acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Self-Improving Robot Skills for Long-Horizon Tasks via Recursive State-Aware Credit Assignment

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

11 views

Abstract

Long-horizon robot programs can fail when early operations leave states that compromise later execution. We present Recursive State-Aware Credit (RSAC) for improving robot skills through program revision, with the language model and action primitives fixed. Continuations of unchanged program suffixes from saved stage exits estimate how intermediate states support complete-task success. State-aware credit (SA) separates local passage deficits from poor exit-state quality. RSAC recursively compares gains in terminal-outcome dependence across stage boundaries to select an editing region for the current program. Execution experience guides localized revisions, and paired full-task validation determines adoption for the next iteration. Across eight simulated quadrupedal robot tasks, with ten independent optimization runs per task and configuration, RSAC achieves 44.4% task-averaged success, compared with 30.3% for ASPIRE and 35.4% for one-step localization. Controlled interventions and online revisions connect the diagnostic evidence to concrete program changes and improved task performance.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
robot learning, long-horizon tasks, skill self-improvement, large language models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_M76QOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Recursive State-Aware Credit assignment (RSAC), a method that iteratively improves a code-as-policy approach to robot learning. Given an initial policy expressed in code, RSAC will save checkpoints throughout execution as the policy progresses through stages of the code. With a handful of stages and checkpoints, RSAC then runs several rollouts from each checkpoint to estimate that checkpoint's individual success-rate. RSAC then applies an LLM to update the code to improve success rates from the various stage checkpoints, validating with full end-to-end rollouts to ensure that the fixes do not cause performance regressions.

Critical strengths
  • The paper proposes an iterative improvement strategy to a code-as-policy approach to robot learning, which enables backprop-free and interpretable policies for robots.
  • RSAC seems to perform well against baselines, and the components are ablated and demonstrated to contribute to overall success.
Critical weaknesses
  • The paper is almost impossible to understand. Variables are acronyms are entirely undefined, even those which seem very important to the paper (for example "SA" is used frequently but is never defined, the variable YY in equation 3 seems important but is likewise not defined, and many others exist in the paper). The method is impenetrable, I would absolutely not be able to reproduce this.
  • The results, like the method, are very difficult to parse and follow. The exact experimental setup is not clear -- the paper says that 3 iterations of program improvement were given, yet RSAC defines a method which seems to require significantly more than three rollouts to estimate success rates, make policy updates, validate that no updates have caused regressions, etc. At each update iteration, methods had equal rollout count, but it is not clear what this count was, or if it was fair to other methods (which may rely on more iterations and fewer rollouts).

Ultimately, the primary and overwhelmingly strong weakness of this paper is its legibility. This paper seems to have been entirely LLM generated after prompting with a code repo and results directory, from the text to the figures. It does not serve as a useful contribution to the community, as it is not clear enough to offer learnings or insights to the broader community.

Questions for authors

I do not know where to begin with questions. I would need a significant rewrite to have meaningful and interesting questions about the work.

Reviewer_AQJiOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a framework for improving long-horizon robot programs through iterative code revision while keeping the language model and low-level controllers fixed. The key idea is to identify program stages responsible for downstream failures by evaluating intermediate states through fixed-suffix continuations. Experiments on simulated quadrupedal robot tasks show performance improvements over selected baselines.

Critical strengths
  • The credit assignment rule appears to be principled.
  • A Theorem attempts to establish a connection between boundary gains and marginal recovery through replay under explicit assumptions (in Appendix A).
  • Empirical performance appears to be strong within the tested tasks and evaluated baselines. Ablations and intervention studies are performed.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited evidence for deep recursive localization. Among 135 online decisions, 83% retain the initial stage, 17% redirect one stage upstream, and none redirect multiple stages upstream (from Table 10).
  2. Computational overheads are unclear. Comparative computational costs, including simulator steps and wall-clock time, are not quantified nor reported.
  3. Insufficient realistic evaluations: All experiments use one single MuJoCo robot environment with predefined stages and restorable simulator states. No real-robot experiments are conducted. Generalizability to other settings and reliability in real-world conditions are not demonstrated.
Questions for authors

See weaknesses.

Reviewer_v3wGOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper tackles the problem of adapting robotic programs through detection of failure points through multiple stages of execution. As the main contribution, the authors define state-aware credit and gain as metrics derived from success rates estimated from checkpointed rollouts at different exit points. They show that the state aware credit jointly measures local pass and exit-quality deficits and that the gain measures marginal recovery properties. This is then used to define an algorithm which selects code regions for revision by an LLM, which is then subsequently validated using paired outcomes from checkpoints. The method is then evaluated across 8 MuJoCo-based quadruped tasks, where it shows improvements in mean success rate over three baselines.

Critical strengths
  • The derivation of success-rate based edit region detection is a nice grounding of the method in theoretic considerations, which adds novelty to the field and potentially opens doors for similar considerations in other problems with task dependencies.
Critical weaknesses
  • The stated setting is not really fitting: The authors motivate their method with "long-horizon robot tasks". Their evaluation considers a sequence of at most 8 sub-tasks, which is not really long-horizon, and they state in Appendix C.4 that in the analysed instances, 83% retain the initial focus, 17% move one stage up and none move the initial target at least two stages, so the evaluation setting does not seem to be fitting to investigate long horizons. Furthermore, the dependence on checkpointing and known editing regions for different subtasks makes the method very dependent on situations where good simulators are available and the robotic programs are structured a certain way.
  • Evaluation and statistical significance: The evaluation shows that the method performs best in all tasks, and while 200 seeds across 10 runs seem quite good, the given standard deviations are very high, mean ±\pm 1SD intervals of RSAC and ASPIRE overlap in 7/8 cases. No confidence intervals or statistical tests are given, so the significance of task level improvements cannot be verified. (Assuming the reported SDs are over the 10 runs, not all 2000 seeds, reconstruced 95% confidence intervals of the difference of means of ASPIRE and RSAC include zero in 5/8 cases.) Furthermore, although the ablations in the paper do provide evidence that the individual components as well as their combination add value, an ablation in edit region selection, e.g. random edit regions or giving the whole program for review, would be good as a stronger control that the region selection itself adds value.
Questions for authors
  • Is there evidence that the method can help in long-horizon tasks, where editing in regions many tasks before the failed task is necessary?
  • Are the improvement results statistically significant?
  • Is there a benefit of the selection method in comparison to random edit region selection?
  • Does this work on a real robot, given the restrictions?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.