- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GeoMIL, a geometry-aware multiple instance learning framework for few-shot whole-slide image classification. It addresses feature manifold degradation and attention instability through a shared learnable Riemannian metric. Specifically, TSLP preserves feature geometry while enabling task adaptation, and GQA generates attention queries from geometric representations. Experiments on three pathology datasets demonstrate improved classification performance and attention-based localization.
Critical strengths
- The paper identifies a meaningful connection between feature manifold degradation and attention instability in few-shot WSI classification, providing a geometry-based perspective on existing MIL limitations.
- The paper provides comparative experiments against ten representative MIL methods on three pathology datasets, together with ablation studies and attention localization analyses to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed framework.
Critical weaknesses
- The claimed causal relationship between feature manifold degradation and attention instability is not sufficiently supported. Specifically, Figure 1(c) measures attention concentration rather than instability across epochs. A more appropriate metric would be the Jensen–Shannon divergence between consecutive attention distributions, . The attention concentration curves in Figure 1(c) rapidly increase and then stabilize, without clearly demonstrating the claimed oscillations.
- The computational efficiency of GeoMIL is insufficiently evaluated. The proposed framework introduces additional Riemannian metric pretraining and a teacher–student architecture, but the paper provides no comparisons of training time, inference time, or computational complexity with existing MIL methods. Such analyses are necessary to assess the practical overhead of the proposed approach.
- A decreasing effective rank does not necessarily indicate harmful manifold degradation, as it may reflect beneficial discriminative feature compression that suppresses task-irrelevant variations.
- The practical validity of the assumptions underlying Theorem 1 remains insufficiently examined. Moreover, the theoretical analysis only establishes the geometric preservation properties of the feature transformation, without directly demonstrating that preserving feature geometry leads to improved attention stability.
Questions for authors
- Further experiments directly measuring attention fluctuations and establishing the causal role of feature geometry are needed to substantiate the central motivation.
- Please clarify which evaluation metric is used as the criterion for early stopping.
- The independent contribution of GQA appears limited. Although GQA generally improves performance, some gains are relatively small compared with the reported standard deviations across random seeds. Paired statistical significance tests and direct comparisons of attention fluctuations with and without GQA are needed to better establish its effectiveness.
- Please provide additional experimental results on multi-class classification datasets to further demonstrate the generalizability of GeoMIL.