- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper incorporates convex‑optimization principles into neural‑network modules to address the challenge from the ill‑posed non‑line‑of‑sight (NLOS) reconstruction problem. By introducing the Potential Assimilation Module (PAM) and the Resolvent Correction Module (RCM), the proposed SplitIR method outperforms existing CNN-based, Transformer-based and specialized NLOS imaging algorithms across multiple quantitative metrics on four distinct datasets. Extensive ablation studies and robustness evaluations further validate the effectiveness and limitations of the designed modules.
Critical strengths
- The Operator‑Splitting idea is conceptually novel. By combining convex optimization with deep‑learning architecture, the model interpretability is improved.
- The paper adopts a comprehensive set of comparison baselines. The ablation studies and robustness evaluations are thorough and well‑executed.
Critical weaknesses
- The learned metric, center, coordinate-wise radius in this paper are dynamically predicted by neural networks during the forward propagation. While such a paradigm is common for plug‑and‑play hybrid deep‑unfolding architectures, it raises interpretability concerns. The paper provides no validation to verify whether these network‑predicted parameters are physically meaningful or accurate. Moreover, lacking online correction mechanisms, these learned predictions may produce invalid outputs when test samples deviate from the training distribution, e.g., under mismatched scene geometry or noise levels.
- Five competing baselines (DRS, Flatland, NLOS‑OT, TransiT, PromptIR) yield identical quantitative metrics on the Password dataset. The provided qualitative output of NLOS‑OT is an all‑white reconstruction, which appears abnormal.
Questions for authors
- How do these adaptive parameters (metric, center, radius) behave in practice? I suggest the authors to add supplementary statistics or visualizations to verify or interprete the parameter design. Moreover, as the training loss consists purely of reconstruction‑oriented objectives, there are no additional loss terms to regularize the values of these dynamically predicted parameters. It is also suggested to investigate the benefits of introducing appropriate prior‑based penalty terms.
- I strongly suggest the authors to clarify the baseline metrics. Does the designed experimental setup appear to be so specialized that these baselines cannot adapt to, or does the training process simply collapse when reproducing these comparison methods?