- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes Lapras, a post-training framework that equips time-series language models with latent reasoning instead of textual reasoning. Lapras uses a shared-parameter teacher–student self-distillation setup. Across 4 TSLM backbones and 5 time-series QA benchmarks, Lapras improves macro-F1 over explicit CoT by up to 10.79% while generating far fewer tokens, and its continuous thoughts can be decoded back into readable traces.
Critical strengths
- The paper is well-written and easy to follow.
- The problem this paper tackles is interesting and validates the feasibility of latent reasoning in time-series reasoning.
- The experiments on multiple benchmarks validate the effectiveness of the proposed method over other latent reasoning baselines.
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty is somewhat limited, since, compared to text reasoning, this work conditions on the time series as input; however, there's no specific design toward learning the time series. It is similar to Coconut [1] with multimodal input.
- There's a lack of comparison between textual and visualized time series representations as inputs for reasoning. Although latent reasoning shows improvements, it cannot justify its advantage over textual reasoning based on models like Qwen3.5 and Qwen3-VL.
- Figure 6 shows Lapras incurs substantially more wall-time than No-CoT (e.g., 171 ms vs 68 ms on ECG), contradicting the claim of “less than 8 ms overhead compared to No-CoT.
- Benchmarks are all multiple-choice. It remains unclear whether the approach scales to open-ended benchmarks.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses above.
We thank the reviewer for the thorough feedback. We have added the relevant experiments to the revised manuscript, and below we summarize these results along with our clarifications.
W1 Novelty Concern. The novelty of our work lies not only in "what" we propose but also in "why" and "how" current standard CoT-SFT fails in time series reasoning tasks, which directly motivates latent reasoning as a promising alternative paradigm for TSLM. As our primary contribution, we are the first to reveal a fundamental limitation of CoT-SFT in TSLMs, which we term the verbalization bottleneck: when the model translates a continuous time series into text, it discards task-relevant temporal evidence, and the resulting errors propagate through the reasoning chain (Section 3.1). We further support this through our systematic evaluation across four backbones and five tasks, which indicates that explicit CoT underperforms No-CoT in average F1 in most cases while incurring a substantially higher inference cost. Given this diagnosis, we adopt latent reasoning to keep reasoning in the joint time series and text embedding space, and for simplicity we only add time series masking to prevent shortcut learning. To our knowledge, Lapras is the first to show that latent reasoning can operate in a joint time series and text embedding space, and achieves significant performance improvement over the conventional CoT-SFT models.
W2 Time Series Representation. We have included the experiment that the reviewer suggested in Appendix A.4. In summary, we follow the standard protocol of ChatTS, which also compares time series encoder inputs against serialized text and rendered plot inputs. Specifically, we give each series to Qwen3-8B as serialized numeric text and to Qwen3-VL-8B as a rendered plot, and we evaluate both models zero-shot and after CoT-SFT on the same training data for the same number of steps as Lapras. As the results show, both textual and visualized time series representations perform poorly in the zero-shot setting. After CoT-SFT, the average accuracy rises from 30.5% to 56.7% with the text representation and from 34.7% to 59.8% with the plot representation. Both still underperform our time series encoder CoT-SFT baseline (61.8%) and fall well short of ChatTS-Lapras (71.2%). Overall, the results are consistent with the conclusion of ChatTS that text and plots are not effective representations of time series, which justifies our use of a time series encoder.
Table A.4. Time series encoder vs. text and plot inputs. Accuracy (%) on the five tasks. Bold marks the best per column.
W3 Typo. Thanks for catching this typo. The intended statement is that Lapras adds less than 87 ms of overhead on average relative to No-CoT, which remains a favorable tradeoff given its performance gains. We have corrected this in the revised manuscript
W4 Evaluation Protocol. We clarify that evaluation uses open-ended generation, following the protocol of OpenTSLM [ICML 2026] and ST-Reasoner [ACL 2026 Oral]. The model reasons and writes its final answer as free text. Each question comes with its own candidate answers, which makes the setting look like multiple choice, but these candidates exist only so that rule-based answer extraction can score the free-text output reliably.
Above all, we hope we have clarified that Lapras addresses a fundamental limitation that goes beyond its training recipe. This work offers two insights that prior work has not shown. First and most importantly, we identify and empirically characterize the verbalization bottleneck, in which errors that arise while describing the signal in text propagate through the reasoning chain. Second, we show that latent reasoning can operate in the joint time series–language space rather than in text embeddings alone. If our responses have addressed your concerns, we would be grateful if you would consider raising your score.