The paper was formulated strangely, and it was not easy to understand what it was about. Partly through the structure or introduction, but also because of the way the model is presented. The model choice is not motivated well. I will proceed with details now.
Abstract:
Line 013: “how fast that body wears” - I had to read this line 3 times. I assume you mean “wear and tear“ but because there’s no clear context it would be good if you say it in different words. At first, I thought you were talking about clothes for the robot, but that obviously doesn’t make sense.
Line 014: “would reveal its wear resistance wears the body it would protect” - I am not sure I understand what this tries to say. Are you trying to say that it is not possible to test the properties that protect a robot from damage because testing them would precisely have to probe the behaviors that create that damage?
Line 016: “set before the body is drawn” - what do you mean by "drawn"? After a lot of reflection, I suspect you mean drawn from a distribution, but that is a very weird thing to say without context. A body is constructed, a body is grown or something like that. Please clarify.
What is a “load-gated” nociceptive channel? Why does it matter here?
Line 018: this whole sentence is very difficult to parse. What do you mean by “best paid work, not yet felt rather than the gentlest“? I have an idea what you might mean but I’m not sure.
Line 019: what do you mean by an agent without retention? Do you mean memory?
Line 024: what is the working life of 55? Days, years? If the latter, that sounds more like a statement about humans, but you have been talking about robots, no? The whole numbers don’t mean anything without context and units. At some point later you say years, but what does it have to do with the topic of your work? Are you studying humans? Later in your declarations, you say that you get the data from the literature, but how are they related to the robots?
Line 026, what does -.54 output mean?
Line 028: “the difference is what a species prior already supplies and a single body has none” - I can only guess what you mean. I suspect what you mean, as that an individual organism of species does not have access to the priors about damage.
That is not quite true if that’s what you mean. In fact, there are a lot of priors baked into the bodies of organisms. In fact, some theories, like the free energy theory, make the point that the evolutionary priors determine how decisions are being made, even if we do not directly assume nociception, which is of course, part of the priors in general.
What is \chi?
After reading the abstract, I was left quite disoriented and only after the whole paper I started seeing what was probably meant. Please rewrite.
Main paper:
Line 038 following: the first paragraph was not entirely clear
Line 052: you say “what remains as memorization, conditioning on what has been felt rather than an estimate“ – this is confusing because I thought you were talking about less than one informative event, rather trying to avoid these states. In short, I don’t really understand what the point of the sentences.
Line 059: “load-gated” - what do you mean by this and why?
Line 060: "affords substitution within the repertoire a trade or a mission permits“ - I can only guess what this means, please spell it out.
Line 062 and following: the sentence starting with “pain moves the allocation” is not clear. Many things are expressed relatively indirectly with concepts that the author may have in mind but that are not clear to the reader. Do you mean to say that pain makes sure that the agent allocates behaviors in different regions of behavior? What’s the role of the load? Please rewrite.
Line 067: “and returns it“ – what is “it“? “Whenever the signal dips“ – what is the signal? Is it pain? Is it work? Is it reward?
Line 070: “the loop is conditional at every link“ – I have no idea what that means. Conditional on what? What link? “That still clears the output floor“ – what is the output floor? What does clearing mean?
Line 072: like in the abstract, it appears that the paper seems to jump between machine learning context and human context. When you mention the clinical counterpart, is that an analogy or is it something you are going to model or is it something that you’re going to apply it to?
If it is an analogy, what is it that exactly you’re trying to say? Is it that a very specific sensation may fool the machine to believe that it is not harmful despite it being harmful? Or is that something else?
Later you talk about various numbers and about 2000 paired bodies, and it seems you speak about humans, but it’s not clear. What is the context within your machine learning study? If you switch context, give a motivation give an explanation and make it explicit.
Line 079: “when it reads the signal“ – do you mean the pain signal?
Line 086-087: I do not understand these two lines
Line 092: “the channel is worth the same“ – what channel?
Line 119: “an untried option looks free” – what does free mean here?
Line 143: what is a world with a “hidden“ body?
Line 145: you say that the slow loop receives nothing back. But in evolution that is not really true. The slow loop is evolution and that receives feedback by selection. If I misunderstood what you’re talking about, please explain better.
Line 152: “the load the body carries is neither“– what do you mean by it is chosen inside the life?
Line 154: “requires no genomic assumption” – what do you mean by genic assumption? Also, it seems that you have evolution in the back of your mind, which means there is feedback into the system even if slow. Please separate all your levels of learning clearly, and also whether you talk about an artificial agent or a human because currently the paper seems to jump between the different levels without announcement and it makes it very hard to follow.
Line 155:M_t, is that a real valued number?
Line 157: “best paid day type wears the joint” – this is very difficult to understand. I think what you’re trying to say is that if you purely optimize for reward, you might not appropriately minimize wear and tear, and may be hard on the robot joints. Is that what you mean? Feel free to reformulate it but it needs to be clear, without context.
What is \Delta?
Line 157-158: I do not understand that sentence
Figure 1: what do you mean by “work lost when no mix clears it“? Then, in the slow loop you talk that nothing returns from life. However, we do have evolution. So what do you mean by this?
I completely fail to understand the measurement box.
Line 188: in the wear worlds – what does this mean? What do you mean by “hazard weighted load times an amplification that rises”? What is “net of a slow repair term”? What is \kappa? Is that a number or something else?
Line 195: “no admissible mix clears y“ – what do you mean by admissible mix? What do you mean by y?
Line 205: what is the filtration over? Why does it appear here? What is its role? What channel set C do you talk about? What is the reference arm defined by?
Line 209: what is C? how is that the deployment competence and what does that mean?
Lines 212 following: I completely don’t understand the following paragraph
Line 221: what is S?
Line 222: what does it mean when you say “activity is worked”? What do you mean by saying work substitutes away from it?
Line 224: “Salience-gating: events saturate the scale so the spike alone triggers a write" – I have absolutely no idea what you’re talking about. Do you use a neural spiking model here?
Line 235: what mix are you talking about? What does equation 2 tell us? Where does the noise \sigma_s suddenly come from in the model. I was not aware that we had included any stochasticity so far.
Equation 3: what is y? What is c?
Lines 258 and the next following lines: I don’t understand what this paragraph is talking about? How is the forgetting implemented?
You need to explain your model in detail so that it’s reproducible. Details can be, of course in the appendix, but even on a high-level I have no idea how your model looks like.
Line 301 and following: “on the channel we ship no residual information” – what does it mean? What’s the role of the filtration here? What does it model?
Theorem 1: “mean return alone does not pay protection” – what does this mean? Does it mean that by looking at the mean return you can’t see if damage is incurred? One would expect that because of course mean is not complete without variance, and the letter determines if you exceed the tolerances of your system. But I don’t understand the subsequent formula c > (p^+-p) L_e
Line 387 and following, Table 1: what is this talk about cartilage lost? How does it relate to your machine learning theorems? What is meniscal competence? What are the units of the numbers in the table?
Line 404: “what one life adds to a body that knows nothing“ – unclear
Line 434: “on one floor layers knee” – what does this mean?
Lines 436 and 437: I do not understand what you talk about in terms of gain and loss
Line 480: replace “in” by “for”
Line 486 following, reproducibility statement: it appears that the authors have some kind of care scenario in mind if that’s the case and if that is relevant to the scenario above, it should be stated very clearly at the beginning it would make it much easier to understand the text.
Line 539: “the protection the body model buys is not needed“ – what does this mean?