- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
CoRER reconstructs the silhouette of a person hidden around a corner using a single RGB image containing weak indirect reflections from a wall. Its architecture combines RDCR and SCRR to achieve this reconstruction. The study also incorporates the ReflectHuman dataset, a real-world dataset acquired in four corner environments, and evaluates the method through baseline comparison, component ablation, and robustness experiments. This task presents a challenging scenario for non-line-of-sight (NLOS) imaging.
Critical strengths
-
ReflectHuman supports research on a challenging real-world perception task. Capturing faint wall reflections in multi-corner environments provides useful experimental data for recovering hidden human contours. This dataset allows researchers to examine non-line-of-sight (NLOS) reconstruction under real-world imaging conditions and compare the performance of different methods on common tasks.
-
The architecture is tailored to a specific problem and validated from multiple experimental perspectives. The separation of RDCR and SCRR provides a clear modular structure for the reconstruction process. In addition to overall performance comparisons, the authors investigated individual components through ablation experiments, robustness checks, boundary-sensitive metrics, and diagnostic tests. These analyses help characterize the network's behavior.
Critical weaknesses
-
The distinctions between CoRER and closely related methods are not adequately clarified. This paper omits discussion of two directly related studies: SLD-Net (CVPR 2026), entitled “Hidden Person Detection Based on Similarity-Consistent Likelihood Diffusion from Wall Reflections,” and DiProxB-Net (IEEE Transactions on Multimedia, 2026), entitled “Recovering Occluded Human Boundaries from Single-Frame Indirect Observations.” Both studies explore methods for hidden person perception or boundary reconstruction using indirect wall observations. Their implementations differ from CoRER, but they overlap significantly in perceptual assumptions, task definitions, and research motivations. The comparison with DiProxB-Net is particularly important because it also reports results on the ReflectHuman dataset. This paper needs to more clearly articulate CoRER's contributions beyond these methods, supplemented with targeted numerical comparisons and visual examples under similar conditions.
-
Some interpretations and evaluation conclusions lack sufficient justification. RDCR appears to assess consistency between features across different scales, but the use of "coherence" fails to clearly distinguish this computational property from optical coherence. Standard RGB images record intensity rather than directly measuring optical phase, thus any physical interpretation requires careful articulation. Similarly, phase jitter analysis fails to adequately link its image spatial transformation to the underlying measurement process. The evaluation scheme also suffers from uncertainty regarding test independence. The paper should explain the distribution of scenes, acquisition sequences, and participants during the training, validation, and testing phases, and clearly indicate which reported results used reserved data. Furthermore, current evidence is insufficient to distinguish between reconstructions based on information-rich wall reflections and predictions primarily shaped by learned prior information about human contours.
Questions for authors
-
What are the specific technical advantages of CoRER compared to SLD-Net and DiProxB-Net? Given the implementation and data, could the authors compare these methods using matched inputs, evaluation protocols, and representative visual results?
-
How are the training, validation, and test sets constructed? Please explain whether the acquisition sequences, environments, or subjects are shared between the sets, and describe measures taken to prevent accidental overlap.
-
Does "coherence" refer to feature consistency, optical properties, or other quantities? Please define the phase jitter transform and explain the hypotheses it tests. Using control variables such as empty scenes, known changes in human position, or selectively occluded wall observations can also help determine the dependence of the prediction results on the measured reflected signal.
-
Could the authors provide the complete training objective and loss weights, define the calibration operator (B_j), and describe each step used in the inference process? For baseline methods developed for transient measurements or LiDAR data, please explain how they are converted to single-frame RGB input and compare how their different sensing assumptions are considered.