acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Edited Endpoints as Partial Goals for Image-to-Video Generation

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Edited endpoint images make the target of an image-to-video transition explicit and can improve transition completion, but also preserve context in the source image's layout. Full-frame endpoint conditioning turns this preserved context into requirements on the video's final state, potentially inducing temporal artifacts. We measure them with Hard-Cut (HC) and Background Motion Reversal (BMR), for abrupt transitions and late background reversals, alongside Dynamic Degree (DD) for motion reduction, and observe model-specific artifacts across five video models spanning training-free and learned endpoint conditioning. We study Partial, a selective conditioning scheme that constrains only an edit-relevant region estimated from image-editor attention and leaves the remaining terminal content to the video model. Across three backbones on TC-Bench-I2V, Partial reduces temporal artifacts relative to full-frame conditioning, with no significant difference in Transition Completion Ratio (TCR); on Wan2.2-Turbo, uniformly weakening conditioning does not reproduce these reductions. A donor-context intervention, which replaces only the context outside the edit-relevant region with the final frame of a Partial video under the same full-frame conditioning, lowers HC and BMR on HunyuanVideo-1.5 and lowers BMR while restoring DD on Wan2.2-Turbo, with no significant difference in TCR, so constraint extent alone does not account for these artifacts. Together, these findings suggest that edited endpoints should serve as partial future goals, although edit relevance does not guarantee future validity.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
video generation, image editing, diffusion/flow models, image-to-video, conditional generation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 25%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.75 over 4 reviews, above 25% of the others.
Reviewer_wQYzOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The task of this paper appears to be as follows: given a source image, a transition prompt, and an edited endpoint image produced by an image editor, the goal is to generate a video that completes the specified visual transition. Directly enforcing the entire endpoint as the final frame can lead to over-specification, since the unedited regions are also forced to remain consistent with their states in the source image. To address this issue, the paper proposes to treat only the edit-relevant regions of the endpoint as the future goal, while allowing the video model to generate the remaining regions freely.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses
  • The supplementary material does not include generated videos. For a video generation task, static frames are insufficient for assessment.

  • The task definition and presentation need substantial improvement. In the current version, I found it difficult to clearly understand the intended task from the Introduction. For the example “change the bus to purple,” is the goal to generate a video in which the bus gradually changes from its original color to purple? If so, this should be clearly defined and illustrated at the beginning of the paper. The current title, Image-to-Video Generation, also feels overly broad for what appears to be a more specific transition-generation setting. In addition, key terminology such as “full-frame endpoint conditioning” is introduced before being explained sufficiently clearly, which makes the paper unnecessarily difficult to follow.

  • The evaluation scope appears limited for the claimed video generation task. The task seems primarily focused on generating videos that complete a specified visual transition, but the paper provides little direct qualitative comparison with existing image-to-video models or video editing methods. Without side-by-side video comparisons against relevant baselines, it is difficult to judge the practical generation quality and understand how much the proposed setting and method improve over existing approaches.

Questions for authors

See Weaknesses.

Reviewer_8tGwOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the use of edited images as terminal goals for image-to-video generation. Its central observation is that an edited endpoint contains both the requested change and context preserved from the source image. Applying the entire endpoint as a terminal constraint can therefore require the scene to return to its original spatial arrangement, potentially causing abrupt transitions, background reversals, or reduced motion.

The proposed Partial scheme estimates an edit-relevant mask from the image editor’s attention and constrains only that region during video generation using masked projection, as in RePaint/Blended Diffusion. The main contribution is the empirical analysis of which endpoint content should constrain the future.

The paper evaluates this strategy across several backbones and investigates conditioning strength, support size and placement, and endpoint content. A donor-context intervention changes the surrounding endpoint content while retaining full-frame conditioning. The contribution is primarily an empirical investigation of endpoint constraints, supported by a selective conditioning strategy.

Critical strengths

Critical Strengths

  1. Useful problem formulation.

    The paper distinguishes desired semantic or appearance edits from unintended constraints on future scene layout. This provides a useful explanation of why an edited source image can become a problematic video endpoint.

  2. Informative donor-context intervention.

    Changing terminal content while retaining full conditioning support provides evidence that content matters beyond constraint extent. Same-seed and cross-seed donors further examine the role of trajectory compatibility.

  3. Substantive experimental controls.

    Comparisons across multiple backbones, together with conditioning-strength and support-size and placement controls, systematically examine factors influencing the results. Diagnostic cross-checks and documented residual failures strengthen the empirical assessment.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The practical benefit remains tied to the evaluated projection implementations.

    All direct Full-versus-Partial comparisons use training-free terminal projection. These establish the benefit of selective conditioning within those implementations, but not its applicability to native learned conditioning. Although learned endpoint baselines are included, the mixed results do not clearly identify when Partial is preferable. Improving over Full is therefore informative experimentally, but does not by itself establish a practical advance over existing approaches. A matched Full-versus-Partial comparison through one native learned spatial-conditioning interface would help establish whether the benefit generalizes beyond projection.

  2. Improved diagnostics are insufficiently connected to perceptually better videos.

    The metrics capture relevant temporal properties, but their changes do not necessarily indicate more appropriate or natural transitions. For example, MfM’s only significant temporal change under Full conditioning is reduced DD, while HC and BMR do not change significantly (Table C8). Less movement can suit the intended endpoint, and detecting a reversal does not establish that it is undesirable. The omission of playable generated videos further limits assessment of whether the reported gains produce better transitions. Representative paired comparisons would help connect the measured improvements to their practical significance.

  3. The donor intervention supports a narrower conclusion than the proposed spatial explanation.

    The experiment establishes that terminal content matters at fixed constraint extent. However, replacing context jointly changes layout, visibility, image properties, and trajectory compatibility. It therefore does not isolate source-layout preservation as the cause of the artifacts. Although acknowledged, this limitation leaves the specific spatial-over-specification explanation less firmly established than the broader content effect.

  4. Completion benefits are uneven, and their limitations remain unexplained.

    On Wan, Partial provides no demonstrated completion gain over Endpoint-free for object-binding transitions (Table C7). The “dog catches a frisbee” example uses support covering only 0.8% of the frame before token pooling (Figure A1), raising the question of whether the selected region sufficiently specifies the intended interaction. It remains unclear whether weaker interaction performance reflects incorrect endpoints, inadequate support selection, or limitations of endpoint-only control. Furthermore, the Full-to-Partial confidence intervals permit meaningful completion losses, so preservation of completion is not established despite the close point estimates (Table C1).

Important Remarks

  • The paper should discuss Time-to-Move [1], which uses masked blending for video conditioning and highlights a limitation of RePaint-style control: unmasked regions can evolve inconsistently. Its dual-clock denoising suggests a potential way to balance endpoint adherence with coherent surrounding content. Discussing or testing an endpoint-only adaptation could clarify whether its denoising strategy better balances endpoint adherence and drift outside the mask.

Minor Weaknesses

The distinction between the empirical contribution and the practical method could be introduced more clearly.

The abstract and introduction bring together the problem formulation, conditioning variants, metrics, and controlled interventions densely. A clearer statement of the central research question and principal findings would make the contribution easier to identify and distinguish its demonstrated results from its proposed explanation.

[1] Singer et al., Time-to-Move: Training-Free Motion Controlled Video Generation via Dual-Clock Denoising, ICLR 2026.

Questions for authors
  1. Generalization and practical value: Does selective conditioning remain beneficial through a native learned conditioning interface? A matched Full-versus-Partial comparison would help clarify this. Under what conditions should practitioners prefer Partial over existing approaches?

  2. Perceptual significance: Could you provide representative paired videos showing whether the diagnostic improvements correspond to more natural, appropriate transitions while preserving completion?

  3. Causal interpretation: What evidence specifically supports source-layout preservation as the cause of artifacts, beyond general endpoint-content sensitivity? Given the acknowledged confounds, how narrowly should the mechanistic conclusion be interpreted?

  4. Interaction failures: Can analysis of object-binding failures distinguish incorrect endpoints, inadequate support selection, and limitations of endpoint-only control? This would help clarify which interactions the method reliably supports?

Reviewer_YRpJOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies how edited endpoint images can over-constrain video generation by preserving source-time context. It proposes Partial, which retains only estimated edit-relevant terminal constraints. Experiments compare completion and temporal artifacts across video backbones, then use donor context, global softening, and spatial controls to examine the source of the improvement.

Critical strengths
  1. The donor-context experiment is a useful controlled comparison. Equation 5 changes terminal context while keeping full support, addressing a confound in Full versus Partial. Cross-seed donors and the spatial controls help explain the observed gains.
  2. Paired prompt-level uncertainty and the discussion of residual failures are useful. The distinction between edit relevance and future validity also makes the limits of the method explicit.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The diagnostic gains still lack independent confirmation that they correspond to errors perceived by humans. 𝐻𝐶=mediantmedian_t sts_t - mintmin_t sts_t ​measures a relative drop in adjacent-frame similarity, while BMR measures late motion against an early reference direction. These capture the reported patterns, but do not by themselves distinguish legitimate reversals or camera motion from forced background returns, and do not measure overall video quality. The blinded VLM and tracking checks are useful, but the latter also measure reversal, and HC's VLM validation excludes Hunyuan, where the HC improvement is largest. A small blinded human study of unjustified cuts, forced background returns, and completion would provide more convincing validation.

  2. The practical motivation feels dated. Spatially masked conditioning is already available in VACE (Jiang et al., 2025) and Many-for-Many (Li et al., 2026), as lines 109–112 acknowledge. Yet Partial is tested only in the three projection-based settings. Showing artifacts under learned Full conditioning does not establish Partial's benefit in those systems. The paper needs to explain what limitation remains in existing masked frameworks and whether its proposed insight helps there.

  3. The presentation is poor, and the method section is difficult to follow. Section 3.3 compresses attention-to-mask construction into a few sentences, while Section 3.4 moves between input blending, clean-prediction projection, and noise-matched projection across backbones. Appendix A supplies details, but the main text needs one complete algorithm showing where M0M_0 enters each sampling step. Reference formatting is also inconsistent, including shortened author lists in some entries and much longer lists written out in full.

Questions for authors
  1. What does Partial add to an existing learned masked-conditioning framework, and does the same diagnosis and improvement hold there?
  2. Can a complete sampling algorithm clarify mask construction, input conditioning, timestep handling, and projection for each backbone?
Reviewer_56v4OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies image-to-video transitions where an image editor generates the target last frame (“edited endpoint”) and the video model is conditioned to end on it. The authors argue that full-frame endpoint conditioning also contains the background to and this causes temporal artifacts. They measure these with several metrics. The proposed method "Partial" constrains the last frame only within an edit-relevant mask derived from the editor’s attention. On TC-Bench-I2V, Partial reduces these artifacts relative to full-frame conditioning without a significant change in completion.

Critical strengths
  1. The experimental design is carefully controlled (shared source and prompt, multiple seeds).
Critical weaknesses
  1. Presentation Clarity. The abstract and introduction contains many newly coined terms ("edited endpoint", "donor-context intervention"). "Partial" as the method name is misleading because it is a common adjective (also appear in L29). Besides, the hedged writing ("with no significant difference in TCR” appears twice) hides the core idea.

  2. The evaluation relies entirely on automatic proxies, some of them tied to the method itself.

(1) There is no human study and no general quality metrics such as aesthetic or subject-consistency score

(2) BMR is tied to the method. The main BMR is measured outside M0M_0, which is exactly the region Partial frees and Full constrains, so the metric is partly built to reward the proposed method.

  1. The donor-context experiment does not isolate the proposed mechanism. The paper attributes Full’s artifacts to spatial over-specification: preserved context pinned to its source-time layout. The donor intervention replaces that context with a Partial rollout’s final frame, which changes three factors at once: layout, pixel source (editor-rendered → video-model-rendered), and compatibility with the recipient’s own trajectory (same seed). The authors acknowledge this. The cross-seed control removes trajectory compatibility and cuts the effect. The residual effect remains confounded between layout and distribution mismatch between editor output and video-model output. These explanations imply different remedies (masking vs. harmonizing the endpoint), so the central claim is stronger than the evidence supports.
Questions for authors
  1. Does the donor effect come from layout or from pixel source? The donor endpoint differs from the original in two ways beyond trajectory compatibility: (a) the background is no longer in its source-time layout, and (b) its pixels are rendered by the video model rather than the image editor. The paper attributes the effect to (a), but the cross-seed result is equally consistent with (b). Could you add a control that varies one factor at a time? For example: re-render the original endpoint’s background with the video model at low denoising strength (source layout, video-model pixels), and re-render a cross-seed donor with the editor (moved layout, editor pixels). In both cases, check with optical flow that the layout is unchanged. If the artifacts follow layout, that supports spatial over-specification. If they follow pixel source, the remedy may be to harmonize the endpoint rather than mask it.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.