acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Latent-Space Denoising for Temporal Causal Representation Learning with Mechanism Sparsity

Abstract

Observation noise poses a major challenge to causal representation learning. In temporal data, noise affects latent representations at successive time steps, making temporal dependencies harder to estimate and causal structures harder to recover. To address this challenge, we integrate our latent-space denoising module with an existing mechanism-sparsity method to form a joint learning framework, Latent Denoising with Mechanism Sparsity (LDMS). The framework uses free-energy-guided particle dynamics to refine the latent distribution and combines denoising regularization with variational reconstruction and sparse transition estimation to improve the representations used for temporal mechanism learning. Our theoretical analysis considers the effects of both latent states and auxiliary variables at the preceding time step on the current latent state. We establish stability bounds for mechanism strengths after denoising, sufficient conditions for preserving sparse dependencies, and consistency conditions for joint denoising and mechanism estimation. These results quantify how denoising error affects mechanism estimation and graph recovery, providing a theoretical basis for the joint framework. Experimental results show that LDMS improves latent factor alignment and graph recovery, demonstrating the benefits of latent-space denoising for existing temporal causal representation learning methods and its potential as a plug-and-play module.

Primary area:
causal reasoning
Keywords:
Causal Representation Learning, Latent-Space Denoising, Mechanism Sparsity, Temporal Dependencies, Causal Structure Recovery

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.25 over 4 reviews, above 49% of the others.
Reviewer_DctYOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Overall, this paper addresses an important and practical problem—alleviating the negative impact of measurement observation noise on temporal causal representation learning. The problem formulation is novel, and the proposed approach using free-energy particle dynamics for latent space denoising is supported by decent theoretical guarantees.

Critical strengths
  1. The motivation to address measurement observation noise in temporal causal representation learning is logical and practical, tackling a crucial bottleneck toward real-world applicability.

  2. The proposed LDMS framework is backed by decent theoretical proofs, providing clear guarantees for mechanism strength stability, sparse support preservation, and joint estimation consistency.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The authors compare their proposed method against only a single baseline: the mechanism-sparsity VAE without the denoising regularizer[8, 25]. The paper fails to include comparisons with existing mainstream temporal causal representation learning methods (e.g., LEAP, TDRL, CITRIS, CtrlNS)[ 2, 11, 12] or robust/denoising ICA baselines[2, 11]. Without these benchmarking results, there is no clear evidence that LDMS offers a distinct performance advantage over the state-of-the-art[8, 30].
  2. In key evaluation experiments (e.g., Table 1 and Table 2), LDMS incorporates a lower-triangular support prior, whereas the baseline employs an unrestricted candidate support. This asymmetric setup introduces a major confounding factor, making it impossible to determine whether performance gains stem from the latent particle denoising module itself or merely from the stronger structural prior.
  3. Although the authors claim that the denoising module is "plug-and-play", it is only integrated into a single framework without demonstrating efficacy on alternative CRL backbones. Furthermore, essential ablation studies on hyperparameter sensitivities (e.g., particle count NN, inner update steps KiterK_{iter}, and denoising loss weight λD\lambda_D) are completely missing, leaving the isolated contribution and robustness of the module unverified.
Questions for authors

See Weaknesses.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Latent-Space Denoising for Temporal Causal Representation Learning with Mechanism Sparsity

We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments. We address the concerns regarding baseline comparisons, structural priors, and hyperparameter robustness below.

W1: Comparisons with Existing Methods

The current experiments mainly compare LDMS with the mechanism-sparsity baseline. To provide a more comprehensive evaluation, we include representative temporal causal representation learning methods, namely LEAP, TDRL, and CtrlNS [1,2,3], as well as SNICA [2] as an additional baseline. All experiments are conducted on the TimeNonDiag dataset introduced by Lachapelle et al.[4], with 100,000 samples, and each experiment is repeated independently five times. The table below summarizes the comparison results.

MethodMCC ↑SHD ↓Time ↓
LDMS0.712 ± 0.02531.600 ± 5.177607.449 ± 6.271
MS0.674 ± 0.02629.400 ± 8.173366.593 ± 6.921
TDRL0.484 ± 0.03146.400 ± 6.22933.712 ± 0.140
LEAP0.479 ± 0.01644.400 ± 2.60817.298 ± 0.452
CtrlNS0.475 ± 0.02144.800 ± 2.68378.462 ± 1.190
SNICA0.459 ± 0.02146.000 ± 5.29217.043 ± 0.303

LDMS achieves the best performance in terms of MCC for latent variable recovery, indicating that the latent-space denoising module helps improve latent variable recovery accuracy.

W2: Experimental Comparisons

We agree with the reviewer that the use of different structural priors may affect the fairness of the comparison between the baseline and LDMS, making it difficult to isolate the contribution of latent-space denoising.

To address this issue, we conducted two sets of controlled experiments: (1) neither method uses the lower-triangular support prior; and (2) both methods use the same lower-triangular support prior. In both settings, all other model architectures, training configurations, and evaluation procedures are kept identical. The corresponding results are presented in our response to Reviewer dQ2z, under Q2 & W3: Experimental Fairness and the Contribution of Denoising. These controlled experiments allow us to evaluate the contribution of latent-space denoising more fairly under matched structural assumptions.

W3: Generalizability and Hyperparameter Robustness

We conduct sensitivity analyses on the hyperparameters that may affect the performance of the latent-space denoising module, including the number of particles NN, the number of inner particle updates KiterK_{\mathrm{iter}}, and the denoising weight λD\lambda_D.We evaluate each configuration on TimeDiag with five random seeds.The results are shown in the following table.

HyperparameterValueMCC ↑SHD ↓Latent RMSE ↓
NN640.702 ± 0.0360.000 ± 0.0000.771 ± 0.048
NN2560.685 ± 0.0530.000 ± 0.0000.791 ± 0.068
NN10240.710 ± 0.0400.200 ± 0.4470.760 ± 0.052
KiterK_{\mathrm{iter}}10.693 ± 0.0400.000 ± 0.0000.782 ± 0.050
KiterK_{\mathrm{iter}}20.650 ± 0.0380.000 ± 0.0000.836 ± 0.046
KiterK_{\mathrm{iter}}80.685 ± 0.0500.000 ± 0.0000.791 ± 0.065
λD\lambda_D0.010.729 ± 0.0610.400 ± 0.5480.732 ± 0.084
λD\lambda_D0.0250.744 ± 0.0420.000 ± 0.0000.714 ± 0.057
λD\lambda_D0.20.570 ± 0.0240.000 ± 0.0000.927 ± 0.026

The results show that LDMS is sensitive to the choice of hyperparameters. In particular, λD=0.025\lambda_D=0.025 achieves the highest MCC and lowest Latent RMSE, while a larger weight (0.2) degrades latent representation recovery. These results highlight the importance of appropriate hyperparameter selection.

In addition, we will further clarify the scope of this study. LDMS integrates latent-space denoising based on free-energy-guided Wasserstein particle flows into the mechanism-sparsity framework. Our experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of this specific combination. However, we have not fully explored whether the denoising module is compatible with other causal representation learning methods. We will discuss its potential for use in other causal representation learning frameworks in the revised paper. Further exploring its integration with these methods will be an important direction for future work.

We thank the reviewer again for the helpful suggestions. We believe the proposed revisions will strengthen the experimental evaluation and clarify the scope of LDMS.

References

[1] Gradient Flows in Metric Spaces and in the Space of Probability Measures, Birkhxauser,2008.

[2] Disentangling Identifiable Features from Noisy Data with Structured Nonlinear ICA, NeurIPS, 2021.

[3] Unsupervised Feature Extraction by Time-Contrastive Learning and Nonlinear ICA, NeurIPS, 2016.

[4] Nonparametric partial disentanglement via mechanism sparsity: Sparse actions, interventions and sparse temporal dependencies. JMLR, 2026.

Reviewer_MZw1OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The primary contribution of the paper is an objective for joint latent-space denoising and sparse temporal mechanism estimation that the authors label Latent Denoising with Mechanism Sparsity (LDMS). The motivation is at least partly the observation that temporally stable causal mechanisms can be expected to be sparse, which seems intuitively justifiable.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses a critical problem, and applies well understood methodologies in this task. Despite the lack of references to previous works most of the formalisms use are well known. This lends strentgh to the authors' arguments.

Critical weaknesses

The paper reads as though it was mechanically translated from another language. Each sentence makes some sense individually but is surprisingly unrelated to those before and after it. This is most evident in the related work section which is a laundry list devoid of synthesis or insight.

The paper is mathematically dense to the point of being almost entirely devoid of explanatory text or motivational information for most passages. There is no narrative to guide the reader through the derivations, or provide intuition as to why they are important or relevant.

Given tha tthis is a densely covered subject, the sparsity of references in the main text makes it very difficult for the reader to identify what is actually novel.

Questions for authors

What is actually novel about the paper, technically. I don't mean what are the stated contributions, I mean, given the existing literature, how does the paper advance the state of the field? The paper needs a clear statement like 'The rest of the field is doing X but we're doing Y because it's more ...' or 'technique X has achieved important results when applied to ... and we investigate here whether this extends to time series', or something like that. The paper needs a better justification than 'Applying X to Y gives slightly better benchmark results than existing methods'.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Latent-Space Denoising for Temporal Causal Representation Learning with Mechanism Sparsity

We sincerely thank the reviewer for the constructive comments. We acknowledge that the paper needs clearer explanations, better organization, and a more explicit discussion of its technical contributions. We will revise the paper accordingly.

W1: Presentation and Structural Organization

We will revise the paper to improve the language, logical flow, and mathematical explanations.

First, we will reorganize Section 2 (Related Work) to provide a clearer overview of temporal causal representation learning and intervention-based methods. We will also add relevant references and discuss the main ideas and limitations of existing methods. This will help readers better understand the background of our work and identify our work differences from previous studies.

Second, we will improve the explanations in Sections 3 and 4. In Section 3, we will clarify why latent-space denoising is introduced into the mechanism-sparsity framework and how the two components are combined. In Section 4, we will add intuitive explanations before the main assumptions, equations, and theoretical results to explain their motivation and roles. We will also reduce unnecessary mathematical details in the main text.

Q1: Methodological Novelty and Technical Contributions

The main contribution of our work is to improve the existing mechanism-sparsity framework [1] by introducing latent-space denoising for temporal causal representation learning under observation noise.

The original framework focuses on learning sparse temporal dependencies among latent variables but does not explicitly address the effects of observation noise on latent representations. To address this limitation, we introduce latent-space denoising based on free-energy-guided Wasserstein particle flows and combine it with sparse mechanism estimation through a joint optimization objective. This enables the model to refine latent representations while learning sparse temporal mechanisms, improving its performance under observation noise.

Unlike the original mechanism-sparsity framework, our method jointly considers latent distribution refinement and sparse mechanism estimation. We also provide theoretical results on mechanism-strength stability, sparse-support preservation, and joint estimation consistency. These results explain how representation errors affect mechanism estimation and under what conditions the sparse structure can be preserved.

We thank the reviewer again for the valuable feedback. We believe these revisions will improve the clarity of the paper and better explain the motivation and technical contributions of our work. We welcome any further comments or suggestions.

References

[1] Nonparametric partial disentanglement via mechanism sparsity: Sparse actions, interventions and sparse temporal dependencies. JMLR, 2026.

Reviewer_dQ2zOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies temporal causal representation learning under observation noise. In temporal data, noise distorts the latent representations at successive time steps, which makes temporal dependencies harder to estimate and the causal structure harder to recover. To address this challenge, the paper proposes LDMS, a joint learning framework that combines a latent-space denoising module with an existing mechanism-sparsity method (Lachapelle et al., 2026). Theoretically, the authors derive stability bounds for mechanism strengths after denoising, sufficient conditions for preserving sparse dependencies, and consistency conditions for joint denoising and mechanism estimation. Together, these results characterize how denoising error affects mechanism estimation and graph recovery, and they provide a theoretical foundation for the joint framework. Empirically, the authors report that LDMS improves latent factor alignment and graph recovery, which they present as evidence for the benefit of combining the denoising module with mechanism sparsity.

Critical strengths
  • The problem is real and well motivated. From the perspective of identifiability and disentanglement in causal representation learning, it is reasonable to combine the restrictions imposed by mechanism sparsity with a denoising module.
  • The theoretical analysis gives significant contribution. The theory separates the error into clear sources: representation error, mechanism-fitting error, and evaluation error. The paper provides a conditional guarantee that adding latent denoising preserves the sparse mechanisms targeted by the original method. It also establishes the consistency of the joint estimation.
Critical weaknesses
  • Unclear novelty of the denoising module. The main contribution is the combination of two components: latent-space denoising and mechanism sparsity. However, it is unclear whether the denoising module is introduced in this submission or taken from prior work. The paper repeatedly refers to “our latent-space denoising module” but gives no citation for it, and the module is not listed among the stated contributions. If the module comes from prior work, the contribution reduces to combining it with the model of Lachapelle et al. (2026), plus the theory section. I ask the authors to clarify this. If the module was introduced earlier, they should cite that work (in the third person) and state explicitly what is new in this submission.
  • Clarity: key quantities are defined only in the appendix. I could not find a mathematical definition of R^LDMS\hat{R}_{\text{LDMS}} in the main body, although it is a core component of the method and appears in the main training objective (Eq. 9). Similarly, the kernel density estimates, the particle update rule, and related quantities appear only in Appendix D.2 (Eqs. 43–45). These should be defined in the main body so that the method can be understood without the appendix.
  • Limited empirical evidence. The reported improvements are largely incremental. For most datasets, the mean ± SD of LDMS overlaps with that of the baseline. Also, LDMS uses a lower-triangular support prior that the baseline lacks. So the gain from denoising alone is never isolated. In my view, the experiments do not provide sufficient evidence to support the theoretical analysis.
Questions for authors
  • Was the denoising module introduced in prior work? If so, cite it and state what is new here.
  • Run LDMS without the lower-triangular prior, or give the baseline the same prior, so that the effect of denoising alone is visible.
  • Report an empirical estimate of ∆z, or of the representation error, for the baseline and for LDMS. This would connect the experiments to the theory.
  • Report runtime and memory, since the particle update is quadratic in the number of particles.
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Latent-Space Denoising for Temporal Causal Representation Learning with Mechanism Sparsity

We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments. We agree that the original paper did not sufficiently clarify the provenance of the denoising module, the methodological details, and the experimental evidence. We address these concerns point by point below.

Q1 & W1: Provenance of the Denoising Module and Novelty of Our Work

We clarify the methodological contributions of this work as follows.

This work integrates latent-space denoising based on free-energy-guided Wasserstein particle flows into the mechanism-sparsity framework of Lachapelle et al. [1] to address observation noise in temporal causal representation learning. Our main contribution is to combine these two components into a joint optimization framework. We also establish theoretical results on mechanism-strength stability, sparse-support preservation, and joint estimation consistency, showing how latent representation errors affect mechanism estimation and graph recovery.

We will clarify the role of the denoising module and the main methodological and theoretical contributions in the revised paper.

W2: Method Description

We agree that the computational details of the latent-space denoising module should be presented more clearly in the main text. The precise mathematical definition of the empirical denoising regularizer R^LDMS\widehat{\mathcal R}_{\mathrm{LDMS}} is given in Eq. (45) of Appendix D.2. Intuitively, this regularizer uses the refined particle distribution to guide the encoder toward a better latent distribution. Its precise mathematical definition is given below.

let P={Vm}m=1N\mathcal P=\{V_m\}_{m=1}^{N} denote the particle set, and Ym=Vm+bqζmY_m=V_m+\sqrt{b_q}\zeta_m, where ζm∼N(0,Id)\zeta_m\sim\mathcal N(0,I_d). The empirical denoising regularizer is defined as

= \frac{1}{N}\sum_{m=1}^{N} [\log \widehat{q}_{\mathcal{P}}(Y_{m})-\log \widehat{\nu}_{\phi}(Y_{m})] -\frac{\lambda_H}{N}\sum_{m=1}^{N} \log \widehat{\rho}_{\mathcal{P},-m}(V_{m})$$ Here $\widehat q_{\mathcal P}$, $\widehat\nu_\phi$, and $\widehat\rho_{\mathcal P,-m}$ denote the KDEs of the Gaussian-convolved particle distribution, encoder outputs, and leave-one-out particle distribution, respectively. In the revised paper, we will move its definition, the associated KDEs, and the particle update rule to Section 3, while retaining detailed derivations and implementation settings in the appendix. **Q2 & W3: Experimental Fairness and the Contribution of Denoising** We agree that using different lower-triangular priors makes it difficult to fairly assess the contribution of denoising. Therefore, we conduct controlled experiments under two settings: (1) neither method uses the lower-triangular prior; and (2) both methods use the same prior. All other settings remain unchanged. |Data|method|MCC ↑|SHD ↓| |:-|:-|-:|-:| |TimeNonDiag-chain| Baseline (no prior) | **0.718 ± 0.058** | **9.000 ± 0.000** | |TimeNonDiag-chain| LDMS (no prior) | 0.665 ± 0.030 | **9.000 ± 0.000** | |TimeNonDiag-triangular| Baseline (no prior) | 0.605 ± 0.030 | 33.200 ± 5.630 | |TimeNonDiag-triangular| LDMS (no prior) | **0.680 ± 0.029** | **31.600 ± 6.070** | **Q3: Empirical Analysis of Latent Representation Error** We calculate the Latent RMSE of the baseline and LDMS on synthetic datasets to measure the difference between the estimated and true latent variables. The results are shown in the following table. |Data|method|Latent RMSE ↓| |:-|:-|-:| |TimeNonDiag-chain| Baseline (no prior) | **0.747 ± 0.079** | |TimeNonDiag-chain| LDMS (no prior) | 0.818 ± 0.036 | |TimeNonDiag-triangular| Baseline (no prior) | 0.889 ± 0.034 | |TimeNonDiag-triangular| LDMS (no prior) | **0.799 ± 0.036** | **Q4: Runtime and Memory Usage** We will report the training time and peak memory consumption of the baseline and LDMS under the same hardware and experimental settings. We will also provide empirical computational costs to complement the theoretical complexity analysis of the particle updates in Appendix D.6. |Data|method|CPU Peak RSS (MB)| Time (s) | |:-|:-|-:|-:| |TimeNonDiag-chain| Baseline (no prior) | 2067.55 ± 0.47 | 991.06 ± 4.70 | |TimeNonDiag-chain| LDMS (no prior) | 2068.52 ± 0.46 | 1541.51 ± 6.81 | |TimeNonDiag-triangular| Baseline (no prior) | 2071.96 ± 1.41 | 956.49 ± 13.36 | |TimeNonDiag-triangular| LDMS (no prior) | 2071.24 ± 1.11 | 1517.46 ± 38.08 | We thank the reviewer again for identifying these issues. The revisions and additional experiments will clarify the provenance and novelty of our method, improve the accessibility of its technical description, and provide a more controlled and comprehensive evaluation. **References** [1] Nonparametric partial disentanglement via mechanism sparsity: Sparse actions, interventions and sparse temporal dependencies. JMLR, 2026.
Reviewer_XcH7OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper addresses the important problem of how noise poses a major challenge to causal representation learning. In temporal data, noise affects latent representations at successive time steps, making temporal dependencies harder to estimate and causal structures harder to recover. To address this challenge, they integrate our latent-space denoising module with an existing mechanism-sparsity method to form a joint learning framework, Latent Denoising with Mechanism Sparsity (LDMS). The framework uses free-energy-guided particle dynamics to refine the latent distribution and combines denoising regularization with variational reconstruction and sparse transition estimation to improve the representations used for temporal mechanism learning. Their theoretical analysis considers the effects of both latent states and auxiliary variables at the preceding time step on the current latent state.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper targets a fundamental challenge in temporal causal representation learning: recovering interpretable latent causal variables from noisy, high-dimensional observations while preserving the underlying temporal mechanisms. Combining latent-space denoising with mechanism sparsity is a potentially valuable direction because these components address different but related difficulties. Denoising may improve the reliability of learned representations, while sparsity regularization can constrain the space of admissible causal mechanisms. If the paper establishes that their interaction yields benefits beyond applying the two techniques independently, this would constitute a meaningful methodological contribution to causal representation learning.
  2. The emphasis on mechanism sparsity provides a promising inductive bias for recovering compact temporal causal structures rather than relying exclusively on reconstruction or prediction objectives. In combination with latent-space denoising, this could improve the stability of representations under noisy observations and reduce spurious temporal dependencies. Such properties would be consequential for practical applications involving complex time-series data, particularly where meaningful causal interpretation and robustness are important. The strength of this contribution ultimately depends on whether the manuscript demonstrates improved causal recovery rather than only better reconstruction or predictive accuracy.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The theoretical justification and methodological novelty require rigorous differentiation from existing temporal causal representation learning methods. A central concern is whether the integration of latent-space denoising and mechanism sparsity provides a genuinely new causal identification principle or primarily combines existing methodological components. Mechanism sparsity has already been investigated extensively in causal representation learning, and denoising-based regularization is also well established in representation learning. Therefore, the paper needs to establish precisely what new theoretical or methodological capability emerges from their combination.

  2. Robust experimental validation and isolation of the proposed components are essential to substantiate the claimed advantages. The effectiveness of the proposed framework should be evaluated beyond conventional reconstruction or prediction performance. In particular, causal representation quality, causal structure recovery, and robustness to observation noise are distinct evaluation objectives that should be assessed independently.

Questions for authors

Question 1: Theoretical identifiability and causal preservation — clarification request

What precise assumptions are required for the proposed latent-space denoising procedure to preserve the identifiability of the underlying temporal causal factors and mechanisms? Specifically, can the authors clarify whether denoising changes the conditional independence relationships or structural dependencies that are necessary for causal identification? It would also be important to explain how the proposed framework distinguishes observation noise from weak but genuine causal dependencies and what guarantees, if any, remain valid when mechanism sparsity assumptions are only approximately satisfied.

Question 2: Novelty and complementary contributions — clarification request

What is the fundamental methodological or theoretical advancement achieved by combining latent-space denoising with mechanism sparsity compared with existing sparsity-based temporal causal representation learning approaches? Can the authors identify the specific component or theoretical property that cannot be obtained using mechanism sparsity alone? In particular, what evidence establishes that the two components interact constructively rather than independently contributing standard regularization effects?

Question 3: Experimental evidence and robustness — clarification request

Do the submitted experiments separately quantify the contributions of latent-space denoising and mechanism sparsity to causal factor recovery and temporal structure identification? If so, which existing results demonstrate that their combination consistently improves causal recovery across different noise conditions and causal graph densities? Please also clarify whether the reported improvements persist when the true underlying causal mechanisms are moderately dense or when the assumed sparsity level differs from the ground truth.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Latent-Space Denoising for Temporal Causal Representation Learning with Mechanism Sparsity

We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments. We address the concerns regarding theoretical analysis, experimental validation, and the scope of applicability below.

Q1: Theoretical Identifiability and Causal Preservation

The theoretical guarantees rely on the identifiability conditions of the underlying mechanism-sparsity framework [1], together with finite-moment and exogenous transition-noise assumptions and regularity conditions on the mechanisms. Our analysis does not claim that denoising automatically preserves all conditional independence relationships. Instead, it establishes bounds on changes in mechanism strengths through the conditional Wasserstein representation error Δz\Delta_z.

In particular, Theorem 1 shows that the original sparse supports are preserved when the representation error is sufficiently small relative to the minimum nonzero mechanism strength. Thus, distinguishing weak genuine dependencies from noise requires sufficient signal separation; exact recovery of arbitrarily weak mechanisms is not guaranteed. Under approximate sparsity, the guarantees apply to sufficiently strong mechanisms rather than all potentially nonzero dependencies.

Q2&W1:Methodological Novelty and Theoretical Contributions

This work does not propose a new mechanism-sparsity principle. Instead, it introduces latent-space denoising based on free-energy-guided Wasserstein particle flows into the existing mechanism-sparsity framework, forming a joint framework for temporal causal representation learning under observation noise.

The key contribution lies in coupling latent distributional refinement with sparse mechanism estimation. We further establish perturbation bounds for mechanism strengths, sufficient conditions for sparse-support preservation, and consistency conditions for joint estimation. These results characterize how representation errors affect mechanism estimation and graph recovery, providing theoretical guarantees beyond the original mechanism-sparsity framework.

Q3&W2: Experimental Validation and Method Robustness

We agree with the reviewer that further experiments are needed to separate the contributions of the two components and evaluate the robustness of our method. To this end, we conduct controlled ablation studies under the same structural priors and training settings. We compare three settings: mechanism sparsity alone, latent-space denoising alone, and their combination. We conduct experiments on two datasets: TimeNonDiag-chain and TimeNonDiag-triangular. Each experiment is run five times, and the average MCC over the five runs is calculated. We then subtract the average MCC of the VAE baseline, which uses neither component, from the average MCC of each method. The results are shown in the following table.

DataVAE+LDBaseline (VAE+MS)LDMS (VAE+LD+MS)
TimeNonDiag-chain-0.038+0.081-0.032
TimeNonDiag-triangular+0.049+0.047+0.053

The two components show a positive combined effect on TimeNonDiag-triangular, suggesting their complementarity in learning dense lower-triangular graphs. In contrast, mechanism sparsity has a stronger effect on sparse graphs.

We evaluate LDMS under different noise levels and graph densities using MCC and SHD to measure latent representation and graph recovery, respectively. Results are reported as mean ± standard deviation.

edgemethodMCC ↑SHD ↓
10Baseline0.686 ± 0.0730.000 ± 0.000
10LDMS0.727 ± 0.0630.000 ± 0.000
32Baseline0.597 ± 0.01125.250 ± 2.990
32LDMS0.671 ± 0.02722.000 ± 7.120
55Baseline0.690 ± 0.05132.400 ± 12.840
55LDMS0.703 ± 0.04229.200 ± 9.440

LDMS achieves higher MCC across all three graph densities (10, 32, and 55 edges). It also achieves lower SHD for graphs with 32 and 55 edges, while both methods obtain zero SHD for graphs with 10 edges. These results demonstrate the effectiveness of LDMS across different graph densities.

Noise level (σ\sigma)methodMCC ↑SHD ↓
0.01Baseline0.665 ± 0.06432.000 ± 11.888
0.01LDMS0.615 ± 0.04629.500 ± 4.435
0.1Baseline0.607 ± 0.01137.000 ± 14.095
0.1LDMS0.620 ± 0.03431.000 ± 8.869
1.0Baseline0.165 ± 0.01850.000 ± 9.092
1.0LDMS0.178 ± 0.02157.000 ± 8.718

LDMS outperforms the baseline in both MCC and SHD at σ=0.1\sigma=0.1. It achieves lower SHD at σ=0.01\sigma=0.01 and higher MCC at σ=1.0\sigma=1.0. These results demonstrate the robustness of LDMS, particularly under moderate noise.

We sincerely thank the reviewer again for the constructive comments.

References

[1] Nonparametric partial disentanglement via mechanism sparsity: Sparse actions, interventions and sparse temporal dependencies. JMLR, 2026.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.