- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Reci-Q, a class-aware patch sampling curriculum for imbalanced 3D medical image segmentation. The method decouples class selection from spatial patch localization and introduces a reciprocal sampling schedule that transitions from class-balanced sampling to natural prevalence-based sampling and back. Experiments on five Medical Segmentation Decathlon tasks demonstrate improvements over the nnU-Net baseline, particularly for underrepresented classes, without additional models or loss modifications.
Critical strengths
-
The proposed method provides a lightweight, class-aware sampling strategy that can be easily integrated into existing segmentation frameworks without modifying network architectures, introducing auxiliary models, or increasing training complexity significantly. The reciprocal curriculum is intuitive and straightforward to implement.
-
The method is evaluated on five 3D medical segmentation tasks with different class imbalance characteristics. The experiments show improvements in both overall and tail-class Dice scores over the nnU-Net baseline. The ablation studies comparing static and dynamic sampling schedules also provide useful evidence for the effectiveness of the proposed curriculum.
Critical weaknesses
-
The method primarily combines existing class-aware sampling with a predefined curriculum. The choice of the reciprocal schedule lacks sufficient theoretical justification, and the implicit loss-reweighting interpretation is not rigorously established. Thus, the novelty is limited.
-
The comparisons with existing sampling methods are limited, and the reported improvements are relatively modest. The main experiment only compare the proposed method with four nnU-net based methods.
Questions for authors
- The first question is about the motivation of the specific reciprocal schedule (q:0\rightarrow1\rightarrow0)? Could the authors provide a more rigorous justification for why returning to class-balanced sampling improves generalization compared with other schedules, such as cosine or stepwise scheduling?
- In Eq. (5), background sampling selects anchor voxels uniformly from the entire volume, meaning that the actual anchor class may differ from the selected class. How does this affect the approximation in Eq. (9) and the claimed relationship between sampling probabilities and class-specific loss contributions?
- Could the authors include stronger class-aware patch sampling or adaptive curriculum baselines to better demonstrate the advantages of Reci-Q over existing sampling strategies?
- Since the experiments do not use a separate validation set, how were the curriculum schedule and phase ratio selected? Were these choices determined independently of the test sets?