- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SLatHarmony, a framework for local 3D editing that aims to preserve non-edited regions while maintaining geometric and texture consistency. The authors observe that existing methods often introduce unintended changes to non-edited regions, while directly combining source and edited SLat features can lead to geometric discontinuities and texture inconsistencies at the boundaries. To address these issues, the authors propose a shape SLat seamer to refine geometric transitions and a texture SLat harmonizer to reduce appearance mismatches between the original and edited regions.
The method is evaluated on Edit3D-Bench against three existing TRELLIS-based editing methods, along with several component-level ablation studies. The experimental results show improved preservation of non-edited geometry and appearance while maintaining competitive semantic alignment with the editing instructions. Overall, the paper presents a relatively straightforward and practical approach to addressing boundary consistency issues in local 3D editing.
Critical strengths
The authors propose a reasonable and straightforward method for addressing boundary inconsistencies in local 3D editing. The experimental results show promising improvements in preserving non-edited regions while maintaining competitive editing quality.
Critical weaknesses
- The experimental evaluation is not sufficiently comprehensive. The paper only compares against three existing methods, and the ablation studies are not thorough enough. In particular, the authors do not provide a comparison with direct SLat composition without the proposed modules, or an ablation that uses only the channel-wise texture shift without the learned residual correction. These experiments are important to understand whether the proposed modules are actually necessary and how much improvement they bring over simpler alternatives. Moreover, SLatHarmony uses a 512-resolution TRELLIS.2 configuration, while the baselines use 1024-resolution configurations, which raises additional concerns about the fairness of the comparisons. Overall, I feel that the current experimental evidence is not sufficiently convincing.
- The methodological novelty is relatively limited. While the proposed approach is reasonable, I find it somewhat engineering-oriented. The method mainly combines latent feature composition with relatively standard feature completion and alignment techniques. Although the results are promising, I am not convinced that these components offer sufficient technical novelty for a main conference like ICLR. In my opinion, the work may be more suitable for a workshop.
Questions for authors
- Regarding the experimental evaluation: I feel that the current experimental evaluation is not sufficiently comprehensive. The number of baselines is relatively limited, and the ablation studies are not thorough enough to fully justify the proposed design. More importantly, SLatHarmony uses the 512-resolution TRELLIS.2 configuration with a 32³ sparse grid, while the compared baselines use 1024-resolution configurations with 64³ sparse grids. This makes the experimental settings inconsistent across methods. Could the authors explain how this difference affects the fairness of the comparisons and provide more comprehensive experimental evidence to support their claims?
- Regarding the methodological novelty: Could the authors further clarify what the key technical novelty of the proposed method is, beyond combining existing feature completion and alignment techniques? I feel that the current design is relatively straightforward and engineering-oriented. It would be helpful to understand why these specific modules are necessary and what makes the proposed approach fundamentally different from simpler alternatives or existing SLat-based editing methods.