- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
GeoPert addresses single-cell perturbation prediction by modeling variation across population distributions and among cells within each population. It represents each population through a finite vector of Fisher–Rao MMD distances to selected anchor populations. A conditional diffusion model generates these population signatures from pretrained gene embeddings, and a stochastic decoder maps each signature and independent Gaussian noise to individual expression profiles. This separation also enables augmentation using synthetic populations with computable signatures. The paper provides theoretical justification for the population distance and coverage-dependent guarantees for the anchor representation, and evaluates the method on unseen single-gene perturbations across four cell lines and on combinatorial perturbations in the Norman dataset.
Critical strengths
The method is very interesting. I particularly like the idea of predicting the anchor distances as a parametrization of a population distribution. The decoder, using that signature together with Gaussian noise as a way to sample from the population, is also a great way to parametrize the sampling. While the overall formulation is similar to PerturbDiff, I think the multilateration idea and doing diffusion directly in this space are substantial contributions.
The theory backing the method is well-established, and the paper is well written. With the square-root map, normalized expression profiles are embedded into a hypersphere and the Fisher–Rao distance becomes the angular distance. This is quite intuitive to me. Using medoid-initialized farthest-first traversal to select anchors also seems well motivated, especially how Proposition 1 leads into this choice.
Critical weaknesses
The experiments are a bit weak. I would like to see some ablations on the main parts of the method, particularly whether stochastic population modelling meaningfully contributes performance improvements, and how much the method depends on pretrained gene embeddings. I would also want to see performance on larger scRNA-seq datasets if compute permits, e.g. PBMC.
A minor comment: Figure 3 is too small to be legible, especially the legend in Figure 3(d).
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors explicitly describe how the candidate collection in Equations (9)–(10) is constructed? From the implementation, my understanding is that each candidate comprises all retained cells for one training perturbation, pooled across batches, and that the selected anchors remain fixed during training. Is this correct? How should the anchor count be chosen when fewer than 100 training populations are available?
-
Which grouping strategy was used for the reported experiments? Please clarify the discrepancy between the batch-based default described in Appendix D.1 and the random grouping specified in the released configurations, and explain how the modeled population variability should be interpreted when random partitions are used.
-
Could the authors compare stochastic signature generation with a deterministic signature predictor while retaining the same stochastic cell decoder and decoder-training setup? This would help establish whether modeling multiple possible population distributions contributes beyond modeling variation among cells within a single predicted population.
-
Beyond comparing different pretrained embedding sources, could the authors quantify the dependence on pretraining itself—for example, using embeddings learned from scratch or one-hot conditioning as controls? Please specify how unseen perturbation genes are handled so that these comparisons can be interpreted appropriately.
6 comments
Q2: Which grouping strategy was actually used in the reported experiments, and how should population variability be interpreted when random rather than batch-based grouping is used?
Answer: We thank the reviewer for requesting this clarification. We used batch-defined groups for K562, RPE1, HepG2, and Jurkat, and random groups for Norman. Although the original Norman experiment processed cells across eight 10x Chromium lanes, labeled as gemgroups 1–8, the GEARS-processed file used in our experiments does not retain the corresponding batch annotations. Technical batching can introduce variability within the same perturbation, as illustrated by our batch-resolved analysis. Such variability may remain in the pooled data even when batch annotations are unavailable. In this setting, we randomly partition cells within each perturbation to construct multiple empirical populations. Each population has its own RKHS mean embedding, yielding multiple population representations in place of a single pooled representation.
This procedure provides population-level augmentation for learning responses across different empirical realizations. Our Norman ablation supports the predictive benefit of this strategy fig9: performance improves as the number of groups increases from one to three, with three groups achieving the highest Pearson Delta and lowest RMSE. These results support modeling variability among empirical populations even without batch annotations.
Q3: Does stochastic population-signature generation provide benefits beyond modeling variation among cells within a single predicted population, compared with a deterministic signature predictor?
Answer: We appreciate the reviewer raising this important question about the necessity of meta-distribution modeling. We agree that stochastic population modeling is not strictly necessary in every setting. When only one replicate is available per perturbation, deterministic and stochastic signature prediction cannot be meaningfully distinguished from the observed data alone. However, when multiple replicates exist, their variability must be addressed rather than simply discarded through aggregation. GeoPert provides a unified way to characterize both the central tendency and variability of perturbation responses. Specifically, an empirical Fréchet mean minimizes the average Energy Distance to individual replicate distributions and represents their prototypical consensus response fig2a. Beyond this central estimate, stochastic sampling from the meta-distribution captures the range of possible population realizations fig3.
This distinction is particularly relevant when experimental conditions differ across batches or sequencing platforms. A deterministic predictor collapses each perturbation into one signature, whereas GeoPert can represent multiple possible population-level outcomes. Its architecture can also be extended to incorporate platform-specific conditioning, although suitable multi-platform perturbation benchmarks are currently lacking.
We recognize that estimating a reliable meta-distribution requires sufficient replicate observations, and current public perturbation datasets remain limited in this respect. To directly isolate the contribution of hierarchical modeling, we introduced a deterministic signature predictor while retaining the same stochastic decoder and training objective. Hierarchical modeling consistently improves Pearson Delta and RMSE across all four datasets fig2c.
Furthermore, the DDX47 and RPS28 analyses fig3 reveal substantial batch-associated variation, including occasional reversals in individual batches. Averaging multiple predicted population realizations recovers the predominant response directions across batches, demonstrating how GeoPert can extract more conservative perturbation effects while retaining population-level variability.
We sincerely appreciate the reviewer’s careful reading of our manuscript and the thoughtful questions raised during the review. We are grateful that the reviewer engaged deeply with the central ideas of our work and highlighted several important questions regarding the modeling assumptions, geometric representation, and empirical validation of GeoPert. We believe that such constructive discussions are valuable for strengthening the work, and we address each concern in detail below.
Q1: How are the anchor candidate populations constructed, selected, and fixed during training, and how should the anchor number be chosen when fewer than 100 candidates are available?
Answer: Our goal is to model, for each perturbation, a distribution over the RKHS embeddings of its constituent subpopulations. Accordingly, candidates are constructed at the perturbation × batch level: each candidate comprises all retained cells from one training perturbation within one batch. Farthest-first iteratively selects the candidate whose distance to its nearest existing anchor is largest, favoring broad geometric coverage. This discourages redundant selection of nearby batch populations from the same perturbation, while allowing multiple batches to be selected when their distributions differ sufficiently.
The anchors are selected once and remain fixed, including their defining cell collections, throughout all training phases. They therefore provide a consistent reference system for population representations.
When fewer than 100 candidate populations are available, all candidates are used as anchors; the small candidate pool keeps the computational cost manageable. So actually, we use M=min(Mdefault,∣C∣), with Mdefault=100. We apologize for not describing these details sufficiently clearly and will make them explicit in the camera-ready version if the paper is accepted.