- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces PLACID, a controlled stochastic differential equation framework for causal structure discovery from irregularly sampled dynamical systems. The method separates structural drift from data-dependent control, using control-energy regularization and group sparsity to encourage interpretable drift dependencies. The authors establish theoretical connections between path-space KL divergence, least action, and structural recovery, including conditions under which accurate drift estimation implies graph recovery.
The framework is evaluated on Lorenz–96 and Glycolysis systems, with comparisons against SCOTCH, Neural Graphical Models, and deterministic alternatives. The results show moderate causal graph recovery, although the experiments do not establish a consistent advantage from stochastic diffusion or control. Additional ablations examine controller collapse, sparsity, and the relationship between prediction accuracy and structural recovery.
Critical strengths
-
Interesting theoretical treatment of structural recovery. I find the distinction between drift accuracy and causal structure recovery important. In particular, the counterexample showing that vanishing action can coexist with incorrect graph structure is useful. The analysis also clarifies the additional assumptions required for structural recovery, including occupation coverage, smoothness, and sufficient interaction strength.
-
Careful separation of prediction and structure learning. The experiments explicitly distinguish forecast accuracy, causal graph ranking, and sparsity. I appreciate the inclusion of deterministic and no-control comparisons, alongside the controller-capacity ablations. These results expose important limitations of controlled SDE formulations rather than assuming that adding stochasticity necessarily improves causal discovery.
Critical weaknesses
-
The main methodological contribution is not supported by clear empirical improvements. The central motivation is that stochastic dynamics and least-action control can improve structural discovery. However, the matched Lorenz–96 experiments show essentially identical graph recovery between the full controlled SDE (AUROC 0.7456), the no-control SDE (0.7541), and the deterministic comparator (0.7450). The no-control model also achieves substantially lower prediction error on Glycolysis. These results raise the question of whether the additional control and stochastic components are necessary, particularly given their computational complexity.
-
Causal graph recovery remains relatively weak, particularly in higher dimensions. While the reported AUROC values suggest some structural ranking ability, these improvements do not translate into reliable graph recovery. For Lorenz–96 with 50 variables, directed SHD reaches approximately 343–366, whereas an empty graph would have an SHD of 200 under the same inclusive-edge convention. Furthermore, the headline AUROC includes self-edges, which makes the results appear stronger than the off-diagonal evaluation. For example, Lorenz D10 AUROC decreases from 0.7456 to 0.6608 when self-edges are excluded. I would like to see stronger graph recovery before considering the approach effective for causal discovery.
-
The theoretical guarantees are disconnected from the implemented optimization. The main consistency result assumes a fixed posterior joint law, known diffusion, and sufficient occupation coverage. In contrast, the implemented method jointly learns the encoder, diffusion, and structural drift using endpoint consistency and control-energy penalties. The theoretical recovery results also concern functional drift derivatives, whereas the experiments evaluate first-layer weight norms. Consequently, the analysis does not establish consistency or identifiability for the actual estimator. This substantially limits the theoretical justification for the proposed methodology.
-
The experimental comparisons and irregular-sampling evaluation are insufficient. Although SCOTCH and NGM are included, several reported comparisons use different training protocols, while the local SCOTCH evaluation is incomplete, particularly at higher dimensions. This makes it difficult to assess whether PLACID offers meaningful improvements over existing stochastic causal discovery methods. Furthermore, irregular sampling is a central motivation, but the experiments provide limited systematic analysis of how recovery changes with observation gaps, variable-specific missingness, or sampling frequency. More controlled comparisons would strengthen the empirical conclusions.
-
Limited evidence of generalization and causal identifiability. The experiments primarily use simulated systems with known coordinates and fixed underlying graph structures. The learned latent coordinates are aligned using validation simulator states, which would generally be unavailable for an unknown physical system. Additionally, the exploratory DREAM3 experiments achieve AUROC close to random guessing, approximately 0.49–0.50. It therefore remains unclear whether the framework can recover meaningful causal relationships in more realistic, partially observed systems with unknown latent representations.
Questions for authors
See above.
Please join the author-reviewer discussion
Dear all reviewers,
Our author and reviewer discussion will end soon in 18 November (AOE). If you have not yet joined the discussion, now it is the time to start it. We highly appreciate your time on discussing and exchanging thoughts to keep our ICLR standards. Many thanks!
Bests,
Your AC