- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This work addresses the problem of adaptive action chunking. From my understanding, the method applies guidance or correction to the diffusion process to make the diffused action chunk more consistent with the unexecuted portion of the previous chunk. The consistency is weighted so that the guidance is stronger in directions that have larger second differences (along the diffusion path). The setup also provides a mechanism for deciding how long to execute the chunk before observing.
Critical strengths
The proposed method appears to work and (if I understanding things correctly) and the guidance framework would enable the model to diffuse more consistent trajectories.
Critical weaknesses
Writing could be clearer. Please provide a clear problem statement and setup in Section 3.
The overall denoising process could be better explained. The action chunk is denoted as in 3.1. But in 3.2, this changes to and then the updated is denoted as candidate ?
How is c adapted to obtain the final denoised action chunk? From what I can infer, the final correction term is \Delta p_hist where the potential is scaled with W_n. I'm having trouble understanding why the matrix W_n (which captures curvature) would be useful in this setup. Why are the historical second differences across the diffusion process meaningful? What is the intuition? It is capturing "uncertainty" in the diffusion process.
Also, I think the nature of the action chunk being denoised needs some clarification. For this to work out, I think the chunk c (or x) should represent velocities or position differences / increments? Absolute position targets don't seem to make sense given the accumulation. Perhaps I am misunderstanding here.
It is unclear to me what the "variation energy" is in Eq (4) or how it is obtained or set? It appears to be some sort of regularization given it is part of the solution W_n.
The experimental results in Table 1 suggest the method does perform better in some settings compared to the baselines but the performance difference is very small. Are these differences meaningful and statistically significant?
minor:
- There has been recent work on streaming flow policies [Jiang et al, CoRL'25] and their stochastic counterparts that permit guidance/conditioning [Jiang et al, R:SS'26]. Are they related?
- "Collaboration et al., 2023"" is not the right citation for the OpenX Embodiment paper
- What is the "resulting metric" or the "stability readout"? These are mentioned without being first defined or explained. It is only defined later in (5) and (7).
Questions for authors
Please see the questions in the weaknesses section above.