- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies how a seller can reduce differences between group-average prices while retaining the random variation needed for demand estimation. The authors propose an approach called FRSD to extend Random Shock Design (RSD) with the introduction of a fairness penalty scaled by virtual queues.
Critical strengths
The main point of strength of this work is the terminal-disparity guarantee while preserving consistent demand estimation. The mathematics seems solid under the declared assumptions and the experimental part introduces useful ablations and evaluations.
Critical weaknesses
The experimental comparison is limited to RSD and to two ablations of the penalty (fixed and current-gap). There is no comparison with existing fair dynamic pricing methods, such as Cohen et al. (2025) or Doubly Fair Dynamic Pricing (Xu et al., 2023), nor with primal-dual controllers from the constrained bandit literature that the paper itself cites (Guo and Liu, 2024; Bernasconi et al., 2025).
The improvement over RSD on the Retail experiment is relative to the RSD with matched estimation and exploration parameters. Other RSD configurations achieve higher revenue and lower disparity, although with higher estimation error. Comparisons under common fairness and estimation budgets would help to better assess FRSD's advantage.
Demand coefficients are fixed, and changing demand is not evaluated or explicitly discussed. This is particularly relevant because both estimation and fairness correction retain historical information, potentially slowing adaptation after a regime change.
Considering the related work, I suggest to include Chen, Lyu, Zhang and Zhou, "Fairness-aware Online Price Discrimination with Nonparametric Demand Models". Moreover, the distinctions from the already cited works of Cohen et al. (2025) and Xu et al. (2023) would also benefit from a more technical discussion.
Questions for authors
Could you provide a technical justification for excluding a test in a common experimental setting with the existing similar approaches highlighted in the related work?
Does FRSD admit an upper bound on its excess loss relative to the optimal fair benchmark? If not, could you clarify what conclusions about the optimality of the policy can be drawn from the regret lower bound?