acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Skill Cleanliness: Diagnosing and Restoring Execution Recoverability in Agent Skills

Abstract

Skills provide language-model agents with reusable knowledge and operating procedures. Yet an agent can fail even when a Skill contains correct knowledge sufficient to solve the task. We introduce Skill Uncleanliness to describe organizational barriers that make task-relevant knowledge difficult to extract or available knowledge difficult to turn into executable actions. To diagnose these barriers, we propose Skill Cleanliness Score (SCS), which evaluates how knowledge can be accessed and used for a particular task and executor, and localizes defects that obstruct execution. We further propose Verified Skill Restoration (VSR), which uses the diagnosis to expose relevant evidence and make execution relations explicit while retaining their source support, intervening only when the repair has verifiable grounding. Experiments across task environments and model families show that targeted restoration can improve task success. On ScienceWorld, VSR improves success by 4.8–9.3 percentage points over a raw demonstration overlay with the same execution gate across seven executors from four model families. On ALFWorld, observation-driven progress restoration substantially improves execution by smaller models.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
large language models, skills

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_92nFOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies two problems in using existing agent skills: extracting task-relevant knowledge and converting the available knowledge into executable actions. It introduces Skill Uncleanliness to describe organizational barriers, Skill Cleanliness Score (SCS) to diagnose them across Relevance, Dependency, Grounding, and Progress, and Verified Skill Restoration (VSR) to apply targeted repairs with source-support and structural checks. Experiments across multiple environments and model families show that targeted skill restoration can improve task success, including gains of 4.8–9.3 percentage points over raw demonstration overlays on ScienceWorld and substantial improvements for smaller models on ALFWorld.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses a practical problem: helping agents make better use of knowledge already available in existing skills. It illustrates the problem through concrete examples and introduces four clear diagnostic dimensions to characterize barriers between available knowledge and executable actions.
  2. The experiments provide empirical evidence that targeted skill restoration can improve task success. On ScienceWorld, it consistently outperforms raw demonstration overlays across seven executors from four model families. ALFWorld also shows gains from progress restoration across all three evaluated model sizes.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper presents SCS and VSR largely through concepts and formal conditions, with insufficient detail on how key steps are implemented and connected. In particular, semantic parsing and scoring procedures, the respective roles of LLMs and deterministic rules, and how diagnostic outputs guide concrete repairs are not clearly specified in the main text.
  2. The diagnostic validity of SCS remains insufficiently established, and the theoretical analysis does not link its scores to actual execution recoverability. The main experiments primarily demonstrate the effectiveness of specific repairs. Although controlled defect-detection and routing results are reported, evidence remains limited that SCS reliably identifies execution barriers or that SCS-based repair selection provides consistent gains over always applying the same repair strategy under matched execution settings.
Questions for authors
  1. Please describe how each stage of the method is implemented. Which steps in semantic parsing, SCS computation, defect localization, repair generation, and verification are performed by LLMs, and which use deterministic rules? What information is passed between these stages, and how do the diagnostic outputs determine the repair operations?
  2. What motivates the SCS scoring rules and weights, and how do these metrics relate to the conditional recovery probabilities in the theoretical analysis? Beyond distinguishing predefined Clean/Dirty and Static/State conditions, is there evidence that SCS accurately identifies execution barriers in natural skills and predicts the benefit of corresponding repairs?
  3. Recent work such as SkillTracer (Li et al., 2026) and SkillRevise (Liu et al., 2026) already uses execution evidence to diagnose skill failures and guide targeted revisions. How does SCS/VSR differ from these approaches in its diagnostic evidence, repair mechanisms, and validation criteria? What evidence from the current experiments supports these advantages, taking differences in execution feedback and computational budgets into account? [1] Yuyang Li, Yiran Dou, Jie-Jing Shao, Yueming Lyu, Ivor Tsang, and Haiyan Yin. SkillTracer: Structural failure attribution and refinement of agentic skills in long-horizon web tasks. In Proceedings of the 32nd ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining, 2026. [2] Yuxuan Liu, Zhaochen Su, Lingyun Xie, Yuhao Zhang, Qing Zong, Jiahe Guo, Zhongwei Xie, Yiyan Ji, Yauwai Yim, Hongyu Luo, Xiyu Ren, Chenyu Ruan, Haoran Li, and Yangqiu Song. SkillRevise: Improving LLM-authored agent skills via trace-conditioned skill revision. Findings of EMNLP, 2026.
  4. Which components primarily account for the gains on ALFWorld? Table 3 already includes static-representation and initial-token-matched controls, but State simultaneously introduces progress updates, executable-step guidance, and safeguards against repeated actions. Can the contributions of these runtime components be further distinguished, and can the role of SCS-based selection be explained?
  5. What measurable reliability benefits does semantic verification provide? Figure 4(b) already reports configurations involving structural verification and semantic auditing, but acceptance coverage and iterative repair settings also vary. With the same candidates and repair budget, can the authors show what additional errors semantic verification identifies and how accepting or rejecting these candidates affects execution outcomes?
  6. How can failures caused by organizational barriers be distinguished from those caused by missing or incorrect knowledge? For natural skills, how can their knowledge be independently confirmed to be correct and sufficient to complete the task? Please explain how the evaluation distinguishes these two types of failure and thereby defines the scope of the execution-recoverability explanation.
4 comments

W1 — How are SCS/VSR implemented, and how do the stages pass information?

Response. The pipeline is LLM semantic extraction → deterministic SCS scoring → typed repair → verified deployment.

StageInput → outputImplementation
Semantic parsing and normalizationTask + Skill → source-linked obligations, dependencies, parameters, and checkpointsLLM extraction; code checks formats, span references, and relation endpoints
SCS diagnosisDiagnostic graph → R/D/G/P scores and defect certificatesDeterministic scoring, frozen thresholds, and executor capability gates
Typed repairDefect certificate → candidate overlay/ContractDeterministic rendering or LLM compilation
Verification and deploymentCandidate + original source → accept, revise, or source fallbackStructural and provenance checks; semantic auditing where configured
Online executionContract + environment observations → actions, progress, and ready stepsLLM selects actions; code updates the execution frontier and applies guards

Type mapping: Relevance → evidence selection; Dependency → producer–consumer links; Grounding → parameter binding; Progress → observation-driven progress. The paper reports that 269/269 matched-type dispatches pass and 807/807 wrong-type dispatches are rejected (Appendix G.4).

W2 — Does SCS diagnosis and selective repair actually help?

Response. With shared candidate repairs, SCS exceeds a length heuristic by 6.56 pp (95% CI [+0.26, +12.79]); it is 2.25 pp below Always, while reducing harmful interventions by 27% and candidate-compilation tokens by about 27.1%. Its value is mainly an accuracy–risk–cost trade-off.

Setup. MedCalc under the paper's protocol, with 1,600 new cases (40 calculators); candidates are fixed, comparing No repair, Always, a length heuristic, and the SCS Router.

MedCalc: Qwen3.5-4B, Full source, 1,600 cases

PolicyAccuracyIncorrect→CorrectCorrect→IncorrectCandidate-generation tokens (deployment policy)
No repair735/1600 (45.94%)——0
Always948/1600 (59.25%)2978431.08M
Length heuristic807/1600 (50.44%)1154331.08M
SCS Router912/1600 (57.00%)2386122.67M

Full/Selected mixture: 1,600 cases × 2 representations = 3,200 inputs per model.

ModelNo repairAlwaysSCS RouterRouter − No repairRepair decisions / deployed
4B52.6%59.3%58.1%+5.5 pp36.6% / 34.2%
9B64.8%68.2%67.5%+2.7 pp36.6% / 34.2%
27B78.0%78.1%78.0%+0.0 pp0.0% / 0.0%

Q1 — How does diagnosis determine the concrete repair?

Response. SCS outputs source-linked defect certificates. Relevance selects the relevant evidence; Dependency makes producer→consumer links explicit; Grounding binds and disambiguates parameters; Progress maintains completion state and ready steps from environment observations. Candidates are deployed after source, structural, and (where applicable) semantic checks, and otherwise fall back to the source.

Q2 — How do SCS scores and weights relate to the theoretical recovery probabilities?

Response. SCS measures the structural recovery burden of executable relations; it does not directly estimate the conditional recovery probabilities in the theory.

DimensionScoring rule
R · RelevanceHarmonic mean of obligation coverage and relevant evidence precision
D · DependencyInverse recovery depth of required dependencies
G · GroundingInverse of the number of source-supported candidate bindings
P · ProgressStep checks, termination, online state, and repeat guards

The overall score is a weighted geometric mean over applicable dimensions (equal weights by default). Within Progress, weights are 0.40 step, 0.25 termination, 0.25 online state, and 0.10 guard; on 24 ALFWorld diagnostic manifests, ±20% weight perturbations leave every typed dispatch decision unchanged. The scores are not numerically calibrated to the theoretical probabilities (Appendix M).

Q3 — Differences from SkillTracer/SkillRevise and budget control

Response. SkillTracer/SkillRevise focus on revision from trajectories and execution feedback; SCS/VSR diagnoses the source Skill and task and restores dependency, binding, and progress relations.

Setup. ALFWorld, 128 tasks, Qwen3.5-9B; with the same execution budget we compare one-shot rewriting, trajectory-conditioned revision, and VSR Full State.

MethodSuccessOnline tokensRewriting tokensFeedback-trajectory tokens
One-shot generic rewrite61/128 (47.7%)30.870M0.041M0
Trajectory-conditioned revision70/128 (54.7%)29.564M0.230M32.545M
VSR Full State110/128 (85.9%)21.491M00

Full State improves over the two baselines by +38.28 pp (95% CI [+29.69, +46.88]) and +31.25 pp (95% CI [+22.66, +40.62]).

Q4 — Which online components account for the ALFWorld gains?

Response. With Guard, retry, and run budget fixed, the main gains come from observation-driven search memory and executable-step guidance.

Setup. ALFWorld, 128 tasks per model, Qwen3.5-4B/9B; Guard, retry, and budget are fixed while completion progress, search memory, and step guidance are ablated.

ModelStatic + GuardCompletion progress + GuardProgress + search memory + GuardFull State + Guard
4B74/128 (57.8%)73/128 (57.0%)94/128 (73.4%)108/128 (84.4%)†
9B67/128 (52.3%)72/128 (56.3%)95/128 (74.2%)110/128 (85.9%)
Change4B9B
Static → progress + search memory+15.63 pp+21.88 pp
Completion progress only → + search memory+16.41 pp (CI [+7.81, +25.00])+17.97 pp (CI [+9.38, +26.56])
Static → completion progress only−0.78 pp+3.91 pp

Additional controls (9B, 128 tasks): completion progress + step guidance + Guard: 82/128; Full State without Guard: 84/128.

† 4B Full State is the paper's State Machine run recounted on the same 128 tasks.

Q5 — What protection does semantic verification provide with the same candidates and budget?

Response. On the additional AppWorld tasks, strict verification outperforms structure-only verification; across all 585 tasks the gain is +3.1 pp (p = 0.0079). Human review further separates acceptance correctness from execution success.

Setup. AppWorld, the paper's 417 tasks plus 168 new tasks, 585 in total; with the same candidates and budget we compare strict semantic verification and structure-only verification.

MetricOriginal 417Additional 168Combined 585
Strict verification success96/417 (23.0%)68/168 (40.5%)164/585 (28.0%)
Structure-only success100/417 (24.0%)46/168 (27.4%)146/585 (25.0%)
Strict − structure-only−1.0 pp+13.1 pp+3.1 pp
Paired wins/losses (strict vs. structure-only)2/628/630/12
Exact McNemar p0.2890.000200.0079

For the 100 disputed contracts accepted by the original verifier and rejected by the independent auditor, a three-expert majority judges 98/100 acceptable and 2/100 unacceptable (unanimous on 97/100; Fleiss' κ = 0.66). Of the 48 candidates additionally admitted by structure-only checks on the original 417 tasks, humans judge 40 unacceptable and 8 acceptable. The two samples analyze, respectively, the auditor disagreement and the filtering effect of semantic checks on structurally valid candidates.

Q6 — Distinguishing organizational barriers from missing or incorrect knowledge

Response. We first determine whether the Skill's knowledge is correct and sufficient for the task. If execution improves when the knowledge content is fixed and only the organization of dependencies changes, this supports an organizational-barrier explanation; if a necessary fact is missing or a rule is incorrect, the failure is attributed to knowledge; when evidence is insufficient, the cause is marked undetermined.

Setup. 64 closed-graph tasks; with knowledge and token count held fixed, we compare shuffled and dependency-ordered relations, and simulate missing knowledge by deleting a key fact.

ConditionSuccess
Shuffled relations19/64 (29.7%)
Dependency-ordered29/64 (45.3%)
Gain from organizational repair+15.63 pp (95% CI [+4.69, +26.56])

A symbolic solver confirms that deleting the terminal fact makes the answer non-unique, separating organizational barriers from missing knowledge in this construction.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Looking Forward to Your Feedback (Reviewer 92nF)

Dear Reviewer 92nF, thank you again for your suggestions on the implementation of SCS and VSR, the diagnostic validity of SCS on natural skills, and the roles of runtime guidance and semantic verification. We would be grateful for your thoughts on whether our additional experiments and clarifications answer your questions. If you feel we have addressed your concerns, we would greatly appreciate it if you would consider raising your rating accordingly. We look forward to hearing from you.

Reviewer_o1B7OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies organizational barriers that prevent an agent from executing a skill even when its knowledge is correct and task-sufficient. Skill Cleanliness Score (SCS) diagnoses Relevance, Dependency, Grounding, and Progress defects. Verified Skill Restoration (VSR) then applies source-supported evidence selection, task binding, dependency repair, or an online state representation, retaining the source when checks fail. Evaluation includes MedCalc, controlled SRA, ScienceWorld, ALFWorld, and AppWorld, with supplementary natural-skill studies, negative results, and auditor-agreement analyses.

Critical strengths
  1. Recovering executable relations from available knowledge is a useful perspective. Separating knowledge availability from an executor's ability to recover dependencies, parameters, and progress helps characterize distinct sources of failure. Source preservation, explicit provenance, and fallback make interventions inspectable. The ScienceWorld task-binding example clearly connects a diagnosed mismatch to a concrete repair (Section 3; Table 7).

  2. The evaluation is broad and includes targeted paired controls. ScienceWorld compares Raw Overlay and VSR under a shared source library and execution gate across seven executors, reporting gains of 4.8–9.3 percentage points. ALFWorld and AppWorld include static representations, online state, and initial-token-matched controls. Fallback outcomes remain in the reported evaluations, and the paper reports paired statistics as well as negative natural-skill results and auditor disagreements. These results support the utility of some representation repairs and make their limitations inspectable (Tables 2–6; Appendices C and E–H).

Critical weaknesses
  1. Diagnostic validity on natural skills is not sufficiently established. High detection rates on controlled Clean/Dirty and Static/State constructions do not directly establish that SCS identifies useful repairs in naturally occurring skills, since those constructions explicitly instantiate the targeted defects. In Appendix H, frozen routing changes natural-SRA accuracy by −0.19 percentage points with an interval crossing zero, and CHAMP/TheoremQA shows no reliable overall routing benefit. Moreover, the large ALFWorld improvement includes an online state controller: this supports that intervention, but not independently the added selection value of SCS. Router and Always State have identical performance on its constructed mixture (Appendices C.2 and H).

  2. An important discrepancy leaves semantic verification reliability unresolved. In Appendix G.4, an independent Qwen3.5-27B auditor rejects all 100 sampled AppWorld contracts accepted by the original verifier. Disagreement does not establish which auditor is correct, but it leaves the semantic reliability of the verified artifacts without independent support. The 269 matched and 807 mismatched dispatch checks primarily test a deterministic type interface, rather than independently validate provenance, dependency completeness, or semantic correctness. The disagreement needs explanation and adjudication against explicit criteria through human or executable checks.

Questions for authors
  1. On natural skills without constructed Clean/Dirty or Static/State pairs, how much does the current four-dimensional diagnosis and typed routing add over always applying the same repair? How should the negative results in Appendix H and equality with Always State in Appendix C.2 be interpreted?

  2. Which checks or criteria cause the complete auditor disagreement on the 100 accepted AppWorld contracts? Can independent human adjudication or executable validation of disputed examples estimate the original verifier's false-acceptance rate?

  3. For ALFWorld/AppWorld, can SCS diagnosis and semantic verification be ablated while retaining the same online state controller and comparable execution budget? This would help separate improvements to the execution interface from the contributions of diagnosis and verification.

The paper contains substantial useful experimentation, and some source-preserving and task-binding repairs have clear benefits. However, these gains do not yet sufficiently establish the broader diagnostic and semantic-verification claims: natural-skill routing gains are limited, and independent auditing reveals severe disagreement. My concern is with these central claims rather than whether representation repair can help. I therefore lean toward weak rejection until they are better supported.

3 comments

W1 — Does diagnose-then-repair add value over Always on natural Skills?

Response. We added a direct comparison on natural Skills in CHAMP / TheoremQA. SCS and Always both reach 38/146 (26.03%), while the number of deployed repairs drops from 105 to 80 and answering tokens drop by 33.72%. In this study, the value of SCS is selective deployment, not higher final accuracy.

Setup. 78 CHAMP and 68 TheoremQA tasks, 146 tasks in total, with 23 Skills newly extracted from two training demonstrations each (disjoint from the evaluation tasks; distinct from the 98 benchmark-provided Skills and the earlier 23-Skill development audit in Appendix H.2). Qwen3.5-4B; we compare the original Skill, Always, SCS, a simple rule, and single-component repair.

MethodCHAMPTheoremQAOverallDeployed repairsIncorrect→Correct / Correct→Incorrect
Original Skill21/7812/6833/146 (22.60%)0—
Always24/7814/6838/146 (26.03%)1055 / 0
SCS Router25/7813/6838/146 (26.03%)806 / 1
SCS + source check25/7813/6838/146 (26.03%)636 / 1
Length rule24/7814/6838/146 (26.03%)1055 / 0
Parameter/variable binding only28/7815/6843/146 (29.45%)10510 / 0

Result. Making variable bindings explicit alone improves accuracy by 6.85 pp over the original Skill (33/146 → 43/146). SCS matches Always in accuracy with 25 fewer repairs; SCS + source check uses 42 fewer. The 95% CI of the SCS − Always accuracy difference is [−3.68, +2.88] pp. The two SCS policies reduce answering tokens by 33.72% / 37.34%; including diagnosis, extraction, and repair, total tokens increase by 25.23% / 19.83%.

W2 — Reliability of the AppWorld semantic verifier

Response. Among the 100 disputed contracts accepted by the original verifier and rejected by the independent auditor, a three-expert majority judges 98 acceptable. The paper's 269/269 and 807/807 checks validate the typed dispatch interface and are not used as evidence of semantic correctness. We also extended the AppWorld test population to compare strict verification directly with structure-only checks.

Setup. Three-expert adjudication of the 100 disputed contracts; AppWorld keeps the original 417 tasks and adds 168 tasks, comparing the two verification configurations with the same candidates and execution budget.

Human adjudicationResult
Original verifier / independent auditor acceptances100/100 / 0/100
Accepted by three-expert majority98/100
Rejected / undetermined2 / 0
Unanimous among three experts97/100
Fleiss' κ0.66
48 candidates additionally admitted by structure-only checks40 unacceptable / 8 acceptable
AppWorld metricOriginal 417Additional 168Combined 585
Strict verification success96/417 (23.0%)68/168 (40.5%)164/585 (28.0%)
Structure-only success100/417 (24.0%)46/168 (27.4%)146/585 (25.0%)
Strict − structure-only−1.0 pp+13.1 pp+3.1 pp
Paired wins/losses (strict vs. structure-only)2/628/630/12
Exact McNemar p0.2890.000200.0079

Result. Strict verification gives a significant positive gain on the additional 168 tasks and on the combined 585 tasks; on the original 417 tasks it shows no significant advantage. Human adjudication supports the original verifier's majority acceptance of the disputed contracts.

Q1 — How much does selective routing add over Always on natural Skills?

Response. In the new 146-task natural-Skill study, SCS and Always are both 38/146, while repairs drop from 105 to 80 (see W1). On the paper's natural SRA, SCS likewise mainly reduces harmful interventions rather than significantly improving accuracy.

Paper's natural SRA: 19 Skills, 5,928 task–seed inputs (transitions relative to the original native Skill, 5,224/5,928).

MetricAlways (source-preserving Overlay)SCS Router
Accuracy5,241/5,928 (88.41%)5,213/5,928 (87.94%)
Harmful interventions (Correct→Incorrect)12973 (−43%)
Incorrect→Correct14662
Online tokens11,397,1669,707,688 (−14.8%)

Additional setup. MedCalc uses the same 40 calculators with 1,600 new cases; Qwen3.5-4B; No repair, Always, a length rule, and SCS are compared with the same candidates.

MedCalc: 4B, Full sourceNo repairAlwaysLength ruleSCS Router
Accuracy735/1600 (45.94%)948/1600 (59.25%)807/1600 (50.44%)912/1600 (57.00%)
Incorrect→Correct / Correct→Incorrect—297 / 84115 / 43238 / 61
Candidate-generation tokens (deployment-demand accounting)031.08M31.08M22.67M

SCS exceeds the length rule by 6.56 pp (95% CI [+0.26, +12.79]); it is 2.25 pp below Always, while reducing harmful interventions by 27% and candidate-generation tokens by about 27.1%.

Full/Selected mixture: 1,600 cases × 2 representations = 3,200 inputs per model.

ModelNo repairAlwaysSCS RouterRouter − No repairRepair decisions / deployed
4B52.6%59.3%58.1%+5.5 pp36.6% / 34.2%
9B64.8%68.2%67.5%+2.7 pp36.6% / 34.2%
27B78.0%78.1%78.0%+0.0 pp0.0% / 0.0%

Appendix C.2. On the balanced Static/State mixture, SCS and Always State reach the same success counts (226/220/258 of 268 for 4B/9B/27B), but SCS repairs only the static inputs. This shows that SCS avoids redundant intervention; it does not show an additional accuracy gain from the Router.

Q2 — What causes the disagreement, and how does the original verifier actually perform?

Response. The independent auditor and the original verifier assume different runtime checks. Human adjudication (98/100 acceptable, 2/100 unacceptable) indicates that the independent auditor substantially over-rejects on this sample, while the original verifier is not error-free. Of the 48 candidates additionally admitted by structure-only checks, humans judge 40 unacceptable, supporting the filtering value of semantic checks.

In the paired 585-task AppWorld evaluation, strict verification improves success over structure-only checks by 3.1 pp (p = 0.0079); the effect direction differs between the two subsets (see W2). Human review checks source support, parameter binding, step dependencies, task coverage, and completion conditions, and permits source-supported runtime queries.

Q3 — With the online controller fixed, how much do SCS and semantic verification contribute?

Response. Most of the ALFWorld improvement comes from the observation-driven execution interface; the selection effects of SCS and the verifier are evaluated separately below.

Setup 1. Qwen3.5-4B, 100 tasks each from ALFWorld and AppWorld; all four arms share the same online controller and execution budget, toggling SCS and semantic verification (800 executions in total).

ConfigurationSCSSemantic verificationALFWorld success / 100AppWorld success / 100
Full✓✓7612
w/o SCS×✓7912
w/o semantic✓×7621
w/o both××7814

In this 100-task local ablation, ALFWorld success ranges over 76–79 across the four arms; on AppWorld, removing semantic auditing raises success from 12 to 21. This measures local component effects under a fixed controller and is a different experiment from the 417 + 168-task same-candidate verification comparison in W2; their denominators and conclusions should not be combined.

Setup 2. ALFWorld, 128 tasks per model, Qwen3.5-4B/9B; Guard, retry, and budget are unified, and only the state information shown to the executor changes.

ModelStatic + GuardCompletion progress + GuardProgress + search memory + GuardFull State + Guard
4B74/128 (57.8%)73/128 (57.0%)94/128 (73.4%)108/128 (84.4%)†
9B67/128 (52.3%)72/128 (56.3%)95/128 (74.2%)110/128 (85.9%)

Isolated gain of search memory (completion progress → completion progress + search memory): 4B +16.41 pp (95% CI [+7.81, +25.00]), 9B +17.97 pp (95% CI [+9.38, +26.56]).

† 4B Full State is the paper's State Machine run recounted on the same 128 tasks.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Looking Forward to Your Feedback (Reviewer o1B7)

Dear Reviewer o1B7, thank you again for your suggestions on evaluating routing on natural skills, investigating the AppWorld auditor disagreement, and isolating the contributions of diagnosis and verification. We would be grateful for your thoughts on whether our additional experiments and response answer your questions. If you feel we have addressed your concerns, we would greatly appreciate it if you would consider raising your rating accordingly.

Reviewer_AsbCOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies why agents fail to use skills that contain sufficient, correct knowledge. It proposes a four-dimensional Skill Cleanliness Score (SCS) and Verified Skill Restoration (VSR), which selects evidence, repairs dependencies and task bindings, or exposes execution progress. Results support several targeted repairs, especially task binding in ScienceWorld and online state tracking in ALFWorld.

The targeted repairs are useful and supported by substantial experiments. My main reservation is that the distinctive diagnosis-and-verification contribution remains less convincing than the underlying execution improvements. Stronger evidence for selective routing on natural skills and a resolution of the verifier disagreement would materially improve the case for acceptance.

Critical strengths

The ScienceWorld comparison is well controlled: Raw Overlay and VSR share the source library and execution gate, isolating verified task binding. Improvements of 4.8–9.3 percentage points across seven executors provide useful evidence that this intervention transfers.

The ablations go beyond comparing against an untreated baseline. Static contracts, source removal, token-matched inputs, and online state representations help distinguish evidence selection from execution support.

The appendix reports negative results, compilation costs, family-level uncertainty, and verifier disagreement. This transparency makes the contribution easier to assess.

Critical weaknesses

The value of selective diagnosis is not established beyond the repairs themselves. In MedCalc, always selecting evidence outperforms SCS routing; in ALFWorld, routing matches always using the State representation. The natural-skill evaluations in Appendix H show no reliable routing benefit. These results support particular representation changes, but leave unclear whether SCS can identify when intervention is useful on unfamiliar skills. This is consequential because diagnosis-guided restoration is a central contribution. A comparison against always-repair and simple heuristic routing, using identical candidate repairs and accounting for cost and harmful interventions, would directly address this gap.

The reliability of verification remains unresolved. In Appendix G.4, an independent auditor rejects all 100 sampled AppWorld contracts accepted by the original verifier. This disagreement does not establish which auditor is correct, but it leaves the acceptance criterion without convincing independent validation. The structure-only variant also achieves slightly higher full-set success, although the difference is not significant. Since verification is central to the justification for deploying repairs, human adjudication of disputed contracts and a controlled comparison on the same task population are needed to establish what protection it provides.

Questions for authors

On naturally occurring skills, when does typed SCS routing improve accuracy or cost over simply applying the corresponding repair whenever applicable?

What explains the complete AppWorld auditor disagreement? Could human adjudication of a small sample distinguish verifier errors from differences in acceptance criteria?

How much of the ALFWorld gain remains with guards and retry budgets held constant while only observation-driven progress tracking changes?

Does evidence-selection verification preserve every previously supported obligation, or only aggregate coverage?

4 comments

W1 — Value of selective diagnosis beyond the repairs

Response. With identical candidate repairs, the SCS Router exceeds a length heuristic by 6.56 pp (95% CI [+0.26, +12.79]). It is 2.25 pp below Always, while reducing harmful interventions by 27% and candidate-generation tokens by 27.1%. The value of SCS is therefore an accuracy–risk–cost trade-off, rather than uniformly higher accuracy than Always.

Setup. The original 800-question MedCalc test set is unchanged. We add 1,600 new cases covering 40 calculators. All policies share the same candidate repairs; routing is decided at the calculator-Skill level. Full is the original Skill and Selected contains task-relevant verbatim source units (Appendix B.1).

MedCalc: Qwen3.5-4B, Full source, 1,600 cases. Incorrect→Correct / Correct→Incorrect are relative to No repair.

PolicyAccuracyIncorrect→CorrectCorrect→IncorrectCandidate-generation tokens
No repair735/1600 (45.94%)——0
Always948/1600 (59.25%)2978431.08M
Length heuristic807/1600 (50.44%)1154331.08M
SCS Router912/1600 (57.00%)2386122.67M

Full/Selected mixture: 3,200 inputs per model.

ModelNo repairAlwaysSCS RouterRouter − No repairRepair decisions / deployed
4B52.6%59.3%58.1%+5.5 pp36.6% / 34.2%
9B64.8%68.2%67.5%+2.7 pp36.6% / 34.2%
27B78.0%78.1%78.0%+0.0 pp0.0% / 0.0%

W2 — Reliability of AppWorld verification

Response. The original verifier and the independent auditor disagree on all 100 sampled accepted contracts, so we added human expert adjudication.

Human adjudication of the 100 disputed contracts

MetricResult
Original verifier / independent auditor acceptances100/100 / 0/100 (paper, Appendix G.4)
Accepted by three-expert majority98/100
Rejected / undetermined2 / 0
Unanimous among three experts97/100
Fleiss' κ0.66
Rejection type: unsupported by source / parameter error / missing dependency / insufficient coverage0 / 2 / 0 / 0

Votes: 95 unanimous acceptances, 3 two-to-one acceptances, 2 unanimous rejections; 98 contracts are accepted by majority, with Fleiss' κ ≈ 0.66.

Strict vs. structure-only verification (same candidates, same budget)

MetricOriginal 417 tasksAdditional 168 tasksCombined 585 tasks
Strict verification success96/417 (23.0%)68/168 (40.5%)164/585 (28.0%)
Structure-only success100/417 (24.0%)46/168 (27.4%)146/585 (25.0%)
Strict − structure-only−1.0 pp+13.1 pp+3.1 pp
Paired wins/losses (strict vs. structure-only)2/628/630/12
Exact McNemar p0.2890.000200.0079

We extended the AppWorld test population and compared strict verification (semantic auditing + structural checks) with structure-only checks under the same candidates and budget. On the additional 168 tasks, strict verification achieves significantly higher success than structure-only checks. Among the 48 candidates additionally admitted by structure-only checks, human review judges 40 unacceptable and 8 acceptable, showing that semantic auditing filters candidates that pass the structural checks.

Q1 — When does typed SCS routing beat always applying the repair on natural Skills?

Response. SCS is most useful when a repair carries a risk of negative transfer or when candidate generation is costly. In the new MedCalc comparison, Correct→Incorrect falls from 84 to 61 and candidate-generation tokens fall by 27.1%, at 2.25 pp lower accuracy than Always.

Q2 — What explains the complete AppWorld auditor disagreement?

Response. Two factors coexist: (1) the two auditors make different assumptions about what the shared executor checks at runtime; (2) the original verifier misses some cases (e.g., nonexistent return fields, incorrect login parameters). Human adjudication accepts 98/100 disputed contracts; the category breakdown and agreement statistics are in W2. We will add the specific contracts, the corresponding API schemas, and the rejection reasons to the revision.

Q3 — ALFWorld gain with guards and retry budgets fixed

Response. With Guard, retries, and action budget held constant and only the state exposed to the executor varied, the main gain comes from observation-driven search memory (the paper's negative search evidence).

The Static + Guard condition below uses a different run protocol from the Static Contract in Table 13. The new runs unify Guard, retry, internal state tracking, and execution budget, and use 128 test tasks (one task per ALFWorld family reserved for development checks).

New component ablation on the same 128 tasks

ModelStatic + GuardCompletion progress + GuardProgress + search memory + GuardFull State + Guard
4B74/128 (57.8%)73/128 (57.0%)94/128 (73.4%)108/128 (84.4%)†
9B67/128 (52.3%)72/128 (56.3%)95/128 (74.2%)110/128 (85.9%)
Change4B9B
Static → progress + search memory+15.63 pp+21.88 pp
Completion progress → + search memory+16.41 pp (CI [+7.81, +25.00])+17.97 pp (CI [+9.38, +26.56])
Static → completion progress−0.78 pp+3.91 pp

† 4B Full State is the paper's State Machine run recounted on the same 128 tasks.

Q4 — Does evidence-selection verification preserve each obligation or only aggregate coverage?

Response. Eq. 3 guarantees that aggregate Coverage over the same extracted obligations does not decrease; it does not strictly guarantee that every previously supported obligation keeps its evidence (Appendix L.2). We will state this limitation in the main text and list pointwise coverage verification as future work.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Looking Forward to Your Feedback (Reviewer AsbC)

Dear Reviewer AsbC, thank you again for your detailed questions about the value of selective routing, the reliability of verification, and the contribution of progress tracking. We would particularly value your assessment of whether the additional routing, human adjudication, and ablation results address the concerns you raised. If your schedule permits, we would appreciate any feedback while the discussion is open, so we have a chance to respond to any remaining questions. We look forward to continuing the discussion.

I thank the authors for their detailed response. I appreciate the human adjudacation and component ablation, as well as the acknowledgement of aggregate-coverage limitation in Q4. However, my primary concern with W1 remains. I still believe the natural-skill results in Appendix H were not directly answered. Additionally, the Medcalc router has the same proportion of Always repairs and harmful flips, suggesting that the router is simply intervening less often. I would be interested to see a random-routing baseline at the same repair rate.

For W2, the advantage of strict verification may come from the newly added AppWorld tasks rather than the original task list. How were these new tasks chosen? And why do they exhibit such different behaviors?

For Q3, the guarded Static condition performs better than the reported static baselines, indicating that guards and retries are responsible for a substantial portion of the original gain.

Finally, I recognize that I have not left much time for the authors to respond. I would welcome any textual response to the stated questions if there is insufficient time to run the experiments.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.