- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper address wildfire forecasting via student-teacher distillation. For this, it proposes to apply Morse theory to guide the student to focus on relevant events in space and time to add additional teacher supervision. First, a spatio-temporal graph is constructed then a Morse theory is used to simplify the graph into critical nodes. The distillation is then enforced on these detected critical nodes. The paper tested the proposed distillation method on different wildfire datasets and showed better results than different baselines.
Critical strengths
- I think the proposed method is applicable to broader tasks beyond wildfire forecasting.
Critical weaknesses
This paper should be rejected because:
- The paper is unclear and misses many details. Just to give few examples, the problem formulation is unclear, the input spatial and temporal resolution as well as the forecast horizon is not mentioned. What are the predictors? How is the architectural design? How is pretraining of the teacher network done?
- Unfortunately, the experiments do not provide convincing evidence of the correctness of the proposed approach. Why should the critical events be wildfire? I also believe that the experimental setup is not standard for wildfire forecasts and the experiments were not run on benchmarks. The evaluation metric does not fit the task. The paper should report classification metrics e.g., F1 AORUC, AUPRC, ... etc. The RMSE is not a measure for wildfire forecasting.
Questions for authors
- “Experiments on 10 wildfire benchmarks”. This is not true. Are these really benchmarks? I couldn’t find the references for these benchmarks. Where do the baselines come from and are the reported numbers from the benchmark’s papers?
- Ablation study should report all combinations of MorseDistill components. Some components could be redundant. Why not only add weights to the critical events instead of feeding two graphs? I mean the methodological design is not motivated or validated.
- Can’t we just give more weight to critical events? Why do we need to encode them separately? Do you have any experiments to motivate the design?
- Did you use AI for writing the code? Scripts like transformer_st.py are AI-generated. Please make the AI-statement computable.
- Can you show the raw graph and the simplified one from morse along with the critical events?
- L437: “We conduct a systematic search over all hyperparameters”, the hyperparameters are identical for all models.
- Is the spatial location of the graph fixed for each dataset? What is the spatial and temporal resolution? What is the forecast horizon? Many details are missing about the methodology. The paper only focuses on the MorseDistill. What are the input variables?
Minor:
- L62-65: I do not think this is true. There are cheap transformers and many state-of-the-art systems e.g., weather forecast systems use transformers in an operational setting.
- L120-129: point 2 is redundant.
- Related works is incomplete: Wildfire is a well studied problem. You are also assuming that wildfire problem is essentially only timeseries forecast. This is not true.
- L158-159: Diffusion is introduced without introduction. I think you should mention that you want to use generative diffusion in the introduction otherwise lines 158-159 are out of context.
- L167: “Full and Critical Event Encoding” this is not shown in the figure. Unclear.
- Shouldn’t the diffusion output discrete values to localize the events? How do you convert the continuous output to discrete ones. Or does the diffusion output wildfire probability at each time steps?
- Basin-level alignment is unclear.
- L342-343: what is the ? it is not clear?
- L128-129: When you talk about cost, is it only about inference? Because this is misleading.
16 comments
Response to Reviewer QNNh (2/8)
Q2: Why should the critical events be wildfire? I also believe that the experimental setup is not standard for wildfire forecasts and the experiments were not run on benchmarks. The evaluation metric does not fit the task. The paper should report classification metrics e.g., F1 AORUC, AUPRC, ... etc. The RMSE is not a measure for wildfire forecasting.
A: In this paper, we study next-event prediction in a spatio-temporal point process (STPP). Given the times and locations of past wildfire observations, the model predicts how much time will elapse before the next observation and where it will occur. In a hotspot sequence, successive observations can be detections of the same fire. Our choice of metrics follows the accepted practice in fire sciences (see, e.g., Eaturu and Vadrevu, “Evaluation of machine learning and deep learning algorithms for fire prediction in Southeast Asia” Scientific Reports 2025) as well as ML studies on the next-event evaluations such as DSTPP (Yuan et al., KDD 2023) and TEN-DM (Liu et al., ICLR 2026). Both DSTPP and TEN-DM report temporal RMSE for the interval until the next event and mean Euclidean distance for its location. These metrics measure the two quantities our model predicts. F1, AUROC, and AUPRC would be appropriate for a question such as whether a fire occurs in a specified grid cell within a given time window, and such classification task falls outside the scope of our study which focuses on predicting when and where the next wildfire observation will be recorded.
Eaturu, A. and Vadrevu, K.P., 2025. Evaluation of machine learning and deep learning algorithms for fire prediction in Southeast Asia. Scientific Reports, 15(1), p.18807.
Yuan, Y., Ding, J., Shao, C., Jin, D. and Li, Y., 2023, August. Spatio-temporal diffusion point processes. In Proceedings of the 29th ACM SIGKDD conference on knowledge discovery and data mining (pp. 3173-3184).
Liu, Y., Wang, K., Yang, C.Y., Gel, Y.R. and Chen, Y., 2026, January. TEN-DM: Topology-Enhanced Diffusion Model for Spatio-Temporal Event Prediction. The International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR).
Q3: “Experiments on 10 wildfire benchmarks”. This is not true. Are these really benchmarks? I couldn’t find the references for these benchmarks. Where do the baselines come from and are the reported numbers from the benchmark’s papers?
A: Yes, they are really open-source benchmarks. eMAS, GK2A, and MASTER are three subsets of Fire-D (https://zenodo.org/records/15428368), a public collection of calibrated wildfire and smoke imagery with georeferenced labels maintained by NASA’s Jet Propulsion Lab. The three names identify the instruments or platforms that collected the observations. Fire-D provides the source data, and our paper defines the next-observation forecasting task used to compare methods. eMAS contains airborne multispectral imagery collected by the Enhanced MODIS Airborne Simulator aboard NASA’s ER-2 research aircraft. GK2A contains satellite imagery collected by the Advanced Meteorological Imager aboard South Korea’s Geo-KOMPSAT-2A geostationary satellite, which repeatedly observes the Korean Peninsula. MASTER contains airborne multispectral imagery collected by the MODIS/ASTER Airborne Simulator, which measures radiation across visible and infrared wavelengths.
For Canada (CAN), we use hotspot observations from the publicly available Canada Wildfire 2023 – Hotspot Data (https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/brsdincer/canada-wildfire-2023-hotspot-data).
For the United States, we use publicly available wildfire records from the US Wildfire Dataset (2014–2025) and evaluate all methods separately on six state-level subsets drawn from this collection: Arizona, California, Montana, Oklahoma, Oregon, and Texas (https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/firecastrl/us-wildfire-dataset).
All reported numbers come from running all models on the same datasets, that is, we ran all baselines ourselves under the same experimental settings and with the same computational budget as our MorseDistill.
Response to Reviewer QNNh (3/8)
Q4: Ablation study should report all combinations of MorseDistill components. Some components could be redundant. Why not only add weights to the critical events instead of feeding two graphs? I mean the methodological design is not motivated or validated.
A: We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. To directly examine whether the dual-branch Morse architecture is necessary, we conducted an additional ablation study comparing our dual-branch design against a simpler alternative that assigns higher weights to critical events within a single branch (Critical Weight). Both variants use the same critical-event identification procedure, allowing us to isolate the effect of explicitly modeling critical events through a separate branch. The results are summarized in Table 2. Our dual-branch design consistently outperforms critical-event reweighting across all four datasets, reducing spatial Euclidean distance by 31.09% and temporal RMSE by 8.32% on average. We have also evaluated statistical significance. Our dual-branch Morse architecture achieves statistically significant reductions in spatial Euclidean distance across all four datasets (). For temporal RMSE, our method consistently achieves lower errors across all datasets, with a statistically significant improvement on CA (). These results suggest that simply increasing the importance of critical events within a single representation is insufficient to capture their distinct structural contributions. We have added these new results to the revised version (see Appendix C.4).
Table 2 ( indicates statistically significant)
| Dataset | Dual-branch Spatial ↓ | Dual- branch Temporal ↓ | Critical weight Spatial ↓ | Critical weight Temporal ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CA | 1.2407±0.0166 | 0.0852±0.0010 | 2.4638±0.2231 | 0.1191±0.0059 |
| AZ | 0.8926±0.0063 | 0.3652±0.0079 | 1.4394±0.0600 | 0.3768±0.0055 |
| OK | 0.8381±0.0118 | 2.3260±0.0186 | 1.0260±0.0271 | 2.3394±0.0158 |
| TX | 1.4509±0.0080 | 0.8343±0.0052 | 1.7783±0.0657 | 0.8442±0.0123 |
Note that MorseDistill has one architectural component under consideration, namely the critical-event branch and four distillation objectives. Particularly, matches predictions, matches full-history features, and adds prediction supervision at critical events. These three objectives remain defined without ; on the other hand, matches the separately encoded critical-subsequence features , so retaining this loss while removing is not a valid component combination. In essence, we note that reweighting changes the contribution of existing discrepancies to the loss. The separate branch changes the representations, as the teacher encodes the selected events together (independently of the noncritical events) and the student adds its critical-branch features at their original history positions. Consequently, reweighting full-history feature discrepancies does not implement the critical-subsequence feature objective or introduce the branch’s inference-time computation. From the theoretical stance, the branches receive observations from the same history, particularly the full sequence and its Morse-selected subsequence. The Morse construction supplies one representative per gradient basin, and the encoders do not explicitly receive the Morse quotient’s adjacency. Our additional Critical Weight ablation directly compares the separate-branch design with single-branch critical-event reweighting, using the same selection procedure.
Q5: Did you use AI for writing the code? Scripts like transformer_st.py are AI-generated. Please make the AI-statement computable.
A: We used AI to revise portions of the code for readability, including in transformer_st.py, so reviewers could more easily follow the implementation. We have updated the AI-use statement.
Response to Reviewer QNNh (1/8)
Thank you for your constructive comments and suggestions. We have revised the paper to address all reviewers’ concerns. Here are our point-by-point responses.
Q1: The problem formulation, the input spatial, temporal resolution, forecast horizon, predictors, architectural design, pretraining.
A: We have added more detail into the paper. Given the observed history Hn={(ti,si)}i=1n, where ti and si denote the time and location of the i-th observation, the model learns the conditional distribution of (tn+1−tn,sn+1) given Hn. The predictors are the times and spatial coordinates of past wildfire observations. The target is the next record in the dataset. In a hotspot sequence, two consecutive records can be detections of the same ongoing fire. Our MorseDistill and all baselines receive the same historical times and locations. We evaluate temporal accuracy by the RMSE between predicted and observed inter-event times, and spatial accuracy by the mean Euclidean distance between predicted and observed locations.
MorseDistill uses a Transformer-based diffusion teacher and a smaller student with MLP encoders, as shown in Figure 1. For each dataset, we first train the teacher on the training split to predict the time until the next recorded observation and its location. We then freeze the teacher and train the student on the same split. During distillation, both models receive the same history of observation times and locations for each training example. Each model uses two encoders. The first processes the full observation history. The second processes a chronological subsequence selected by the discrete Morse procedure. This procedure connects observations that are close in space and time and selects one representative per Morse basin at a local peak in detection density. Both encoders use sinusoidal embeddings for timestamps and a learned projection for spatial coordinates. The teacher uses two separate Transformer encoders, and the student uses two independently parameterized MLP encoders. To combine the branches, each model adds the feature vector from the subsequence encoder to the full-history feature vector at the selected observation’s original position. This retains every observation while allowing each selected event to carry information about its relationship to other selected events. The student’s training objective combines a diffusion loss on the observed next event with losses that match the teacher’s predictions and intermediate features. These distillation losses provide supervision over the full history and give additional weight to the Morse-selected observations. At inference, the student’s two MLP encoders produce a combined history representation. The student then uses this representation to guide iterative denoising and jointly predict when and where the next wildfire observation will be recorded.
Each event is represented by a continuous-valued tuple (t,lon,lat). The diffusion model predicts the elapsed time until the next event and its coordinates, (Δt,lon,lat), in continuous space and time. We use discretization only to construct the spatiotemporal Morse features that condition the model. For each dataset, we choose a spatial zoom level targeting approximately 400 cells (50–300 events per cell), and we divide time into 16 quantile bins. The forecast horizon is one event ahead. Each forecast uses the observed history through event i to predict event i+1, so the elapsed time varies across forecasts. Evaluation uses the observed history at each step and involves no autoregressive rollout.
The datasets cover different time scales. In the single-acquisition remote-sensing datasets (eMAS_fire, MASTER_fire, GOES18_smoke, GOES_smoke, and GK2A_fire), observations within a sequence span seconds to minutes. In Canada_fire and the US-state wildfire datasets, sequences can span roughly one day to one week and include observations from successive satellite revisits or fire reports. Table 1 shows mean training-sequence span for each dataset. For a sequence of n observations, we compute its span as tn−t1, the elapsed time from the first observation to the last, and average this quantity over all training sequences in that dataset.
To clarify these time scales, Table 1 reports the mean duration covered by a sequence, while the lead time for an individual forecast is the interval between two consecutive observations. For a sequence of n observations, we compute its span as tn−t1, the elapsed time from the first observation to the last, and average this quantity over all training sequences in that dataset.
Table 1