- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents scUS, a framework that uses the differences between contextualized unspliced and spliced RNA representations to characterize cell states. Rather than combining the two representations into a single embedding, the authors compute gene-wise distances and use them as a cell-level profile. The paper evaluates this idea through cell clustering, context-dependent analyses, stimulus-response experiments, and an extension to ATAC-seq data.
Critical strengths
- Most existing methods focus on learning representations from individual modalities or integrating multiple modalities. This paper instead looks at the relationship between two representations of the same gene. The gene-wise distance profile is a simple but interesting way to capture this information, and I think this perspective is worth exploring.
- The experiments provide good support for the main idea. The authors evaluate the approach on several datasets and examine it from different angles. In particular, the distance profiles outperform pooled representations from the same encoder across all three clustering datasets. The matched-bin analysis is interesting, as it shows that the learned distances can vary across cellular contexts even when the local inputs are matched.
Critical weaknesses
- The method uses cosine distance to measure the differences between paired representations. It would be useful to know whether similar results can be obtained with other distance metrics, such as Euclidean distance. A comparison could help establish how sensitive the findings are to this choice.
- Some experimental settings are a little difficult to follow, particularly the preprocessing steps and differences between evaluation protocols. A table summarizing these settings would make the comparisons easier to understand.
Questions for authors
- Have the authors explored other distance metrics besides cosine distance, such as Euclidean distance? I wonder whether the observed cell-state structure is specific to cosine distance or whether similar patterns can be obtained with other measures.
- Could the authors clarify the main differences in preprocessing and feature selection across the evaluated methods? A brief summary table would be helpful for understanding the comparisons, particularly those involving scGPT and scFoundation.
- What are the relationship between gene-wise distances of scUS and gene expression levels? While Figure 5 provides some examples, it would be interesting to see whether there is a general relationship.