acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Passing Is Not Learning: Rethinking Guidance in Coding Agent Training

Abstract

Teacher guidance can turn failed coding attempts into verified successes, but these guided successes do not necessarily yield independent problem solving. We study terminal and repository-repair tasks that a 9B coding agent persistently fails after standard reinforcement learning, asking what guidance leaves behind once removed. Distilling autonomous, hint-assisted, and teacher trajectories improves unaided performance on intervention tasks but yields little gain on held-out tasks when privileged channels are blocked. Audits further show that success filtering also favors trajectories accessing privileged information, while open-channel evaluation can overstate unaided capability. We therefore propose Hint-Twin Coupled Reinforcement Learning (HTC-RL), a two-stage recipe that first distills mixed trajectories under hint-free contexts, then couples reinforcement learning on unhinted rollouts with hint-free online distillation of successful hinted rollouts. The complete recipe achieves 28.1 on Terminal-Bench 2.1 and 57.2 on SWE-bench Verified, 4.5 and 6.4 points above our Stage 0 standard-RL baseline. Against plain RL from the same distilled initialization, its gains extend beyond the initial demonstrations: on 197 terminal tasks absent from those demonstrations but included in continued training, it solves 16 versus 6. On 600 Stage 0-screened hard tasks from repositories excluded from our post-training recipe, it reaches 7.2% unaided 8, versus 5.2% for plain RL. Guidance should therefore be judged by the independent capability acquired from it, not simply by the passes it enables.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
coding agent, distillation, reinforcement learning, large language models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_2eoUOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies model improvements obtained in distillation with guidance transfer once the teacher hints are removed. Across terminal and repository repair tasks, a 9B model after distillation, improves performance on practiced tasks but fails to transfer to held-out tasks. To address this problem, the paper proposes Hint-Twin Coupled Reinforcement Learning (HTC-RL), combining reinforcement learning from unhinted rollouts with online distillation of successful hinted trajectories under hint-free contexts. The proposed approach achieves 28.1% on Terminal-Bench 2.1 and 57.2% on SWE-bench Verified, outperforming standard RL from the same distilled checkpoint.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper tackles a very important problem in the area of distillation via RL differentiating the model’s performance on guided signals vs independent problem solving. This is essential to see if the prompt scaffolds provide the information needed and if the task instructions provided in training are internalized into the weights at inference time.
  2. To address sparse rewards on difficult tasks, the paper preserves unhinted policy gradient updates while learning from hinted success. This makes HTC-RL a simple RL strategy to handle a very important problem.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Combining guided self-distillation with reinforcement learning overlaps with existing approaches, including Hindsight Hint Distillation, ReLIFT, and related joint SFT/RL methods and the relevant literature. The paper should differentiate why modification of those approaches won’t work here and why there is a need for a newer one.
  2. While the paper argues that success filtering favors trajectories accessing privileged information, there is a high chance that the privileged information enters the training data via the open channels in Stage 1. It is unclear if these trajectories were excluded. The teacher demonstration collections (K) in stage 1 were done using open channels / privileged channels containing a command naming the target commit.
  3. Insufficient statistical significance. The paper does not report confidence intervals or multi-seed runs. Several improvements on held-out tasks correspond to only three or four additional solved problems.
Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors provide results across multiple independent training seeds, together with confidence intervals or paired significance tests, particularly for the held-out evaluations?
  2. Does HTC-RL retain its advantage over plain RL when the total training-token or computational budget is matched?
6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 2eoU — Part 1/3

We greatly appreciate your careful review and recognition of the importance of distinguishing guided performance from independent problem solving. Our responses below address the related-work comparison, the Stage 1 data, and the statistical and training-budget questions.

References for this response are listed at the end of Part 3.

"(Q1) Reviewer: Combining guided self-distillation with reinforcement learning overlaps with existing approaches, including Hindsight Hint Distillation, ReLIFT, and related joint SFT/RL methods and the relevant literature. The paper should differentiate why modification of those approaches won’t work here and why there is a need for a newer one."

A1: We appreciate your suggestion to clarify the relationship to these methods. HTC-RL is designed for coding agents, with the goal of improving the student's independent performance beyond the training tasks, without teacher assistance.

HTC-RL shares with related work the use of guidance and combined training objectives, but our core design is two-stream online joint optimization using student-generated trajectories. In Stage 2, the continually updated student generates both hint-assisted and hint-free interaction trajectories for the same task. Verified hint-assisted successes provide supervised learning targets after the hint is removed from the training context, while hint-free trajectories provide reward-driven policy-gradient updates. The two objectives are optimized in the same parameter update. Thus, not only autonomous exploration but also the successful trajectories used for supervision are continually refreshed as the student policy evolves. The goal is to improve independent problem solving beyond the training tasks, rather than only performance under teacher assistance.

We evaluate this design in two representative coding-agent settings: repository-level software repair (SWE) and terminal interaction.

We summarize the comparison below.

Method comparison. The columns describe the reported training procedure and experimental coverage, rather than matched performance.

MethodTrainingHint-guided rolloutsJoint updateSWETerminal
HHD [1]Iterative SFT✓—✓—
Agent-RLVR [2]SFT followed by iterative offline DPO✓—✓—
ReLIFT [3]Interleaved RL / online SFT————
ECHO [4]RL + environment prediction—✓—✓
HTC-RLRL + online SFT✓✓✓✓

Joint update means that the policy-gradient and auxiliary supervised losses are optimized in the same parameter update; ReLIFT alternates RL and SFT updates. Hint-guided rollouts means student execution conditioned on a task-specific hint, not merely use of teacher data. SWE/Terminal indicate experiments reported in the cited version; a dash does not imply that a method cannot be adapted to that domain.

ReLIFT dynamically identifies difficult questions during RL and uses teacher solutions for SFT; these solutions may be collected in advance or obtained on demand. By contrast, the supervised targets in HTC-RL's Stage 2 are successful trajectories generated by the current student while executing tasks with hints. We remove those hints for supervision and jointly optimize this objective with independent RL. The distinction is therefore in the source of successful supervision, its training context, and its coupling with autonomous reward learning, rather than simply the presence of both SFT and RL.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 2eoU — Part 2/3

"(Q2) Reviewer: While the paper argues that success filtering favors trajectories accessing privileged information, there is a high chance that the privileged information enters the training data via the open channels in Stage 1. It is unclear if these trajectories were excluded. The teacher demonstration collections (K) in stage 1 were done using open channels / privileged channels containing a command naming the target commit."

A2: This is an important point that warrants a direct clarification. We did retain K trajectories that accessed privileged information, and used them in Stage 1 distillation. This was intentional in the diagnostic study: rather than removing these examples in advance, we examined whether apparently successful experience actually translated into independent ability.

The Stage 1 results in Table 1 of the original paper show the pattern that motivated this analysis: successful-trajectory distillation improves performance on the intervention tasks, while held-out performance remains largely unchanged. Together with the environment audit, this illustrates why success on the tasks supplying demonstrations should not be equated with improved independent problem solving on tasks outside the training data. It also highlights a limitation of ordinary distillation in this setting.

This observation motivates HTC-RL. In Stage 2, we combine dynamically generated successful-trajectory supervision with autonomous reinforcement learning to address the learning and transfer problem exposed by Stage 1. The core claim is that this combination improves independent performance beyond the training tasks.

"(Q3 & Q4) Reviewer: Insufficient statistical significance. The paper does not report confidence intervals or multi-seed runs. Several improvements on held-out tasks correspond to only three or four additional solved problems.

Could the authors provide results across multiple independent training seeds, together with confidence intervals or paired significance tests, particularly for the held-out evaluations?

Does HTC-RL retain its advantage over plain RL when the total training-token or computational budget is matched?"

A3 & A4: We agree that the training-budget comparison and statistical reporting need to be clearer. We first discuss the training-budget question, then present the additional control together with the three-run standard deviations.

The effect of the training-token budget deserves careful examination, particularly to distinguish the benefit of additional successful-trajectory supervision from that of HTC-RL's coupling mechanism. We understand that you are asking for more than just giving Plain RL the same training-token budget as HTC-RL. In Figure 3 of the original paper, HTC-RL stays ahead at the measured checkpoints after step 50, and the gap widens later in training: at step 150, it solves 40 terminal intervention tasks, compared with 30 for Plain RL. This trend suggests that simply training Plain RL for 10% more steps, from 150 to 165, would be unlikely to close the gap. We therefore also test Plain RL with additional supervision from successful trajectories, as described below.

We conduct an additional ablation, Plain RL + successful replays, which augments autonomous RL with supervised learning on successful trajectories collected in an HTC-RL run. For the current training task xx, it retrieves trajectories for that same task from a fixed pool and removes the hints before supervision. In contrast, HTC-RL generates its supervised trajectories online using the current student. The two training schemes are summarized below.

Source of supervision for an intervention task xx. Both variants also optimize autonomous RL.

MethodAutonomous RLSuccessful-trajectory supervision
HTC-RLCurrent student attempts xx without hintsCurrent student attempts xx with a hint; keep verified successes and remove the hint for SFT
Plain RL + successful replaysCurrent student attempts xx without hintsRetrieve successful HTC-RL trajectories for the same task from a fixed pool; remove hints for SFT
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 2eoU — Part 3/3

A3 & A4 (continued):

Both methods start from the same Stage 1 checkpoint and train for 150 updates. The table below extends Table 3 of the original paper with Plain RL + successful replays. Each setting was executed three times, and the corresponding standard deviations are included.

Results extending Table 3 of the original paper. Scores are unaided pass@8 (%), with standard deviations over three runs. All Stage 2 variants start from the same Stage 1 checkpoint and train for 150 updates.

ModelTerminal Intervention (251)Terminal Held-out (161)SWE Intervention (148)SWE Held-out (92)
Stage 1: SFT(A+B+K)9.2 ± 0.72.5 ± 0.616.2 ± 1.24.3 ± 1.1
Plain RL12.0 ± 1.13.7 ± 0.617.6 ± 1.25.4 ± 1.1
Hinted-only8.4 ± 0.82.5 ± 1.114.9 ± 1.25.4 ± 1.9
Plain RL + successful replays13.5 ± 0.83.1 ± 0.618.2 ± 1.45.4 ± 1.1
HTC-RL15.9 ± 1.15.6 ± 0.619.6 ± 1.49.8 ± 1.9

Adding successful replays modestly improves the intervention scores over Plain RL: from 12.0 to 13.5 on Terminal and from 17.6 to 18.2 on SWE. However, on the key held-out sets, the scores are unchanged or lower: 3.1 versus 3.7 on Terminal, and 5.4 versus 5.4 on SWE. Both baselines remain below HTC-RL, which achieves 15.9/5.6 on Terminal intervention/held-out and 19.6/9.8 on SWE intervention/held-out. These results support the value of coupling autonomous RL with dynamically refreshed, guided-success supervision, beyond simply replaying a fixed pool of successful trajectories.

Reference

[1] Shengjie Wang, Guanghe Li, Zonghan Yang, and Yang Gao. 2026. Hindsight Hint Distillation: Scaffolded Reasoning for SWE Agents from CoT-free Answers. arXiv:2605.11556.

[2] Jeff Da, Clinton Wang, Xiang Deng, Yuntao Ma, Nikhil Barhate, and Sean Hendryx. 2025. Agent-RLVR: Training Software Engineering Agents via Guidance and Environment Rewards. arXiv:2506.11425.

[3] Lu Ma et al. 2026. Learning What Reinforcement Learning Can't: Interleaved Online Fine-Tuning for Hardest Questions. ICLR 2026. arXiv:2506.07527.

[4] Vaishnavi Shrivastava, Piero Kauffmann, Ahmed Awadallah, and Dimitris Papailiopoulos. 2026. ECHO: Terminal Agents Learn World Models for Free. arXiv:2605.24517.

Reviewer_FGYfOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes an approach to use teacher guidance or hints to improve LLMs in terminal tasks that simple RLVR is not able to post-train for. The paper argues that "Passing is not learning", that although we can distill teacher trajectories into a student, it is still not guaranteed to learn how to perform the task at hand, especially on held out tasks. They propose a simple algorithm to mitigate this and show strong performance and generalization.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper's core method is simple and they motivate it with some preliminary analysis, which become the core tenets of their approach.
  2. The paper's results and ablations are good.
Critical weaknesses
  1. My main concerns about the paper is the lack of discussion on literature in the context of hint-based or curriculum based post-training. For instance, hint-based RLVR is not new and has been studied extensively [1,2,3], the method should compare against these strong baselines.

  2. More recently in this area of terminal agents, a new method called as ECHO [4] has been used. This paper has a very similar RLVR + lambda*SFT loss, the authors should compare against this method because their proposed approach is very similar. Another concern comes because of how close the methods resemble to each other, what are benefits of their proposed approach over the other, because this is a genuine "novelty" concern.

  3. Personally, I would prefer if the paper was rewritten a bit, especially the sections about the preliminary analysis. For instance, I don't think dividing the method into unrelated A,B and K is meaningful. This division is not logical and appears adhoc and the reader needs to remember what were these phases about.

[1] BREAD: Branched Rollouts from Expert Anchors Bridge SFT & RL for Reasoning, Neurips 2025 [2] Reuse your FLOPs: Scaling RL on Hard Problems by Conditioning on Very Off-Policy Prefixes, ICML 2026 [3] Learning to Reason under Off-Policy Guidance (LUFFY), Neurips 2025 [4] ECHO: Terminal Agents Learn World Models for Free, arxiv 06/2026

Questions for authors

See weaknesses above.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FGYf — Part 1/3

We greatly appreciate your constructive review and your positive assessment of the method's simplicity, experimental results, and ablations. Below we address the related-work and novelty concerns together, followed by the presentation issue.

References for this response are listed at the end of Part 3.

"(Q1 & Q2) Reviewer: My main concerns about the paper is the lack of discussion on literature in the context of hint-based or curriculum based post-training. For instance, hint-based RLVR is not new and has been studied extensively [1,2,3], the method should compare against these strong baselines.

More recently in this area of terminal agents, a new method called as ECHO [4] has been used. This paper has a very similar RLVR + lambda*SFT loss, the authors should compare against this method because their proposed approach is very similar. Another concern comes because of how close the methods resemble to each other, what are benefits of their proposed approach over the other, because this is a genuine "novelty" concern."

A1 & A2: Thank you for pointing us to these related papers, which we had not adequately included in the comparison. They share our interest in using external guidance to overcome learning barriers on difficult tasks. HTC-RL is designed for coding agents, with the goal of improving the student's independent performance on tasks outside training, without teacher assistance at inference time.

HTC-RL shares with related work the use of guidance and combined training objectives, but our core design is two-stream online joint optimization using student-generated trajectories. In Stage 2, the continually updated student generates both hint-assisted and hint-free interaction trajectories for the same task. Verified hint-assisted successes provide supervised learning targets after the hint is removed from the training context, while hint-free trajectories provide reward-driven policy-gradient updates. The two objectives are optimized in the same parameter update. Thus, not only autonomous exploration but also the successful trajectories used for supervision are continually refreshed as the student policy evolves. The goal is to improve independent problem solving beyond the training tasks, rather than only performance under teacher assistance.

We evaluate this design in two representative coding-agent settings: repository-level software repair (SWE) and terminal interaction.

The following table compares HTC-RL with the four methods you raised.

Comparison with the methods raised in your review. SWE/Terminal indicate experimental coverage reported in the cited papers.

MethodRL dataAuxiliary lossSWETerminal
BREAD [1]Prefix-guided rollouts¹———
PrefixRL [2]Guided + unguided rollouts———
LUFFY [3]Student + teacher traces—²——
ECHO [4]Unguided rolloutsEnvironment prediction—✓
HTC-RLUnguided rolloutsHint-free online SFT✓✓

¹BREAD introduces expert prefixes when independent sampling does not yield sufficient success. ²LUFFY incorporates teacher trajectories into mixed-policy RL; its importance weighting and policy shaping are part of that objective rather than a separate auxiliary supervised loss. Dashes in the SWE/Terminal columns indicate unreported task families, not inapplicability.

BREAD, PrefixRL, and LUFFY. BREAD and PrefixRL optimize student continuations conditioned on retained expert or off-policy prefixes; PrefixRL also trains on unguided rollouts. HTC-RL instead uses guided successes for supervised learning under a hint-free context while retaining RL on independently executed trajectories. LUFFY combines teacher trajectories and student rollouts in mixed-policy advantage computation. In HTC-RL, the guided successes come from the current student and are kept separate from the independent branch's advantage calculation.

ECHO. The key distinction is the supervision target. ECHO predicts environment responses in interaction trajectories, learning action consequences from both successful and unsuccessful interactions. HTC-RL supervises verified successful student actions, and removes the hints that supported their generation from the supervised training context. Thus, although both objectives add a cross-entropy term to policy-gradient learning, they differ in what is supervised, how the trajectories are obtained, and the context used for optimization.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FGYf — Part 2/3

A1 & A2 (continued):

Does this design provide benefits beyond additional successful supervision? We conduct an additional ablation, Plain RL + successful replays, which augments autonomous RL with supervised learning on successful trajectories collected in an HTC-RL run. For the current training task xx, it retrieves trajectories for that same task from a fixed pool and removes the hints before supervision. In contrast, HTC-RL generates its supervised trajectories online using the current student. The two training schemes are summarized below.

Source of supervision for an intervention task xx. Both variants also optimize autonomous RL.

MethodAutonomous RLSuccessful-trajectory supervision
HTC-RLCurrent student attempts xx without hintsCurrent student attempts xx with a hint; keep verified successes and remove the hint for SFT
Plain RL + successful replaysCurrent student attempts xx without hintsRetrieve successful HTC-RL trajectories for the same task from a fixed pool; remove hints for SFT

Both methods start from the same Stage 1 checkpoint and train for 150 updates. We add the new baseline to Table 3 of the original paper and report the standard deviation across three runs for each setting.

Results extending Table 3 of the original paper. Scores are unaided pass@8 (%), with standard deviations over three runs. All Stage 2 variants start from the same Stage 1 checkpoint and train for 150 updates.

ModelTerminal Intervention (251)Terminal Held-out (161)SWE Intervention (148)SWE Held-out (92)
Stage 1: SFT(A+B+K)9.2 ± 0.72.5 ± 0.616.2 ± 1.24.3 ± 1.1
Plain RL12.0 ± 1.13.7 ± 0.617.6 ± 1.25.4 ± 1.1
Hinted-only8.4 ± 0.82.5 ± 1.114.9 ± 1.25.4 ± 1.9
Plain RL + successful replays13.5 ± 0.83.1 ± 0.618.2 ± 1.45.4 ± 1.1
HTC-RL15.9 ± 1.15.6 ± 0.619.6 ± 1.49.8 ± 1.9

Adding successful replays modestly improves the intervention scores over Plain RL: from 12.0 to 13.5 on Terminal and from 17.6 to 18.2 on SWE. However, on the key held-out sets, the scores are unchanged or lower: 3.1 versus 3.7 on Terminal, and 5.4 versus 5.4 on SWE. Both baselines remain below HTC-RL, which achieves 15.9/5.6 on Terminal intervention/held-out and 19.6/9.8 on SWE intervention/held-out. These results support the value of coupling autonomous RL with dynamically refreshed, guided-success supervision, beyond simply replaying a fixed pool of successful trajectories.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FGYf — Part 3/3

"(Q3) Reviewer: Personally, I would prefer if the paper was rewritten a bit, especially the sections about the preliminary analysis. For instance, I don't think dividing the method into unrelated A,B and K is meaningful. This division is not logical and appears adhoc and the reader needs to remember what were these phases about."

A3: We agree with your assessment that the preliminary analysis needs clearer organization and more descriptive notation. We would first like to clarify that A, B, and K are related sources of successful experience, not three unrelated phases:

  • A: autonomous student trajectories. The student completes the task independently.
  • B: hint-assisted student trajectories. The teacher provides a diagnostic hint, and the student executes the task.
  • K: teacher-generated trajectories. The teacher executes the task directly.

The distinction is organized around who executes the task and what assistance the student receives. It allows us to study the learning effects of different sources of successful experience and their combinations. Table 1 of the original paper also shows that their value varies by domain: relative to A-only, adding B improves Terminal intervention performance by 5.6 percentage points, while adding K improves it by 2.8 points. On SWE, the corresponding improvements are 0.7 and 6.8 points. The subsequent held-out evaluations and environment audit examine whether these gains translate into independent ability and task transfer.

Our original naming treated A and B as the two student-executed sources commonly considered in guided-learning setups, while K denoted fully teacher-generated demonstrations, using Kimi as the teacher. In retrospect, these letters do not communicate the underlying distinctions well. We will replace them with the following descriptive names and notation, and highlight the corresponding changes in the revised manuscript.

Descriptive notation proposed for the manuscript revision.

OriginalDescriptive name and notationExecutor and assistance
AAutonomous student trajectories, Dauto\mathcal{D}_{\mathrm{auto}}Student executes without hints
BHint-assisted student trajectories, Dhint\mathcal{D}_{\mathrm{hint}}Student executes with a teacher's diagnostic hint
KTeacher-generated trajectories, Dteacher\mathcal{D}_{\mathrm{teacher}}Teacher executes the task directly

This makes the relationship explicit: the student acts independently → the teacher guides the student → the teacher acts directly. We will use this progression to reorganize the explanation and reduce the need for readers to remember arbitrary letter labels.

Reference

[1] Xuechen Zhang, Zijian Huang, Yingcong Li, Chenshun Ni, Jiasi Chen, and Samet Oymak. 2025. BREAD: Branched Rollouts from Expert Anchors Bridge SFT & RL for Reasoning. arXiv:2506.17211.

[2] Amrith Setlur, Zijian Wang, Andrew Cohen, Paria Rashidinejad, and Sang Michael Xie. 2026. Reuse your FLOPs: Scaling RL on Hard Problems by Conditioning on Very Off-Policy Prefixes. arXiv:2601.18795.

[3] Jianhao Yan, Yafu Li, Zican Hu, Zhi Wang, Ganqu Cui, Xiaoye Qu, Yu Cheng, and Yue Zhang. 2025. Learning to Reason under Off-Policy Guidance. arXiv:2504.14945.

[4] Vaishnavi Shrivastava, Piero Kauffmann, Ahmed Awadallah, and Dimitris Papailiopoulos. 2026. ECHO: Terminal Agents Learn World Models for Free. arXiv:2605.24517.

Reviewer_6C8yOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates whether successful experiences obtained under teacher guidance during coding-agent training can be converted into independent problem-solving ability. The authors find that hint-assisted trajectories may exploit privileged information that is unavailable to the model at actual deployment, and propose HTC-RL, which combines reinforcement learning on hint-free trajectories with supervised distillation of hint-assisted successful trajectories under a hint-free context. Experimental results show that the method outperforms the plain reinforcement learning baseline and achieves some improvement on additional hard tasks.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper focuses on a practical and important problem: completing a task under teacher guidance does not mean that the model possesses independent problem-solving ability. This perspective is inspiring for both the training and evaluation of coding agents.
  2. The analysis of privileged information channels reveals an easily overlooked issue: successful trajectories may depend on information that is unavailable to the model at deployment, thereby overestimating the actual benefits brought by guidance methods.
  3. HTC-RL combines hint-free reinforcement learning with supervised distillation of hint-assisted successful trajectories; the idea is relatively intuitive. In the experiments, the method outperforms the plain RL baseline on both main benchmarks, and the results on additional hard tasks also show a certain trend of improvement.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The distinction between HTC-RL and existing hint-assisted distillation and guided reinforcement learning methods is not sufficiently clear. In particular, the paper has not adequately explained whether the performance gains come from its specific coupling mechanism or from additional supervision on successful trajectories.
  2. HTC-RL uses about 10% more training tokens than plain RL, but there is no compute-budget-matched control experiment. In addition, ablations on key designs such as successful-trajectory filtering, zero policy-gradient advantage, and hint-free context distillation are insufficient, making it difficult to determine the actual contribution of each component.
  3. The paper's argument for generalization still requires caution. The 197 tasks that did not appear in Stage 1 demonstrations actually participated in Stage 2 training and therefore cannot serve as independent test tasks to demonstrate generalization; the 600 additional hard tasks provide some supplementary evidence, but the improvement is relatively limited.
  4. The experiments are mainly based on one 9B model and two types of coding tasks, and it remains unclear whether the method is equally effective for models with different capability levels, hints of different quality, and other task types.
  5. The effectiveness of HTC-RL may depend on the availability of high-quality hint trajectories, but the paper has not adequately analyzed the impact of hint quality and the successful-trajectory filtering mechanism on method performance.
Questions for authors
  1. What are the main technical differences between HTC-RL and hint-assisted distillation methods such as HHD? Can a more direct comparison show that its coupling mechanism brings additional benefits, rather than merely exploiting more successful trajectories?
  2. If the number of training tokens is controlled and the same successful-trajectory supervision is added to plain RL, can HTC-RL still achieve a clear advantage? Can the existing ablations further clarify the role of each key design?
  3. How large is the benefit of HTC-RL on tasks completely uninvolved in post-training? How do the authors rule out the possible influence of the base model's pretraining data, and determine whether the method can transfer to different models or tasks?
6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 6C8y — Part 1/3

We greatly appreciate your careful review! Our point-by-point responses are given below.

References for this response are listed at the end of Part 3.

"(Q1) Reviewer: What are the main technical differences between HTC-RL and hint-assisted distillation methods such as HHD? Can a more direct comparison show that its coupling mechanism brings additional benefits, rather than merely exploiting more successful trajectories?"

A1: You ask an insightful question about the source of HTC-RL's gains. We agree that using guidance or combining SFT with RL is not new. HTC-RL's contribution is how guided successes are coupled with independent RL.

In Stage 2, the current student attempts the same task with and without a hint. The unhinted trajectories provide reward-driven policy-gradient updates. Only verified successful hinted trajectories are used for SFT, with the hint removed from the supervised training context. We optimize the RL and SFT losses in the same parameter update. Unlike HHD's iterative SFT [1], this retains direct reward-driven learning from independent attempts.

Both streams are regenerated as the student policy changes. Thus, the successful trajectories used for supervision are also generated online by the current student, rather than coming from a fixed replay pool. The goal is to improve independent problem solving beyond the training tasks, not merely performance under teacher assistance.

We evaluate this design in two representative coding-agent settings: repository-level software repair (SWE) and terminal interaction.

We summarize the differences from related methods in the table below.

Method comparison. The columns describe the reported training procedure and experimental coverage, rather than matched performance.

MethodTrainingHint-guided rolloutsJoint updateSWETerminal
HHD [1]Iterative SFT✓—✓—
Agent-RLVR [2]SFT followed by iterative offline DPO✓—✓—
ReLIFT [3]Interleaved RL / online SFT————
ECHO [4]RL + environment prediction—✓—✓
HTC-RLRL + online SFT✓✓✓✓

Joint update means that the policy-gradient and auxiliary supervised losses are optimized in the same parameter update; ReLIFT alternates RL and SFT updates. Hint-guided rollouts means student execution conditioned on a task-specific hint, not merely use of teacher data. SWE/Terminal indicate experiments reported in the cited version; a dash does not imply that a method cannot be adapted to that domain.

In summary, HTC-RL couples unhinted reward learning with online imitation of verified hint-assisted student trajectories, removing hints from the supervised training context.

The additional experiment in our response to Q2 below examines whether the gains can be reproduced by simply adding successful-trajectory supervision.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 6C8y — Part 2/3

"(Q2) Reviewer: If the number of training tokens is controlled and the same successful-trajectory supervision is added to plain RL, can HTC-RL still achieve a clear advantage? Can the existing ablations further clarify the role of each key design?"

A2: We appreciate your suggestion to distinguish the effect of additional supervision from that of the training mechanism.

The effect of the training-token budget deserves careful examination, particularly to distinguish the benefit of additional successful-trajectory supervision from that of HTC-RL's coupling mechanism. We understand that you are asking for more than just giving Plain RL the same training-token budget as HTC-RL. In Figure 3 of the original paper, HTC-RL stays ahead at the measured checkpoints after step 50, and the gap widens later in training: at step 150, it solves 40 terminal intervention tasks, compared with 30 for Plain RL. This trend suggests that simply training Plain RL for 10% more steps, from 150 to 165, would be unlikely to close the gap. We therefore also test Plain RL with additional supervision from successful trajectories, as described below.

We conduct an additional ablation, Plain RL + successful replays, which augments autonomous RL with supervised learning on successful trajectories collected in an HTC-RL run. For the current training task xx, it retrieves trajectories for that same task from a fixed pool and removes the hints before supervision. In contrast, HTC-RL generates its supervised trajectories online using the current student. The two training schemes are summarized below.

Source of supervision for an intervention task xx. Both variants also optimize autonomous RL.

MethodAutonomous RLSuccessful-trajectory supervision
HTC-RLCurrent student attempts xx without hintsCurrent student attempts xx with a hint; keep verified successes and remove the hint for SFT
Plain RL + successful replaysCurrent student attempts xx without hintsRetrieve successful HTC-RL trajectories for the same task from a fixed pool; remove hints for SFT

Both methods start from the same Stage 1 checkpoint and train for 150 updates. We extend Table 3 of the original paper with the new replay baseline and report the standard deviation across three runs for each setting.

Results extending Table 3 of the original paper. Scores are unaided pass@8 (%), with standard deviations over three runs. All Stage 2 variants start from the same Stage 1 checkpoint and train for 150 updates.

ModelTerminal Intervention (251)Terminal Held-out (161)SWE Intervention (148)SWE Held-out (92)
Stage 1: SFT(A+B+K)9.2 ± 0.72.5 ± 0.616.2 ± 1.24.3 ± 1.1
Plain RL12.0 ± 1.13.7 ± 0.617.6 ± 1.25.4 ± 1.1
Hinted-only8.4 ± 0.82.5 ± 1.114.9 ± 1.25.4 ± 1.9
Plain RL + successful replays13.5 ± 0.83.1 ± 0.618.2 ± 1.45.4 ± 1.1
HTC-RL15.9 ± 1.15.6 ± 0.619.6 ± 1.49.8 ± 1.9

Adding successful replays modestly improves the intervention scores over Plain RL: from 12.0 to 13.5 on Terminal and from 17.6 to 18.2 on SWE. However, on the key held-out sets, the scores are unchanged or lower: 3.1 versus 3.7 on Terminal, and 5.4 versus 5.4 on SWE. Both baselines remain below HTC-RL, which achieves 15.9/5.6 on Terminal intervention/held-out and 19.6/9.8 on SWE intervention/held-out. These results support the value of coupling autonomous RL with dynamically refreshed, guided-success supervision, beyond simply replaying a fixed pool of successful trajectories.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 6C8y — Part 3/3

"(Q3) Reviewer: How large is the benefit of HTC-RL on tasks completely uninvolved in post-training? How do the authors rule out the possible influence of the base model's pretraining data, and determine whether the method can transfer to different models or tasks?"

A3: You raise an important question about the scope of HTC-RL's generalization. We are happy to discuss both the additional evidence and the practical considerations for extending the study.

Additional tasks outside our post-training setup. We evaluate HTC-RL and the baselines on agentic benchmarks BFCL v3 [5] and τ2\tau^2-bench [6]. For τ2\tau^2-bench, we average the airline, retail, and telecom domains with equal weight. The following table reports the mean and standard deviation over three evaluation runs. Stage 0 denotes our local reproduction of the Tmax recipe [7], not scores copied from the Tmax paper.

Additional benchmark results (%). Entries are means ± standard deviations over three evaluation runs. The τ2\tau^2-bench score is the equal-weight mean over airline, retail, and telecom.

Model / training stageBFCL v3τ2\tau^2-bench
Qwen3.5-9B31.8 ± 2.257.5 ± 1.6
Stage 0: local Tmax recipe48.0 ± 1.762.0 ± 2.0
Stage 1: SFT(A+B+K)31.3 ± 2.157.1 ± 1.7
Plain RL49.1 ± 1.963.3 ± 1.8
Plain RL + successful replays49.5 ± 1.765.1 ± 1.9
HTC-RL52.3 ± 1.869.5 ± 2.1

HTC-RL reaches 52.3 on BFCL v3 and 69.5 on τ2\tau^2-bench, compared with 49.1 and 63.3 for Plain RL and 49.5 and 65.1 for Plain RL + successful replays. These additional evaluations provide evidence of transfer beyond the two coding-agent task families used in our training study.

Base-model influence and cross-model evaluation. We have not yet completed an end-to-end experiment with another base model. In selecting an open model of comparable size and capability to Qwen3.5-9B, we found the set of suitable candidates limited. Repeating the full Stage 0–Stage 1–Stage 2 pipeline is also costly. Our approximate resource accounting is 6,100 A100 GPU-hours for Stage 0, 116 A100 GPU-hours for Stage 1, and 8,000 A100 GPU-hours for Stage 2, plus approximately USD 1,400 in teacher API costs for guidance and trajectories.

Our exploratory experience also suggests that the base model's pretrained capabilities materially affect whether this training pipeline can get started. Much of the Qwen3-8B work we initially considered focused on SFT for SWE tasks. In our own attempts to apply RL to Qwen3-8B on terminal tasks, successful rollouts were too sparse to provide a reliable learning signal. We therefore could not establish a reliable Stage 0 baseline in that setup, which in turn prevented us from running the complete HTC-RL pipeline with that model.

Reference

[1] Shengjie Wang, Guanghe Li, Zonghan Yang, and Yang Gao. 2026. Hindsight Hint Distillation: Scaffolded Reasoning for SWE Agents from CoT-free Answers. arXiv:2605.11556.

[2] Jeff Da, Clinton Wang, Xiang Deng, Yuntao Ma, Nikhil Barhate, and Sean Hendryx. 2025. Agent-RLVR: Training Software Engineering Agents via Guidance and Environment Rewards. arXiv:2506.11425.

[3] Lu Ma et al. 2026. Learning What Reinforcement Learning Can't: Interleaved Online Fine-Tuning for Hardest Questions. ICLR 2026. arXiv:2506.07527.

[4] Vaishnavi Shrivastava, Piero Kauffmann, Ahmed Awadallah, and Dimitris Papailiopoulos. 2026. ECHO: Terminal Agents Learn World Models for Free. arXiv:2605.24517.

[5] Huanzhi Mao et al. 2024. BFCL V3: Multi-Turn & Multi-Step Function Calling Evaluation. Berkeley Gorilla project report.

[6] Victor Barres, Honghua Dong, Soham Ray, Xujie Si, and Karthik Narasimhan. 2025. τ2\tau^2-Bench: Evaluating Conversational Agents in a Dual-Control Environment. arXiv:2506.07982.

[7] Hamish Ivison, Junjie Oscar Yin, Rulin Shao, Teng Xiao, Nathan Lambert, and Hannaneh Hajishirzi. 2026. Tmax: A Simple Recipe for Terminal Agents. arXiv:2606.23321.

Comments on the paper

2 comments

Thank you. We are happy that you like our answers, and we thank you again for your constructive suggestions. In the revised manuscript, we will incorporate the related-work discussion and rename the three data sources A, B, and K.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response

We thank all three reviewers for their constructive feedback. All three asked how HTC-RL differs from prior work. They also raised questions about the training-token budget (6C8y, 2eoU), whether adding supervision from successful trajectories to Plain RL can reproduce HTC-RL’s gains (6C8y), insufficient statistical significance (2eoU), and generalization beyond coding (6C8y).

In response, we conducted additional experiments and revised the manuscript as follows.

  • Comparison with prior work. Table 6 compares how HTC-RL and related methods use guidance during training. HHD uses iterative SFT on hinted trajectories, ReLIFT uses teacher solutions for supervision, and ECHO predicts environment responses. HTC-RL combines RL on unaided attempts with online SFT on the current student’s verified hinted successes on the same task, removing the hint before supervision.
  • Training budget and successful-trajectory replay. The added supervision brings HTC-RL’s total training-token count about 10% above Plain RL’s. Between updates 100 and 150, Plain RL goes from 28 to 30 terminal intervention tasks solved unaided, while HTC-RL goes from 34 to 40 (Figure 3). This trend suggests that giving Plain RL 10% more updates, from 150 to 165, would be unlikely to close the gap. We also tested a replay baseline, which augments Plain RL with supervision from a fixed pool of successful trajectories on the same tasks and uses roughly as many training tokens as HTC-RL. At update 150, HTC-RL achieves higher unaided pass@8 than replay on held-out terminal tasks (5.6% vs. 3.1%) and repository-repair tasks (9.8% vs. 5.4%).
  • Repeated evaluation and transfer beyond coding. Table 3 now reports standard deviations across three runs for the coding ablations. Across three evaluations per checkpoint on two additional agentic benchmarks, HTC-RL outperforms Plain RL by 3.2 points on BFCL v3 and 6.2 points on τ²-bench (Table 5).

We have uploaded the revised manuscript with changes marked in blue. Following FGYf’s suggestion, we also replaced A/B/K with descriptive names for the three sources of training trajectories.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.