- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a framework for smart-home agents that replaces repeated LLM-based decision-making with a combination of typed option selection, learned skill preconditions, and deterministic temporal reasoning. The key idea is that many decisions in tool-using agents can be formulated as selecting from predefined options rather than generating text. The framework uses an LLM to extract task goals, a specialized decision model (Jev) to select devices and actions, and rule-based components to handle temporal constraints and execution. Experiments on SimuHome and TimeArena demonstrate substantial improvements in task success and efficiency compared with existing agent baselines.
Critical strengths
-
Clear motivation and interesting perspective. The paper is well written, and the motivation is clearly presented. I appreciate the idea that not all agent decisions require LLM generation, and that separating different types of decisions can improve reliability and efficiency.
-
Strong experimental results. The proposed framework outperforms existing baselines, including ReAct, Reflexion, and ExpeL, particularly on tasks involving temporal constraints and dependencies.
-
Comprehensive evaluation and useful ablations. The paper evaluates different task types, including infeasible requests and concurrent scheduling. The ablation studies provide useful evidence about the contributions of individual components, particularly temporal consistency checking and the explicit none option.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited methodological novelty. While the proposed framework achieves impressive results, the overall contribution feels more like an engineering effort than a novel algorithmic contribution. Most components are based on existing techniques, and the design choices, although effective, are relatively intuitive. I find the empirical improvements convincing, but the paper does not seem to provide particularly surprising or novel algorithmic insights beyond combining these components.
-
Heavy reliance on hand-crafted rules and unclear generalizability. The framework relies on numerous manually designed rules for device grounding, temporal parsing, execution ordering, and tool-call repair. It remains unclear how well this approach would generalize to new smart-home settings with different devices, tool interfaces, or operational requirements. Although the paper evaluates a held-out device type, a more systematic investigation of generalization and the dependence on domain-specific engineering would strengthen the contribution.
-
Limited contribution from some proposed components. The ablation studies suggest that the temporal consistency check and the explicit none option account for most of the performance improvements. In contrast, removing learned contracts only reduces overall success from 92.3% to 90.5%, while replacing the specialized decision model with LLM-based decisions results in a similarly small accuracy difference (92.3% vs. 91.8%), although it increases latency. This raises questions about how much the proposed skill-learning and typed-decision components contribute to task success relative to the simpler deterministic mechanisms.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.
5 comments
Response to Reviewer 3bq7 (2/3)
W2. Dependence on hand-crafted rules and generalizability to new devices, tool interfaces, and operational requirements
We conducted three systematic experiments to quantify rule dependence and test zero-shot generalization across devices, interfaces, and physical requirements (Tables R2, R5, and R6).
1. Ablating all hand-crafted rules (Table R2). We removed every rule of Table 3 at once across 5 seeds.
Table R2. Contribution of the description rules (Table 3) on SimuHome, Gemma 4 12B, mean over five seeds (42–46; 600 episodes each). Columns report success on feasible (F), infeasible (IF) and infeasible scheduling (QT4 IF) episodes and overall (%), precision (%), and agent time per episode (s). "No description rules" removes every component of Table 3 at once and leaves all other components unchanged.
| Variant | F | IF | QT4 IF | Overall | Precision | Time (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ours | 92.8 | 92.9 | 93.1 | 92.8 | 90.5 | 11.5 |
| No description rules (all of Table 3) | 60.3 | 82.4 | 88.9 | 71.3 | 52.7 | 11.6 |
Interpretation of Table R2: Even with zero description rules, our agent achieves 71.3% overall, 82.4% on infeasible episodes (IF), and 88.9% on infeasible scheduling (QT4 IF), outperforming every baseline in Table 1a (ExpeL 62.3%, Reflexion 52.7%, Workflow Memory 45.7%, ReAct 44.8%) by +9.0 to +26.5 points. Infeasible-request detection relies almost entirely on our STN and the none grounding option, while Table 3 rules address simulator-specific conventions on feasible episodes (such as Matter's hundredths unit scaling and working around SimuHome's broken ChangeChannel tool).
2. Generalization to unseen devices: Leave-one-device-type-out across all 16 device types (Table R5). Extending the paper's held-out dehumidifier experiment, we held out every device type one at a time by removing all demonstration trajectories and calls involving that type prior to learning.
Table R5. Leave-one-device-type-out generalization on SimuHome across all 16 device types. For each device type, every demonstration request or call that reads or operates that type is removed before learning, as for the dehumidifier in the paper. Success (%) is reported on the test episodes whose goals involve that type, mean over three seeds (42–44). Because multi-device requests involve more than one device type, the 16 device-type subsets (914 device-episode occurrences in total) span the 500 unique device-involving episodes in SimuHome. The rules of Table 3 are unchanged.
| Held-out device type | Episodes | Gemma 4 12B | Qwen 3.5 9B |
|---|---|---|---|
dehumidifier (Table 1a) | 58 | 98.3 | 96.6 |
on_off_light | 176 | 98.5 | 96.6 |
laundry_dryer | 128 | 89.1 | 83.9 |
laundry_washer | 106 | 82.4 | 80.2 |
dishwasher | 83 | 87.1 | 83.1 |
window_covering_controller | 54 | 98.1 | 93.2 |
air_conditioner | 53 | 89.3 | 89.9 |
air_purifier | 49 | 100.0 | 100.0 |
dimmable_light | 43 | 97.7 | 91.5 |
refrigerator | 33 | 91.9 | 91.9 |
fan | 29 | 98.9 | 96.6 |
heat_pump | 26 | 84.6 | 84.6 |
tv | 26 | 79.5 | 75.6 |
freezer | 19 | 98.2 | 82.5 |
rvc (robot vacuum) | 17 | 82.4 | 82.4 |
humidifier | 14 | 100.0 | 92.9 |
| Mean over device types | 500 | 92.2 | 88.8 |
Interpretation of Table R5: Across all 16 device types (500 unique device-involving episodes), holding out each device type from skill learning yields a mean success rate of 92.2% (Gemma 4 12B) and 88.8% (Qwen 3.5 9B)—within 0.6 percentage points of our full-demonstration agent (92.8% and 89.4%), and reaching 98.1%–100.0% on air_purifier, humidifier, fan, on_off_light, dehumidifier, freezer, and window_covering_controller. Even on multi-step cycle appliances (laundry_washer, dishwasher, laundry_dryer), the agent maintains 82.4%–89.1% without ever seeing that appliance type in demonstrations, because the learned state precondition (OperationalState.Start requires OnOff = true) is abstracted at the Matter cluster level rather than tied to a specific device name, and candidate actions are enumerated directly from the target device's live interface.
3. Generalization to modified tool interfaces and operational requirements (Table R6). With our agent's code and rules completely frozen, we evaluated two modified environments: (i) Modified interface, where tool names, argument keys, and attribute names are renamed and response formats altered; and (ii) Modified requirements, where the environment's public control rules and device operational requirements (e.g., valid setpoint ranges and power prerequisites) are mutated and ground-truth labels recomputed.
Response to Reviewer 3bq7 (3/3)
Table R6. Robustness of SimuHome success (%) to changes in the tool interface and in operational requirements, mean over three seeds. Original is the test set of Table 1a (Overall). Modified interface uses the same episodes with tool names, argument keys and attribute names renamed and response formats changed, with the same semantics. Modified requirements uses the same episodes with the environment's public control rules and device requirements changed (for example, setpoint ranges and power prerequisites), with labels recomputed. Both sets were created after the agent's code was frozen, and no rule was changed. Δ is the change from Original.
| Method | Original | Modified interface | Δ | Modified requirements | Δ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gemma 4 12B | |||||
| Ours | 92.8 | 93.3 | +0.5 | 82.9 | −9.9 |
Interpretation of Table R6: Renaming the tool interface causes zero degradation (93.3%, +0.5%), because our agent dynamically populates its multiple-choice options from the interface specification rather than memorizing tool strings. Even when the physical operational requirements and setpoint bounds of the environment are mutated without updating our frozen rules or re-running skill learning (Modified requirements), our agent achieves 82.9%—still outperforming the strongest baseline on the unmodified environment (ExpeL, 62.3%) by +20.6 percentage points.
W3. Contribution of skill learning and typed decisions in the ablations
We scaled the single-seed ablations of Table 2a to five seeds (42–46; 3,000 episodes per variant) in Table R4.
Table R4. Ablations of Table 2a over five seeds (42–46), SimuHome, Gemma 4 12B, 600 episodes per seed; mean ± standard deviation. Columns as in Table 2a.
| Variant | F | IF | QT4 IF | Overall | Precision | Time (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ours | 92.8 ± 0.7 | 92.9 ± 2.2 | 93.1 ± 2.8 | 92.8 ± 0.8 | 90.5 ± 0.9 | 11.5 ± 1.3 |
| LLM decisions (backbone answers the questions) | 92.7 ± 0.6 | 92.5 ± 1.6 | 93.7 ± 1.6 | 92.6 ± 0.6 | 90.4 ± 0.8 | 16.1 ± 2.1 |
| No learned contracts | 89.1 ± 0.7 | 92.9 ± 1.8 | 93.1 ± 2.0 | 91.0 ± 0.8 | 87.9 ± 1.0 | 11.5 ± 1.4 |
| No none option in grounding | 92.9 ± 0.6 | 66.5 ± 2.3 | 93.7 ± 1.6 | 79.7 ± 0.9 | 77.4 ± 0.8 | 11.8 ± 1.6 |
| No temporal consistency check | 92.9 ± 0.6 | 49.3 ± 1.4 | 5.9 ± 0.7 | 71.1 ± 0.5 | 63.6 ± 0.6 | 11.6 ± 1.4 |
| No read-back or repair | 91.5 ± 0.8 | 92.8 ± 1.8 | 92.9 ± 2.1 | 92.2 ± 0.7 | 90.4 ± 1.0 | 11.6 ± 1.6 |
Interpretation of Table R4:
- Skill learning (
Learned contracts) eliminates 34% of remaining errors on Feasible SimuHome episodes and drives multi-task planning on TimeArena: Because 50% of SimuHome episodes are infeasible (IF) and are refused before any action is executed, learned preconditions and fallback repairs only act on feasible (F) episodes. Across 5 seeds, learned contracts boostFsuccess from to (+3.7 points, ) and precision from to (+2.6 points), cutting the feasible failure rate by more than a third (from 10.9% to 7.2%). Furthermore, on TimeArena—where multi-step action dependencies dominate—the learned programs and contracts improve completion from 75.6% to 90.0% (+14.4 points) on two-task episodes and from 54.4% to 66.7% (+12.3 points) on three-task episodes (Table 2b). - Typed decisions (
Formulation+Specialized Decision Model): Our typed-decision mechanism contributes in two distinct ways:- First, formulating grounding and action selection as closed-set typed questions (used by both
OursandLLM decisions) accounts for the +5.3 to +18.7 point accuracy advantage over rule-and-STN-equippedCodeAct,LLM+P, andLLMCompiler(Table R1). - Second, answering those typed questions with the specialized decision model (
Jev) instead of the 12B backbone (LLM decisions) cuts end-to-end episode latency by 29% ( across 5 seeds, including the API round-trip), speeds up per-request decision inference by 24.5$\times$ (, Appendix F.3), reduces backbone calls from 2.68 to 1.06 per episode, and yields a calibrated probability distribution over actions to rank fallback repairs.
- First, formulating grounding and action selection as closed-set typed questions (used by both
We hope these results fully resolve your concerns and support a positive reassessment of our work, and we warmly welcome any further questions during the discussion period.
Response to Reviewer 3bq7 (1/3)
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment of our paper's clarity, motivation, and empirical results. We address each of the three concerns with new experiments below.
W1. Methodological novelty: Why the division of decisions is non-trivial
While individual building blocks (schema-constrained extraction, multiple-choice selection, skill compression, and Simple Temporal Networks) have roots in prior literature, how an agent decomposes and routes tool-use decisions across them is a fundamental architectural question. Prior hybrid agents (
LLM+P,LLMCompiler,CodeAct) still rely on a generative LLM to synthesize formal plans, dependency DAGs, or executable code that jointly handles entity grounding, action mapping, and temporal constraints.To test whether our performance is simply a consequence of combining an LLM with domain rules and an external temporal/execution engine, we ran a matched comparison (Table R1) where
LLM+P,LLMCompiler, andCodeActare given the exact same interface rules (Table 3, Appendices B.3 and B.6), the exact same STN (Section 3.4, Appendix B.5), and the exact same execution machinery (Section 3.5) and budget (400 tool calls, 900 s).Table R1. SimuHome success (%) of structured-output, hybrid-planner, and code-generation baselines given the same interface knowledge (Table 3, including Appendices B.3 and B.6) and the same execution machinery (Section 3.4 and Appendix B.5; Section 3.5 without learned components). All methods use the same backbone and the same budget of 400 tool calls and 900 s per episode; means over three seeds (42–44). Superscripts follow Table 1a: S marks evaluation by the simulator's state and J by the panel of LLM judges.
Interpretation of Table R1: Giving existing hybrid and code planners our exact rules, STN, and execution engine still leaves a gap of 5.5 to 18.9 points on Gemma and 9.1 to 22.4 points on Qwen (and up to +32.6 points on multi-device concurrent scheduling
QT4-3 F). When an LLM is asked to generate PDDL plans, DAGs, or Python code, it conflates natural-language extraction with symbol grounding and temporal wiring. Our core algorithmic insight—that generation should only extract ungrounded literal mentions, while symbol grounding and action/argument binding should be posed as factored, closed-set selections over live interface primitives—is precisely what closes this gap.