- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates surgical phase as a strong prior for vessel segmentation in laparoscopic gastrectomy. Experiments on the LapGC-KVAD-30 dataset show that Phase-FiLM improves binary vessel segmentation over a no-phase baseline. The authors also conduct additional ablations on feature injection strategy, backbone choice, wrong-phase inputs, and simulated phase-recognition errors.
Critical strengths
The research motivation is clear and has clinical significance. The paper utilises the ‘surgical phase’ as prior information to assist with vessel segmentation. This approach aligns with the characteristic of surgical procedures having a well-defined phasic structure, and phase-only classification experiments demonstrate a strong correlation between the phase and the appearance of blood vessels.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty appears relatively limited. The proposed Phase-FiLM primarily incorporates surgical phase embeddings into SAM2 features through the conventional scale-and-shift operations of FiLM. While the experimental improvements are encouraging, the architectural contribution is largely an adaptation of an existing conditioning mechanism. The authors should more clearly distinguish their technical contributions from established feature modulation approaches and provide stronger justification for the methodological novelty.
-
The manuscript would benefit from further polishing and refinement. The abstract contains an extensive discussion of experimental results and numerical comparisons, which somewhat obscures the main research motivation and methodological contributions. In addition, several sections contain noticeable formatting and spacing inconsistencies, particularly around mathematical expressions and numerical results. A more concise abstract and careful proofreading would improve the overall presentation.
-
The task formulation does not fully exploit the available annotations. Although LapGC-KVAD-30 provides annotations for 15 vessel categories, the primary segmentation task combines them into a single binary vessel mask. This formulation evaluates vessel localization but does not address the more challenging task of distinguishing individual vascular structures. Given that the paper emphasizes phase-dependent anatomical information and vessel recognition, additional experiments on fine-grained multi-class vessel segmentation would substantially strengthen the contribution.
-
The experimental validation is limited to a single dataset. All experiments are conducted on LapGC-KVAD-30, which contains 30 surgical procedures collected at a single institution. Although the authors adopt case-level data splits and evaluate multiple backbones, these experiments do not fully establish generalizability across different surgical procedures, imaging conditions, or clinical institutions. Additional cross-dataset or external validation would provide stronger support for the broader applicability of the proposed approach.
-
The figures could be improved to communicate the technical contributions more effectively. Figure 1 presents the overall architecture but offers limited insight beyond the standard FiLM conditioning mechanism described in the text. Similarly, several experimental figures primarily visualize numerical comparisons without providing additional analysis. The authors could improve the information density and clarity of these figures by highlighting the feature modulation mechanism more explicitly and incorporating more informative qualitative or diagnostic visualizations.
-
The practical applicability of phase-conditioned segmentation requires further validation. The main experiments assume access to ground-truth surgical phase labels at inference time. Although the authors simulate phase recognition errors through random label corruption, this setting may not adequately reflect the temporally correlated and phase-dependent errors produced by real phase recognition models. An end-to-end evaluation using predicted surgical phases would provide more convincing evidence of the method's practical effectiveness.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors clarify the novelty of Phase-FiLM relative to standard FiLM-based conditioning? It would be helpful to better distinguish the methodological contribution from a straightforward application of existing FiLM conditioning.
-
Can the authors further improve the presentation quality of the manuscript? The current abstract is unusually dense, several figures are visually simplistic.