- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes SymDiff Planner, which extends a diffusion-based trajectory planner with a reverse attention assignment branch and a conditional gate controlling its intensity. The design aims to complement standard trajectory-to-scene attention with scene-to-trajectory assignment. Evaluation on nuPlan includes closed-loop comparisons, component ablations, and plug-in experiments across three planner backbones.
Critical strengths
- The closed-loop evaluation covers both non-reactive and reactive traffic across three nuPlan splits. The improvements, particularly on Test14-hard under non-reactive evaluation, suggest that the decoder modification has practical value.
- The plug-in experiments report gains across regression, flow-matching, and diffusion planners. This suggests that the proposed module may be useful beyond a single backbone.
Critical weaknesses
- The motivation for interaction symmetry is not sufficiently established. The paper argues that one-sided cross-attention conflicts with joint multi-agent generation, but joint modeling does not inherently require symmetric assignment. The proposed attention branch and gate are intuitively reasonable, yet the analysis does not clearly establish what useful property this symmetry provides beyond an alternative way of aggregating scene features. Its connection to diffusion modeling is also unclear.
- The experiments don't isolate the claimed source of improvement. The ablations show benefits from adding the modules, but lack capacity-matched comparisons, such as an additional standard cross-attention branch. It remains unclear whether the gains come from the proposed assignment direction, additional parameters, or stronger scene conditioning.
Questions for authors
- Could you clarify why joint multi-agent generation needs symmetric assignment, and what benefit the proposed design provides over standard cross-attention? Is the argument specific to diffusion, or is this a general attention modification?
- Have you compared models with a similar number of parameters that differ only in which axis the attention weights are normalized over? These would help determine whether the gains support the symmetry motivation rather than additional model capacity.
- How is the “ASM only” variant implemented in Table 3, given that ASM is defined as a gate on the reverse branch introduced by DRA?
We thank the reviewer. All changes and additions are included in the revised PDF. The revised version renumbers some items; your Table 3 corresponds to Table 4 here, and all references below use the revised numbering.
Comment 1 (W1/Q1): Why symmetry, what benefit, and diffusion-specificity
Comment 2 (W2/Q2): Capacity and normalization-axis controls
Comment 3 (Q3): Implementation of the ASM-only variant
We will promptly address any further questions the reviewer may have.