acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

DA-VLA: A Dynamics-Aware Vision-Language-Action System for High-Speed Manipulation

Abstract

Existing VLA systems remain limited in task execution speed on real robots, making it difficult to meet the throughput demands of practical applications. To improve execution throughput while reliably completing tasks, a VLA system needs to naturally connect continuously updated policy outputs with ongoing motion, preserve motion stability and execution reliability, and fully exploit the robot's dynamics. To this end, we present DA-VLA, a dynamics-aware VLA system for high-speed manipulation that coordinates continuous policy action generation with the robot's actual motion capabilities. On the policy side, we introduce an execution-aware objective that promotes smooth motion within each action chunk during training while constraining continuity between newly generated chunks and already committed motion. The same objective guides action generation during inference, allowing successive policy updates to naturally extend the motion already being executed. On the execution side, DA-VLA evaluates the robot's available motion capability from its current state and continuously adapts execution according to upcoming action trends, avoiding unnecessary conservative slowdowns between successive policy targets and enabling fast, stable, and accurate motion within the robot's dynamic capabilities. Further speed-success comparisons show that, at a matched task success rate, \svla achieves nearly twice the execution throughput of . These results show that \svla can better exploit the robot's physical capabilities to improve practical execution throughput while preserving task reliability.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Robotic Arm, Vision-Language-Action Model, Control Algorithm

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_Hqs9OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a vision-language-action system for high-speed manipulation. The authors train a policy based on Qwen3-VL-4B and add three components. For training, they propose an intra-chunk smoothness and cross-chunk continuity loss. For inference, they use the same loss for gradient guidance. For execution, they utilize dynamics-aware trajectory generation and tracking under motion constraints. Experiments verify that the proposed DA-VLA achieves better performance and throughput across tasks than the baseline methods.

Critical strengths
  1. The problem is meaningful. Rather than focusing only on VLA inference latency, the authors consider the training objective, trajectory continuity, dynamics, and other factors within a unified high-speed system.
  2. The proposed system is comprehensive and sound. From the policy to the controller, the overall design is well integrated.
  3. The experiments are extensive, covering different tasks and baseline methods, and validate the effectiveness and efficiency of the proposed DA-VLA.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The ablation study is somewhat limited. The paper could benefit from separately evaluating motion capability prediction and trajectory interpolation, as well as dynamics-aware regularization and guidance.
  2. It is unclear why MinJerk produces much larger acceleration and jerk than linear interpolation in Table 2. The paper could benefit from a clearer explanation of this result.
  3. It is unclear why DA-VLA requires training a separate policy based on Qwen-VL. Could it instead start from a strong VLA such as π0.5? In addition, the proposed execution layer could potentially be directly applied to existing VLA models such as π0.5. Could such policies also benefit from it?
Questions for authors

See weakness 1-3.

4 comments

W1

Thank you for suggesting that we distinguish the contributions of the components more clearly. We separately evaluate dynamics-aware regularization and guidance on the policy side, and further distinguish the roles of motion capability prediction and trajectory interpolation on the execution side through a capability-bound comparison and an analysis of the interpolation submechanisms. In the original manuscript's combined ablations, disabling both dynamics-aware regularization and guidance changes the average SR across the five tasks from 80.6% to 51.8%; replacing the combination of motion capability prediction and trajectory interpolation with piecewise MinJerk changes the average SR to 70.8%. Building on this, we add experiments that independently toggle training regularization and inference guidance, as well as a capability-bound comparison that keeps trajectory interpolation unchanged. Together with the tracking-error, motion-smoothness, and latency analyses already reported in Table 2, these experiments associate the combined gains with the specific roles of each stage.

First, for dynamics-aware regularization and guidance, we independently toggle training-stage regularization and inference-stage guidance on Book Insertion. The results are as follows:

Dynamics-aware regularization (training)Guidance (inference)SRMean successful-trial duration (s)ETS
OnOn65%20.851.59
OnOff60%25.531.18
OffOn40%27.760.67
OffOff30%29.920.45

The results show that enabling either factor when the other is off also yields consistent improvements. These results support their complementary roles: dynamics-aware regularization improves the predicted action distribution, while guidance adjusts the action chunk generated at each update according to the current observation and the motion already committed for execution. We also separately remove intra-chunk training smoothness on Book Insertion while retaining cross-chunk continuity and inference guidance. With intra-chunk smoothness enabled, the lateral-deviation RMS is lower at all three local reference scales, and the back-and-forth rate under a 5 mm threshold decreases from 0.701 to 0.470 times/s. This provides further evidence of the motion-quality benefits of an individual term in the training regularizer.

Second, regarding motion capability prediction and trajectory interpolation, the former provides state-dependent acceleration bounds, while the latter uses these bounds to connect discrete action targets. The piecewise MinJerk evaluated in the paper does not use the predicted bounds; the original MinJerk ablation evaluates the task-level benefit of the combined motion capability prediction and trajectory interpolation. To further test the role of capability prediction, we keep trajectory interpolation and the low-level tracking setup fixed, and compare results with and without state-dependent acceleration bounds. The mean acceleration RMS and the estimated torque-demand RMS reduces approximately 12.6% and 4.7%, respectively. This evaluates the role of the capability bounds separately from the task-level benefit of the full interpolation combination.

Finally, the main text already gives a detailed analysis of the mechanisms and roles of the execution-layer components. Table 2 further analyzes trajectory interpolation and its submechanisms in terms of tracking error, motion smoothness, and latency; all interpolation methods use the same underlying dynamics-compensated trajectory tracking setup. Chunk Fusion corresponds to the intermediate-reference insertion and continuous bridging at larger target changes in Figure 3 ("bridge large gap with c3"). Inheritance corresponds to "terminal velocity estimation": it lets a new segment continue the motion trend already in progress, and computes the next desired velocity jointly with the trend of subsequent targets. In the original manuscript, removing Chunk Fusion increases acceleration and jerk RMS by 18.1% and 7.1%, respectively; removing Inheritance increases alignment latency by 126.2%. These results further associate the gains from trajectory interpolation with continuous bridging and motion-state inheritance. The specific design and how these components connect are described in Appendix B.

These analyses separately present the roles of dynamics-aware regularization and guidance, motion capability prediction, trajectory interpolation, and its submechanisms: training regularization improves action generation, guidance adapts to the current handoff state, capability prediction provides state-dependent bounds, and trajectory interpolation connects discrete targets into continuous references. The independent toggles, bound comparison, and interpolation-submechanism analysis together explain the task-level gains of the complete combination and each stage's contribution to continuous execution.

W2

Thank you for the question. The results in Table 2 arise from the relationship between the boundary conditions of piecewise MinJerk and high-frequency action references: the MinJerk evaluated in this paper constructs a quintic curve separately for each pair of adjacent VLA position points, with zero start and end velocity and acceleration, whereas Linear maintains a constant slope within each interval. Thus, the two methods place velocity changes differently: piecewise MinJerk accelerates and decelerates within every short interval, while Linear's velocity changes occur mainly at the boundaries between adjacent intervals.

Specifically, at a 50 Hz action-reference rate, MinJerk uses q(s)=q0+D(10s3−15s4+6s5)q(s)=q_0+D(10s^3-15s^4+6s^5), where D=q1−q0D=q_1-q_0, s=t/Ts=t/T, and T=20T=20 ms. Given the start and end positions and zero velocity and acceleration at both ends, it minimizes the integrated squared jerk; Linear uses different boundary conditions, so its discrete transmitted sequence can have a lower jerk RMS without contradicting this optimality result. For example, in one segment of the original replay with a displacement of 0.019929 rad, the average velocity is approximately 0.996 rad/s in each interval for Linear, whereas for MinJerk it is approximately 0.413, 1.580, 1.580, and 0.413 rad/s, reflecting the acceleration and deceleration within each 20 ms interval.

Statistics over the same 10 trajectories further locate this difference:

MetricLinear interpolationPiecewise MinJerkDA-VLA
RMS of transmitted-velocity changes at 50 Hz point boundaries (rad/s)0.3330.1640.102
RMS of transmitted-velocity changes within inter-point intervals (rad/s)0.0890.5060.084
Transmitted jerk RMS (rad/s3\mathrm{rad}/\mathrm{s}^{3})1,522.9710,361.77935.78

Piecewise MinJerk reduces velocity changes at point boundaries, but introduces larger velocity changes within the intervals. This also explains why its acceleration RMS is higher than Linear's: 54.46 versus 11.10 rad/s2\mathrm{rad}/\mathrm{s}^{2}. These comparisons use the same discrete transmission and statistical protocol.

This comparison shows that the acceleration and jerk differences between MinJerk and linear interpolation should be interpreted in light of their respective boundary conditions and where velocity changes occur. DA-VLA uses cross-segment trajectory interpolation to handle transitions between adjacent action points, making velocity changes smoother during continuous execution instead of repeatedly performing a motion that starts and ends at rest within every short interval.

W3

Thank you for the suggestions. DA-VLA's design does not depend on the Qwen-VL backbone and can also be adapted to existing VLAs with the corresponding training and sampling interfaces. We chose Qwen3-VL-4B to establish a reproducible policy-execution research pipeline. Regarding whether the execution layer can be applied directly to π0.5\pi_{0.5} and provide benefits, π0.5\pi_{0.5} in the main table already uses our execution layer, and the new MinJerk comparison further validates this benefit.

First, choosing Qwen3-VL-4B allows us to connect public robot data, target-robot adaptation, continuous-action learning, and real-robot execution in one pipeline. Its accessible action head and training workflow support a unified implementation of dynamics-aware regularization and guidance, and provide a basis for open, reproducible research across the full pipeline. This is our research-design rationale for using this backbone; transferring the policy-side methods to existing VLAs such as π0.5\pi_{0.5} requires integrating the corresponding regularization and guidance into their training objectives and action-sampling interfaces.

Second, the execution layer receives outputs from different VLAs through a shared action-reference interface. π0.5\pi_{0.5} and the other baselines in the main table already use the same motion capability prediction, trajectory interpolation, and dynamics-compensated trajectory tracking, while retaining their respective policy-update mechanisms. We further fix the π0.5\pi_{0.5} checkpoint, policy-update mechanism, and low-level tracking setup at the 100 Hz operating point on Table Clearing, and replace the combination of motion capability prediction and trajectory interpolation with piecewise MinJerk. With our execution combination, SR is 78% and ETS is 8.20; with MinJerk, they are 68% and 7.27, respectively. This directly demonstrates its value for high-speed execution with an existing VLA.

In summary, DA-VLA provides both a reproducible policy-execution research pipeline and an execution layer that existing VLAs can use. The deployment of π0.5\pi_{0.5} and the new MinJerk comparison demonstrate the transferable benefits of the execution design, while the main-table comparisons under a shared execution layer further support the contribution of our coordinated policy and execution design.

Thanks for the response. It addressed most of my concerns. Therefore, I would llike to maintain my score to support the paper.

We appreciate your continued support for the paper. Your questions helped us explain more clearly what each component contributes, why the interpolation methods behave differently, and how the execution layer can benefit other VLA policies. Thank you for taking the time to follow up.

Reviewer_KFcFOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents DA-VLA, a dynamics-aware vision-language-action system for high-speed manipulation. The policy combines a pretrained Qwen3-VL-4B backbone with a flow-matching action head, recursive multi-scale training, and an execution objective used for both training regularization and inference guidance. The execution framework estimates state-dependent acceleration bounds, constructs continuous trajectories, and applies dynamics-compensated tracking. Experiments cover five real-world tasks on DA-Arm. The full system achieves an average success rate of 80.6%, compared with 77.4% for π0.5. On table clearing at 100 Hz action-reference dispatch, it achieves 90% success and 15.92 successful completions per minute under the paper's throughput definition. The work also includes module ablations and an analysis of tracking accuracy and motion smoothness from motor feedback.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses an important practical bottleneck in VLA deployment: translating continuously updated action predictions into fast and reliable physical motion. It implements a complete pipeline covering action generation, asynchronous chunk transitions, state-dependent trajectory interpolation, and dynamics-compensated tracking. This system perspective is useful for understanding execution limitations that improvements in policy inference alone may not resolve. The evaluation includes five real-world tasks covering bimanual manipulation, contact-rich execution, and dynamic interception. Task-level results are complemented by motor-feedback measurements and component ablations. The strong table-clearing results under accelerated execution, together with reduced acceleration and jerk RMS at comparable tracking error, provide evidence of the integrated system's practical value.

Critical weaknesses

The methodological contribution and the source of the performance gains remain insufficiently established. The framework combines policy regularization and sampling guidance with a substantial execution stack, but the current comparisons do not adequately separate their contributions or establish the independent value of dynamics information. Moreover, the relationship between the policy objective and the trajectories reconstructed by the execution layer is not sufficiently analyzed, leaving the claimed coordination between policy generation and physical execution only partially substantiated. The experimental evidence is not yet strong enough to support the breadth of the performance claims. The average success-rate improvement over π0.5 is modest, several evaluations involve few trials, and uncertainty estimates are missing. The throughput metric also relies on imputed failure durations, while the matched-success speed comparison lacks a clearly documented estimation procedure. These issues make it difficult to assess the stability and practical magnitude of the reported advantage.

Questions for authors
  1. The contributions of the policy and execution framework are not sufficiently disentangled. Removing motion-feasible interpolation reduces average success from 80.6% to 70.8%, below π0.5's 77.4%. Could the authors evaluate π0.5 with the same interpolation and tracking framework under matched scheduling, action dispatch rates, and controller settings? This would help distinguish policy improvements from execution-layer gains and their interaction.
  2. The policy evaluates smoothness and dynamics consistency on predicted action chunks, whereas the execution layer subsequently modifies terminal velocities, projects targets, reconstructs trajectories, and clips motion references. Does reducing the policy loss actually reduce downstream corrections, and how do these modifications preserve task intent and timing? Please quantify the discrepancy between predicted actions and final execution references and analyze its relationship to the policy loss.
  3. The objective combines smoothness, position/velocity consistency, and nominal torque consistency, while the ablation jointly removes training regularization and inference guidance. Could the authors isolate the contribution of dynamics information by removing only torque consistency while retaining the other terms? Please report the relative loss or gradient magnitudes, particularly given the torque weight of 1e-9, and separately assess training regularization and inference guidance.
  4. Failed trials receive an imputed duration of 1.5 times the mean successful-trial duration, so the reported metric may differ from actual elapsed-time throughput. Moreover, the approximately 1.94-fold improvement at 100 Hz compares different success rates, 90% and 78%. Could the authors report measured trial durations and sensitivity to the failure penalty, and provide the measurements and estimation procedure supporting nearly twice the throughput at matched success?
  5. The average success-rate gain over π0.5 is 3.2 percentage points, while several tasks use only 20 trials, making one success equivalent to five percentage points. Each OOD condition uses only 10 trials. Could the authors provide confidence intervals, variability estimates for completion time and throughput, and independent repetitions of key comparisons to establish the stability of the performance and generalization claims?
  6. Figure 1 provides task snapshots, but these offer limited insight into the quality of real-robot execution over time. Could the authors include representative execution sequences, particularly under accelerated settings and during contact-rich or dynamic tasks? Comparisons with π0.5 using matched conditions and annotated timestamps or motion traces would help illustrate differences in motion continuity, tracking, and task completion. Representative failure cases would also help explain the remaining limitations.
8 comments

W1

We thank you for your systematic comments on the methodological contribution, sources of performance gains, and reliability of the evidence. Our central contribution is to coordinate policy generation with robot execution for higher efficiency while maintaining task success. Shared-execution comparisons and separate ablations of policy regularization, sampling guidance, torque consistency, and state-dependent acceleration bounds assess model-side gains and the role of dynamics information; Table 2 examines trajectory-interpolation mechanisms. The relationship between the policy objective and final-reference changes provides process-level evidence of this coordination, while repeated evaluations and time-cost analysis clarify the precision and practical magnitude of the gains. Below, we address these contributions and evidence, including the measured conditions underlying the approximately twofold efficiency result.

First, to distinguish policy regularization, sampling guidance, and execution-system contributions, π0.5\pi_{0.5} and the other main-table baselines share DA-VLA's motion capability prediction, trajectory interpolation, and dynamics-compensated tracking while retaining their respective policy-update mechanisms. The four-way regularization–guidance comparison shows that adding either component with the other fixed improves observed SR and ETS, with the complete combination performing best. Removing only training-time torque consistency shows that, at the same observed success rate, DA-VLA has 8.5% lower position-tracking RMS and 10.5% lower velocity-tracking RMS. With trajectory interpolation fixed, state-dependent acceleration bounds further reduce acceleration and estimated torque demands. Execution-side contributions are evaluated at two levels: the MinJerk replacement tests the task-level benefit of combined motion capability prediction and trajectory interpolation, while Table 2 isolates Chunk Fusion and Inheritance to examine their effects on smoothness and latency. These comparisons link each contribution to the component changed.

Second, regarding the relationship between the policy objective and trajectories generated by the execution layer, we associate the execution regularizer in each predicted action with changes to the final execution reference for the same request. In Book Insertion, both the total execution regularizer and the position-continuity term are positively correlated with the difference RMS between the controller input and the subsequently sent reference. After matching input velocity and action magnitude within the same continuous spatial segment of the same trajectory, requests with higher loss still correspond to larger reference changes. Comparisons of training objectives also show that DA-VLA has smaller cross-chunk position differences and smaller downstream reference changes. We additionally examine recorded video events to check the ordering of grasping, carrying an object, and releasing it, relating the motion metrics to the actual manipulation process. Thus, the policy–execution coordination is supported both by a quantitative link between the policy objective and changes to the execution reference and by process-level evidence from reference tracking and task events.

Third, regarding the stability and practical magnitude of the performance gains, we report per-task success counts, Wilson 95% intervals, and completion-time variability, and add intervals for OOD conditions. With 50 evaluations per task and method, the five-task average SRs are 80.8% and 76.4%. DA-VLA achieves higher observed success rates on Book Insertion and Table Wiping; the two methods have similar success rates on Garment Folding, while DA-VLA has a shorter mean successful-trial duration. The five-task aggregate presents overall performance, and the separately reported 100 Hz operating point clarifies the gain and its estimation precision under the high-speed condition.

Finally, regarding throughput based on imputed failure durations and the comparison at matched success, the main table reports ETS values of 15.92 for DA-VLA and 8.20 for π0.5\pi_{0.5} at 100 Hz, with success rates of 90% and 78%, respectively. The 1.94×1.94\times result uses the same action-reference dispatch frequency, and the abstract will state this comparison condition explicitly. In a sensitivity analysis of the failure penalty over λ=1–2\lambda=1\text{--}2, the ETS ranking remains unchanged across tasks, and the ratio at 100 Hz ranges from 1.84 to 2.04. Using measured failure durations under the corresponding operating point, the estimated throughputs are 17.51 and 10.59 trials/min, respectively, a ratio of approximately 1.65.

Together, these comparisons and execution analyses clarify the sources of DA-VLA's gains, the link between policy generation and execution, and the magnitude and uncertainty of the reported performance.

Q1

We thank you for suggesting a comparison under a shared interpolation and tracking framework to distinguish policy and execution contributions. In the main table, π0.5\pi_{0.5} already uses the same motion-feasible interpolation and tracking framework as DA-VLA, and extra experiments show that our execution layer improves both SR and ETS over piecewise MinJerk on Table Clearing at 100 Hz. As the action-dispatch rates and local-controller settings are matched at the corresponding operating point in the main table, the average SRs of 77.4% and 80.6% are obtained under a shared local execution layer. For scheduling, the base π0.5\pi_{0.5} retains its own action-chunk update mechanism, while π0.5\pi_{0.5}+RTC shares the asynchronous workflow and committed prefix with DA-VLA.

To directly assess execution-layer gains for an existing VLA, we additionally compare π0.5\pi_{0.5} with our execution combination against π0.5\pi_{0.5} with piecewise MinJerk at 100 Hz on Table Clearing. We keep the checkpoint, scheduling, action-dispatch rate, and low-level tracking settings fixed, replacing motion capability prediction and motion-feasible interpolation with MinJerk. Our execution combination achieves 78% SR and 8.20 ETS, compared with 68% and 7.27 for MinJerk—an increase of 10 percentage points in SR and approximately 12.8% in ETS. This directly demonstrates that the execution design also benefits π0.5\pi_{0.5}.

The original 80.6%-to-70.8% ablation evaluates the same execution combination within DA-VLA, while the 80.6%-versus-77.4% comparison evaluates the model-side approaches under a shared local execution layer. Table 2 further analyzes tracking and motion quality across interpolation methods. Together, the shared-layer comparisons and the execution-layer ablations within DA-VLA and π0.5\pi_{0.5} clarify the respective contributions of policy design and robot execution.

Q2

We thank you for focusing on the relationship between policy loss and downstream corrections, and on how these modifications preserve task intent and timing. We paired each returned action chunk with its subsequent execution interval to quantify reference changes, and checked the recorded grasp–transport–release sequence to assess whether the required task order was preserved. In our measurements, a lower policy execution-regularizer diagnostic is associated with a smaller difference between the controller input and the final sent reference. This association persists after matching motion phase, velocity, and action magnitude. Regarding task intent and timing, the execution layer retains the original action targets while adjusting local boundary conditions and reference arrival times to generate continuous motion. Process records further check whether grasping, carrying an object, and releasing it occur in the required order. We therefore assess policy–execution coordination from three perspectives: reference changes, their relationship to the loss, and actual manipulation events.

First, to analyze the relationship between policy loss and downstream corrections, we associate the execution-regularizer diagnostic for the action chunk returned at the end of each request with the input-to-sent-reference difference RMS over the subsequent execution interval. We first calculate the Spearman correlation within each trajectory and then average the coefficients with equal weight:

MetricDA-VLATraining regularization disabled
Correlation between total execution regularizer and input-to-sent-reference difference RMS0.7660.685
Correlation between weighted position-continuity term and input-to-sent-reference difference RMS0.7880.706

Both correlations are positive: lower execution-regularizer diagnostics generally accompany smaller downstream reference changes. After additionally matching input velocity and action magnitude within the same continuous spatial segment of the same trajectory, the input-to-sent-reference difference RMS for higher-loss requests remains larger by 0.00221 and 0.00129 rad, respectively; the trajectory-resampled 95% intervals are [0.00116, 0.00296] and [0.00068, 0.00194] rad. This shows that the association persists after controlling for the motion phase and magnitude.

Second, to quantify the difference between action targets entering the execution layer and the final sent references, we separately remove either intra-chunk training smoothness or training-time torque consistency, retaining the other training objectives and execution settings:

MetricDA-VLAIntra-chunk training smoothness removedTraining torque consistency removed
Cross-chunk position-continuity loss contribution0.092470.164120.13405
Controller input →\rightarrow sent-reference RMS (rad)0.090800.095580.09627

DA-VLA has both smaller cross-chunk position differences and smaller downstream reference changes. This RMS measures the difference between the controller input and final sent reference at corresponding times and includes both path and timing adjustments. The request-level association and training-objective ablation support the link between the policy objective and subsequent trajectory interpolation from the perspectives of runtime behavior and model configuration, respectively.

Finally, regarding task intent and timing, local interpolation continues to track the original action target; target projection adjusts the reachable reference within the current planning window, and subsequent replanning continues toward the original target. The reference arrival time can be adjusted to satisfy motion constraints. We use dual-view video and execution logs to check that grasping, carrying the object, and releasing it at the target are completed in the required order. In process records for the same task, these event sequences are completed in 23/25 records for DA-VLA and 21/25 for the intra-chunk-smoothness-removed ablation. This reflects completion of the necessary operations and their order; task success still requires satisfying all task conditions—for example, a trial remains a failure if the robot grasps another object after releasing the target.

These analyses separately address the discrepancy between predicted actions and final execution references, its relationship to policy loss, and the actual preservation of task intent and timing. The request-level association and training-objective ablation support a link between the execution regularizer and downstream corrections, while the manipulation events connect reference changes to task actions and their temporal order.

Reviewer_QYmdOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents DA-VLA, a system for accelerating real-world VLA execution while maintaining task reliability. It combines a few-step flow-matching policy with training-time smoothness and cross-chunk continuity regularization, inference-time guidance, and a local execution stack that incorporates state-dependent acceleration bounds, trajectory interpolation, and dynamics-compensated tracking. Experiments cover five real-world tasks on DA-Arm. The method reports 80.6% average success compared with 77.4% for pi0.5, and stronger performance under accelerated action-reference dispatch in Table Clearing.

Critical strengths

s1:An important practical problem. Improving physical execution speed while preserving reliability is valuable for deploying VLA systems. The paper considers the complete policy-to-execution pathway, including asynchronous action generation, trajectory construction, and low-level tracking.

s2:Real-world evaluation with execution-level measurements. The experiments include bimanual manipulation, contact-rich tasks, and dynamic interception, together with component ablations and motor-feedback analysis. The accelerated Table Clearing results provide promising evidence that the complete system tolerates faster execution better than the evaluated baselines.

Critical weaknesses

w1:The smoothness objective may alter task-critical motion, but this trade-off is insufficiently examined. The method directly penalizes second-order differences in predicted joint positions during training and applies related guidance during inference, without explicitly preserving necessary waypoints or contact transitions. Such regularization may suppress meaningful motion changes as well as noise—for example, rounding a required turn and missing an essential intermediate configuration—yet the paper does not isolate this effect or demonstrate how task fidelity is preserved.

w2:Insufficient evaluation and attribution in dynamic settings. The paper does not systematically evaluate combinations of object speed, direction, and acceleration, or explain how demonstrations cover these conditions. Consequently, it remains unclear whether improved dynamic-task performance comes from faster execution, broader training coverage, or generalization to unseen motion combinations. Also, The tasks in this paper can be done in slow execution, which is not insufficient to show the strength of your system.

I would be willing to raise my raitng if the authors can clarify these issues.

Questions for authors
  1. Preservation of task-critical motion. How does the smoothness objective distinguish unwanted oscillations from necessary changes at critical waypoints, obstacle boundaries, or contact transitions? Please provide trajectory and failure analyses showing whether these configurations are preserved, and isolate intra-chunk smoothing from cross-chunk continuity.

  2. Alternative treatment of demonstrations. Have you compared prediction-level regularization with training on demonstrations that are smoothed under task constraints and validated through successful replay? This would clarify the benefit of the proposed objective relative to improving demonstration quality directly.

  3. Throughput at matched success. Please report actual successful and failed trial durations, explain how Figure 1 was estimated, and provide uncertainty for the speed–success comparisons. Which measured operating points support the approximately twofold gain at matched success, and does it persist when actual elapsed times replace imputed failure durations?

  4. Dynamics-specific contribution and baseline configuration. Could you isolate the effects of training regularization, inference guidance, torque consistency, and state-dependent acceleration bounds while keeping the remaining components fixed? Please also specify which execution and speed-adaptation components were retained when deploying pi0.5+RTC and RTVLA-v2.

  5. Dynamic evaluation, demonstration coverage, and attribution. Could you evaluate additional real-world dynamic tasks across object speeds, motion directions, and accelerations, and compare against relevant dynamic manipulation methods, such as DynamicVLA, where applicable? Please clarify:

    • Data collection: How are demonstrations collected across these conditions, and how are failed demonstrations or temporally augmented trajectories validated?
    • Generalization: How does performance differ between unseen combinations of familiar motion parameters and parameter values outside the training range?
    • Attribution: Do improvements come from faster execution, broader demonstration coverage, or their interaction? Comparisons that independently vary execution settings and training coverage would help distinguish these effects.
6 comments

W1&Q1

Thank you for highlighting the trade-off between unwanted oscillations and task-critical motion. We jointly optimize task-action supervision and soft smoothing: observation-conditioned demonstrations supervise necessary actions at critical waypoints, obstacle boundaries, and contact transitions, while finite-weight intra-chunk smoothing penalizes second-order position changes to suppress unwanted oscillations. Critical configurations are thus learned through task supervision rather than explicitly classified by the smoothing term. In the analyzed grasp-adjustment trials, DA-VLA corrected its motion and completed the grasp in all three recorded insufficient-reach cases, while showing lower lateral deviation and less local back-and-forth motion than the model without training-time intra-chunk smoothing. These results support improved continuity alongside necessary task adjustments. Below, we isolate training-time intra-chunk smoothing while retaining cross-chunk continuity and inference guidance, and examine trajectory statistics, grasp adjustments, and tracking results.

First, to separate intra-chunk smoothing from cross-chunk continuity, we remove only training-time intra-chunk smoothing on the contact-intensive Book Insertion task, while retaining the training-time cross-chunk continuity term and inference guidance. Within the lateral-approach segment of the second grasp, identified using the same spatial partition, we quantify local motion fluctuations using lateral deviation and back-and-forth motion, and interpret these statistics together with the grasp-adjustment events below.

MethodLateral-deviation RMS (mm), smoothing scale 0.2 / 0.4 / 0.6 sBack-and-forth rate (events/s), threshold 2 / 5 / 10 mm
DA-VLA0.402 / 1.021 / 1.8300.526 / 0.470 / 0.361
Without training-time intra-chunk smoothing0.449 / 1.253 / 2.3350.701 / 0.701 / 0.680

Lateral RMS measures deviation of the actual path from its Gaussian-smoothed reference in the plane perpendicular to the local direction of motion; the time scale is the filter's full width at half maximum. Back-and-forth events are counted along the end-effector x direction, with one event counted whenever a reversal displacement reaches the threshold, and the count is divided by the segment duration. DA-VLA's lateral RMS is 10.4%–21.6% lower, and its event rate at the 5 mm threshold is 33.0% lower. The direction of the comparison remains unchanged when we vary the velocity threshold used to estimate the local direction of motion.

Second, to check whether fewer oscillations still allow necessary task-related changes, we analyze failures and recovery during the second-book grasp:

MethodRecorded initial-grasp behaviorSubsequent outcome
DA-VLAInsufficient forward reach on the first attempt in 3 trialsSelf-adjusted and completed the grasp in all 3 trials
Without training-time intra-chunk smoothing3 grasp failures1 retry completed the grasp; 2 stopped

DA-VLA self-adjusted and completed the grasp in all three trials after initially reaching insufficiently far forward, indicating that the smoothing objective allows the policy to make the depth correction required by the task. Together with the lower lateral deviation and back-and-forth rate, these records show smoother local motion alongside successful task-required corrections. The event analysis checks whether the necessary adjustments occurred, while the trajectory statistics quantify the associated local motion.

Finally, we further examine the effect of intra-chunk smoothing on physical execution and add Table Clearing, a task with faster task motion. Sent-reference and feedback tracking metrics complement the event analysis above, which checks necessary actions, by evaluating execution quality:

TaskExecution metricDA-VLAWithout training-time intra-chunk smoothing
Book InsertionSent-to-feedback position RMS (rad)0.010990.01112
Book InsertionSent-to-feedback velocity RMS (rad/s)0.056270.05709
Table ClearingController-input-to-sent position RMS (rad)0.090800.09558
Table ClearingSent-to-feedback position RMS (rad)0.007300.00853
Table ClearingSent-to-feedback velocity RMS (rad/s)0.115380.12671

These results address unwanted oscillations, necessary changes, and the isolated role of intra-chunk smoothing, respectively: the single-component ablation shows less local deviation and back-and-forth motion; the failure and recovery analysis shows that DA-VLA still makes the correction needed to complete the grasp; and the tracking results reflect the physical execution quality of these actions. We therefore jointly optimize task-action supervision and soft smoothing to improve continuity while preserving the motion adjustments required by the task.

W1&Q2

Thank you for suggesting that we assess the value of prediction-level regularization by improving demonstration quality. We compare policies trained on the original demonstrations and on task-constrained smoothed demonstrations: smoothing the demonstrations improves closed-loop acceleration and jerk metrics, whereas training on the original demonstrations yields a higher task success rate. These approaches act at different stages: demonstration smoothing changes the training supervision, prediction-level regularization constrains actions generated under new observations, and cross-chunk continuity and inference guidance further address committed motion during the current execution. We therefore retain the original task supervision and coordinate action continuity at the prediction level; the comparison below explains the basis for this choice.

First, demonstration quality concerns not only trajectory smoothness but also the correspondence among images, robot states, actions, and gripper timing. Smoothing actions can change their relationship to the recorded scene, contact locations, and states; modifying execution timing also requires synchronized treatment of observation-action alignment. Thus, task-constrained demonstration smoothing must jointly preserve necessary configurations, manipulation events, and multimodal supervision relationships. Successful replay checks whether the processed trajectories are executable, while closed-loop policy evaluation further checks whether the modified supervision supports task execution under new observations.

Second, prediction-level regularization directly acts on actions generated by the policy. Even when training demonstrations have been smoothed, deployed actions remain affected by current observations, sampling variation, and robot execution state. Prediction-level regularization constrains these newly generated actions, while inference guidance further adjusts them using the current observation and committed motion. This applies execution requirements to model outputs rather than only to demonstration labels processed before training.

Third, cross-chunk continuity depends on the state of the current online execution. During asynchronous inference, the robot continues executing committed actions, and a new action chunk must continue from the state that arrives afterward; preprocessing demonstrations cannot account for the committed motion in a particular inference instance. Even when demonstrations have passed successful replay, adjacent action chunks generated online still need to connect continuously at the actual handoff state. Demonstration smoothing and prediction-level regularization therefore address complementary stages: training supervision and online generation.

In the Parcel Selection comparison, we keep gripper commands, observations, and timestamps unchanged, freeze joint actions near gripper-opening and closing events and at the trajectory endpoints, and jointly optimize trajectory deviation and second-order differences over the remaining intervals, while limiting per-joint deviation. After excluding sustained low-speed waiting, the closed-loop results are:

EvaluationOriginal demonstrations + same training and inference componentsSmoothed demonstrations + same training and inference components
Feedback acceleration RMS during active intervals (rad/s2\mathrm{rad}/\mathrm{s}^{2})1.8631.711
Feedback jerk RMS during active intervals (rad/s3\mathrm{rad}/\mathrm{s}^{3})47.2642.56
Task SR86%66%

Task-constrained demonstration smoothing reduces feedback acceleration and jerk RMS by 8.2% and 10.0%, respectively, showing that demonstration processing does improve motion smoothness. The policy trained on the original demonstrations, however, achieves a higher task SR: 86% versus 66%. This result shows that demonstration smoothness and closed-loop task performance need to be evaluated separately.

We therefore retain the task actions and multimodal correspondences in the original demonstrations, improve the model's actual outputs through prediction-level regularization, and address handoffs under currently committed motion through cross-chunk continuity and inference guidance. With the same demonstrations, DA-VLA achieves an average SR of 80.6% across five tasks, compared with 51.8% when both regularization and guidance are disabled, further illustrating the value of coordinating task objectives and execution continuity during action generation.

W2&Q3

Thank you for asking us to clarify the measurement basis for "throughput at matched success." The approximately twofold measured result in the paper corresponds to a 1.94×1.94\times ETS at the same 100 Hz action-reference dispatch rate, where DA-VLA and π0.5\pi_{0.5} have success rates of 90% and 78%, respectively; we will revise the condition of the comparison in the abstract accordingly to specify the same dispatch rate. Figure 1 estimates local success rates conditional on observed duration, with uncertainty shown using bootstrap intervals. We describe the estimation and its uncertainty below, then report the measured operating point supporting the efficiency ratio, and finally give throughput computed using actual successful and failed trial durations. Using actual successful and failed trial durations, the estimated throughput at 100 Hz is 17.51 trials/min for DA-VLA and 10.59 trials/min for π0.5\pi_{0.5}, a ratio of approximately 1.65; the advantage remains.

First, the lower-right panel of Figure 1 shows the relationship between observed duration and local success rate on Table Clearing. Each record contains the observed duration TiT_i and success label yiy_i of one attempt, with both successful and failed attempts included. At query duration tt, we use wi(t)=exp⁡[−(log⁡Ti−log⁡t)2/(2h2)]w_i(t)=\exp[-(\log T_i-\log t)^2/(2h^2)], with a bandwidth of h=0.18h=0.18 shared across all models; the local success rate is ∑iwi(t)yi/∑iwi(t)\sum_i w_i(t)y_i/\sum_i w_i(t). Thus, attempts with durations closer to the query receive greater weight. The horizontal axis is 60/t60/t, in min$^{-1},somovingrightcorrespondstoashorterobservedduration.Thehumanteleoperationreferencelinecorrespondsto5.065s,orapproximately11.85min, so moving right corresponds to a shorter observed duration. The human teleoperation reference line corresponds to 5.065 s, or approximately 11.85 min^{-1}$.

Within each model, we preserve the pairing of duration and outcome and perform 2,000 resamples with replacement, refitting the curve each time. Pointwise 95% intervals are formed from the 2.5% and 97.5% quantiles:

Reciprocal observed duration (approximately min$^{-1}$)Corresponding duration (approximately s)DA-VLA local SRPointwise 95% intervalπ0.5\pi_{0.5} local SRPointwise 95% interval
125.0094.0%[85.0%, 100.0%]92.0%[81.8%, 99.7%]
183.3384.9%[67.0%, 99.0%]44.2%[22.4%, 74.2%]

At approximately 5 s, the local success rates are similar; at approximately 3.33 s, DA-VLA has a higher local success-rate point estimate, while the pointwise intervals show the estimation uncertainty. Figure 1 describes the local success proportion among attempts with similar observed durations, including failed attempts that may have terminated early. The main table compares overall task performance at a fixed dispatch rate. The approximately twofold efficiency result corresponds to the following measured operating point at 100 Hz:

Measured operating point at 100 HzTask SRETS
DA-VLA90%15.92
π0.5\pi_{0.5}78%8.20

15.92/8.20≈1.9415.92/8.20\approx1.94 is obtained at the same dispatch rate, alongside a higher success rate. We will therefore clarify the abstract to state: "1.94×1.94\times ETS at the same action-reference dispatch rate, while maintaining a higher task success rate."

Finally, to determine whether the advantage persists when actual elapsed times replace imputed failure durations, we hold each operating point's SR and mean successful-trial duration fixed and estimate throughput using the mean failed-trial duration measured under the same configuration:

ConfigurationSRMean successful duration (s)Mean failed duration (s)Estimated successful-task throughput (successful trials/min)
DA-VLA, 50 Hz92%4.933.2911.50
π0.5\pi_{0.5}, 50 Hz96%5.453.0010.77
DA-VLA, 100 Hz90%3.231.7717.51
π0.5\pi_{0.5}, 100 Hz78%5.141.8710.59

Using measured successful- and failed-trial durations, the estimated successful-task throughput at 100 Hz is 17.51 successful trials/min for DA-VLA and 10.59 for π0.5\pi_{0.5}, a ratio of approximately 1.65. Mean successful duration is computed over successful trials; failed duration determines the time cost of failed attempts. The uncertainty in Figure 1, the fixed-operating-point efficiency comparison, and the actual failure timing together show that DA-VLA achieves both a higher success rate and higher efficiency under the same 100 Hz dispatch condition.

Comments on the paper

1 comment

Thank you for your careful review and constructive questions about task-critical motion, component contributions, and the evaluation of efficiency and dynamic performance. Your feedback helped us clarify our design and strengthen the supporting evidence. We appreciate your time in reviewing our supplementary materials and updating your rating.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.