- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates a method for food ingredient recognition based on the dynamic response of an electronic nose. For this task, this paper proposes that the amplitude of changes, cross-scale structure, and dynamic representations must be considered simultaneously, whereas existing time-series methods tend to mix information encoding.
This paper proposes the Finite-Structure Additive ILR Network (FSA-ILR), which explicitly organizes the contributions of different types of dynamic information to classification through amplitude–composition reparameterization and additive category score outputs. Finally, the score is obtained by summing the composition match score and the temporal score.
The proposed method was evaluated on the SmellNet-Base dataset using four sensor signals and achieved the best results when compared to MLP, CNN, ScentFormer, and BiLSTM.
Critical strengths
-
The method described in this paper achieved the best accuracy and F1 score when the data was grouped by collection date. Ablation experiments demonstrate that all component paths contribute to the results.
-
This paper proposes a method for constructing scores by summing three different paths, taking into account temporal dynamics, amplitude, and sensor-scale scaling. This transparent structural composition is beneficial for sensor tasks.
Critical weaknesses
-
Figure 1 indicates that this is a schematic diagram. The claim that “Existing time-series methods typically encode these types of information jointly, leaving the contribution of cross-scale ratios to class discrimination largely to implicit learning.” is not supported by actual experiments or data.
-
The claimed contributions of this method lack empirical evidence, and its novelty is limited. The performance improvement may stem from the architecture itself or from the manually designed multiscale features.
-
The generalizability of the method is not sufficiently demonstrated. Given that the study is based on only one dataset and includes few comparison methods, the conclusion that this method can serve as a general approach for dynamic response recognition lacks supporting evidence, considering the scope of this study.
Questions for authors
I have a few questions I’d like the author to answer and clarify.
- Figure 1(b) is an illustrative example. Is this supported by actual experiments and data?
- The paper states that the core idea is that existing models rely on implicit learning of cross scale proportional information. I would like to see additional experimental explanations regarding the validity of this claim for such tasks.
- The core method of this paper relies on the combined effects of different modules. As shown in Table 2, when considering only the temporal path, the results are essentially consistent with those of ScentFormer. If other methods were to incorporate the statistical path mentioned by the authors, would their performance also improve? If so, is this improvement due to the concatenation of additional feature paths? I would like to see more fair comparative experiments.
- The abstract states that “FSA-ILR outperforms the comparison methods in Acc@1, Acc@5, and macro-F1 under all four sensor-only input settings,” but the main text does not include experimental results for Acc@5.
- This paper uses only one experimental dataset. Additionally, it lacks comparisons with baselines such as TimesNet, TimeMixer and others.
- Please review the results in Table A2.