acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Enhanced Simulation Environment Based on Distribution Matching and Large Language Model-Guided Reinforcement Learning

Abstract

Autonomous driving simulation environments often suffer from systematic statistical drift during long-term closed-loop operation, where the behavior of background vehicles gradually deviates from real-world traffic statistics. Existing enhancement methods either rely on rule-based models with limited statistical fidelity or retain online large language model (LLM) calibration during simulation, which introduces prohibitive computational overhead for real-time multi-vehicle control. To alleviate the above limitations, this paper proposes Enhanced Simulation environment based on Distribution matching and Large language model Guided reinforcement learning (ESDLG), a two-stage simulation enhancement framework for background-vehicle policy learning. Rather than introducing a new divergence measure or a new reinforcement learning algorithm, ESDLG introduces χ²-divergence-based state occupancy matching and uses LLM-guided policy learning for long-term traffic simulation enhancement. In the first stage, inspired by state occupancy matching formulations, ESDLG introduces a χ²-divergence dual optimization module into PPO; PPO learning is designed to simulate and control vehicles after training, to provide a real-data-driven distribution-matching prior without requiring expert action labels. In the second stage, real trajectories are clustered into three distinct driving styles, and three style-specific PPO policies are fine-tuned using LLM-guided exploration. The LLM guidance is used only during training and distilled into lightweight policy networks; during deployment, the LLM is completely removed from the simulation loop. Experiments conducted in highway-env with HighD data show that ESDLG achieves balanced traffic-statistic fidelity, obtaining the best spacing MAPE and the second-best Hellinger distance for speed-distribution matching among the compared methods. ESDLG also preserves competitive coarse-grained driving style diversity while reducing the per-step inference time to 15.9 ms, corresponding to a 5,424× speedup over online LLM calibration. Additional evaluations on traffic density and style ratio further indicate that ESDLG remains robust under varying traffic densities and supports soft scenario-level controllability through policy assignment.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Autonomous driving, Simulation environment enhancement, Large language model, Reinforcement learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_BRKrOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces a LLM-based rl learning method for traffic simulation. It uses two stages: in Stage 1, the authors incorporate a x2-divergence state-occupancy matching module, inspired by SMODICE, into PPO. In Stage 2, HighD trajectories are clustered into three driving styles—Conservative, Moderate, and Aggressive—and the Stage-1 policy is copied into three style-specific PPO policies. An LLM provides high-level corrective actions only when speed-distribution or spacing deviations exceed thresholds; these actions are distilled into the PPO policies through an imitation loss. The method is tested on highD dataset.

Critical strengths
  1. The idea to combine Dice and PPO is interesting.
  2. The paper addresses a meaningful practical problem. Long-horizon distribution drift is an important issue for background traffic simulation.
  3. Using distribution similarity as constraint instead of the single action lable is appealing.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper assumes that llm decision distribution is similar with real human driver decision distribution. But this assumption is not validated.
  2. The paper validate its method on a single small highD dataset. Its scalability and transferability is unclear. Consider experimenting on more complex waymo or nuplan dataset.
  3. A lot of related works on traffic simulation are missing such as smart, smart-r1, DecompGAIL.
  4. The metric is too limited. More metrics on WOSAC can be included.
Questions for authors
  1. How many LLM queries are required to train each style policy, and what is the total training-time LLM cost?
  2. Which LLM is used in Stage 2, what is the exact prompt, and what are the trigger thresholds?
  3. Can the authors add a PPO + Stage-2 LLM fine-tuning baseline without Stage-1 DICE initialization? This seems essential for determining whether occupancy matching contributes to the final result.
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer BRKr

Thank you for the detailed review and for recognizing the importance of distribution drift and the potential of occupancy matching.

  1. Validity of LLM guidance. Thank you for questioning the relationship between LLM decisions and human driving. Using an LLM as a teacher does not establish that its decision distribution matches human behavior. We will make this distinction explicit and avoid treating human-like teacher behavior as a validated assumption. We plan to prioritize no-teacher and simpler-teacher controls, together with behavioral and safety measures, to assess the actual effect of guidance.

  2. Evaluation scope, metrics, and related work. Thank you for highlighting these limitations and suggesting SMART, SMART-R1, DecompGAIL, and WOSAC-related evaluation. The current highway-env/highD results do not establish urban-scenario transfer or broad competitiveness. We will improve the related-work discussion and prioritize held-out evaluation, interaction metrics, longer rollouts, and different learned-agent counts. We will examine compatible external baselines and the feasibility of more complex datasets, while clearly acknowledging unvalidated transfer claims.

  3. LLM configuration and training cost. Thank you for identifying these reproducibility requirements. Deployment without an LLM does not eliminate training-time teacher costs. We will explicitly document the model/version, complete prompt, target-style conditioning, trigger statistics and thresholds, checking frequency, and action parsing. We will also verify and report per-style query counts, retries, token usage, monetary or compute costs, and training-time overhead. These require concrete implementation records rather than a general efficiency statement.

  4. Stage-1 ablation. Thank you for proposing PPO followed by Stage 2 without occupancy-matched initialization. We agree that this is essential for isolating Stage 1’s contribution. We plan to prioritize this control using consistent Stage-2 settings and accounting for total training budgets. If the simpler initialization performs comparably, we will revise the necessity claim accordingly.

Thank the authors for the detailed reponse. My concerns are not addressed. I therefore keep my original score.

Reviewer_MCkrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes ESDLG, a traffic simulation enhancement framework based on distribution matching and LLM-guided reinforcement learning, aiming to mitigate statistical drift in long-term closed-loop simulation and the high computational cost of online LLM inference. The framework adopts a two-stage training strategy. First, χ²-divergence-based state occupancy matching is incorporated into PPO to improve the statistical consistency between simulated traffic and real-world data. Then, driving-style clustering and LLM guidance are employed to train style-specific policies, while the LLM is removed during deployment. Experiments conducted in highway-env using the HighD dataset demonstrate improved inter-vehicle spacing matching, competitive speed distribution matching, and significantly reduced inference latency.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses a practical problem in traffic simulation. The two-stage framework has a clear overall structure and combines traffic distribution matching with driving-style learning.

  2. The method achieves good spacing accuracy and much faster inference than the online LLM-based baseline. Removing the LLM during deployment makes the approach more suitable for real-time simulation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. I noticed that in the experimental comparisons, the authors discuss several recently proposed traffic simulation methods in the related work section, but in the actual experiments, they only conduct internal ablation-style comparisons and a comparison with one external method. Among the baselines selected by the authors, ESDLG does show certain advantages in performance and deployment efficiency, but these results do not convince me that ESDLG is competitive with recent traffic simulation methods.

  2. In addition, the authors' contribution combines existing techniques, including PPO + χ²-divergence-based distribution matching and LLM-guided policy learning. I would like to understand whether this combination represents a meaningful new integration mechanism and whether there is a necessary synergistic effect between the two stages. For example, if standard PPO is directly used for initialization, followed by the same LLM-guided training, could it also achieve good performance?

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors add comparisons with currently representative baseline methods? If direct comparisons are not possible due to unavailable code or differences in task settings, the authors should also discuss the specific reasons and limitations in detail.

  2. Could the authors sufficiently validate the effectiveness of each module and demonstrate the necessity of the two-stage integrated design?

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer MCkr

Thank you for the constructive review and for recognizing the practical motivation and deployment-efficiency benefit.

  1. Representative external baselines. Thank you for pointing out the limited comparisons. We agree that performance against the selected baselines does not establish competitiveness with recent traffic simulators. We will prioritize compatible representative methods and clarify differences in observations, action interfaces, training data, and rollout settings. Where a fair comparison is difficult, we will explain the specific obstacle and its implications rather than imply unsupported superiority.

  2. Contribution of the integration. Thank you for requesting a clearer explanation. Stage 1 is intended to improve population-level statistical consistency, while Stage 2 supports style-specific learning through training-time guidance. These complementary roles motivate the design, but do not themselves demonstrate synergy. We will clarify the information passed between stages, the objectives used during Stage 2, and the contribution beyond the individual existing techniques.

  3. Necessity of Stage 1 and individual modules. Thank you for proposing standard PPO followed by the same LLM-guided training. This is a key control for isolating the value of Stage-1 initialization. We plan to prioritize this comparison, alongside style-specific fine-tuning without LLM guidance, while accounting for training-budget differences. If the simpler variants perform comparably, we will narrow the necessity claim accordingly. We will distinguish the demonstrated deployment advantage from claims about simulation quality and module synergy.

Thank the authors for the detailed rebuttal. I therefore keep my original score of 2: weak rejection.

Reviewer_1BaROpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a framework called Enhanced Simulation environment based on Distribution matching and Large language model-Guided reinforcement learning (ESDLG), a two-stage framework for improving the realism and efficiency of traffic simulations. The first stage incorporates χ²-divergence-based state occupancy matching into PPO to align simulated traffic statistics with real-world data. The second stage uses LLM-guided reinforcement learning to train three driving-style-specific policies, allowing the simulator to generate diverse traffic behaviors without requiring LLM inference at deployment. Experiments are conducted with highway-env and the HighD dataset.

Critical strengths

This work taps into a practically useful problem and the motivation is clear, which I like. The experiments show there is some value in the proposed method (as shown in table 2). While I appreciate these results, I find the experiments are largely lacking the rigor and comparisons needed to rigorously establish the utility of the method.

Critical weaknesses

One of my major lines of concerns are with experimental results. I am not sure whether the evaluation really demonstrates realistic and robust closed-loop traffic simulation. The experiments are limited to a relatively simple highway-env setting alone, with 60-second episodes and only 12 RL-controlled vehicles, while the remaining vehicles follow IDM+MOBIL. There are many research that look at better traffic simulations (e.g., https://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.15677) and there are standard metrics that are often used (e.g., https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12032). The current work does not consider any of these. The evaluation focuses heavily on marginal speed and spacing distributions, which do not necessarily capture realistic driving interactions. Two simulators can match these statistics while producing very different lane-changing behavior, collision rates, braking patterns, or time-to-collision distributions. Evaluating these interaction-level and safety-related metrics against real traffic data would provide much stronger evidence of realism. Since the main motivation is to address statistical drift during long-term closed-loop simulation, I think evaluating only 60-second episodes also needs more testing. A particularly important experiment would be to run different simulation durations to compare how the speed, spacing, and driving-style distributions evolve over time for all baselines. I would also like to see experiments with a larger fraction of learned background vehicles, ideally including fully learned traffic, to determine whether the method remains stable when interactions between learned policies become more frequent (also since many state of the art methods on traffic simulations can control more than 12 vehicles). The method is trained and evaluated using the same HighD dataset, and the paper does not clearly establish generalization to independent recordings or traffic environments. Testing on held-out recording locations or another trajectory dataset would be important to show that the learned policies generalize beyond the particular traffic statistics used during training.

My other line of concerns are that the experiments do not sufficiently isolate the contributions of the two proposed stages, especially the LLM guidance. The paper compares ESDLG against PPO and DICE, but these comparisons do not establish whether the LLM is actually necessary for the improvements. In particular, the DICE baseline performs worse than standard PPO on speed distribution matching (0.3470 vs. 0.3258), while the full method only slightly improves over PPO (0.3226). This makes it difficult to understand how much of the final performance comes from distribution matching, LLM supervision, or simply additional fine-tuning with separate style-specific policies. I think a more complete ablation is necessary, including PPO with style-specific fine-tuning but no LLM, PPO with LLM guidance but without distribution matching, and the full method with LLM guidance replaced by a simpler heuristic or rule-based teacher. These comparisons would help determine whether the proposed combination is actually needed or whether similar results could be achieved using a much simpler training procedure. It would also be useful to compare methods under matched training budgets, since the full method receives additional training beyond the Stage 1 baseline.

The presentation of the paper could also be improved to enhance clarity and readability, as I often found myself revisiting different sections to understand the proposed approach and its contributions. Overall, I believe the work would benefit from more rigorous experimental evaluation and stronger empirical evidence before it is ready for publication.

Questions for authors
  1. Since all three driving-style policies are initialized from the same PPO checkpoint and receive LLM guidance triggered by the same traffic-level distribution metrics, what ensures that the policies learn genuinely distinct driving behaviors rather than converging toward similar actions? Is the LLM guidance explicitly conditioned on the target driving style?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 1BaR

Thank you for the careful review and for recognizing the practical importance of the problem.

  1. Evaluation scope and realism. Thank you for highlighting the limitations of marginal speed and spacing metrics. We agree that these statistics alone cannot establish realistic interactions or long-horizon stability. The current evidence is limited to the evaluated highway setting and rollout duration. We will clarify this scope and prioritize interaction-level metrics, longer rollouts, different learned-vehicle fractions, and evaluation on independent recordings. We will also examine the suggested references to improve the evaluation protocol.

  2. Ablations and training fairness. Thank you for identifying the missing controls. The small speed-matching improvement over PPO does not, by itself, establish the contribution of either stage. We plan to prioritize PPO followed by Stage-2 guidance without Stage 1, style-specific fine-tuning without an LLM, and a simpler teacher alternative. These comparisons should account for total training budgets and teacher overhead. We will avoid claiming that the LLM or Stage-1 initialization is necessary without supporting evidence.

  3. Driving-style differentiation. Thank you for this important question. Shared initialization and a common triggering criterion do not themselves guarantee distinct styles. The relevant distinction is between when guidance is requested and what style-dependent information guides learning. We will explicitly document whether and how the target style enters the prompt and training objective, and prioritize quantitative comparisons of the resulting behaviors.

  4. Presentation. Thank you for pointing out the readability issues. We will clarify the relationship between occupancy matching, guidance triggering, and policy distillation, and make the experimental assumptions and limitations more explicit.

Reviewer_1BaROpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Response

I thank the authors for laying out the plan for addressing my concerns. I will keep my score for now.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.