- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the problem of personalized bidding strategies in online advertising auto-bidding and proposes the ADAPT framework. The core ideas include: (1) a two-stage training paradigm — in Stage 1, static and dynamic advertiser profiles are extracted from an advertiser memory bank via contrastive learning; in Stage 2, the dynamic profile is disentangled into a “common profile” and a “private profile” through a correlation loss, with all three profiles jointly conditioning the bidding decision; (2) Training-free Adaptation — for new advertisers, zero-shot cold start is achieved using the common profile, while for existing advertisers, profiles are updated online via exponential moving average (EMA) without retraining. On the real-world Alibaba AuctionNet dataset, ADAPT outperforms baselines including USCB, BCQ, CQL, IQL, DiffBid, DT, CDT, DT-score, and GAS under various budget settings.
Critical strengths
1.Practical significance of the problem setting. Auto-bidding is a core component of advertising systems. Introducing advertiser profiles into auto-bidding and addressing the challenges of their construction and utilization represents a research direction with genuine practical value. 2.Reasonable engineering consideration in training-adaptation decoupling. Decoupling model training from online profile updates and employing a training-free approach (EMA + common profile distillation) for online adaptation aligns well with industry needs for low maintenance costs. 3.Comprehensive experiments. The paper compares nine baseline methods on a real-world dataset and conducts multiple ablation studies, including profile effectiveness, disentanglement effectiveness, zero-shot cold start, and training-free updates. The appendix also includes hyperparameter sensitivity analysis and profile visualization.
Critical weaknesses
1.The fusion mechanism of the three profiles in Stage 2 is not clearly described. How do the static profile, common profile, and private profile interact with the Decision Transformer? Is it through concatenation, cross-attention, or another mechanism? Figure 1 shows a Cross Attention Layer, but the main text lacks corresponding formulas and dimension specifications.
2.Missing comparison with recent generative auto-bidding methods. The references mention LBM (Li et al., 2026, WWW), but this work is not included in the baseline comparisons. Given that LBM is a recent method combining large models with auto-bidding, the lack of comparison with it weakens the experimental persuasiveness.
3.CPA constraint satisfaction is not reported. The core constraint in auto-bidding is CPA (Cost Per Acquisition), yet the experimental metrics only report Score and Conversion, without reporting the CPA constraint satisfaction rate or Budget Consumption Rate. This makes the assessment of practical effectiveness incomplete.
4.The average cosine similarity of the common profile is as high as 0.9027 (Table 9), which may actually indicate insufficient disentanglement. If the common profiles of all advertisers are nearly identical, the role of the “common profile” may degenerate to a shared bias term, contributing little to personalized decision-making. The authors should further discuss this phenomenon and analyze the mutual information between common and private profiles to quantitatively demonstrate the disentanglement effect.
Questions for authors
1.Please provide the precise mathematical definition of the correlation loss L_cor, and explain how its gradient is backpropagated.
2.How do the methods perform in terms of CPA constraint satisfaction rate and budget consumption rate?
3.Does the average common profile similarity of 0.9027 indicate insufficient disentanglement? Please further analyze this from the mutual information perspective.
4.Why was a 16-dimensional state and 1-dimensional action space chosen? Were larger dimensions attempted?
We are pleased that our clarifications and additional experiments have helped address your concerns, and we sincerely appreciate your continued positive assessment. In particular, thank you for recognizing the genuine practical value of introducing advertiser profiles into personalized auto-bidding, the industry-aligned, low-maintenance design that decouples model training from training-free profile adaptation, and the comprehensive experimental evaluation, including extensive baseline comparisons, component ablations, zero-shot cold start, and training-free updates. Together, these strengths highlight ADAPT’s value in supporting personalized bidding and continued advertiser adaptation without advertiser-specific retraining. Your constructive feedback has helped us clarify the methodology and strengthen the empirical evidence in the revised manuscript.