acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Robot-Centric Scaffolding Advances the Frontier of VLM-Based Manipulation

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

In 2024, as foundation models became able to handle real software tasks, coding scaffolds emerged and greatly accelerated AI coding. General-purpose vision-language models (VLMs) can now turn natural-language goals into useful manipulation without task-specific policies. Existing coding scaffolds complete some robot tasks but fail systematically, because they rely on three assumptions that hold only in digital environments: that actions can be checked afterward and undone, that targets are named exactly by symbols, and that habits formed on digital tasks carry over. We therefore propose Qoboter, a robot-centric scaffold that redesigns its loop, tools, and skills accordingly. Its loop plans task-level subgoals but commits only to the next local action, chosen from the latest observation. Its five core tools let the model select target pixels, then convert them into 3D points, check reachability before execution, and batch frequently co-occurring operations. Its skills guide the model to interpret occlusion, contact, and control error and to judge progress by observed evidence. On four simulators and a real robot, we weigh success against token and turn cost. With model weights fixed, Qoboter raises success on every frontier model at a similar token cost, from 75.8% to 90.0% on GPT-6-Astra and from 43.3% to 55.0% on Opus 5. The same configuration transfers unchanged to three open-weight models, raising their success by 5.0 to 8.4 points. These results suggest that scaffolding complements model scaling as a lever for reliable VLM-based manipulation.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Vision Language Models, Scaffold, Zero-shot Robotic Manipulation.

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_27siOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Qoboter, a robot-centric scaffold for VLM-based manipulation, consisting of three components, including Loop, Tools, and Skills. The VLM plans task-level subgoals, observes the environment, selects and executes actions through tool calls, and adjusts its decisions based on feedback. Experiments across four simulators and a real robot demonstrate improved success rates over existing coding scaffolds, with additional cross-model evaluations and ablation studies.

Critical strengths
  1. This work focuses on the design of Coding Scaffolds for robotic manipulation, which is a relatively new research direction for both robotics and Coding Scaffold-based agents. The authors achieve promising results, demonstrating that the robot can adjust its actions and correct its mistakes in response to environmental feedback.
  2. The authors organize their framework into three levels: Loop, Tools, and Skills. This provides a clear separation of responsibilities and makes the overall system architecture easier to understand and analyze. (I have some concerns about the description and motivation of these components, which I will discuss later.)
Critical weaknesses
  1. Admittedly, this paper appears to achieve quite good results (based on the anonymous video link provided by the authors), but it's overshadowed by low quality writing. The authors show their design intentions and ideas, but do not explain the details of their work in sufficient depth. At the very least, a pipeline example such as Figure 8 should be clearly explained in the main text, even if it is only a demo (ideally covering a broader range of situations or examples). After reading the main text, I do not think readers can clearly understand how the authors actually implemented this work.
  2. The story showed by the authors feels rather forced. In particular, the authors take certain typical characteristics of the environments in which Coding Agents operate and generalize them into inherent assumptions of Coding Scaffolds such as Codex and Claude Code. They then use argument that these assumptions do not hold in robotic environments to motivate the three design components of Qoboter. But the authors don't sufficiently justify whether these three assumptions are valid in the first place. For example, the authors claim that Coding Scaffolds rely on the reversibility of actions, but Codex can execute shell commands (e.g., sudo rm -rf ~/), and such operations are not necessarily reversible. The use of "rely on" in the abstract may also be inaccurate or overly absolute, or there may even be a logical flaw in this argument. Furthermore, the authors do not establish a clear causal relationship between these assumptions and the observed failures of the baselines in their experiments.
  3. The authors should pay more attention to details, including but not limited to reporting the specific version numbers of Codex and Claude Code, as both are continuously updated. In Figure 2, the legend for "Loop" does not match the actual diagram. Several layers use boxes that appear to correspond to the "Loop" legend, but all of them have dashed borders, and there is not a single white box with a solid border as indicated in the legend. Additionally, there appears to be a missing arrow below "RoboDojo · insert tubes", or is there a missing connection in the flow?
Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors provide a more detailed explanation of their pipeline and include it in the main text?
  2. I would like to discuss with the authors the claimed shortcomings of Coding Scaffolds (codex or cluade code, maybe) in embodied AI about their claim. At least for now, I find the authors' story insufficiently rigorous. It's a major motivation for this paper, I think it a relatively important concern. I cannot be entirely sure that my interpretation is correct.
  3. The authors should pay more attention to their figures. In my opinion, most of them need revision. For example, Figure 3 still shows noticeable signs of AI generation, raising concerns that the use of AI may go beyond what is disclosed in the "AI USE STATEMENT."
  4. It would be helpful if the authors could provide some comparisons with methods based on other paradigms, such as VLA-based approaches. I am interested in understanding the performance differences between these paradigms on the same tasks. (just a suggestion)
Reviewer_bhubOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how scaffolding affects zero-shot robotic manipulation with fixed vision-language models. The proposed system, Qoboter, combines task-level planning with observation-driven local execution, geometric tools that convert model-selected pixels into actionable coordinates, and procedural skills for interpreting physical feedback. The interface also batches observations, geometric queries, and motion commands.

The simulation evaluation covers 40 selected tasks across four simulators. Compared with the corresponding coding scaffolds, Qoboter improves average success from 75.8% to 90.0% for GPT-6-Astra and from 43.3% to 55.0% for Opus 5, while reducing output-token usage. The configuration also transfers to three additional models without per-model tuning. Ablations investigate geometric tools, batching, segmentation, and procedural skills. The manuscript describes a five-task real-robot evaluation protocol and provides qualitative hardware examples, while directing readers to an external website for quantitative hardware results.

Critical strengths
  1. Meaningful system-level improvements across multiple platforms and backbones. The paper addresses a useful question: how much can manipulation performance improve by changing the scaffold while keeping the underlying model fixed? Within each model block, the evaluation shares tasks, initial states, sensing, executors, and success judges. The substantial improvements for GPT-6-Astra and Opus 5 in Table 2 are encouraging. The Raw API control is also valuable because it shows that simply removing the coding scaffold does not explain the gains. Transfer to three additional models without per-model tuning further supports the usefulness of the design beyond one backbone.

  2. Concrete and interpretable interface design. The separation between VLM-based target selection and deterministic geometric computation is practical. The appendices explain calibration, pose conventions, controller feedback, and recovery behavior in considerable detail. The qualitative examples connect these choices to specific observations: Figure 5 shows a bad correspondence rejected through ray-gap diagnostics, while Figures 6–8 illustrate feedback-driven correction and active perception. These examples make the engineering contribution understandable and potentially reusable, although they do not independently establish its aggregate causal effect.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The mechanisms are not cleanly isolated, and the batching comparison may change effective execution resources. Table 4 keeps the loop enabled throughout, so it does not isolate the contribution of task-level planning with observation-driven local execution. The Raw API comparison changes the loop, tools, and skills simultaneously. More importantly, Appendices E and F.2 state that an entire multi-pose path counts as one motion command under the default 60-command cap, whereas granular actions count individually. Consequently, an equal command cap may allow different amounts of physical execution. The feedback schedules also differ: granular actions return camera images, while batched actions require a separate observation call. These differences could contribute to the performance gap attributed to batching. There is also an interface ambiguity: Appendix F.3 states that RoboTwin, RoboLab, and LIBERO publish granular/minimal surfaces, which needs reconciliation with the cross-platform five-tool batched interface and the four-simulator batching ablation. These issues do not demonstrate that the gains are invalid, but they prevent a clear attribution of the large granular-tool performance drop to the proposed interface design.

  2. The empirical evidence needs stronger uncertainty reporting and more complete hardware and cost results. Most simulator cells contain only 30 episodes across ten tasks, without confidence intervals or paired outcome analyses. This is particularly relevant for the smaller improvements, such as the 3.4-point average gain on Qwen3.8-Max and the mixed effects of procedural skills. Appendix B also discloses different handling of infrastructure failures across experiments. In Table 4, the complete Qwen3.8-Flash-Next configuration incorporates a six-scene LIBERO rerun, while the other variants use three scenes, weakening the claimed one-factor comparison. Quantitative real-robot results are absent from the supplied PDF and could not be verified from the external website during this assessment. The selected hardware example in Appendix C.5 uses GPT-6-Sol and takes 61 motion commands and approximately 29 minutes, requiring clarification relative to the stated model blocks and default command cap. Finally, output-token usage alone does not capture input/vision processing costs or latency. The results demonstrate promising success/output-token operating points, but do not yet establish the broader reliability and cost claims as convincingly.

Questions for authors
  1. Could you clarify the exact interfaces and budgets used for every configuration?
  2. What evidence isolates the contribution of the proposed interaction loop?
  3. How robust are the gains under a consistent paired evaluation?
  4. Could you provide the quantitative hardware results and complete inference settings?
Reviewer_5cNrOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes Qoboter, a framework that lets a frozen VLM control a robot through tool calls, without training a robot policy. It is a pretty standard setup these days as long as a person can afford the astronomical token cost to control the robot using a SOTA LLM.

Critical strengths

As VLMs become increasingly capable of controlling robots through natural language interfaces, assessing their capabilities is timely and important. The authors' rapid evaluation of a newly released VLM (within 2 weeks of Astra release) is particularly interesting!

Critical weaknesses
  1. The contribution needs clearer positioning - The paper appears better positioned as an empirical benchmark, given its limited methodological novelty. However, under that framing, what does it contribute beyond existing benchmarks, including RoboDojo, which it already uses? Task-level planning, closed-loop visual feedback, geometric grounding, and written behavioral instructions are established ideas. The paper should clarify what new knowledge emerges from their integration. What are the key machine learning insights gained other than "X is better than Y."Since, I believe, a coding agent itself can run a similar benchmark in less than a day with a simple prompt, it is important to highlight the novelty of the approach and key contextual insights.
  2. The baselines do not sufficiently establish the contribution - Although coding agents are useful controls, they are relatively weak primary baselines for robotic manipulation. Stronger comparisons with existing robot agent frameworks (e.g., Manipulate-Anything, VoxPoser, and Inner Monologue) are needed to establish whether the proposed scaffold improves over established approaches to robot planning, execution, and recovery. From our personal experience, Astra, Fable, etc. just works on robots without much hassle.
  3. Reliability and practical efficiency remain insufficiently established. Each simulated task uses only 3 initial scenes, with no reported uncertainty or significance analysis. Output token counts omit input costs, tool execution, and wall-clock latency, limiting the practical meaning of "similar cost." I appreciate the authors for choosing an expensive experimental setup, but the resulting evaluation gaps still limit the conclusions readers can draw.
Questions for authors
  1. See weaknesses above.
  2. What was the actual dollar cost of each experimental configuration, and how did it compare across the proposed method and baselines?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.