- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the problem of blur issue of 3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS), which called "blur trap" in this paper. The blur trap comes from two main reasons: (1) the orthogonality between the dominant position gradient and the viewing ray, which limits depth optimization, particularly for distant Gaussian primitives; and (2) gradient attenuation caused by alpha-blending, which weakens the densification signal for occluded Gaussian primitives. To solve the problem, this paper proposed two simple exploration strategies: Random Seeding and Random Splitting. Random Seeding generates some random gaussian primitives at randomly sampled 3D positions. Random Splitting randomly selects existing Gaussian primitives for splitting, with a preference for larger ones. The experiment result shows this paper achieves overall better novel view synthesis result compared with other baselines.
Critical strengths
- The paper provides a detailed analysis of potential causes of blurring artifacts in 3DGS, supported by both theoretical derivations and experimental observations.
- The paper conducts extensive experiments across multiple datasets and demonstrates competitive or improved novel view synthesis performance compared to existing methods.
Critical weaknesses
- Though this paper devotes substantial effort to analyzing the reasons of blur, the proposed solution essentially relies on randomly introducing or splitting Gaussian primitives during training. However, neither Random Seeding nor Random Splitting explicitly identifies or targets the specific failure modes discussed in the theoretical analysis. Random Seeding does not identify regions suffering from insufficient depth gradients, and Random Splitting does not explicitly account for gradient attenuation caused by occlusion. In my opinion, the paper somewhat overstates the relationship between its theoretical findings and methodological contributions. Given the simplicity of the proposed approach, I find the methodological novelty and overall contribution somewhat limited.
- Adding more gaussian primtives would naturally increase the performance. Therefore, it is important to distinguish improvements resulting from the proposed exploration strategies from those caused by changes in the number and distribution of Gaussian primitives. Although Table 9 reports the final number of Gaussian primitives and shows that the proposed method does not consistently increase the primitive count, the paper also modifies the Gaussian pruning threshold, which may affect both the number and distribution of the retained primitives. Further experiments under the same pruning settings and comparable Gaussian budgets are needed to better validate the effectiveness of the proposed strategies.
Questions for authors
Please refer to "critical weakness".