acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

From Bayesian Belief to Generative Behavior: Uncertainty-Preserving Quantum Bayesian Feedback under Evolving Evidence

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Generative systems under incomplete or changing evidence must decide both which conditions to express and how frequently to express them. The challenge is to translate uncertainty over alternative conditions into observable generative behavior. We introduce Quantum Bayesian Feedback (QBF), which maintains a persistent joint belief over task hypotheses and observation noise, recursively updates it with new evidence, and maps the resulting belief to a distribution over controls for a frozen generator. We show that QBF belief updates are equivalent to Bayesian filtering, derive bounds characterizing uncertainty preservation through readout and generation, and quantify information lost under point-valued readouts. Experiments with pretrained diffusion models demonstrate that posterior differences not captured by posterior-mean or maximum a posteriori (MAP) readouts remain reflected in generated regional attributes under posterior sampling. Target-switching experiments further depict how belief revision translates into adaptive changes in generative response across candidate sets. Extending QBF to real-image evidence and native semantic generation further reveals trade-offs among accuracy, stability, and recovery under different belief-update dynamics. Measured by the mean energy score, QBF achieves 31.6–34.3% lower regional generation loss than point-valued readouts and semantic scores close to those of adaptive feedback baselines, while preserving posterior distinctions and adapting to target changes. Ideal quantum simulations show that the belief dynamics are induced directly by QBF state evolution and readout. Overall, QBF translates evolving posterior uncertainty into adaptive generative behavior under changing evidence, from regional attribute control to semantic high-resolution generation.

Primary area:
probabilistic methods (Bayesian methods, variational inference, sampling, UQ, etc.)
Keywords:
generative control, Bayesian filtering, uncertainty preservation, quantum machine learning, diffusion models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_QxfTOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Summary of the paper

This paper aims to control conditional data generations through updating a belief designed by making use of the quantum state. The pipeline, as far as I understand, is as follows.

  • Conditional generation part:
\text{Quantum "belief": }\rho_t \xrightarrow{\text{meas.}} & h \\\\\\ &\downarrow \text{lookup} \\\\\\ &r_h & \sim \nu_t \\\\\\ &\downarrow \text{cond.} & & \nwarrow \\\\\\ &K_\theta(x|r_h) & \sim Q_t & \text{making them similar.} \\\\\\ &\downarrow f_\\# && \swarrow \\\\\\ & \text{attribution of gen data} & \sim f_\\# Q_t \end{array}$$ - Quantum version of belief $\rho_t$ update. They also validate their proposals in the numerical experiments. # Contributions The contributions of this paper are - Mathematical connections between Bayesian belief updates based on quantum states and several classical results: - Proposition 1 demonstrated that the diagonal components of the channel correspond to conventional Bayesian updates, - Proposition 2 provided an upper bound for the Wasserstein-1 distance between the $f_\\# Q_t$ and $\nu_p$, - Proposition 3 demonstrated potential information loss when the belief inputs are in a deterministic quantity (such as summary statistics), - Experimental validations of the above theoretical results. # Validation The authors validate the formulation by running some numerical experiments: - Regional control: - 16 image hypotheses and eight noise levels -> belief -> generator = a frozen CIFAR-10 DDPM, - observations for updating belief: 32 steps (stable) -> 32 steps (noise shift) -> 32 steps (target shift), and - Semantic control: - classes from corrupted real images using frozen ResNet-20 likelihoods -> belief -> generator = Stable Diffusion 1.5, In each case, the proposed method improves energy score (10) over histories.
Critical strengths
  • This paper presents a method for controlling the output results of a data generation model through Bayesian belief updating, where the quantum state serves as the basis for the belief update component. While this approach may appear to transcend conventional reasoning in an intuitive sense, evaluating its effectiveness and uniqueness proves challenging, as acknowledged by the authors themselves.
Critical weaknesses
  • The paper replaces the conventional Bayesian updating component with quantum state updates. However, the theoretical effectiveness and unique characteristics of this approach remain unclear. While the claim that the diagonal components reproduce classical Bayesian updating is intuitively clear, going beyond this to discern any particularly interesting properties that emerge only when extending to the quantum domain proves challenging.
  • This may be due to my limited familiarity with Bayesian updating, but from merely reading the text alone, grasping the overall progression from the proposed methodology to the resulting findings in this paper is difficult. This is not about mathematical propositions, but rather about the overall flow of the complete paper.
Questions for authors

Question regarding the aforementioned weakness

  • If dephasing means "setting off-diagonal elements to zero", then Corollary 1 would essentially be saying it's unnecessary, implying that quantum mechanical effects themselves would be unnecessary?
  • I understand the argument that QBF sampling yields better performance in numerical experiments. Regarding the above question, could the performance improvement be more related to the use of sampling rather than quantumness itself?

General questions/comments

  • I was somewhat confused about how rhr_h is determined during training. I now understand that there exists a lookup table for h→rhh \to r_h, and that f:X→Af: X \to A represents a different function altogether. However, due to the words "Assign each hypothesis attributes rh∈Ar_h∈A, measurable in generated outputs by f:X→Af:X→A.", I mistakenly assumed it referred to the same entity.
  • In Figure 1, the generator is denoted as GθG_\theta, which appears to be a typo for either Gθ\mathcal{G}_\theta or something else entirely?
  • What is the capitalized letter DD appearing in Proposition 2?
Reviewer_C1kVOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This work studies how to transmit posterior uncertainty, updated through sequential observations, to the outputs of a frozen generator. QBF maintains a joint belief over task hypotheses and observation noise, updates the posterior as new evidence arrives, and samples generation conditions from it. The authors provide a quantum implementation equivalent to classical Bayesian filtering, analyze how readout and generation errors affect the output attribute distribution, and discuss what information is lost when using only a MAP estimate or a mean. The regional generation experiments show gains from posterior sampling over MAP and mean readouts, while the ten-class semantic experiments produce results close to other adaptive filtering methods. Ideal quantum simulations also validate the proposed state updates. I think this is a meaningful problem, and the distinction between different sources of uncertainty is useful. However, I am still not quite clear on the main contribution beyond bringing these existing components together. The experimental support is also fairly limited in scope, so I currently lean toward a score of 2.

Critical strengths
  1. What I appreciate is the distinction between uncertainty about which generation condition to use and the generator’s own randomness once that condition is fixed. The paper further separates readout distortion from conditional-generation error and explains what information relevant to the target attributes may be lost through point summaries such as MAP or mean readouts. This makes the problem more concrete and helps clarify what the theoretical results actually explain.

  2. The regional experiments use targeted controls. The methods share paired observation histories and generation randomness, and posterior sampling achieves lower mean energy scores than MAP and mean readouts across 96 histories. The authors also report cases favoring static inference or quota readout and acknowledge that some method rankings in the semantic experiments remain unresolved. I think this helps make the benefits and scope of the method easier to assess.

Critical weaknesses
  1. My biggest question is what the main new contribution of this work actually is. Proposition 1 and Corollary 1 already establish that classical Bayesian filtering can reproduce the control laws, and Section 2 connects posterior-sampled conditioning to Bayesian model averaging. The attribute-fidelity and point-summary information-loss bounds mainly follow from coupling and the triangle inequality. These results can be valid, and the authors do not claim a quantum computational advantage. However, I still do not see a sufficiently clear new result or capability that the quantum implementation and the overall framework provide beyond these existing components. My concern here is mainly about contribution and significance, rather than the method being incorrect.

  2. The experiments establish the transmission of specified attributes more clearly than they establish broader generative benefits. In the regional experiments, DDNM nearly exactly enforces the control attributes used for evaluation, so these results mainly test whether the selected control distribution is faithfully transmitted. This is consistent with the authors’ objective. However, in the semantic study with only 20 observation histories, QBF and quota readout have the same overall score, and paired intervals against adaptive controllers include zero, leaving the rankings unresolved. Quota readout also improves early frequency fidelity in the semantic experiments, but there is no corresponding regional comparison. I therefore do not think the current results are enough to establish what practical advantage this approach offers over simpler methods that also retain the full posterior.

Questions for authors
  1. Given that the control laws are equivalent to classical Bayesian filtering, and Section 2 already discusses the connection to Bayesian model averaging, what is the main new result or capability beyond Bayesian filtering, model averaging, and existing quantum Bayesian updates?

  2. Is there an existing quota-readout comparison for the regional control task? If not, why was this baseline included only in the semantic experiments? Please point to existing results or explain this design choice; no new generation experiment is requested during the rebuttal.

Reviewer_226NOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces Quantum Bayesian Feedback (QBF), that can effectively steer (control) the generation process of a frozen generator based on new-coming evidence. The qualitative results are promising, yet qualitative evaluation does not include other baselines. Quantitave evaluation is solely based on a statistic of energy score RR and the merits of QBF (in Table 2) seem marginal (see Table 2). The mathematical background of QBF is heavy.

Critical strengths
  • The mathematical background of QBF and closer evaluation of some propositions and proofs seem valid (Prop. 2,3 and proofs in A.2) .
  • The qualitative results are promising.
Critical weaknesses
  • The quantitative results seem insufficient. Only one evaluation metric is used (a statistic of energy score RR) and the advantages over the baselines seem marginal.
  • An analysis on the computational complexity of QBF is not shown, while there are well-grounded concerns regarding the time and memory overhead introduced by QBF (see ρt\rho_t in Eq. 6).
  • The paper is really dense both in notations and mathematical formulations, as well as reporting (and not sufficiently explaining) evaluation scores. Some notations are introduced, without being defined clearly.
  • Moreover, I think Sec. 3 could elaborate (more) on how each theoretical result (e.g., propositions) contribute to the advantages of QBF. The same applies to commenting on the qualitative and quantitave results (see Questions and Suggestions bellow).
Questions for authors

Introduction: It will be helpful to provide (clearer) intuitive description of key concepts and notations. For instance, evidence could be in practice? Annotated data samples? Which could be the alternative tasks? What could be the task hypotheses in practice? What ideal quantum simulations means in practise?

Figure 1: How should we interpret the posterior mass bars? Does this show the merits of QBF on controlling (i.e., steering the generation process) or the Gap: at t=30 the task-relevant uncertainty has been erased or something else? A short addition on the caption on how the gap or the QBF merits is visualized would enhance readability.

Notations: In Sec 3.1, please clearly define (name) all notations used. A dedicated paragraph with preliminaries it might help. I notice that the same pattern extends to the appendix, where page-length is not limited. Clarifying the notations will make mathematical contributions easier to audit, which will facilitate the appreciation of the mathematical contributions.

Eq. 6 (computational cost of ρ\rho): What is the computational complexity of ρ\rho? Does this limits the scope of application or introduces excessive memory and time overhead? Is this an acceptable trade-off given the merits of QB

Eq. 6 (assumption): How strong is the assumption that the trace of the matrix BtρˉtBtTB_t\bar{\rho}_t B_t^T is positive? Moreover you define it as the success probability? Could you please clarify why this trace taking values in (0,1](0,1] is an acceptable assumption.

lines 232-235 (empirical-to-population error): How critical is the empirical-to-population error. Reading appendix A.2. It is not clear if this error is actually quantified and considered in the upper-bound or not. Is this the ϵsample\epsilon_\mathrm{sample} that is mentioned in the next paragraph? If yes, please consider introducing the notations in lines 232-235. If it is not this and it is not factored into the upper-bound, could you please demonstrate whether it is negligible or not? If you cannot estimate it, could you provide the error rate in terms of the total number of the readouts from ρ\rho and ρ~\tilde{\rho}, and clarify how many samples where used in your experiments.

Evaluation: Please justify why the evaluation is so heavily based on a single evaluation metric RR.

Table 1: Results regarding the average RR seem promising. However, Table 1 shows no evidence regarding the stability of each method, reporting the std along with the average (RR) could mitigate such concerns. If QBF demonstrates high variance, a failure analysis on such cases (along with justification) would be appreciated. Also a failure analysis on the 34 history averages that do not favor QBF would also be meaningful. Elaborating on what "Stable", "Noise shift", and "Target shift" means would also facilitate readability.

Figure 2: How should we interpret the empirical CDFs? I.e., how the advantage of QBF against MAP and Mean is visualized? A comment on what we should look for (plateauing on 0.5?) and why is this meaningful.

Table 2: The results show only marginal score differences among baselines and QBF. While QBF ranks first at the Overall RR, this is not the case for the remaining two columns. Consider including the std, not just the mean over 20 histories. If there are metrics regarding the computation overhead of each method, such as runtime estimation, please report them. I think that the R results alone do not advertise the merits of QBF sampling, if QBF outperforms baselines in other axes please elaborate on that.

Figure 4: Again, one line about intuitive interpretation of the result would facilitate readability. E.g., the drastic increase in final-target share shows the responsiveness (?) of QBF sampling at steering the generation process.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.