- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces WholeSight, a multimodal model that uses regional search and local zooming to answer questions about whole-slide pathology images. Training starts with supervised fine-tuning on complete interaction trajectories, followed by reinforcement learning. The model achieves 54.13% accuracy across 2,956 questions in ten evaluation settings. This is a 12.01 percentage-point gain over the original backbone with the same tool interface. The paper also examines observation strategies, tool-call budgets, and visual history.
Critical strengths
1.The comparison using the same backbone and tool interface is convincing. Accuracy rises from 42.12% to 54.13%, with gains in all ten evaluation settings. This provides direct evidence that the training pipeline improves performance. 2.The paper addresses an important problem in whole-slide analysis: finding the evidence needed to answer a question. It brings evidence acquisition and answering into a single training pipeline. The evaluation spans multiple tasks and slide sources. Overall, this is a well-developed system.
Critical weaknesses
1.The methodological contribution is still unclear. Supervised fine-tuning, tool use, and reinforcement learning are well established. The paper mainly brings these components together for whole-slide analysis. The results show that training improves the system. They do not yet establish what this interactive approach adds over other reasonable training strategies. This is my main reservation about acceptance. 2.The local-inspection experiments do not cleanly isolate the value of adaptive decisions. Fixed and adaptive cropping differ in image size, number of observations, and reasoning procedure. The trained model already reaches 50.61% using only the initial retrieved views, compared with 54.13% for the full system. Local inspection helps, but the controls do not separate the effects of location selection, crop scale, and sequential decisions. A baseline that plans all crops upfront would test the core idea more directly. It should use the same backbone and observation budget.
Questions for authors
1.What are the actual input resolutions, visual token counts, and tool-call counts for fixed and adaptive cropping? Does adaptive inspection still help when these factors are matched? 2.How does the model perform if it plans all high-magnification views upfront from the initial low-magnification images, then answers? Is there evidence that revising the plan after each observation provides an additional benefit? 3.Please provide the exact format-reward settings and visual preprocessing configuration. Could you also report confidence intervals or repeated runs for the main results? These details would help assess reproducibility and interpret the smaller performance differences.