- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3(+1)
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GeoVLT, a UAV vision-language tracking framework that explicitly incorporates camera geometry, including altitude, gimbal pitch angle, and focal length, into target representation, temporal propagation, and coordinate decoding. The paper also introduces GeoUAV, a UAV tracking dataset with language and camera-geometry annotations, and a geometry estimator for benchmarks without such metadata. GeoVLT achieves strong performance on GeoUAV and several public UAV tracking benchmarks.
Critical strengths
-
The paper explores an interesting and practically relevant direction by explicitly introducing camera geometry into UAV vision-language tracking.
-
GeoUAV provides camera-geometry annotations that are largely absent from existing UAV tracking datasets, which is potentially useful for future research.
-
The proposed components consistently improve the baseline in the progressive ablation, and the gains are particularly noticeable under high-altitude settings.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper motivates GeoVLT using changes in altitude, gimbal angle, and focal length during UAV tracking, but all camera parameters remain fixed within each sequence in GeoUAV. The estimator is also applied only once using the initial frames and its prediction is reused throughout the sequence. Therefore, the current evaluation does not demonstrate robustness to dynamically changing camera geometry, which is arguably the more realistic and challenging scenario.
-
The estimator is critical for applying GeoVLT to public datasets without camera metadata, yet the paper does not report direct estimation accuracy for altitude, pitch, or focal length. Consequently, it is difficult to understand how accurate the estimated geometry is and how tracking performance degrades as geometry estimation error increases.
-
The GeoUAV train/test split appears to contain sequences drawn from the same predefined altitude, pitch, and focal-length ranges. Experiments such as leave-one-altitude/pitch/focal-length-out evaluation or interpolation/extrapolation to unseen configurations would better establish whether GeoVLT learns meaningful geometric relationships rather than dataset-specific correlations.
-
The authors should mention more related work in somewhere appropriate: ViewSAM: Learning View-aware Cross-modal Semantics for Weakly Supervised Cross-view Referring Multi-Object Tracking, Gen4track: A tuning-free data augmentation framework via self-correcting diffusion model for vision-language tracking, Consistencies are all you need for semi-supervised vision-language tracking, Beyond visual cues: Synchronously exploring target-centric semantics for vision-language tracking.
-
GCR and GATP consume the full geometry tuple, whereas GCD uses an altitude-conditioned mapping with fixed parameter pairs over altitude intervals. The paper should better justify why pitch and focal length are excluded from the decoding adaptation, particularly given the claim that all three geometry variables affect imaging conditions.
Questions for authors
Please refer to Weaknesses.
5 comments
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you for your review. The authors have submitted their rebuttal. Could you please take a moment to review their responses?
Thank you for your time and contribution!
Best regards, Area Chair
Most of my concerns have been well addressed.
Dear Reviewer cXM8:
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful evaluation and constructive suggestions. We provide our responses below.
Reply to W1:
The scope of this study does not include dynamically changing camera geometry within a tracking sequence. Our experimental setting focuses on geometry conditioning across different fixed settings, where camera parameters remain constant within each sequence but vary across sequences. We will clarify this limitation in the revised paper and investigate dynamically changing camera geometry in future work.
Reply to W2:
We have evaluated geometry estimation accuracy on test sequences and compared tracking performance using recorded and estimated geometry.
Geometry estimation MAE:
Tracking AUC (%):
Using estimated geometry reduces AUC by 0.07, 1.63, and 1.74 percentage points compared with recorded geometry. These results quantify the estimator's accuracy and its impact on tracking performance.
Reply to W3:
We retrain GeoVLT after excluding all training sequences with a focal multiplier of 1.5, while retaining the standard model trained on the original training split for comparison. Both models are evaluated on the same 11 test sequences recorded at 1.5. For the holdout model, we further compare the correct focal multiplier (1.5) with an alternative input (1.4), keeping altitude and gimbal pitch angle at their recorded values.
The holdout model achieves 77.73% AUC, only 0.83 points below standard training. Using the correct focal multiplier further improves AUC by 3.56 points over using 1.4, supporting effective geometry conditioning at an unseen focal setting.
Reply to W4:
We have incorporated all four suggested references, including ViewSAM, Gen4Track, Consistencies Are All You Need, and Beyond Visual Cues, into the Introduction and Related Work sections at appropriate locations. These additions provide a more comprehensive overview of recent vision–language tracking research and better clarify the positioning of GeoVLT relative to existing approaches. This will be reflected in the revised version of the paper.
Reply to W5:
GCR and GATP incorporate all three geometry parameters to condition target representation and temporal propagation. GCD, in contrast, performs local aggregation on response and offset maps that have already been conditioned on the full geometry tuple. Since altitude provides a coarse cue for target scale, we use it to select the local decoding parameters, keeping the final readout simple without introducing additional mappings for pitch angle and focal length.
We further compare shared GCD parameter pairs across altitude groups:
Different altitude groups favor different decoding settings. Altitude-conditioned GCD achieves a mean AUC of 75.61%, compared with 75.34% for the best shared setting among those tested. These results support altitude-dependent decoding adaptation.