acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Trajectory-Level Speculation with Semantic Verification for Tool-Using Agents

Abstract

Large language model agents solve tasks through long sequences of tool calls, and the prevailing design has a single strong model generate every step, although many steps are routine enough for a much smaller model. Existing ways of sharing this work keep the strong model as the generator: routers decide which model produces each step, and speculative methods check a small model's drafts one step at a time, usually against the strong model's own action. We introduce SpecAgent, a collaboration protocol that turns the strong model from the author of each step into a reviewer of steps drafted by a weak model. The weak model executes read-only tool calls as it drafts, so that every step is grounded in real observations, and holds the first action that would modify the environment. The strong model then verifies the drafted segment in a single forward pass, commits the longest prefix it judges semantically valid, and repairs the first rejected step. Because verification replaces autoregressive decoding with parallel prefill, the strong model decodes only short verdicts and occasional repairs rather than every step. On τ²-Bench, SpecAgent comes within one point of the strong model's success rate while roughly halving memory traffic and wall time, and it lowers both on AutomationBench. In an edge–cloud deployment on MCP-Atlas with three cloud models, it closes 53–75% of the weak–strong quality gap while the strong model generates at most half as many tokens. These results suggest that a strong model need not author every step of an agent: reviewing grounded drafts retains most of its quality while cutting both latency and memory traffic.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM agents, tool use, speculative execution, weak-strong collaboration, efficient inference

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_XXqQOpenReview ↗
Rating
2(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

SpecAgent uses a small model to draft actions and a larger model to review them. The small model executes read-only tool calls during drafting and pauses before an action that changes the environment. The larger model reviews the segment, keeps an accepted prefix, and repairs the first rejected step. Experiments on tau^2-Bench, AutomationBench, and MCP-Atlas report success rate, wall time, estimated computation and memory traffic, and API cost. The strongest result is close to Strong-only success on tau^2-Bench with substantially lower wall time.

Critical strengths
  1. Executing reads while holding writes for review is a practical design for interactive tasks. On tau^2-Bench, it substantially reduces wall time with little observed loss in success rate.
  2. The paper reports the additional computation together with latency savings. This helps the reader understand the cost of the method and the serving conditions where it may help.
Critical weaknesses
  1. DualSpec (2026) already uses a strong critic to check drafted actions and regenerates rejected actions. It is cited but not evaluated.
  2. The main table gives only one configuration for each collaboration method. Verification frequency, escalation settings, and reasoning budget can all change success rate and cost. These results are not enough to establish a better quality-efficiency frontier.
  3. The verifier is evaluated mainly through final task success. There are no false-acceptance, false-rejection, or repair-success rates.
  4. Read-only chunks reaching K steps are committed without review. Replies on tau^2-Bench are also sent before checking. A later rejection cannot remove those earlier steps or withdraw a reply.
  5. The design ablations are limited to Retail, and K is not varied. Removing fused replacement also causes a clear accuracy drop. Why a separate repair step changes task success so much needs explanation.
  6. The figures provide little direct evidence about semantic review. Figure 1 illustrates the intended workflow, while Figures 2-4 summarize trade-offs and ablations. Recorded trajectories showing accepted alternatives, missed errors, and successful or failed repairs would make the claimed advantage easier to assess.
  7. The quality trade-off is larger on the other benchmarks. AutomationBench success falls from 15.2% for Strong-only to 10.5%. On MCP-Atlas, the loss is 8.9-12.9 percentage points, and wall time does not consistently improve. The current analysis does not explain where the method remains useful and where reviewing weak drafts is insufficient.

After rebuttal: I raise my rating from 1 to 2. The DualSpec and step-level comparisons address my main concern, and the logged cases make the verifier’s behavior clearer. The results on tau²-Bench are more convincing now, but the success-rate gaps on AutomationBench and MCP-Atlas remain substantial. It is still unclear when SpecAgent is preferable to using the strong model directly.

Questions for authors

see weaknesses

7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer XXqQ (1/6)

hank you for the review. Following your suggestions, we added the evaluations below, ordered by the weaknesses you raised.

[W1] DualSpec: a different design, and now evaluated

DualSpec and SpecAgent share only the generic draft–verify–fallback pattern. They differ in what is drafted, when and how the strong model is used, and the environments they target:

DualSpecSpecAgent
DraftingEvery step: two parallel drafts (small model with reasoning; large model without reasoning), selected by action typeWeak model alone drafts multi-step segments on real tool observations
When Strong is usedDrafts and critiques every stepReviews once per segment, only before a state-changing action
VerificationYes/No log-probability margin vs. a thresholdStructured verdict: longest valid prefix + first-error replacement
On rejectionRegenerate the step with full-reasoning large modelKeep the accepted prefix; fused repair in the same pass
Target tasksRead-only deep research (Search/Visit)Stateful tools with writes and users

We nonetheless evaluated DualSpec with the same model pair, keeping its parallel drafts, original Yes/No critic, and fallback. DualSpec accepts a draft by comparing its critic score with a threshold that must be calibrated on development tasks. We therefore split each domain into development and test tasks: Retail 10/104, Airline 10/40, VitaBench (Delivery) 20/80. The threshold was calibrated once on the Retail development tasks and used unchanged in all domains. Every method is compared on the same test tasks, with 3 runs per task on τ² and 2 on VitaBench (Delivery), matching our original VitaBench protocol. We also include a step-level semantic review variant of SpecAgent as a further per-step reference.

Success is statistically indistinguishable between DualSpec and SpecAgent (paired 95% CIs of the difference include zero in all three domains), while DualSpec uses 6–10× more Strong calls, 1.9–2.8× the estimated HBM-read, and 1.3–1.6× the wall time of SpecAgent. The gap follows from the design: DualSpec puts the strong model on every step, while SpecAgent puts it only at state-changing boundaries. The table below, now Table 2 in §2, places both among the related methods:

MethodTask typeWeak drafterSemantic acceptanceMulti-step verificationEnvironment protection
ISPPlanning✓✗✗✗
Speculative ActionsGeneral tool use✓✗✗△
SPAgentSearch QA✗✗✗✗
SpecReasonReasoning✓✓✗–
DualSpecDeep research✓✓✗✗
AgentCollabDeep research✓–✗✗
SpecAgentGeneral tool use✓✓✓✓

Multi-step verification: one pass keeps the longest valid prefix of several drafted steps. Environment protection: state-changing actions wait for verification. △: side-effect-free actions only; –: not applicable.

Revision: We have added DualSpec to Table 3 (* = test split) and §4.2 of the revised version, its setting to Appendix E.2, the same-task comparisons to Appendix F.1 (Tables 11 and 13), and the design comparison to §2 (Table 2).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer XXqQ (2/6)

[W2, W5] Verification frequency, escalation, and fused repair

Following your suggestion, we vary these settings on both τ² domains, on the same test tasks (Retail 104, Airline 40) with 3 runs each. Δ is the paired difference in Pass@1 from SpecAgent with a 95% CI.

Verification frequency: how much the Strong model reviews. Step-level review checks every action; pending-write-only review lets the verifier reject only the held write.

Pass@1Δ [95% CI]Strong callsEst. PFLOPEst. HBM-read (TB)
Retail
Step-level review86.2−1.0 [−5.4, +3.5]10.40.94157–165
Pending write only81.7−5.4 [−9.9, −1.0]3.10.81117–120
SpecAgent87.2–3.00.78103–106
Airline
Step-level review79.2−5.8 [−12.5, +0.8]12.31.24238–248
Pending write only76.7−8.3 [−17.5, 0.0]3.71.09176–179
SpecAgent85.0–3.21.02149–152

On both domains SpecAgent is the most accurate and the cheapest. Reviewing every step multiplies Strong calls by 3.5–3.9× without higher success; reviewing only the write is as cheap but loses 5–8 points.

Verification frequency: chunk size K (Retail).

Pass@1Δ [95% CI]Strong callsEst. PFLOPEst. HBM-read (TB)
K = 284.6−2.6 [−6.7, +1.6]3.20.81111–114
K = 483.7−3.5 [−8.0, +0.6]3.20.81118–121
K = 6 (default)87.2–3.00.78103–106
K = 881.7−5.4 [−9.9, −1.0]3.10.81120–123

The default K = 6 attains the highest success and the lowest resource use. We report the sweep rather than claim a single optimal K.

Escalation after a rejection: fused repair. With fused repair, the verifier fixes a rejected step in the same pass; without it, every rejection escalates to a separate Strong turn.

Pass@1Strong callsSeparate repair turnsEst. PFLOP
Retail: SpecAgent → fused off86.0 → 82.53.2 → 3.855 → 950.83 → 0.86
Airline: SpecAgent → fused off85.0 → 83.33.2 → 3.995 → 1781.02 → 1.12

Retail: the paper's same-batch ablation (one run per task), where fusion is disabled by removing the replacement field from the verifier's output. Airline: new runs that keep the verifier prompt and only discard replacements at runtime. Repair turns are totals over all runs.

On Retail, removing the replacement field changes the design as a whole: the verifier also rejects more often (16.5% → 20.2% of decisions), and every rejection becomes a hand-off to a Strong turn that sees only the retained prefix and a textual reason. More rejections and more hand-offs give more chances to drift. On Airline, where the verifier's behavior is unchanged (288 vs. 295 reviews), separate repairs still nearly double and success drops in the same direction, by less. Fused repair thus helps in two ways: it keeps the verifier's diagnosis and the fix in one pass, and it removes a Strong turn per rejection. For DualSpec, whose escalation is controlled by a calibrated threshold, the comparison is: 86.9 vs. 87.2 (Retail), 86.7 vs. 85.0 (Airline), and 46.3 vs. 45.0 (VitaBench) Pass@1, with 6–10× more Strong calls than SpecAgent.

Revision: We have added the review-scope controls (Table 11) and the K and fused-off ablations (Table 12) to Appendix F.1 of the revised version, and §5 now explains the fused-off result through hand-offs. The original Retail fused-off ablation was already in Figure 4 of our submission.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer XXqQ (3/6)

[W3] False-acceptance, false-rejection, and repair-success rates

We human-annotated 300 verifier decisions from logged runs on τ²-Bench, VitaBench, and MCP-Atlas. The annotators are three Ph.D. students in computer science who are familiar with tool-using agent benchmarks and received systematic training on our written annotation guidelines before labeling; each annotated a disjoint set of 100 cases. Each case includes its observations, draft, verdict, replacement, executed action, and outcome.

RateValue
False acceptance (incorrect accepted prefixes)4 / 204 (2.0%)
False rejection (incorrect rejections)29 / 149 (19.5%)
Fused replacement semantically correct67 / 85 (78.8%)
Executed repair correct (repair success)127 / 145 (87.6%)

Errors are skewed toward caution: false rejections are about 7× more frequent than false acceptances, and they mainly cost an extra repair. In 15 of the 29 false rejections, the action finally executed was still correct. After a correct rejection, the executed repair was correct in 112 of 116 cases (96.6%). Incorrect fused replacements do occur (18 of 85) and are reported as such.

[W6] Recorded trajectories for each category

We give six logged trajectories, covering accepted alternatives, successful repairs, a missed error, and a fused-repair error, in the following comment.

Revision: We have added these rates to §5 (Table 6) of the revised version, with the annotation protocol, annotator background, and recorded cases in Appendix F.3.

Reviewer_WrsDOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

SpecAgent lets a small model advance a tool-use trajectory using observations from executed read-only calls. When it proposes an action classified as state-changing, execution pauses and a strong model reviews the pending segment, retains its longest acceptable prefix, and repairs the first rejected step. The aim is to replace much of the strong model's step-by-step decoding with small-model drafting and shorter strong-model reviews. The results show near-Strong-only success rates with lower latency on τ²-Bench, but more substantial quality trade-offs on AutomationBench and MCP-Atlas.

Critical strengths
  1. The protocol addresses a genuine complication of tool use. Unlike speculation over text alone, agent actions depend on real observations and may change external state. The combination of executed reads, held writes, prefix reuse, and first-error repair gives a concrete mechanism for handling this distinction (§3.2, Algorithm 1).
  2. The τ²-Bench results are compelling within the tested setup. SpecAgent obtains 86.0% / 87.7% success on Airline / Retail, compared with 86.0% / 88.6% for Strong-only, while reducing mean wall time from 305.2 / 162.4 s to 126.2 / 87.5 s (Table 2).
  3. The paper keeps different efficiency measures separate. It reports FLOPs, estimated HBM reads, and measured wall time, and acknowledges both the increase in FLOPs and the absence of consistent latency gains in the edge–cloud setting (Tables 2–3).
Critical weaknesses

1. The contribution beyond prior semantic draft-and-verify methods remains insufficiently established. SpecReason (NeurIPS 2025, §4.1) already lets a small model propose reasoning steps, uses the larger model to judge their semantic utility, and falls back upon rejection; it also uses prefill-only verification. SpecAgent adds real tool observations, a state-changing-action boundary, and multi-step prefix reuse, so the methods are not identical. However, the paper does not yet show convincingly how much independent benefit these extensions provide, and SpecReason is not cited. There is also a narrower related-work issue: although the introduction acknowledges step-level critics, §2 groups DualSpec with methods requiring agreement with the large model's own action, whereas DualSpec §5.3 uses a reference-free semantic critic.

2. The experiments do not isolate the value of trajectory-level semantic verification. Figure 4 ablates review timing and repair choices, but it does not directly compare step-wise and multi-step semantic review with the same verifier and repair rules, or clearly isolate prefix reuse from restarting a rejected segment. Moreover, Algorithm 1 commits read-only segments that reach KK without review, and Appendix D.1 instructs the verifier to reject executed reads primarily for invalid tools or arguments. It is therefore unclear how often the multi-step reviewer makes a consequential semantic decision over an executed prefix rather than mainly checking the pending write.

3. The strongest quality-and-latency claim is supported mainly on τ², not across the other evaluated settings. On AutomationBench, SpecAgent reaches 10.5% success versus 15.2% for Strong-only. On MCP-Atlas, it loses 12.9, 8.9, and 9.9 percentage points with the three strong models, and latency does not consistently improve (Tables 2–3). These are meaningful cost–quality operating points, but they do not demonstrate broadly preserved strong-model quality together with speedups. A separate wording issue is the reference to “measured Strong traffic” in §1: Appendix B.4 makes clear that strong-model HBM traffic was estimated analytically, not directly measured.

Questions for authors

1. What is the central new technical insight beyond SpecReason, and which results isolate its benefit in the tool-using setting? Please also clarify the description of DualSpec's semantic verifier in §2.

2. Under the existing τ² setup, could the authors compare step-wise semantic review, the current multi-step review, and a version that checks only the pending write, while keeping the models and verifier fixed? The distribution of reviewed segment lengths, the fraction of read-only segments committed at KK without review, and rejection locations (executed reads versus pending writes) would help establish what the trajectory-level review actually contributes.

3. Under what conditions should we expect both near-Strong-only quality and lower latency, rather than a cost–quality trade-off? Please also distinguish analytical HBM estimates from measured traffic when describing the resource results.

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer WrsD (1/3)

Thank you for the precise and fair review. Your three requests map directly onto the new experiments below.

[W1, Q1] Central insight beyond SpecReason, and evidence isolating it

Central insight. In a tool-using agent, the Strong model does not need to generate or check every step. It needs to be on the critical path only where an error would become irreversible. SpecAgent therefore lets the Weak model run ahead on real tool observations and invokes Strong once per segment, right before a state-changing action. In one prefill-dominated pass, Strong returns the longest acceptable prefix and a replacement for the first error. This differs from SpecReason in three ways:

  1. Grounded drafts. SpecReason's steps are internal reasoning text. Ours are tool calls whose observations have already been executed, so a rejection must account for steps that cannot be "un-thought".
  2. Where Strong is invoked. SpecReason judges each step as it is produced. SpecAgent defers review to the state-changing boundary and reviews the accumulated segment together.
  3. Segment verdict plus first-error repair. One Strong pass both commits a prefix and supplies the repair, instead of falling back to Strong regeneration.

Evidence isolating the benefit. Per-step semantic verification, as in SpecReason and DualSpec, is the design point that extensions 2–3 move away from. We therefore ran both a step-level review variant of SpecAgent (same models, verify-and-repair after every action) and DualSpec, with the paper's model pair (Qwen3.5-4B Weak, Qwen3.5-397B-A17B Strong). Because DualSpec's acceptance threshold must be calibrated on development tasks, we split each domain into development and test tasks (Retail 10/104, Airline 10/40, VitaBench (Delivery) 20/80), calibrated once on Retail, and compare all methods on the same test tasks (Avg@3 on τ², Avg@2 on VitaBench):

Both per-step designs spend far more Strong work than SpecAgent: DualSpec issues 6–10× more Strong calls with success statistically indistinguishable from SpecAgent (paired 95% CIs include zero on all three domains), and step-level review issues 3.5–3.9× more Strong calls with lower success on both τ² domains. Moving verification to the state-changing boundary is what removes most Strong work in the tool setting.

SpecReason citation and DualSpec in §2. Thank you for both. We now cite and discuss SpecReason (NeurIPS 2025) in §2 and do not claim semantic step verification itself as our contribution. We agree that DualSpec §5.3 uses a reference-free semantic critic, and thank you for the correction. We have corrected this in §2, where a new table contrasts SpecAgent with the related methods:

MethodTask typeWeak drafterSemantic acceptanceMulti-step verificationEnvironment protection
ISPPlanning✓✗✗✗
Speculative ActionsGeneral tool use✓✗✗△
SPAgentSearch QA✗✗✗✗
SpecReasonReasoning✓✓✗–
DualSpecDeep research✓✓✗✗
AgentCollabDeep research✓–✗✗
SpecAgentGeneral tool use✓✓✓✓

Multi-step verification: one pass keeps the longest valid prefix of several drafted steps. Environment protection: state-changing actions wait for verification. △: side-effect-free actions only; –: not applicable.

Revision: We have added the SpecReason citation and the method comparison (Table 2) to §2, DualSpec to Table 3 and §4.2, and the step-level control and same-task comparison to §5 and Appendix F.1 (Table 11) of the revised version; the DualSpec setting is in Appendix E.2.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer WrsD (2/3)

[W2, Q2] Three-way comparison under τ², and how the verifier's decisions are distributed

Three-way comparison (same models; same τ² test tasks: Retail 104, Airline 40; 3 runs each; Δ = paired-bootstrap difference vs. SpecAgent with 95% CI):

Review scopeRetail Pass@1 (Δ)Retail Strong callsAirline Pass@1 (Δ)Airline Strong calls
SpecAgent (multi-step)87.23.085.03.2
Step-level review86.2 (−1.0 [−5.4, +3.5])10.479.2 (−5.8 [−12.5, +0.8])12.3
Pending write only81.7 (−5.4 [−9.9, −1.0])3.176.7 (−8.3 [−17.5, 0.0])3.7

Among the three variants, multi-step review offers the best balance of cost and accuracy. Step-level review matches it on Retail only at 3.5× the Strong calls. Checking only the pending write has a similar cost to SpecAgent but lower accuracy, even though the verifier sees the same history. SpecAgent rows are our archived runs on the same task IDs.

Requested distributions (all archived main-table runs; MCP-Atlas uses three Strong models):

Drafted chunksMulti-step (n > 1)Reviewed by StrongCommitted at K (read-only)Committed ending in a reply
τ² Airline1,208307 (25.4%)330109769
τ² Retail2,699599 (22.2%)7241831,792
VitaBench (Delivery)3,1001,019 (32.9%)1,1032431,754
AutomationBench5,3732,992 (55.7%)4,0241,349–
MCP-Atlas (Qwen / GLM / DeepSeek)456 / 455 / 59659–68%288 / 300 / 422168 / 155 / 174–

Each chunk is either reviewed or committed without review; on AutomationBench and MCP-Atlas the final reply is the graded answer and is held, so no chunk ends in an unreviewed reply. Multi-step drafting is common on every benchmark (22–68% of chunks). On τ², the policy requires user confirmation before a write, so the preceding reads are usually committed first and the reviewed candidate is often the pending write alone; those reads remain in the verifier's context (every one of the 309/709 single-step reviews has at least two executed reads in its history). Where reads and writes share a chunk (VitaBench, AutomationBench, MCP-Atlas), the verifier routinely judges multi-step segments.

Revision: We have added the three-way comparison to §5 and Appendix F.1 (Table 11), and the distributions above to Appendix F.2 (Table 14) of the revised version.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer WrsD (3/3)

[W3, Q3] When can quality and latency both approach the ideal?

We agree that AutomationBench and MCP-Atlas are cost–quality operating points; SpecAgent is designed as such a trade-off between Weak and Strong. The ideal case is a task dominated by routine, observation-grounded steps that the Weak model handles reliably, with a few decisive state-changing actions where Strong judgment matters. Reviewing such a trajectory is easier than generating it, so the Strong model only needs to correct the decisive steps.

We observe this in practice. Interestingly, Strong is not uniformly better than Weak: on 6/50 Airline and 11/114 Retail tasks, Weak-only succeeds more often than Strong-only (77.8 vs. 44.4% and 84.8 vs. 48.5%). On these tasks SpecAgent largely keeps the Weak model's advantage (66.7% and 72.7%), because the Strong reviewer accepts a valid grounded draft instead of rewriting it, while still correcting Weak errors elsewhere. This complementarity is why SpecAgent matches Strong-only on Airline overall (86.0 vs. 86.0) at 41% of its wall time.

The further a benchmark is from this regime, the more the trade-off shows. Quality depends on how competent the Weak model is:

BenchmarkWeak-onlyStrong-onlySpecAgentWeak→Strong gap recoveredWall: Strong → SpecAgent (s)
τ² Airline80.086.086.0100%305.2 → 126.2
τ² Retail80.488.687.789%162.4 → 87.5
VitaBench (Delivery), new34.048.044.575%197.3 → 135.2
AutomationBench6.815.210.544%307.4 → 174.9

On AutomationBench, Weak alone succeeds in 6.8% of tasks, so most segments need repair and less of the gap is recovered.

Latency additionally requires a Weak step to be much cheaper than a Strong step and Strong decoding to be bandwidth-bound. Both hold in our co-located setups (4B vs. 397B), where wall time drops by 1.5–2.4× on every benchmark above. On MCP-Atlas, the local Weak model takes roughly as long per step as the hosted Strong APIs, so the benefit appears as lower remote API cost (59–81% of Strong-only) rather than time. As §5 analyzes, large decode batches also narrow the gap between decoding and prefill.

HBM wording. Thank you for catching this. We replace "measured Strong traffic" in §1 with "estimated". Throughout the paper, measured wall time is now kept separate from analytically estimated HBM reads, and the HBM columns are labeled as estimates.

Revision: We have corrected the §1 wording and added the recovered-gap analysis and latency conditions to §5 and the conclusion of the revised version.

All manuscript changes described in this response are in the revised PDF. We hope the three-way comparison, the reviewed-segment statistics, and the clarified contribution beyond SpecReason resolve your concerns about what trajectory-level review contributes, and we would be grateful if you would reconsider your score.

Dear Reviewer WrsD,

Thank you again for your precise and fair review. As the discussion period closes tomorrow, we would like to kindly check whether our responses have addressed your concerns. In brief:

  • we now cite and discuss SpecReason, and have corrected the description of DualSpec's critic in §2;
  • we ran the three-way comparison you suggested with the same models and verifier: multi-step review is the most accurate, while step-level review needs 3.5–3.9× more Strong calls and pending-write-only review loses 5–8 points;
  • we reported the reviewed-segment and commit-at-K distributions on all benchmarks, and clarified that the HBM values are analytical estimates.

If any concern remains, we would be glad to clarify it before the discussion closes.

Reviewer_Tjn6OpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces SpecAgent, a weak-strong speculative framework for tool-using agents. In this framework, a weak model drafts actions using tool observations, while a strong model verifies the trajectory semantically and accepts the longest valid prefix. It would repair rejected actions when it is necessary. The main idea is to distinguish read-only actions from state-changing actions and delay the latter until they are verified. The experiments show latency reductions with performance close to the strong model.

Critical strengths

S1. The paper presents a coherent design that transforms the strong model from an author to a batch reviewer of multi-step trajectories from the weaker model, which removes strong model memory intensive decoding phase rather than merely overlapping latency. It's also supported by a renewal reward cost and latency analysis. Although some of these components have been explored in prior works, their combination provides a practical approach to reducing strong model autoregressive decoding in tool-using agents.

S2. The paper shows substantial reductions in measured wall time on the tau2-bench while maintaining performance close to the strong model. The authors also provide a detailed efficiency breakdown across multi-axis efficiency and latency evaluation profiles. The evaluation and framing are valuable. It's showing that the speedups primarily come from replacing costly autoregressive decoding with verification prefill rather than reducing overall compute.

Critical weaknesses

W1. One of my main concerns is the reliability of the semantic verifier itself. The paper does not separately evaluate false acceptance and false rejection, even though the verifier's decisions directly affect the execution of state changing actions. Also, in fused repair, a replacement action can pass the validity checks without necessarily being semantically correct. Without a more detailed error analysis, it is difficult to assess the reliability of this mechanism.

W2. Components such as semantic verification and speculative execution have already been explored in the literature, but the paper does not make a direct comparison with similar methods such as DualSpec and SPAgent or other task-level router/cascade baselines or even alternative training-free speculative planners are empirically evaluated despite being mentioned in the motivation. Also the implementation of Speculative Actions has limitations that may have affected its poor performance. In general, Another baseline nominated for step-level semantic verification could better show exactly how much improvement trajectory-level verification provides.

W3. The paper assumes read-only actions are safe, but in real world settings they can have API costs, rate limits, and other side effects. Also according to Alg 1, several read-only chunks can enter the history without strong verification, since K only limits each chunk followed by another caveat in the evaluation is on tau2-bench, where weak model replies to users are not reviewed at all, so they reach the user without any review. These design choices raise potential safety and reliability concerns, as the weak model may repeatedly issue unnecessary queries that are technically valid but do not contribute to task success, leading to wasted resources or rate-limit throttling.

W4. It's inferred that the efficiency gains depend on a specific setup and serving configuration. HBM-read is estimated, and the strong model was never profiled. The authors say in Sec 5 that the benefit may shrink as batch size grows, and MCP-Atlas with less strong model usage does not give lower latency. It is unclear how far the speedups generalize.

Questions for authors

Please address the weaknesses above also:

Q1. How many consecutive read-only actions are performed without strong model verification? Did authors check out the redundant reads, or can they see if there are impacts on both failures and latency?

Q2. Is it possible to validate the HBM-read estimate for the strong model using hardware counters? Could you do an ablation on how sensitive latency is to batch size and load?

Q3. Could the authors provide an error analysis of the verifier, in particular on false acceptance on state-changing actions and fused replacement errors?

Q4. How much of the improvement comes specifically from trajectory-level verification? A step-level semantic verification baseline would help isolate its contribution.

8 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Tjn6 (1/5)

Thank you for the detailed and constructive review. We address each point below, starting with the baselines.

[W2, Q4] Direct comparison with DualSpec and a step-level semantic verification baseline

We added both, using the paper's model pair (Qwen3.5-4B Weak, Qwen3.5-397B-A17B Strong). DualSpec accepts a draft by comparing its critic score with a threshold that must be calibrated on development tasks. We therefore split each domain into development and test tasks: Retail 10/104, Airline 10/40, VitaBench (Delivery) 20/80. Every method is compared on the same test tasks.

DomainMethodPass@1 (%)Calls (Weak / Strong)Est. PFLOPEst. HBM-read (TB)Wall time (s)
τ² RetailWeak-only (4B)81.113.2 / 00.144744.9
Strong-only (397B)88.50 / 13.00.58188–198158.0
DualSpec86.912.9 / 28.41.31208–228116.9
Step-level review86.213.5 / 10.40.94157–16586.6
SpecAgent87.213.7 / 3.00.78103–10684.5
τ² AirlineWeak-only (4B)81.714.2 / 00.188469.7
Strong-only (397B)85.80 / 13.50.76322–331296.6
DualSpec86.712.4 / 31.31.76401–419204.4
Step-level review79.213.8 / 12.31.24237–248152.4
SpecAgent85.015.3 / 3.21.02148–152127.1
VitaBench (Delivery)Weak-only (4B)31.925.8 / 00.217985.9
Strong-only (397B)46.90 / 22.60.74256–269202.2
DualSpec46.320.6 / 50.01.64294–326179.6
SpecAgent45.024.9 / 8.21.35155–162141.3
  • DualSpec. Its success is statistically indistinguishable from SpecAgent on all three domains (paired-bootstrap 95% CIs of the difference: Retail [−4.8, +4.2], Airline [−5.0, +8.3], VitaBench [−7.5, +10.0]). However, DualSpec issues 6–10× more Strong calls than SpecAgent, with 1.9–2.8× the estimated HBM-read and 1.3–1.6× the wall time, because its large model drafts and critiques every step.
  • Step-level review, a step-level semantic verification baseline, applies the same models and verify-and-repair procedure after every action. It achieves lower success than SpecAgent on both domains (86.2 vs. 87.2 on Retail; 79.2 vs. 85.0 on Airline) while using 3.5–3.9× more Strong calls. This indicates what trajectory-level verification contributes: comparable or better success with roughly a third of the Strong calls.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Tjn6 (2/5)

[W2, continued] SPAgent, routers, and Speculative Actions

SPAgent. We would like to clarify that SPAgent is a single-model method rather than a weak–strong collaboration method, so it is not directly comparable to SpecAgent. It uses a single model: in early steps, that model emits actions without reasoning and gates them with its own 1–5 self-score; later, it speculates alongside its own reasoning and keeps a speculative action only on an exact match (SPAgent §III). Since there is no separate weaker drafter or stronger verifier, it does not reduce Strong decoding, which is the cost SpecAgent targets. It is also evaluated only on read-only search QA (HotpotQA, 2WikiMultihopQA, TriviaQA). We therefore compared against DualSpec, the closest weak–strong method, above. The new Table 2 in §2 contrasts these methods:

MethodTask typeWeak drafterSemantic acceptanceMulti-step verificationEnvironment protection
ISPPlanning✓✗✗✗
Speculative ActionsGeneral tool use✓✗✗△
SPAgentSearch QA✗✗✗✗
SpecReasonReasoning✓✓✗–
DualSpecDeep research✓✓✗✗
AgentCollabDeep research✓–✗✗
SpecAgentGeneral tool use✓✓✓✓

Multi-step verification: one pass keeps the longest valid prefix of several drafted steps. Environment protection: state-changing actions wait for verification. △: side-effect-free actions only; –: not applicable.

Task-level routers and cascades choose which model handles a task. Once Strong is chosen, every step is still decoded by Strong, so they are complementary to SpecAgent, which can serve as the Strong-side executor. AgentCollab, a step-level weak-to-strong escalation baseline, was already included in the main table of our submission: on the full τ² sets it reaches 85.3% (Airline) and 85.7% (Retail) with 18.5 and 16.6 Strong calls per trajectory, versus SpecAgent's 86.0% and 87.7% with 3.1 Strong calls.

Speculative Actions. We ported the authors' officially released agent to τ²-Bench without modifying its speculation logic, and ran it with the same model pair and deployments as all other methods (Appendix E.1, already in our submission). It reaches 72.0% (Airline) and 48.5% (Retail) with 17.4 and 17.1 Strong calls per trajectory. If the reviewer has specific limitations of this implementation in mind, we would be grateful to learn about them, and we would be glad to evaluate a modified variant.

Revision: We have added DualSpec to the main table (Table 3, * = test split) and §4.2, its setting to Appendix E.2, the same-task comparison with all controls to Appendix F.1 (Table 11), and the method comparison above to §2 (Table 2) of the revised version.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Tjn6 (3/5)

[W1, Q3] Verifier error analysis: false acceptance, false rejection, and fused-repair errors

We human-annotated 300 verifier decisions from logged SpecAgent runs on τ²-Bench (Airline, Retail), VitaBench (Delivery), and MCP-Atlas. The annotators are three Ph.D. students in computer science who are familiar with tool-using agent benchmarks and received systematic training on our written annotation guidelines before labeling; each annotated a disjoint set of 100 cases. Each case was shown with its full context: observations, Weak draft, Strong verdict, proposed replacement, the action actually executed, and the outcome. Four decisions were labeled separately.

DecisionCorrectIncorrectAccuracy
Accepted prefix (incorrect = false acceptance)200498.0%
Rejection (incorrect = false rejection)1202980.5%
Proposed fused replacement671878.8%
Action actually executed after rejection1271887.6%

Denominators count only cases where the decision applies; e.g., fully accepted cases have no repair.

  1. False acceptance is rare: 4 of 204 accepted prefixes (2.0%). This is the error that lets a bad state-changing action through.
  2. Errors are skewed toward caution. False rejections (29) are about 7× more common than false acceptances. A false rejection mainly costs an extra repair. In 15 of the 29, the action finally executed was still correct.
  3. When the verifier rejects correctly, the repair is almost always right: the executed action is correct in 112 of 116 such cases (96.6%).
  4. As the reviewer anticipated, fused replacements are not always correct. 18 of 85 proposals were judged semantically incorrect, and 15 of those were executed. These are errors in the Strong model's own repair, which validity checks are not designed to catch. We therefore report semantic correctness separately from validity and do not treat passing the guard as correctness.

To make these cases concrete, we include two logged examples of these failure modes, together with a correct repair for comparison. The content is taken from the logs, with the relevant parts highlighted in bold.

Case A: false acceptance (τ² Retail, task 12).

  • Earlier observation (order #W5490111): payment_history = [payment of $1,023.16 via credit_card_3124723].
  • Policy: "The refund must either go to the original payment method, or an existing gift card."
  • User: "…send the refund to my PayPal."
  • Weak draft (pending write): return_delivered_order_items(order_id = #W5490111, three items, payment_method_id = paypal_9497703).
  • Strong verdict: accept (j = 1). Its reason checks the user's confirmation and the item IDs, but does not compare the refund method with the original payment.
  • Tool: "Error: Payment method should be the original payment method." The agent then explained the policy to the user, and the task passed.

Case B: a fused-repair error (τ² Airline, task 23).

  • Confirmed history: cancel_reservation(K1NW8N) → observation "status": "cancelled".
  • Weak draft (pending write): book_reservation for passenger Mohamed, paying certificate $500 + gift cards $198 + $129 + credit card $44 = the $871 fare (correct).
  • Strong verdict: reject (j = 0), "…leaves the user's request partially fulfilled and the original reservation still active."
  • Fused replacement (executed): cancel_reservation(K1NW8N), cancelling an already-cancelled reservation a second time. Here the verifier overlooked an observation that was already in its context.

Case C: correct fused repair (same Airline task, a later draft).

  • Weak draft (pending write): book_reservation for Mohamed with credit card amount $1,786.
  • Strong verdict: reject (j = 0), "the charge for Mohamed's reservation should only be $44 (after applying the $500 certificate and both gift cards totaling $327 against the $871 fare)."
  • Fused replacement (executed): the same call with credit card $44; the reservation was created.

Revision: We have added this error analysis to §5 (Table 6) of the revised version, with the annotation protocol, annotator background, and recorded cases in Appendix F.3; Appendix D now states that the validity check is structural.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.