The paper is very poorly written, to a point that significantly impedes my ability to assess its scientific value. There are significant issues with the clarity and communication of this work.
Overall. The presentation of the paper is way below the bar for ICLR. As it stands I cannot truly assess the scientific quality from this paper. The paper needs full restructuring, better and more clear motivation, an introduction to the application and the problem formulation, introduction to the data used for this study, clear articulation of the methodology, better examination of the prior work, clear statement of limitations and articulation of the findings.
Below I list a subset of potential clarity/presentation issues:
Starting from the abstract, the authors start with a generic research question:
"Which inductive bias should a spatiotemporal operator have?" and then proceed to describe an experiment for a very specific task i.e. Wildfire spread prediction, which can by no means answer the question they themselves pose. Moreover their sentences are, to me, impossible to follow. For example quoting from the abstract:
"Which inductive bias should a spatiotemporal operator have? We compare a
gated global–local operator—spectral graph mixing fused per cell with local
convolution—against convolutional recurrent baselines on 27 cross-state wildfire
cases, and find that the answer depends on how far the fire front moves per model
step. On the slowest fires of the main pool, under per-fire ROC-AUC, the op-
erator ties the recurrent baseline at h=1 and leads it from h=3 on, the margin
growing with horizon (+0.006, +0.047, +0.064 on a 6 h lattice); on the fastest it
loses, and removing either branch, adding spectral or local capacity, or widening
the training ring does not close that gap."
No build-up, no explanatation. What is a cell? What is h? What is the main pool? What is the data? What is gated global-local operator---spectral graph mixing fused per cell with local convolution? All these are incomprehensible. The main text follows this paradigm.
For example in L44-49:
What is a free-running rollout? What is a front? What is a cell per model step?
L51-53: What is measured per-step displacement? what is base-FNO (never defined). " global spectral path in isolation , degrades
(0.736 →0.731 →0.662)" What do these numbers represent? What is the global spectral path in isolation?
L80-L82. What are the input data? What is the problem you tackle exactly? What are teacher-forced and free-running modes?
Figure 1 is also fully unclear, with a bolded title that conveys no information. The caption needs improvement.
The contribution list is unclear and raise more questions than provides answers. A contribution list should be a clear indicator of the findings of a paper. Here the titles of each bullets do not convey anything to the reader. For example:
-
Bullet 1: A regime-conditioned ranking on a unified spread-rate axis. -- Again what is a "main pool"?
-
Bullet 2: What does re-indexing mean? This is the first time this is discussed.
-
Bullet 3: "removing a branch changes which regime wins rather than uni-
formly hurting performance (at h=5 the spectral-only arm matches the dual-branch model on
two of three states); pure-focal training, widened rings, gate-capacity increases (normalization-
confounded) and unconstrained fusion do not unlock fast-fire performance; "
- What is a branch? This is the first time this is mentioned.
- What is a spectral arm?
- What is the dual-branch model?
- What is pure focal training?
- Widening rings? gate-capacity?
- What is fast-fire? There has been no introduction to the actual application, and no real introduction to the motivation of this work.
L114-127 : "Across this literature the architectures are predominantly local, and compar-
isons are made at a fixed spatiotemporal resolution under teacher-forced or single-horizon evalua-
tion. We complement it by testing California-to-27-fire transfer with free-running feedback, and by treat-
ing the temporal sampling interval itself as an experimental variable. The question is whether rank-
ings remain stable when the protocol changes, not which model wins one leaderboard."
This is section 2 and we still don't know the actual problem, the input data, and the expected output.
Section 3.
L148. In fact this is the fist definition of a frontier set.
L151. F(x) and φ(b,e) are undefined. We can only guess what they represent.
L162 What does endogenous mean in this case?
Section 4.
L175 We discuss the input features to the proposed method but we still don't know what kind of input the method is expected to have.
L182: K1/K5 is undefined. We have no clue what they represent. In fact in L177-188 there are 3 different (probably) Ks. K_seq, Top-K and K1/K5.
L190 Uk is undefined as well.
Section 5.
This is the first time we discuss about the input data. Apparently we are dealing with a VIIRS dataset.
L316: What is WA and AZ maximum? OR? All undefined.
We thank R2 for the careful review. R2 found the two weakest points of our evidence. We made new measurements for both. The first result changes our claim.
Two problems in the submitted Table 3.
New measurement. We evaluated the verified GLOW checkpoints with the Table 1 protocol on this pool and on a second pool of 49 fires. Both contain the 27 main-pool fires. Outside the main pool, they add 26 and 22 fires, with no overlap. We used the ConvLSTM checkpoints of Table 1. On the main-pool fires, the new GLOW scores agree with Table 1 (differences below 10⁻⁴ at h = 1, 3 and 5).
Result outside the main pool (Table 6 of the revised PDF). Of the 48 fires, 16 are scorable.
The relation between rate and Δ is r(log rate, Δ) = +0.06 (p = 0.82). One mid fire (AZ_2020_44) has a ConvLSTM score of 0.30 and Δ = +0.40. Without it, Δ for all fires is −0.026.
What this means.
Corrected table (Table 8 of the revised PDF; verified GLOW, positives-weighted, 27 scorable fires):
The slow and mid leads come from main-pool fires. On the new fires, Δ is −0.067 (2 slow fires, 0 wins), −0.004 (8 mid fires, 3 wins) and −0.023 (2 fast fires, 1 win). Table 8 shows the main-pool fires and the new fires in separate rows. Its weights differ from Table 2, which gives unweighted means.
Our revised claim. GLOW's score relative to ConvLSTM decreases as the spread rate increases. The main pool and the rebuilt dataset show this. A slow-fire lead of GLOW appears only in the main pool. We removed the general slow-fire claim from the abstract and from §1. Table 2 of the revised PDF compares the three sets of fires.