully convinced that the demonstrated contributions are sufficiently substantial for ICLR, and a clearer justification would help inform my assessment.