- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper is about predicting odor perception from EI-MS spectra. The main idea is a form of contrastive distillation: an MS encoder (that is pretrained on the structure/odor information) is trained with a CLIP-like loss to align with frozen structure embeddings (Open-POM or MolFormer) on ~148k NIST spectrum–SMILES pairs, so that only the spectrum is needed at test time. Experiments on GS-LF, a prospective panel, DREAM and 50 lab-measured spectra show consistent gains over EIMS2Vec, and the authors claim the model approaches structure-based models without access to structure at inference.
Critical strengths
1 Olfaction is an important but underexplored problem in ML, and work that pushes this direction forward is valuable to the community. 2 Framing the problem as contrastive distillation from structure to spectra is a neat idea. The authors note that the contrastive objective itself is not new, but applying it between EI-MS and molecular structure makes a lot of sense. Odor modeling has long lacked a good, shared representation, and this approach makes use of ~148k spectrum–structure pairs, while labeled odor data covers only a few thousand molecules. 3 The experiments are extensive, covering four evaluation settings (GS-LF, a prospective panel, DREAM and real lab spectra) along with ablations and significance tests. The results consistently show that the learned representation is useful for odor prediction.
Critical weaknesses
My major concerns:
-
The paper motivates spectrum-only prediction by saying molecular identity is unavailable at inference. But for conventional EI-MS, library search is the standard way to get identity and it is fast. The paper’s own data seemingly shows high library coverage of odorants (385/476 DREAM molecules, 178/208 panel molecules). The obvious baseline is therefore search + Open-POM. The only retrieval comparison (App. E.2) is open-set with top-1 retrieval, which is the worst case for search. I would like to see closed-set retrieval, at least on the 50 lab spectra searched against NIST, plus a top-k / kNN variant, with results split by match score. Without this it is unclear when SCENT is actually useful.
-
This is closely related to point 1: single pure compounds are exactly the setting where library search works best. The cases where search fails (mixtures, background interference, compounds not in the library) are not evaluated. Hasebe et al. (2022), which the paper cites, already works with mixture spectra, but this is not discussed. Even a simple test, such as adding a small fraction of a second compound to a spectrum and measuring how the predictions change, would help. Also, a natural competing pipeline that also uses only spectra at inference is MS → fingerprint → odor model. Ji et al. (2020), cited in the introduction, predicts fingerprints from EI-MS, but it is not used as a baseline or discussed thoroughly.
-
Open-POM is trained with odor labels and is a much stronger teacher than MolFormer on DREAM (Table F2: 0.37–0.42 vs. 0.28–0.34). Yet its student is weaker (Table F3: 0.301 vs. 0.325), and on GS-LF the two students are on par. A stronger, odor-aware teacher giving a weaker student is surprising and deserves analysis.
Minors:
Gains over EIMS2Vec are moderate (+1.8–2.0 micro-AUC, +3.2–3.4 macro-AUC on GS-LF), and SCENT (Open-POM) stays below Open-POM on GS-LF and DREAM. Since both the teacher and the downstream encoder are frozen, have the authors tried fine-tuning the encoder on odor labels after alignment, or training the alignment and odor losses jointly?
The masked reconstruction baseline (76.34 micro-AUC) is far below even EIMS2Vec. Please give its details: masking ratio, reconstruction target, and pooling. If only [CLS] is used downstream, it may receive no training signal under a masked objective.
Related work. CLIP-style alignment has also been used to learn olfactory representations from sensor data, e.g., aligning e-nose signals with images in the wild (New York Smells, Ozguroglu et al., 2025), and similarly on language-guided olfactory representation learning (Tsonis et al., 2026). A short discussion of this line of work would help position the contribution.
Questions for authors
See my major concerns. I am currently slightly leaning towards borderline rejection. I would re-evaluate the rating if the authors could address my concerns.
3 comments
Author's Response to Reviewer quLw (2/2)
C4: Since both the teacher and the downstream encoder are frozen, have the authors tried fine-tuning the encoder on odor labels after alignment, or training the alignment and odor losses jointly?
A4: Compared with structure-based models, MS-based models have less direct access to structure information. Our goal is therefore to transfer this information to the MS encoder. For this reason, we choose to keep the teacher model frozen. We also tested the fine tuning during the downstream task, but the model performance didn’t benefit from it. We hypothesize that this may be due to the limited amount of downstream training data relative to the parameters in the encoder, which prevents the data from effectively refining the upstream representations. We also observed that a randomly initialized classification head can disrupt aligned features during the early stages of training, while also increasing the total training time. Consequently, we opted to freeze the encoder and train only the classification head. We thank the reviewer for raising this question and we clarified our rationale in the Appendix A of the updated paper.
C5: The masked reconstruction baseline (76.34 micro-AUC) is far below even EIMS2Vec. Please give its details: masking ratio, reconstruction target, and pooling. If only [CLS] is used downstream, it may receive no training signal under a masked objective.
A5: Thank you for pointing out this question. We checked the ablation and confirmed that the original MR baseline masked 15% of observed peaks (Bernoulli per peak, replaced by a zero vector), regressed their relative intensities with a per-token decoder, and used the frozen [CLS] output downstream. We therefore re-implemented it two ways with SCENT's architecture and data. The ablation uses BERT-style masking (mask token plus m/z, per-token decoder) and a variant predicting masked intensities from [CLS], training it directly. We report both [CLS] and mean pooling. The results show that the mean pooling is better than [CLS] in this setting, since the [CLS] doesn’t have a task of summarizing the full molecule information. The ablation also proves that the gain of SCENT comes from alignment, not simply from the architecture. We updated Table 2 in the updated version of paper with these results.
| Model Variant | Transformer | Objective | Micro-AUC↑ | Macro-AUC↑ | Adj.Precision@k↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| w/o CLIP 1a, [CLS] | ✓ | MR | 78.06 ± 0.08 | 58.53 ± 0.41 | 29.65 ± 0.10 |
| w/o CLIP 1b, mean pool | ✓ | MR | 86.10 ± 0.10 | 78.68 ± 0.19 | 40.94 ± 0.35 |
| EIMS2Vec | × | PC | 87.98 ± 0.15 | 82.29 ± 0.61 | 46.49 ± 0.53 |
| SCENT (Open-POM) | ✓ | C | 89.80 ±0.09 | 85.45 ±0.30 | 50.60 ±0.53 |
| SCENT (MolFormer) | ✓ | C | 89.99 ±0.18 | 85.71 ±0.26 | 50.62 ±0.75 |
C6: CLIP-style alignment has also been used to learn olfactory representations from sensor data, e.g., aligning e-nose signals with images in the wild (New York Smells, Ozguroglu et al., 2025), and similarly on language-guided olfactory representation learning (Tsonis et al., 2026). A short discussion of this line of work would help position the contribution.
A6: Thank you for highlighting these related studies. We agree that these works help position SCENT within the broader context of multimodal olfactory representation learning. Existing sensor / language guided alignment shows the potential of CLIP-style contrastive learning in bridging olfactory sensory modality. SCENT, although applying a similar approach, grounds the representation in chemistry by mapping the smell signal with exact chemical structure information, and offers a complementary perspective to the community. We added this discussion in Section 2 of our updated paper.
I thank the authors for the additional information and experiments provided in the rebuttal.
Most of my concerns have been addressed. The one that remains is the in-library search issue, which I consider important: the authors should better position their work with respect to the search for in-library compounds. Otherwise, I like the paper. I believe olfaction deserves more attention from the community, as it will matter a great deal for the future of physical AI.
I am therefore raising my score to Weak Accept and this will be the final score.
Author's Response to Reviewer quLW (1/2)
We thank the reviewer for the time spent reviewing our paper. Below, we address the reviewers questions and concerns:
C1: When is SCENT preferable to library search followed by Open-POM? How does it compare with closed-set retrieval and top-k/kNN variants on the 50 laboratory spectra, including performance across different match-score ranges?
A1: We agree that library search is the standard first step, and we have run the requested comparison on the 50 laboratory spectra. Retrieval uses the official NIST MSPepSearch (Identity search, NIST MS Search 3.0 algorithm, pre-search off, m/z 50–180) against 148,212 NIST23 spectra. The top-k retrieved molecules (k = 1, 3, 5, 10) are passed through Open-POM to an odor head trained on the same split as SCENT's head, so neither head has seen the odor labels of these molecules.
For a closed-set (every query in the library) setting, NIST identifies 36/50 measured spectra correctly. Library search → Open-POM performs on par with SCENT: top-1 Macro-AUC is 83.05 ± 0.40 vs. 82.09 ± 0.61 (Δ +1.0 [−1.8, +3.1]), and top-3/5/10 give 82.32–83.41. No match-factor tertile is significantly above SCENT. For an open-set (query removed from the library) setting,top-1 drops to 79.05 Macro-AUC (Δ −3.0 [−7.3, −0.5]), and every top-k variant trails SCENT on Adj.P@5 by 6.9-12.1 points.
We therefore treat SCENT as a useful complement to library search, especially when the query is not in the library. We added these results to the Appendix E.2 and modified the discussion in Section 4.1 in the updated paper.
C2-1: How robust is SCENT when spectra contain mixtures or background interference, or when compounds are absent from the library? Can a controlled second-compound contamination experiment clarify its robustness?
A2-1: We thank the reviewer for raising this point. To answer the reviewer question, we have conducted an experiment where each GS-LF test spectrum was mixed with one spectrum from the training/validation pool, chosen with low (spectra cosine < 0.05) or high (spectra 0.6–0.9) spectral overlap. Both spectra TIC(x)=mxm, giving a=a/TIC(a) and c=c/TIC(c), and mixed as x=a+c. Hence SNR=1010[TIC(a)/TIC(c)]=-1010, swept from 40 dB (=10-4) to 0 dB (=1, equal ion current) in 2 dB steps. We test the robustness of both SCENT variants and EIMS2Vec. The results show that the performance degrades gracefully as the contaminant grows. SCENT stays above EIMS2Vec down to about 15 dB (contaminant ≈ 3% of the target's ion current), the margin closes only below about 10 dB (contaminant ≥ 10%), and a spectrally similar contaminant costs less than a dissimilar one. We added those results with a figure to Appendix E in the updated version paper.
C2-2: How does SCENT compare with an MS → fingerprint → odor prediction pipeline? How does it relate to Ji et al. (2020)
A2-2: Thank you for the question. Ji et al. (2020) predict a binary molecular fingerprint from an EI spectrum and use it to rank candidate structures for compound identification. The difference between this pipeline with SCENT is mainly in this intermediate representation. As Lee et al. (2023) demonstrated that POM captures odor-relevant information more effectively than conventional molecular fingerprints, we chose to focus on this representation rather than explicitly predicting fingerprints. We discussed the differences between our work and the work of Ji et al. (2020) in Section 2 of the updated paper.
C3: Why does the stronger, odor-supervised Open-POM teacher produce a weaker student than MolFormer on DREAM, while their students perform similarly on GS-LF
A3: We thank the reviewer for this question. The student primarily inherits its teacher's dominant, high-variance principal components (R2 0.65 vs. 0.33 for tail components). While Open-POM relies on its low-variance tail directions to predict out-of-vocabulary DREAM descriptors (such as Acid and Chemical), its student fails to recover these weak signals during alignment, whereas MolFormer's broader variance distribution allows its student to capture them. Consequently, the two students tie on GS-LF descriptors (which rely on dominant components), while SCENT (Open-POM) lags specifically on out-of-vocabulary DREAM terms.