- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces FlexTempRule, a neuro-symbolic approach for interpretable time series classification that combines adaptive segmentation, temporal logic rules with different degrees of flexibility, and statistical features. The approach aims to provide model-consistent explanations while maintaining competitive classification performance. Experiments on univariate and multivariate time series.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a relevant problem, and the gaps in the literature are clearly identified through a well-written and up-to-date introduction. A particularly interesting aspect is the combination of multiple time series representations, following a direction similar to approaches such as HIVE-COTE, MultiRocket, and MR-HYDRA. The integration of flexible temporal rules with statistical features is a promising contribution.
Critical weaknesses
The experimental evaluation is limited to a relatively small number of datasets, which is unusual in time series classification, where extensive benchmarking on the UCR/UEA collections is standard. Moreover, an important interpretable competitor, BORF (Spinnato, F., Guidotti, R., Monreale, A., & Nanni, M. (2024). Fast, interpretable, and deterministic time series classification with a bag-of-receptive-fields. IEEE Access, 12, 137893-137912.), is missing. The comparison should also include traditional baselines such as 1-NN with DTW and state-of-the-art approaches such as ROCKET, HIVE-COTE v2, and MultiRocket-HYDRA. Statistical significance tests are also missing. From an interpretability perspective, examples of extracted rules accompanied by the corresponding time series would strengthen the evaluation. Moreover, I personally found the notation involving squares and diamonds difficult to read. Although established in temporal logic, a more intuitive presentation could improve readability.
Questions for authors
Could the authors extend the benchmarking to a larger collection of UCR/UEA datasets, including BORF and other state-of-the-art competitors, and report statistical significance tests? Could the authors provide concrete examples of extracted rules alongside the corresponding time series in the main paper to better illustrate their interpretability?