- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a feedback-based method to control anatomical changes in frozen 3D brain MRI generators. It requests a specific volume change in a target structure while limiting changes to other strucutures.
SynthSeg measures each generated result, and the controller adjusts the intervention until the request is met or the budget is exhausted. Experiments across five generators show improved control accuracy over fixed-strength guidance, although the strict preservation results depending on the segmentation performance.
Critical strengths
- The motivation is nice, achieving a specified anatomical change while limiting unwanted changes to other structures.
- Using external measurement from segmentation model to provide feedback to correct each sample, making the control more precise and variable.
- They evaluate across five released generators thus it supports applicability over different model architectures.
- They provide substantial ablations, independent segmentation checks, and anatomical plausibility analysis that help me to understand which component in their model is working.
Critical weaknesses
- Their strict preservation results depend heavily on synthSeg. I honestly feel the variation between segmentation model's reliability may be even larger than the request volume change. Table 13 shows that strict preservation transfers poorly to FastSurfer. How should the acceptance thresholds account for disagreement between segmentation tools, and what anatomical precision can reasonably be claimed?
- The main baselines use fixed guidance strengths, while their method repeatedly measures and corrects each sample. Please evaluate these guidance methods with comparable per-request feedback and computational budgets to isolate the controller’s contribution.
- The image-quality validation is limited, particularly for larger edits. Matching regional volumes does not establish realistic anatomy or biologically valid disease progression. May authors can consider some reader validation or disease target classifiers.
- I personally feel this paper's presentation/terminology is unnecessarily difficult to follow, multiple variants, acceptance criteria, also the repeating numbers in the results (such as xxx to 200 examples, xx to xx requests). i feel these are unnecessary repeating in text. Authors can consider keeping more high level analysis in discussion and conclusion.
Questions for authors
Mainly already ask in the weaknesses section. One additional question: What benefit does paired probing provide over the simpler one-sided controller, which achieves similar success with fewer generations?
I currently lean toward borderline, i would reconsider if the authors clarify more on the benefit over simpler controllers or less repeated methods. Also, an improvement over the entire writing.
We thank both reviewers for their careful assessment. We have revised the presentation and added experiments to distinguish the contribution of measured feedback from that of the intervention used to steer the generator. The revisions are marked in blue in the manuscript.
For each request, the controller modifies the sampling trajectory of a frozen generator and uses an external verifier, SynthSeg, to measure the resulting anatomical changes. Measurements on the starting noise of that request update the intervention until the contract is satisfied or the probe budget is exhausted. In the single-structure experiments, the requested change is one test-retest floor, with an error of at most 0.25 floors; changes in the other five planned structures are bounded relative to the measured target change (leak threshold 0.1375, including tolerance). A failed request produces no returned volume and counts as a failure.