acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Attention Sinks in Transformer-based Language Models: Emergence Mechanisms and Benign Effects

Abstract

Attention sinks, in which large language models (LLMs) disproportionately attend to specific tokens such as the initial token or weak semantic tokens like punctuation and function words, have become an important focus in understanding Transformer mechanisms. This phenomenon has been shown to affect model performance and efficiency, motivating methods that either mitigate or leverage it to improve architectures. However, its theoretical underpinnings remain insufficiently understood, particularly how these patterns emerge spontaneously during training. In this work, we address this gap by theoretically analyzing a two-block Transformer trained on synthetic text datasets. We show that causal masking causes parameters associated with the first token to accumulate disproportionate gradients, driving the formation of a first-token attention sink, while high-frequency semantic tokens receive significantly larger gradients than other tokens and consequently absorb most of the attention. We further show that these attention sinks are compatible with the Transformer's predictive capacity, even when attention is heavily concentrated on a few tokens. Overall, this work provides a training dynamics explanation for the emergence of attention sinks, offering insights that inform the design of new algorithms and architectures.

Primary area:
learning theory
Keywords:
attention sink, training dynamics, transformer

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_4sQGOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes the underlying mechanisms of attention sinks by theoretically analyzing a two-block Transformer trained on synthetic text datasets. Both first token sink and weak semantic token sink are analyzed.

Critical strengths
  1. The question is well posed and the formulation is clean.
  2. The experiments are well devised.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The main text contains one figure, zero tables, and zero measured numbers. The result includes single run, no seeds and no error bars.
  2. The two-block model may be too simple.
  3. Proof is too long and hard to follow
Questions for authors

check weakness

1 comment

Thank you for your constructive review and for recognizing the well-posed research question and clear formulation. We have expanded the quantitative evidence and will make the experimental results and proof structure more accessible in the main paper. We address your three concerns below.


1. Quantitative results, multiple seeds, and uncertainty estimates.

We have extended the empirical analysis beyond the original illustrative curves. In particular, we evaluated Pythia-160M checkpoints from three independent pretraining seeds on WikiText-2, measuring attention across all layers and heads together with language-modeling performance.

Pretraining stepFirst-position attention: mean ± SDMean NLL
1,0000.00514 ± 0.000345.339
143,0000.14891 ± 0.083463.715

The mean and standard deviation are computed across three independent pretraining seeds. Each checkpoint is evaluated on 128 blocks from 32 articles. First position refers to the beginning of each evaluation window.

All three models show increased first-position attention and reduced NLL, although the final attention magnitude varies across seeds. This provides quantitative evidence beyond a single training run or selected attention head.

We also completed 12 paired continuation runs: four gradient-update conditions for each of the three pretrained seeds, with 1,500 updates per run. Removing the first-position value-gradient contribution reduces subsequent first-position attention in all three seeds. The mean paired difference is −0.000414-0.000414, with a cross-seed 95% confidence interval of [−0.000590,−0.000239][-0.000590,-0.000239]; a norm-matched shuffled control produces almost no mean change.

We will bring the principal numerical results and causal-mask ablation into the main text, add variability bands to the multi-seed plots, and state the statistical unit for each estimate. Across-seed variation and article-bootstrap uncertainty will be reported separately. Deterministic synthetic experiments will be identified as such rather than presented as independent random repetitions.


2. Why the two-block model is informative, and how we examine relevance beyond it.

The two-block model is chosen to separate two processes that are otherwise difficult to analyze jointly: contextual information aggregation and subsequent attention selection. The first block distributes earlier-token information across contextual representations; the second learns which representations to attend to. This allows us to trace how causal visibility affects value learning and how that learning reinforces attention concentration.

This separation is also important for weak semantic tokens. A repeated token can be uninformative in its original identity but carry predictive information after aggregating its preceding context. The model therefore lets us analyze both why such a token attracts attention and why attending to it can remain compatible with correct prediction.

The simplified architecture serves this mechanistic purpose, while the Pythia checkpoint analyses and full-parameter continuation experiments above examine related predictions in pretrained multilayer language models on natural text. We will present these two roles explicitly: the controlled setting establishes the theoretical mechanism, and the real-model experiments test its observable implications beyond that setting.


3. A clearer proof roadmap and a more accessible main text.

We will reorganize Section 5 around the central argument rather than the technical recurrences. For the first-token result, the roadmap is: causal contextualization creates unequal exposure; this produces a target-aligned value-projection advantage; the advantage then reinforces attention through query-key learning. For weak semantic tokens, we will explain the distinction between the shared token's class-agnostic contribution and the predictive information carried by its contextual representation before presenting the supporting lemmas.

We will keep this conceptual roadmap in the main text, move lengthy intermediate inequalities to the appendix, and add a compact notation table and a theorem-to-lemma dependency summary. We will also explain where each assumption enters the argument, helping readers distinguish the main mechanism from the technical conditions used to prove it.

These changes will make the paper easier to follow while preserving the rigor of the analysis. Together with the new multi-seed measurements and uncertainty estimates, they directly address the concerns about empirical support, model relevance, and readability.

Reviewer_a9e6OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a theoretical analysis of attention sinks in causal autoregressive language models. They take the setting of a synthetic text dataset, where each token instance is used exactly once in the dataset at that same position, and the model as two concatenated single-head attention layers (with QK weight matrices combined), and study gradient descent using the softmax cross-entropy loss. They obtain several training dynamics results, such as concentration of attention on the first token and increase in value norm. Under some additional theoretical assumptions on the dataset to add some "semantic tokens", they show concentration of attention on semantic tokens. Finally, they argue that attention sinks do not compromise predictive accuracy.

Critical strengths
  • The analysis is very in-depth, rigorous, and looks reasonably sharp --- it plumbs as much as possible about the simplified theoretical setting, and describes the dynamics that lead to some empirical phenomena.
Critical weaknesses
  • There are not many experiments that relate to concrete testable predictions being made in the paper (for example studying the qualitative correctness of the statistical rates or the mechanisms in the theory).
  • There are also not many implications or predictions for real networks which are more than 2 stacked attention layers, without the toy data assumptions, etc. This limits the impact of the work.
  • This work is arguably not the first work to provide theoretical analysis of training dynamics leading to attention sinks, see for example [1]. Although the current work focuses more on theory, it might be too much of an overclaim to state "In this work, we provide the first rigorous theoretical analysis of the training dynamics underlying attention sinks in Transformers" (the first sentence of the Conclusion) or similar.

[1] Guo, Tianyu, et al. "Active-dormant attention heads: Mechanistically demystifying extreme-token phenomena in llms." arXiv preprint arXiv:2410.13835 (2024).

Questions for authors
  • Does this theory provide any concrete predictions or suggestions for training practical LLMs?
4 comments

Thank you for your thoughtful review and for recognizing the depth and rigor of our theoretical analysis. Your comments highlight an important opportunity to make the theory's testable predictions and relevance to practical models more explicit. We have conducted additional quantitative experiments and address your concerns as follows.


1. Concrete predictions and quantitative tests of the proposed mechanisms.

Our analysis makes predictions about the learning process, not only the final attention distribution. For the first-token sink, it identifies unequal exposure through causal contextualization as the source of the value-learning advantage. For weak semantic token sinks, it identifies how a shared recurring identity changes gradient accumulation in the D2 setting.

We tested these mechanisms through matched interventions:

Mechanism testedControl conditionComparison condition
Causal visibility in D1Full-context attention: 0.0250Causal attention: 0.9766
Token recurrence in D2Four distinct separator identities: 0.0011One repeated separator identity: 0.2662

D1 reports first-token attention; D2 reports total attention to the four separator positions. Within each comparison, dataset size, sequence length, initialization, and training budget are fixed. The D2 comparison also retains the same full-vocabulary prediction objective and separator positions.

The first intervention removes the positional asymmetry while preserving the prediction task; the second changes token recurrence without changing the sequence structure. These results directly test the mechanisms isolated by our theoretical construction. We will organize the revised experimental section around these prediction–intervention correspondences, so that the role of each experiment is immediately clear.


2. Predictions for deeper models and implications for practical training.

A particularly useful prediction concerns the interaction between value learning and attention allocation: changing the first-position value-gradient contribution should affect subsequent first-position attention. This suggests testing the training updates themselves, rather than relying only on attention maps after training.

We investigated this prediction in Pythia-160M through full-parameter continuation from pretraining step 1,000. Each condition was run for 1,500 updates across three independent pretraining seeds, with starting weights and training batches paired within each seed.

Training conditionMean first-position attention after continuation
Standard training0.006357
Remove half of the first-position value-gradient contribution0.006200
Remove the full first-position value-gradient contribution0.005942
Equal-norm shuffled-gradient control0.006358

Results are averaged across three pretrained seeds and all layers and heads. All model parameters remain trainable, and the forward attention computation is unchanged.

Full removal reduces first-position attention in all three seeds, with an average relative reduction of approximately 6.5%. Half-strength removal produces an intermediate effect, while the shuffled control remains close to standard training. The mean paired attention difference for full removal is −0.000414-0.000414, with a cross-seed 95% confidence interval of [−0.000590,−0.000239][-0.000590,-0.000239].

This is a modest but consistent effect during early continuation, supporting the predicted directional influence of value learning on attention evolution. Separately, our evaluation of pretrained checkpoints shows mean first-position attention increasing from 0.0051 to 0.1489 between steps 1,000 and 143,000, while mean NLL decreases from 5.339 to 3.715 across the same three seeds.

The practical implication is a concrete way to investigate and potentially influence attention concentration during training: measure position-specific value-gradient contributions and test targeted changes against norm-matched controls. Our experiments establish a measurable effect on attention allocation; they motivate further investigation of gradient-based training interventions rather than a claim that strong sinks have already been eliminated.

3. Relationship to Guo et al. (2024) and clarification of novelty.

Thank you for pointing us to Active-Dormant Attention Heads. Guo et al. provide a training-dynamics analysis of extreme-token phenomena, including mutual reinforcement between attention sinks and value-state drains. We will cite and discuss this work explicitly and remove the broad “first rigorous theoretical analysis” statement.

Our contribution concerns different sources of learning asymmetry. We isolate causal visibility and shared-token recurrence in two controlled data constructions, then analyze how contextual aggregation and the coupled learning of WVW_V and WQKW_{QK} produce attention concentration. We additionally explain how a weak semantic token can retain predictive information through its contextualized representation. This distinguishes the mechanisms analyzed here without relying on a general priority claim about training dynamics.

We will replace the opening sentence of the conclusion with:

We provide a training-dynamics analysis of first-token and weak semantic token attention sinks in a two-block Transformer, identifying how causal visibility and token recurrence shape their emergence under the stated conditions.

We believe the combination of these specific theoretical mechanisms and their quantitative tests constitutes a meaningful contribution. The revisions will make both the connection to prior work and the implications for practical models substantially clearer.

Thank you for the clarifications.

  1. Concrete predictions and quantitative tests of the proposed mechanisms.

I do not exactly understand what the tests, the proposed mechanisms, or the interventions actually are, as it uses a lot of new vocabulary/jargon that was not emphasized in the paper, meaning that the response is a bit unclear.

A particularly useful prediction concerns the interaction between value learning and attention allocation: changing the first-position value-gradient contribution should affect subsequent first-position attention.

(1) isn't this statement, as written, tautologically true by how the transformer forward pass and backprop are defined? Does theory make finer-grained predictions? (2) Why is this useful? If it is meaningful to dilute the attention concentration during training, as you later write, what is the benefit or downside in terms of loss, etc? (3) The effect of this intervention seems rather small, indeed removing half the gradient barely causes any change.

As a result of this discussion, I keep my score.

Thank you for your follow-up. We realize that our previous response focused too much on the additional experiments without clearly explaining what our theory actually establishes. We would like to clarify this distinction and further discuss the theoretical predictions, their significance, and the experimental results.

1. Does our theory make finer-grained predictions beyond general backpropagation?

You raise a good point that changing gradients can affect attention, which follows directly from backpropagation. However, our theory makes much more specific predictions about how attention sinks emerge.

In our first setting, all tokens are unique and attention is initially uniform. Our analysis shows that causal masking gives earlier tokens a systematically larger advantage in value learning, with the first token receiving the largest advantage. More importantly, we prove that this advantage leads to a persistent preference for the first position: its attention increases monotonically (Lemma 4.3) and eventually becomes highly concentrated (Theorem 4.2). Under the theorem's conditions, this concentration is guaranteed after two gradient steps and persists thereafter.

Our second setting establishes a complementary result: repeated weak semantic tokens can become attention sinks despite having little predictive information in their original embeddings. Theorem 4.4 provides a finite-time guarantee for this behavior under the corresponding assumptions.

Therefore, our theory predicts which tokens become preferred, how this preference develops during training, and when strong concentration is guaranteed. These conclusions go beyond the general observation that gradients influence attention.

2. Why is this useful, and what is the impact on loss?

Our primary goal is to understand why attention sinks emerge, rather than to develop a method for suppressing them.

An important insight from our analysis is that concentrating attention on seemingly uninformative tokens does not necessarily mean wasting attention. As shown in Section 4.3, these tokens can aggregate useful information from preceding contexts, allowing the model to maintain correct predictions despite highly concentrated attention.

This helps explain why attention sinks need not be detrimental and why understanding their formation and function matters when designing methods that modify attention distributions.

Regarding loss, in our Pythia-160M experiment, we resumed training from step 1,000 and removed the first-position contribution to the value-parameter updates. The resulting mean NLL difference was only +0.000007+0.000007 nat/token across three seeds, indicating no clear performance benefit or cost in this setting.

3. Why is the intervention effect small?

The intervention was applied during an early stage of training, when first-position attention was still very low (approximately 0.006), and strong attention sinks had not yet formed. The absolute change in attention is therefore indeed modest.

Nevertheless, removing the full first-position value-gradient contribution consistently reduced attention across all three seeds (from 0.006357 to 0.005942). Removing half produced an intermediate result (0.006200), while removing an equal-norm shuffled contribution had almost no effect (0.006358). These results support the predicted direction of the learning effect, although the intervention was not intended as a method for eliminating attention sinks.

We hope these clarifications better convey the main contribution of our work: understanding why gradient descent systematically develops strong attention preferences toward particular tokens, and how such seemingly counterintuitive behavior can remain compatible with accurate prediction.

Reviewer_yBV3OpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+2)
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper tries to explain the theoretical origin of attention sinks. The authors explain that causal masking causes parameters associated with the first token to accumulate disproportionate gradients, driving the formation of a first token attention sink, while high-frequency semantic tokens receive significantly larger gradients than other tokens and consequently absorb most of the attention. And they also claim that attention sinks are compatible with the Transformer’s predictive capacity.

Critical strengths

The idea the authors propose makes sense, and it is probably the explanation behind attention sink.

Critical weaknesses

I think the paper is interesting but I don't think it adds anything new to the discussion. The experiments show that the proposed behaviour happens numerically in the setting the authors chosen, I think tough that said results mostly reproduce the assumptions used to derive the theory. In fact, they don't really establish that the mechanism is robust, and they also don't provide a proper explanation of the already known causal-mask bias. Plus, I don't really get the structure of the paper: the authors went heavy on the theory in the main paper, but left the results that are actually meaningful in the appendix (for example I'd put the mask-removal experiment in the main paper).

More specifically, in the paper we find the claim that “causal masking causes parameters associated with the first token to accumulate disproportionate gradients” but the paper studies a very specifc situation (the first block is fixed and computes uniform prefix averages, tokens are orthogonal and unique across sequences, initialisation is specially chosen, plus only the second block is trained). So, I think that in this case the results show that causal masking can produce a sink in this construction, but they don't establish that the same gradient mechanism explains sink formation in ordinarily trained AR transformers. (Interesting the experiment in the appendix where the authors remove the attention mask, because it shows that removing the mask eliminates the first token’s advantage in the constructed setting, but under these very specific conditions, we can't really extend the results to LLMs).

An other problem is that the paper argues that frequent tokens become attention sinks because they accumulate larger gradients. But the fact that these tokens appear more often doesn't strictly mean that they produce a stronger learning signal, since the updates from examples with different targets can partly cancel too. In the appendix the paper tries to address this issue, but the argument relies on an early training setting with many possible outputs and not enough target classes. The frequency experiment provides additional support, but it also changes the number of sequences and their structure, and that makes the frequency contribution quite difficult to isolate. So, the results support a frequency-related mechanism in this particular setting, but they don't show that frequency is the general explanation for attention sinks.

Finally, the paper argues that attention sinks are compatible with accurate prediction. But I'd say that in this specific setting these results only show that concentrated attention doesn't prevent the correct classification, unfortunately this doesn't establish that it preserves performance on tasks that require a more general contextual understanding or generalisation. The experiment in the appendix reports attention weights without prediction accuracy or perplexity, so it doesn't really add that much.

I think this paper would is a good starting point, but the authors need to run experiments on real LLMs, and I understand that resources can be limited, but there are few models with checkpoints, like OLMo 1b and 7b, the Pythia suite, SmoLM, Amber. At this point a toy experiment can be meaningful only if the paper also contains complementary results on proper LLMs that point in the same direction.

About the causal mask bias (the authors cite this paper): Wu et al., “On the Emergence of Position Bias in Transformers” (2025) And also this other paper that is quite recent: Peng et al., “What Makes Position Zero Special? A Mechanistic Study of Position Zero Attention Sinks in LLMs” (2026) Plus, in Ruscio et al., "What are you sinking? A geometric approach on attention sink" (2025) the authors do study a bit the evolution of attention sinks using random matrix theory on Pythia checkpoints, and they found that a strong inductive bias for model with regular RoPE is the rotational matrix of the first token, that is an identity matrix.

Questions for authors

Why did you chose this specific approach to work on the mergence of attention sinks?

7 comments

Thank you for your thoughtful review and for recognizing that our proposed mechanism provides a plausible explanation for attention sinks. We also appreciate your constructive suggestions to validate our theory on real pretrained language models and to elevate key empirical analyses from the appendix into the main text.

Our goal is not simply to reproduce the attention-sink phenomenon in a simplified Transformer, but to understand why gradient descent systematically favors certain tokens and how this optimization preference develops into an attention sink. In response to your feedback, we have conducted new experiments on pretrained Pythia-160M checkpoints as well as strictly controlled synthetic ablations to further test our proposed mechanisms. We address your questions and concerns in detail below.


1. Motivation: Why These Formulations and a Two-Block Architecture?

Our starting point is a fundamental question: attention sinks frequently emerge on tokens with starkly different properties—the initial token is special due to its position in an autoregressive sequence, whereas punctuation and function words are special due to their corpus statistics. In natural language, structural position and token frequency are tightly entangled. We designed our theoretical framework to disentangle these two factors and identify the common optimization incentives behind them:

  • Isolating Structural vs. Statistical Asymmetries (D1\mathcal{D}_1 vs. D2\mathcal{D}_2):

  • D1\mathcal{D}_1 (Causal Visibility): By enforcing globally unique, orthogonal token instances across sequences and positions, D1\mathcal{D}_1 removes frequency-based confounding factors. Under causal masking, the first token is the only position visible to every subsequent token. D1\mathcal{D}_1 therefore isolates whether causal visibility alone creates a systematic gradient advantage in value learning (WVW_V) that subsequently drives query-key (WQKW_{QK}) concentration.

  • D2\mathcal{D}_2 (Token Recurrence): Conversely, D2\mathcal{D}_2 introduces a shared, class-agnostic delimiter token (ww) interleaved with sequence-specific semantic segments. This separates a token's statistical frequency from its intrinsic semantic informativeness, allowing us to examine why a frequently occurring but individually uninformative token can become a sink without impairing prediction.

  • Why a Two-Block Architecture is Minimal and Essential: A single-block Transformer cannot capture the context-carrier mechanism of weak semantic tokens. In our two-block formulation, Block 1 aggregates preceding context into intermediate representations, while Block 2 learns where to allocate attention over those representations. This separation makes it analytically tractable to show how a token that is uninformative in its raw embedding becomes predictive after contextualization.

  • Distinction from Prior Work:

  • Guo et al. (2024) characterize a mutual-reinforcement loop involving attention sinks, value-state drains, and residual-state peaks in active-dormant heads. Our work complements theirs by tracing how input-level causal visibility and token recurrence generate the initial gradient asymmetries that initiate WVW_V–WQKW_{QK} reinforcement.

  • Wu et al. (2025) and Peng et al. (2026) examine structural and circuit-level properties of positional bias and position-zero sinks. Our analysis instead characterizes parameter-level gradient updates across training steps and extends the theory to weak semantic token sinks.

  • Ruscio et al. (2025) interpret attention sinks geometrically as reference frames in representation space. Our framework identifies the underlying optimization signals driving attention concentration, including the distinct role of repeated shared tokens.


2. Causal Visibility Drives First-Token Optimization Advantage

Our theory establishes a causal chain: unequal causal exposure →\rightarrow value-projection dominance (WVW_V) →\rightarrow query-key attention concentration (WQKW_{QK}) (Lemma 4.3 & Theorem 4.2). To verify that causal masking is the decisive driver rather than an artifact of data geometry or initialization, we performed a matched ablation on D1\mathcal{D}_1 with identical data, initialization, and training hyperparameters, varying only the first-block attention mask:

First-Block Attention MaskFinal First-Token Attention
Causal Masking0.9766
Full-Context Attention0.0250

Removing the causal mask eliminates first-token dominance completely, leaving attention uniform (0.0250). We will move this ablation directly into the main paper.

3. Pretrained Language Models Exhibit Progressive, Position-Anchored Sink Growth

To test whether these dynamics extend to standard autoregressive LLMs, we evaluated Pythia-160M checkpoints on WikiText-2 across all layers, heads, and three independent pretraining seeds:

Pretraining StepMean First-Position AttentionMean NLL
1,0000.00515.339
143,0000.14893.715
  • Progressive Emergence: Across all three seeds, mean first-position attention increases ~29-fold during pretraining alongside declining NLL, demonstrating that sink behavior emerges progressively via optimization.
  • Position vs. Token Identity Swap: To separate positional bias from lexical identity, we swapped the first token with tokens at positions 32, 64, and 96. Averaged across all three seeds and swap positions, attention to position 0 remained at 0.1371, while attention to the relocated original token dropped to 0.0047. This confirms that the learned sink is tied to causal positional visibility rather than token identity.

4. Direct Gradient Interventions in Pythia-160M Support the WV→WQKW_V \rightarrow W_{QK} Pathway

To directly test whether value-gradient asymmetry influences attention evolution in a real LLM, we continued full-parameter training of Pythia-160M from step 1,000 across three independent seeds (with paired initializations and batches) under four conditions:

Training ConditionMean First-Position Attention
Standard Continuation0.006357
Half-Strength Removal (50% first-position WVW_V-grad)0.006200
Full Removal (100% first-position WVW_V-grad)0.005942
Equal-Norm Shuffled Control0.006358

Suppressing the first-position value-gradient contribution produces a consistent, dose-dependent reduction across all seeds (~6.5% relative decrease under full removal), whereas an equal-norm shuffled-gradient control leaves attention unchanged (0.006358 vs. 0.006357). This direction-specific response provides direct empirical support in a pretrained LLM for the WVW_V-to-WQKW_{QK} mechanism predicted by our theory.

5. Frequency and Target Coherence Jointly Govern Gradient Accumulation

Regarding gradient cancellation in weak semantic token sinks, Lemma 4.5 explicitly separates the class-agnostic embedding projection (where gradients from opposing targets cancel) from the class-discriminative signal aggregated via causal context. To isolate the roles of token frequency and target alignment without altering sequence count, sequence length, anchor groups, or initialization, we measured anchor-projected second-block value gradients:

Token FrequencyTarget ConfigurationIndividual Gradient NormNet Gradient Norm
1 occurrenceConsistent0.20610.2061
4 occurrencesConsistent0.40320.4032
1 occurrenceBalanced (opposing targets)0.2061≈0\approx 0
4 occurrencesBalanced (opposing targets)0.4032≈0\approx 0
  • Frequency ×\times Coherence Interplay: Higher occurrence frequency amplifies per-instance gradient norm (~1.96$\times$), while target alignment determines whether these updates accumulate into a strong net signal or cancel out.
  • Strictly Matched Separator-Identity Ablation on D2\mathcal{D}_2: To avoid any structural confounding factors, we conducted a new matched experiment on D2\mathcal{D}_2 holding the four separator positions, dataset size, and dimensions completely fixed, varying only whether the four separators share a single repeated token identity or use four distinct identities. Using a single repeated identity increases separator attention from 0.11% to 26.62%, cleanly isolating the effect of token recurrence.

6. Context-Carrier Mechanism and Adaptability in Real LLMs

Our theory resolves the apparent tension between attention concentration and prediction accuracy through the context-carrier mechanism: although a weak semantic token's static embedding is class-agnostic, causal attention in Block 1 aggregates preceding semantic signals into its contextual representation (Lemma 4.5 & Eq. 13).

To examine how sink pathways support and adapt during general language modeling, we persistently masked a high-attention sink pathway in Pythia-160M and continued full-model training for 500 updates:

ConfigurationInitial NLLNLL after 500 Updates
Standard Continuation3.28463.2303
Selected Sink Pathway Masked3.44243.2137

Masking the sink pathway induces an immediate NLL penalty (3.4424 vs. 3.2846), demonstrating that the sink actively carries predictive context rather than serving as an idle artifact. Over 500 updates, however, the model redistributes computation and recovers competitive language-modeling performance, yielding a final paired NLL difference of -0.01654 (95% CI: [-0.03551, 0.00244]), well within our predefined 0.01 nat/token0.01\text{ nat/token} non-inferiority margin.


Thank you again for your insightful feedback and constructive suggestions, which have helped us substantially strengthen both the empirical validation and presentation of our work. We will incorporate all of these new results, clarifications, and structural revisions into the updated manuscript, and we hope our response has addressed your concerns.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.