acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

SeeFar: Separating Evidence, Temporal Records, and Relational State in Long-Term Agent Memory

Abstract

Persistent language-model agents must distinguish retrieved experience, tentative evidence, committed records, and relationship-specific adaptation. We study this distinction as a memory representation problem and present SeeFar, a four-layer architecture with an explicit consolidation path and a parallel relational state. The architecture combines heat-based semantic retention, confidence-threshold admission, bitemporal versioning, and mean-reverting relational updates, with asynchronous maintenance as an execution policy. We clarify the assumptions under which these mechanisms provide history preservation and conditional mean stability, while distinguishing both properties from factual correctness and behavioral persona consistency. Across five evaluated backbones, SeeFar attains the highest open-domain LoCoMo F1 among the compared configurations and the highest Temporal F1 in a separate diagnostic workload. The results are task-dependent: SeeFar does not lead the LoCoMo temporal category on any backbone, evidence-promotion precision remains approximately 52%, and persona-oriented ablations show mixed outcomes. Recorded foreground latencies are lower in the diagnostic comparison, but do not establish a reduction in total computational work. These findings support studying memory lifecycle and relational scope jointly, while exposing limits of confidence-based admission, component attribution, and generalization beyond the evaluated settings.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
long-term memory, LLM agents, memory architecture, temporal reasoning, persona consistency, bitemporal records, relational memory

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_9c9yOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces SeeFar, which separates accumulated evidence, committed facts, temporal records, and relational state in an agent's memory. Asynchronous updates are intended to reduce latency in the foreground conversation. SeeFar is evaluated on question answering, factual recovery, and persona-oriented behavior across five backbones.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper provides a clear and interpretable organization of accumulated evidence, committed facts, temporal records, and changing relationships in SeeFar's persistent agent memory.

  2. Table 3 reports large single-hop QA improvements across all five backbones, including scores of 66.01 versus 17.33 for DeepSeek. Such gains would be substantial if supported by equivalent evaluation conditions and faithful baselines.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The headline comparison raises concerns about category alignment and baseline fidelity. Table 3 reports lower single-hop than multi-hop F1 in all 25 baseline rows, whereas SeeFar shows the opposite ordering across all five backbones. This pattern differs from the results reported in the original LoCoMo paper and requires verification. In particular, it remains unclear whether all baselines use the same category IDs and questions. This pattern does not necessarily establish a category mapping error. Appendix A.10 also does not clearly specify the memory operations and budgets retained by the baseline wrappers. These issues make the claimed improvements difficult to assess or reproduce.

  2. The provided ablations do not explain the principal single-hop QA gains, as Table 4 reports results on persona and conflict outcomes rather than single-hop QA. In addition, Section 4.5 reports overlap between the 200 threshold-selection questions and the 841-question evaluation set. Focused QA ablations and an evaluation separated from threshold selection are needed to assess the robustness of the reported gains and the contributions of individual components.

Questions for authors
  1. [Clarification] Could the authors verify the category mapping in Table 3 with sample baseline outputs? Could the authors also clarify the memory operations and budgets retained by the respective baseline wrappers?

  2. [Suggestion] Do the reported single-hop gains persist when evaluated on questions separated from threshold selection? How much does each proposed component contribute to single-hop QA performance in focused ablation studies?

Reviewer_d5NVOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

SeeFar proposes a four-layer memory architecture that separates experience, candidate evidence, versioned records, and user-specific relational state. It combines heat-based retention, threshold admission, bitemporal versioning, and mean-reverting relational updates, while decoupling responses from background maintenance. Experiments cover five backbones and distinguish the full LoCoMo benchmark from diagnostic tests of temporal performance, historical-fact retention, and response latency. On LoCoMo, reported single-hop F1 ranges from 42.51 to 66.01, leading the compared configurations across all five backbones. The gains are task-dependent and do not extend uniformly to multi-hop or temporal questions.

Critical strengths
  1. The architecture makes different memory-update semantics explicit. Section 3 separates candidate evidence, bitemporal records, and user-scoped relational state, rather than applying one update rule to all stored information. The paper also distinguishes history preservation, factual correctness, and conditional mean reversion. These distinctions make the system's intended guarantees and limitations easier to assess.

  2. The single-hop F1 advantage is consistent across all five evaluated backbones. Table 3 reports scores of 42.51–66.01, including 66.01 versus the strongest baseline's 17.33 in the DeepSeek group. The paper also reports that it does not lead the multi-hop or temporal categories and that the persona-oriented ablations are mixed. This provides a clear scope for the demonstrated benefit.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The system-level single-hop advantage is supported, but its attribution requires a more easily auditable account of the compared configurations. The common backbone settings and Table 4 ablations are useful evidence. A compact method-by-method account of history ingestion, retrieval/truncation limits, information visibility, and key read/write choices would clarify the source of the large Table 3 gap. This is a request to make the comparison traceable, rather than evidence that a baseline was weakened.

  2. The mapping from accumulated category scores to a particular committed statement needs clarification. Section 3.1 defines category-level thresholding, while Section 3.3 and Algorithm 1 describe the resulting write. Please specify which candidate summary is committed, what happens to its accumulated score, and how incompatible statements in the same category are handled. Table 5's 52.63% precision is consistent with the stated heuristic limitations. This implementation clarification is not an independent rejection criterion and does not require the Fact layer to guarantee truth.

Questions for authors
  1. For the DeepSeek comparison in Table 3, please summarize LoCoMo-M's history-ingestion scope, retrieval/truncation limits, and key read/write choices alongside SeeFar's corresponding settings. One existing context-construction example would help audit the information conditions. The methods need not retrieve exactly the same content.

  2. Please show an existing update function or one clearly labeled state transition illustrating how a category score triggers a write. The accumulation key, pre/post-update scores, selected summary, and post-commit state would suffice, together with the handling of incompatible statements in the same category. This addresses weakness 2 and does not request an additional effectiveness experiment.

Reviewer_suwjOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces SeeFar, a four-layer memory architecture for long-term LLM agents that separates semantic context, candidate evidence, committed facts, and relationship-specific states. The framework consists of heat-based memory eviction, confidence-threshold fact promotion, bi-temporal versioning, Ornstein-Uhlenbeck mean-reverting relational updates, and asynchronous memory maintenance. The authors evaluated SeeFar across five LLM backbones using LoCoMo, PersonaGym, and SOTOPIA and reported substantial improvements in single-hop factual recall, diagnostic temporal F1, and foreground inference latency.

Critical strengths
  • Isolating tentative evidence, facts, and relationship-specific state is an intuitive design choice for persistent agents. The framework provides a clear organization of memory components with distinct update semantics, which could be useful for agent systems in production.
  • Table 3 reports substantial improvements in single-hop LoCoMo F1 across all five evaluated models. If these gains hold under stronger, better controlled baseline comparisons, they could provide useful evidence for the proposed memory organization (see weaknesses for details).
Critical weaknesses
  • The proposed framework primarily integrates established memory management and database techniques without introducing a fundamentally new algorithm or a learning method. The contribution is largely an engineering effort, and the paper does not provide sufficient empirical insights to justify the scientific significance.
  • SeeFar fails to outperform the strongest baselines on multi-hop and temporal LoCoMo tasks across all five backbones (Table 3). The reported improvements are largely concentrated on single-hop retrieval.
  • The ablations do not isolate the contributions of the proposed memory layers to the main benchmark results, which makes it it difficult to attribute performance improvements to the architecture.
Questions for authors
  • can the authors clarify what scientific insights or methodological contributions SeeFar provides beyond integrating existing memory management techniques?
  • why does SeeFar consistently underperform the strongest baselines on multi-hop and temporal LoCoMo tasks and what explains the large gap between single-hop improvements and performance on more complex reasoning tasks?
  • can the authors provide ablations of the individual memory layers on the main LoCoMo benchmarks to demonstrate their respective contributions?
  • how do the authors ensure fair comparisons when the baselines are lightweight reimplementations rather than the original systems- for example, can they provide evidence that these implementations faithfully reproduce the original methods?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.