- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies multi-step tropical cyclone precipitation forecasting on storm-centered grids conditioned on a given storm track, using historical rainfall fields to predict the next 24 hours. SDRNet treats rainfall as an explicit state and combines backward deformation, survival and renewal, and prediction feedback. Experiments on the Corrected and Raw products of LagTCPMoS use retrospective best tracks and report improvements in spatial matching and heavy-rainfall identification. Controls using the same backbone examine the update parameterization and dynamic conditioning.
Critical strengths
The design has a clear connection to the forecasting problem. Deformation, intensity adjustment, and feedback address rain-area motion and deformation, local intensification or weakening, and the conditions for subsequent predictions. The state remains nonnegative, and the quantities are limited to effective changes in rainfall-product space, avoiding overly strong physical interpretations.
The predictive results and design controls are useful. Chronological testing with intact storms reports improvements in spatial matching and heavy-rainfall identification. With the same backbone and objective, Full outperforms Warp+Residual and Uncoupled, while paired storm-level analyses support the predictive value of the proposed parameterization.
Critical weaknesses
1.The external baseline comparison needs clearer support. NowcastNet-Evolution is a reimplemented baseline, but the available materials are insufficient to assess whether its adaptation and training are appropriate. Please clarify the implementation and training evidence underlying this comparison to support the advantage reported in the main results.
2.The interpretation of skill retention needs verification. The first and final lead times use partly different storm sets, so their score ratio does not directly represent skill retention on the same storms. Please verify retention on fixed storm sets; this concern does not negate comparisons between methods at the same lead time.
Questions for authors
Q1 : What implementation and training evidence supports the NowcastNet-Evolution comparison?
Q2 : Does skill retention hold on a fixed storm set?
Q3 : How are the "forecast-like" track perturbations generated, and how do they relate to actual track forecast errors?
1. NowcastNet-Evolution implementation and training evidence (Weakness 1; Question 1)
Thank you for requesting clearer implementation and training evidence for the NowcastNet-Evolution comparison. The baseline is a task-adapted PyTorch reimplementation of NowcastNet's deterministic Evolution Branch, excluding the conditional generator and discriminator. A shared Evolution Encoder, Motion Decoder, and Intensity Decoder predict motion fields and intensity residuals for recursive evolution. Inputs and outputs are four 6 h fields on a 20×20 storm-centered grid with 50 km spacing. The accumulation loss constrains the bilinearly warped and final evolved fields; motion regularization uses Sobel spatial gradients.
The added implementation paragraph in Appendix C.6 specifies independent training on Corrected and Raw using common storm splits and seeds 9101/9102/9103: Adam, batch size 16, learning rate 10−3, reduced to 10−4 at iteration 200,000, a 300,000-iteration budget, and motion-regularization coefficient 0.01. Checkpoints are selected solely by validation aggregate FSS across four leads; test data are not used for model selection.
Common data, available information, and evaluation and selection rules align the forecasting task. External methods retain their respective training objectives, whereas the same-backbone controls share soft-FSS. External comparisons therefore assess complete adapted methods, while internal controls isolate the update parameterization. Claims about NowcastNet are restricted to this adapted Evolution Branch.
2. Skill retention on a fixed storm set (Weakness 2; Question 2)
Thank you for pointing out that lead-dependent storm sets complicate the interpretation of skill retention. The conclusion holds on fixed storm sets. We agree that the original first-to-last ratio alone does not establish retention on the same storms. We intersect target-eligible storm IDs across all four leads and three thresholds within each product, yielding 138 Corrected storms and 132 Raw storms. All methods, seeds, and threshold–neighborhood components use the same product-specific set, with the original equal weighting of storms and components.
In new Figure S1 (Appendix D.6.1), SDRNet's +24 h FSS is 0.7169/0.7223, compared with 0.6642/0.6686 for NowcastNet-Evolution. Retention relative to each model's +6 h seed-mean score is 93.38%/94.13%, versus 89.82%/90.43%. Their FSS gaps widen from 0.0282/0.0280 at +6 h to 0.0527/0.0537 at +24 h. Thus, higher final-step absolute skill and slower relative degradation both hold on fixed storm sets.
3. Synthetic perturbations and actual forecast-track errors (Question 3)
Thank you for asking how the forecast-like perturbations are generated and how they relate to actual track forecast errors. Original Table D3 changes track conditions through synthetic offsets to Best Track centers: stepwise Gaussian position perturbations with approximately 25 km RMS displacement and forecast-like perturbations with approximately 45 km median position error at +24 h. The latter is a sensitivity setting at a specified error magnitude; it is not presented as a calibrated stochastic model of operational errors. The two magnitudes also use different statistics.
The historical official forecast-track replay in new Table D6 (Appendix D.6.5) separately examines practical relevance. Tracks come from the NHC ATCF archive and are matched to rainfall initialization by actual release time. We prioritize OFCI, the adjusted previous-cycle OFCL forecast. Missing required times are interpolated between valid positions within the selected forecast cycle to obtain 6 h intervals. Historical rainfall inputs and checkpoints remain fixed; all methods share replay samples and the corresponding grids.
SDRNet achieves FSS of 0.714/0.707, exceeding NowcastNet-Evolution by 0.050/0.049. This supports a relative advantage under these historical forecast-track conditions without calibrating the original synthetic perturbations. Best Track and forecast-track conditions also define different evaluation grids, so cross-condition score changes cannot be attributed solely to one source of error.
Table D6. Aggregate FSS under Best Track and historical official forecast-track conditions.