- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper focuses on video transition generation from two boundary images. A shared denoiser predicts noise under forward and backward temporal-attention masks, and the predictions are combined using position-dependent weights. Its training uses progressive frame masking and a motion-filtered curriculum.
Critical strengths
-
The experiments show strong smoothness and latency. The proposed method achieves a human smoothness score of 3.92, which is the best over all baselines. Several consecutive-frame structural-consistency metrics support this result. The generation latency is lower than WAN.
-
The paper reports important failure modes. The ground-truth fidelity evaluation, loss interventions, and unsuccessful ghosting-proxy validation are informative. I appreciate that the authors acknowledge the limits of consecutive-frame metrics and disclose the smoothness–fidelity trade-off rather than claiming universal quality superiority.
Critical weaknesses
-
Unconvincing results. In Tables 6 and 7, the proposed method does not show strong performance. Most evaluation metrics are not SOTA. Moreover, in Tab. 2, the proposed method achieves the best smoothness, but other metrics are significantly weaker than other baselines. Those results show that the proposed method fails to generate high quality videos. There is also very limited visual examples (qualitative results).
-
The comparison is not fair. STRIDE runs at 256², whereas DynamiCrafter and TVG run at 768² and SEINE at 784², despite the paper describing the latter checkpoints' native resolution as 320×512 (Appendix A.1 and Table 5). I do not believe this is fair. The training data should be the same unless the authors claim a new dataset contribution or their training data is not obtainable.
-
The presentation makes the method and evidence unnecessarily difficult to assess. All tables are deferred to the appendix: the human-study summary is on p.14, efficiency on p.19, and the main benchmark tables on pp.20–21. Figure 1 combines training and inference through dense text and equations. The main qualitative comparison is deferred to Figure 4 on p.17.
Questions for authors
I do not have any reason to accept this paper, regardless of the rebuttal. The paper has to be largely reformatted, and the evaluation metrics should be more standardized. The goal should be clear.
Closing discussion after the rebuttal
Thank you to the authors for the rebuttal and to the reviewers for engaging in the discussion. As we wrap up, I’d appreciate a brief final assessment from each reviewer. After reading the rebuttal and the discussion so far, what is the main reason you lean toward acceptance or rejection, and what evidence supports that view? Please note which concerns the rebuttal resolved and which remaining concerns, if any, are decisive for your recommendation.
If your assessment differs from another reviewer’s, please point to the specific claim or evidence you interpret differently. Authors are welcome to clarify any factual points that remain open. This will help us identify where we agree and understand the reasons for any remaining disagreement.