- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Long-term memory is not only about whether historical information can be retrieved. Original evidence may be lost during compression, while outdated abstract evidence may still affect agents. CERES builds an evidence-based memory system. Engram preserves full evidence and integrates memory, while Cortex produces high-level conclusions. The main experiments show that CERES improves over Memora.
Critical strengths
The research question is clearly defined. It concerns how to preserve evidence, store facts, and maintain conclusions in long-term memory. It combines both the engram and cortex parts.
Critical weaknesses
- The number of samples in LongMemEval-S is small (60 tasks?). Essentially, the main experiments are conducted on only one dataset.
- Abstraction + evidence is not a new idea. Could the authors further explain the novelty of the proposed method?
- It feels weird, possibly AI-generated, to capitalize many English words, e.g., Monthly, Consolidate, Trace, and Judge.
Questions for authors
- The experimental setup is not clearly described. For example, readers cannot know what reasoning effort/settings are used for the LLMs. It's also confusing to denote Qwen3.7-Max as Qwen3.7. GPT-6-Astra is used but never mentioned in the table or its caption.
- Why is there blue text used in Figure 4?