- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents BEVLight, a visual traffic signal control framework that directly maps UAV bird’s-eye-view observations to signal phases. The method grounds visual features onto lane-level representations, composes them through the junction topology into movement- and phase-level representations, and applies a shared scorer to rank feasible phases across heterogeneous intersection layouts and signal plans. The model is trained in two stages, first using simulator-provided traffic states to learn control-relevant lane and movement representations, and then using human demonstrations with full phase rankings to train the decision policy. The paper evaluates zero-shot generalization to unseen traffic demands, unseen signal plans, and unseen intersections, and additionally studies transfer from simulated observations to real UAV imagery.
Critical strengths
-
Clear and practically meaningful problem formulation.
The paper addresses a concrete deployment bottleneck in visual traffic signal control: existing methods often rely on structured traffic states or fixed intersection configurations, while BEVLight aims to directly operate on UAV visual observations and generalize across heterogeneous junctions and signal plans. The lane-to-movement-to-phase formulation provides a natural way to remove dependence on fixed action indices. -
Well-motivated topology-grounded architecture.
The proposed architecture closely follows the structure of the control problem. Visual features are first grounded onto individual lanes, then composed into movement and phase representations according to the junction topology, and finally scored using a shared candidate-phase scorer. This design is intuitive and well aligned with the desired cross-layout generalization. -
Reasonably complete closed-loop evaluation.
The paper evaluates progressively harder generalization settings, including unseen traffic demands, unseen signal plans, and jointly unseen intersections, plans, and demands. The reported results are competitive against both conventional and structured-state RL controllers, and the ablations provide evidence for the contributions of visual pretraining and ranking supervision. The paper also includes an offline simulation-to-real study on real UAV observations.
Critical weaknesses
-
The novelty boundary relative to prior visual TSC and topology-generalizable TSC is not sufficiently clear.
Several key ingredients of BEVLight have close precedents. Prior work has already studied direct visual traffic signal control from raw image or BEV observations, while recent generalizable TSC methods have used movement-based representations to unify heterogeneous intersection topologies and signal phases. Therefore, the main contribution appears to lie in the combination of UAV visual grounding, explicit lane-to-movement-to-phase composition, and human ranking supervision, rather than in visual TSC or topology-aware generalization individually. The paper would benefit from positioning this novelty more explicitly against the closest prior work. -
The baseline set does not fully support the paper’s strongest claims.
The current visual baselines are mainly perception-to-structured-state pipelines, rather than competitive end-to-end visual TSC methods. This makes it difficult to determine whether the gains come specifically from BEVLight’s topology-grounded formulation or simply from learning control directly from visual observations. Similarly, since cross-topology generalization is a central claim, stronger comparison with recent universal/generalizable TSC methods would be important. In particular, a direct visual-control baseline and a movement-based cross-topology baseline would make the empirical contribution substantially more convincing.
Questions for authors
Can the authors strengthen the baseline comparison with (i) a direct visual TSC baseline, e.g., a TrafficDojo-style controller that uses the same UAV BEV observations but does not employ the proposed lane-to-movement-to-phase composition, and (ii) a recent movement-based generalizable TSC method such as Unicorn under the same unseen-plan and unseen-junction splits?
3 comments
Response to rebuttal
Thank you for your thorough and thoughtful rebuttal. I believe your responses and additional experiments have adequately resolved my concerns.
However, given my limited expertise in this specific task, I do not feel sufficiently confident to assign the highest score of 4. I appreciate your efforts and wish you all the best with the remainder of the rebuttal process.
Thank you so much for your positive feedback! We really appreciate your time and thoughtful comments throughout the review process. Your suggestions have been very helpful in improving our paper.
We wish you all the best!
Response to Reviewer qBQd
We sincerely thank you for the constructive feedback and positive assessment. In the revised manuscript, we have clarified the novelty relative to prior TSC methods and added new baseline comparisons with vision-only VLMLight variants in Appendix D.2, with all revisions highlighted in blue.
UAVs provide flexible, on-demand BEV observations that capture intersection geometry and lane-level traffic conditions in a unified view, making them well suited for visual TSC. BEVLight is designed to map raw BEV imagery directly to signal decisions across heterogeneous intersection layouts and signal plans, while learning across diverse visual styles to generalize to unseen traffic demands and real-world visual conditions. Unlike prior topology-generalizable controllers that rely on pre-estimated lane scalars or visual controllers tied to fixed action spaces, BEVLight decouples visual observations from fixed action indices and learns appearance-invariant phase rankings.
A TrafficDojo-style controller takes the raw image directly as input to predict discrete action indices, but it cannot be jointly trained or generalized across different configurations because the movement semantics of each action index are not reflected in the road image itself. As illustrated in Figure 4, for Plan A and Plan B of the same intersection such as Gaojiaoyuan, action index 1 represents opposing through movements in Plan A, whereas it represents single-approach through and left-turn movements in Plan B. Consequently, directly mapping BEV images to action indices without lane-to-movement-to-phase grounding creates conflicting action labels across plans during training and results in complete intersection gridlock on unseen signal plans and junctions, confirming the necessity of our topological grounding and composition.
The details of the novelty positioning and boundaries with prior work have been clarified in Abstract and Introduction of the revised manuscript.Under the unseen-demand, unseen-plan, and unseen-junction splits, Table 1 compares BEVLight against representative RL-based TSC methods that receive ground-truth structured traffic states from the simulator, as well as two-stage visual baselines, since very few existing methods directly support generalizable control from UAV BEV imagery.
To further strengthen the baseline comparisons, we have added an evaluation of the recent vision-language controller VLMLight in Appendix D.2. For a fair comparison under purely visual inputs, we do not provide ground-truth structured lane queue lengths to VLMLight; instead, we evaluate both VLMLight and VLMLight-Think using DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-1017 with reasoning mode enabled by providing the UAV BEV image combined with the visual mask diagrams of all candidate phases to select the target phase index. Table 8 in Appendix D.2 reports the closed-loop average vehicle waiting time in seconds:
Here,
-indicates severe intersection gridlock where vehicles fail to clear. Without structured traffic states, general-purpose vision-language models struggle to aggregate fine-grained queues across lanes, particularly for opposing-movement phases in Plan B, leading to high waiting times on Guanghua B and gridlock on Songdo B. In contrast, BEVLight consistently outperforms both vision-only VLMLight variants, prevents gridlock on Songdo B, and matches or surpasses the oracle structured-state baselines.The details of the additional baseline comparisons and domain generalization experiments have been clarified in Related Work and Appendix D.1 (Page 27) of the revised manuscript.