acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Beyond Shared Plans: Alignment-Constrained Tree Search for Embodied Collaboration

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Large language model (LLM) based embodied agents increasingly use shared plans to coordinate long-horizon collaboration. However, a coherent plan does not guarantee coherent execution: agents may progress at different rates, causing ongoing work to be reassigned, completed work to remain active, or new actions to conflict with the current physical state. We study this planning–execution mismatch as the cognition–execution gap and propose Alignment-Constrained Tree Search (ACTS). ACTS connects collaborative planning with ongoing embodied execution through three steps: (1) Planning with Persistent Responsibilities keeps each agent’s active assignment, grounded target, and execution stage across planning calls; (2) Search with Responsibility Constraints admits only continuations supported by current execution evidence before reflection and expansion, while using unmet conditions to revise rejected proposals; and (3) Updating Responsibilities after Execution uses observed progress and confirmed effects to close completed work, preserve compatible ongoing work, and update the state for subsequent planning. Together, ACTS turns repeated plan revision into a closed planning–execution loop in which collaborative search remains consistent with physical progress. Experiments on TDW-MAT and C-WAH validate ACTS’s planning–execution alignment and demonstrate competitive task performance on both benchmarks.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
embodied multi-agent collaboration, collaborative planning, large language model agents, cognition-execution alignment, collaborative tree search

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 5 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_yWw7OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the mismatch between shared plans and actual execution progress in embodied multi-agent collaboration, and formulates it as the cognition–execution gap. The authors propose Alignment-Constrained Tree Search (ACTS), which maintains the task responsibility states of agents throughout the process, filters feasible candidates using current execution evidence before tree search, and dynamically updates responsibility states based on execution outcomes, thereby preserving consistency between planning and physical execution.

Critical strengths
  1. Persistent responsibility establishes a clear and meaningful intermediate state between shared planning and continuous physical execution.
  2. The paper provides a rigorous distinction between planning evidence and execution evidence.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The central concept of the paper is the cognition–execution gap, referring to inconsistencies between planning and actual execution. However, the paper does not quantify how many genuine DD cases occur in CoTS or how much ACTS reduces these cases. The 145 proposals reported in Table 3 are candidates filtered before execution, rather than actual execution failures that have already occurred.
  2. ACTS does not only modify the tree search process but also provides the planner with additional information, including current responsibility, ownership, execution progress, and closure information. Although the authors design two controls, Evidence-text and Structured context, they are not evaluated on the full benchmarks, which weakens the overall persuasiveness of the method.
  3. Compared with CoTS, ACTS mainly introduces execution state tracking, rule-based checking before search, and state updates after execution. These components are useful, but they appear more like additional execution constraints built on top of the existing CoTS framework, making the novelty of the proposed approach relatively limited.
Questions for authors

See Weaknesses

Reviewer_UtJgOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

ACTS extends collaborative tree search with persistent responsibilities, evidence-based admission, proposal revision, and execution-driven updates. Experiments on TDW-MAT and C-WAH examine whether these mechanisms keep shared plans aligned with ongoing work.

Critical strengths
  • The design addresses a concrete coordination failure: replanning can overwrite progressing work or retain completed assignments. Explicit responsibility identity and effect-based closure provide a coherent response.

  • With GPT-4, TDW-MAT transport improves over CoTS from 91.5% to 95.0% with oracle perception and from 82.5% to 85.5% without it. C-WAH and the additional execution audits broaden the evidence.

Critical weaknesses
  • The controls do not fully isolate responsibility maintenance from execution information, admission, and recovery. Table 15 identifies CoTS-S as a shared-executor control, but leaves some shared mechanisms implicit; a matched removal of responsibility updates is missing.

  • Mechanism evidence is narrow. The 145-proposal audit comes from one execution, and fixed-context coverage has no independent gold labels. In Table 18, early gating alone reaches 50% transport versus 70% for the post-search guard and 100% for CoTS. This illustrates component interaction, not a general advantage of gating.

Overall assessment: Weak rejection. The practical design and task gains are promising, but the distinct contribution of responsibility maintenance remains insufficiently isolated.

Questions for authors
  • Clarification: Which information, activation, recovery, and update mechanisms are shared by the Table 15 variants? How does the broader eligibility checker relate to the immediate-step admission rule?

  • Evidence: Can matched controls separately toggle admission and responsibility updates, with variability and executed-gap rates? Please also show whether feasible ongoing work can be reassigned for efficiency under the stated supersession rule.

Reviewer_LUt8OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies inconsistencies between shared plans and ongoing execution in embodied multi-agent collaboration. It proposes Alignment-Constrained Tree Search (ACTS), which tracks each agent’s active responsibilities, checks candidate plans against current execution evidence before reflection and expansion, and uses unmet conditions to revise rejected proposals. Execution feedback then updates the corresponding responsibilities while preserving compatible ongoing work.

Critical strengths

1.The paper addresses a practical issue in multi-agent collaboration: keeping shared plans consistent with ongoing physical execution.

2.The framework connects planning, responsibility tracking, and execution feedback in a coherent loop, with explicit rules for retaining and closing assignments.

3.The evaluation covers two embodied collaboration benchmarks and includes mechanism analyses alongside task-level results.

Critical weaknesses

1.CoTS-S shares the executor but keeps the original plan-update logic. This comparison does not separate the benefit of ACTS’s search mechanism from the benefit of better execution-state tracking.

2.The admission-placement experiment measures invalid candidates using the same checker that filters them. Getting zero checker-invalid candidates after filtering does not establish better execution reliability, especially since the checker also includes formatting and later-step constraints.

3.The efficiency benefit is questionable. In the Stuff revision ablation, ACTS saves only 24 execution frames while increasing token usage from 572,759 to 825,926.

4.Evaluation is limited to GPT-4 and GPT-3.5-Turbo, with no exact model versions. The paper does not establish whether the gains persist with stronger backbones.

Questions for authors

1.What happens if CoTS receives ACTS’s responsibility records and execution-update rules, while keeping its original search? CoTS-S does not appear to test this configuration.

2.In Table 18, the raw tree gate evaluates no checker-invalid ordinary candidates but delivers only 5/10 objects. What specifically prevents the other five deliveries, and which ACTS component resolves those failures?

3.Section C.2 checks immediate assignments, whereas the checker in D.7 also considers later steps and formatting. Which checks are actually used at ACTS’s tree-admission stage? Can a candidate with a supported immediate action still be rejected because of its later steps?

4.In Table 20’s Stuff pair, does the 24-frame saving still translate into faster completion once LLM response time is included? What accounts for the additional 38 model requests?

Reviewer_v28UOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes ACTS, which extends CoTS to be execution-aware for embodied multi-agent collaboration. Each agent keeps a persistent set of responsibilities. Before reflecting and expanding, ACTS checks the candidate assignments, fixes rejected ones based on what conditions weren’t met, and updates responsibilities as execution goes on. On TDW-MAT and C-WAH it performs competitively.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper tackles a real coordination issue: when replanning, you want to keep the work that’s still useful and drop assignments that are already done.

  2. The evaluation covers both oracle and non-oracle perception, both visual and symbolic observations, and the authors ran the locally evaluated methods three times each.

Critical weaknesses
  1. ACTS closely follows CoTS [1]: it inherits CoTS’s planner–critic tree search, persistent plans, and execution-dependent scoring, and its main addition is per-assignment state tracking with programmatic admission/update rules. That difference is meaningful, but the paper has no baseline that applies the same responsibility records and revision logic to a simpler planner, so it is unclear whether the gains come from the search-specific design or from the bookkeeping alone.

  2. The reproduced CoTS baseline does not match the original paper [1]: on C-WAH symbolic, CoTS reports 49 steps in [1] but 55 here, while ACTS achieves 50. Thus ACTS improves over the reproduced baseline but remains slightly worse than the published CoTS result, and the discrepancy should be explained.

  3. The benefit of checking candidates before reflection is not established. In Tab. 18, the raw tree gate lowers TR from 70% to 50% and raises LLM requests from 254 to 319 relative to the post-search guard. Full ACTS does better, but it also adds proposal revision and responsibility updates, so the gain cannot be attributed to early admission.

reference

[1] Collaborative Tree Search for Enhancing Embodied Multi-Agent Collaboration. CVPR 2025

Questions for authors
  1. Does ACTS still outperform single-branch CoTS when both use the same responsibility records, execution checks, and revision logic under a matched token budget? This would separate the benefit of tree search from that of the added execution controller.

  2. Why does the reproduced CoTS require 55 steps on C-WAH symbolic when CoTS reports 49, while ACTS achieves 50? Please explain any differences in model version, search budget, or implementation, and clarify whether ACTS’s gains hold under matched settings.

  3. Does early admission help the complete ACTS system? In Tab. 18, the raw tree gate lowers TR from 70% to 50% and increases requests from 254 to 319. Please compare full ACTS with a variant that checks candidates after reflection while keeping revision and responsibility updates unchanged, and report both task performance and total token cost.

Reviewer_tcQ5OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Alignment-Constrained Tree Search (ACTS), which aims to better coordinate long-horizon collaboration for embodied agents. It takes the asynchronous state of agents in collaboration into consideration and defines responsibility to track the individual state. The workflow includes three steps built around responsibility: planning with persistent responsibilities, search with responsibility constraints, and updating responsibilities after execution. This framework incorporates plan revision with the actual execution state. Experiments on TDW-MAT and C-WAH show better performance than previous methods such as CoTS.

Critical strengths

This paper proposes a clear concept of responsibility and uses it consistently throughout the workflow for better coordination. This responsibility is used for planning aligned with actual physical state and tree search with requirement constraints, and is updated through the execution feedback. This provides a clear structure to track the task state, align planning with execution progress, thus benefiting the overall collaboration.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The overall methodological novelty is limited. ACTS is built upon the previous idea of CoTS with additional responsibility component for tracking the physical state, guiding tree search, and informing plan making. The contribution is useful but somewhat incremental.
  2. The experimental evidence is unclear. (1) The empirical results are mixed. On TDW-MAT with GPT-3.5, ACTS does not establish an advantage over CaPo. On symbolic setting of C-WAH with GPT-4, ACTS loses against PCE. (2) The paper proposes a formal definition of four cognition–execution interfaces. However there lacks a comprehensive and quantitative evaluation of ACTS and baselines on the gap rates. (3) The experiments use GPT-4 and GPT-3.5-Turbo, following previous work. However, as the capability of LLMs advances, it remains unknown whether benefits from this framework would diminish provided the LLM agents are given sufficient context. (4) Following previous work, the evaluation is restricted to two agents. It remains unclear how this framework scales to settings with more agents.
Questions for authors
  1. Could you report the rate of cognition-execution gap of ACTS and other baselines?
  2. Could you add additional experiments using frontier models such as GPT-6.1-sol and compare with the performance of other methods with sufficient information, especially CoTS with a clear execution-status feedback?
  3. How does the framework extend to agents more than two?
  4. With GPT-4, non-oracle setting on TDW-MAT, the paper reports "the overall gain is driven more strongly by Stuff". What do you think causes the discrepancy of performance between different task categories?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.