- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies two problems in using existing agent skills: extracting task-relevant knowledge and converting the available knowledge into executable actions. It introduces Skill Uncleanliness to describe organizational barriers, Skill Cleanliness Score (SCS) to diagnose them across Relevance, Dependency, Grounding, and Progress, and Verified Skill Restoration (VSR) to apply targeted repairs with source-support and structural checks. Experiments across multiple environments and model families show that targeted skill restoration can improve task success, including gains of 4.8–9.3 percentage points over raw demonstration overlays on ScienceWorld and substantial improvements for smaller models on ALFWorld.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a practical problem: helping agents make better use of knowledge already available in existing skills. It illustrates the problem through concrete examples and introduces four clear diagnostic dimensions to characterize barriers between available knowledge and executable actions.
- The experiments provide empirical evidence that targeted skill restoration can improve task success. On ScienceWorld, it consistently outperforms raw demonstration overlays across seven executors from four model families. ALFWorld also shows gains from progress restoration across all three evaluated model sizes.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper presents SCS and VSR largely through concepts and formal conditions, with insufficient detail on how key steps are implemented and connected. In particular, semantic parsing and scoring procedures, the respective roles of LLMs and deterministic rules, and how diagnostic outputs guide concrete repairs are not clearly specified in the main text.
- The diagnostic validity of SCS remains insufficiently established, and the theoretical analysis does not link its scores to actual execution recoverability. The main experiments primarily demonstrate the effectiveness of specific repairs. Although controlled defect-detection and routing results are reported, evidence remains limited that SCS reliably identifies execution barriers or that SCS-based repair selection provides consistent gains over always applying the same repair strategy under matched execution settings.
Questions for authors
- Please describe how each stage of the method is implemented. Which steps in semantic parsing, SCS computation, defect localization, repair generation, and verification are performed by LLMs, and which use deterministic rules? What information is passed between these stages, and how do the diagnostic outputs determine the repair operations?
- What motivates the SCS scoring rules and weights, and how do these metrics relate to the conditional recovery probabilities in the theoretical analysis? Beyond distinguishing predefined Clean/Dirty and Static/State conditions, is there evidence that SCS accurately identifies execution barriers in natural skills and predicts the benefit of corresponding repairs?
- Recent work such as SkillTracer (Li et al., 2026) and SkillRevise (Liu et al., 2026) already uses execution evidence to diagnose skill failures and guide targeted revisions. How does SCS/VSR differ from these approaches in its diagnostic evidence, repair mechanisms, and validation criteria? What evidence from the current experiments supports these advantages, taking differences in execution feedback and computational budgets into account? [1] Yuyang Li, Yiran Dou, Jie-Jing Shao, Yueming Lyu, Ivor Tsang, and Haiyan Yin. SkillTracer: Structural failure attribution and refinement of agentic skills in long-horizon web tasks. In Proceedings of the 32nd ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining, 2026. [2] Yuxuan Liu, Zhaochen Su, Lingyun Xie, Yuhao Zhang, Qing Zong, Jiahe Guo, Zhongwei Xie, Yiyan Ji, Yauwai Yim, Hongyu Luo, Xiyu Ren, Chenyu Ruan, Haoran Li, and Yangqiu Song. SkillRevise: Improving LLM-authored agent skills via trace-conditioned skill revision. Findings of EMNLP, 2026.
- Which components primarily account for the gains on ALFWorld? Table 3 already includes static-representation and initial-token-matched controls, but State simultaneously introduces progress updates, executable-step guidance, and safeguards against repeated actions. Can the contributions of these runtime components be further distinguished, and can the role of SCS-based selection be explained?
- What measurable reliability benefits does semantic verification provide? Figure 4(b) already reports configurations involving structural verification and semantic auditing, but acceptance coverage and iterative repair settings also vary. With the same candidates and repair budget, can the authors show what additional errors semantic verification identifies and how accepting or rejecting these candidates affects execution outcomes?
- How can failures caused by organizational barriers be distinguished from those caused by missing or incorrect knowledge? For natural skills, how can their knowledge be independently confirmed to be correct and sufficient to complete the task? Please explain how the evaluation distinguishes these two types of failure and thereby defines the scope of the execution-recoverability explanation.
4 comments
Q1 — How does diagnosis determine the concrete repair?
Response. SCS outputs source-linked defect certificates. Relevance selects the relevant evidence; Dependency makes producer→consumer links explicit; Grounding binds and disambiguates parameters; Progress maintains completion state and ready steps from environment observations. Candidates are deployed after source, structural, and (where applicable) semantic checks, and otherwise fall back to the source.
Q2 — How do SCS scores and weights relate to the theoretical recovery probabilities?
Response. SCS measures the structural recovery burden of executable relations; it does not directly estimate the conditional recovery probabilities in the theory.
| Dimension | Scoring rule |
|---|---|
| R · Relevance | Harmonic mean of obligation coverage and relevant evidence precision |
| D · Dependency | Inverse recovery depth of required dependencies |
| G · Grounding | Inverse of the number of source-supported candidate bindings |
| P · Progress | Step checks, termination, online state, and repeat guards |
The overall score is a weighted geometric mean over applicable dimensions (equal weights by default). Within Progress, weights are 0.40 step, 0.25 termination, 0.25 online state, and 0.10 guard; on 24 ALFWorld diagnostic manifests, ±20% weight perturbations leave every typed dispatch decision unchanged. The scores are not numerically calibrated to the theoretical probabilities (Appendix M).
Q3 — Differences from SkillTracer/SkillRevise and budget control
Response. SkillTracer/SkillRevise focus on revision from trajectories and execution feedback; SCS/VSR diagnoses the source Skill and task and restores dependency, binding, and progress relations.
Setup. ALFWorld, 128 tasks, Qwen3.5-9B; with the same execution budget we compare one-shot rewriting, trajectory-conditioned revision, and VSR Full State.
| Method | Success | Online tokens | Rewriting tokens | Feedback-trajectory tokens |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| One-shot generic rewrite | 61/128 (47.7%) | 30.870M | 0.041M | 0 |
| Trajectory-conditioned revision | 70/128 (54.7%) | 29.564M | 0.230M | 32.545M |
| VSR Full State | 110/128 (85.9%) | 21.491M | 0 | 0 |
Full State improves over the two baselines by +38.28 pp (95% CI [+29.69, +46.88]) and +31.25 pp (95% CI [+22.66, +40.62]).
Q4 — Which online components account for the ALFWorld gains?
Response. With Guard, retry, and run budget fixed, the main gains come from observation-driven search memory and executable-step guidance.
Setup. ALFWorld, 128 tasks per model, Qwen3.5-4B/9B; Guard, retry, and budget are fixed while completion progress, search memory, and step guidance are ablated.
| Model | Static + Guard | Completion progress + Guard | Progress + search memory + Guard | Full State + Guard |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4B | 74/128 (57.8%) | 73/128 (57.0%) | 94/128 (73.4%) | 108/128 (84.4%)† |
| 9B | 67/128 (52.3%) | 72/128 (56.3%) | 95/128 (74.2%) | 110/128 (85.9%) |
| Change | 4B | 9B |
|---|---|---|
| Static → progress + search memory | +15.63 pp | +21.88 pp |
| Completion progress only → + search memory | +16.41 pp (CI [+7.81, +25.00]) | +17.97 pp (CI [+9.38, +26.56]) |
| Static → completion progress only | −0.78 pp | +3.91 pp |
Additional controls (9B, 128 tasks): completion progress + step guidance + Guard: 82/128; Full State without Guard: 84/128.
† 4B Full State is the paper's State Machine run recounted on the same 128 tasks.
Q5 — What protection does semantic verification provide with the same candidates and budget?
Response. On the additional AppWorld tasks, strict verification outperforms structure-only verification; across all 585 tasks the gain is +3.1 pp (p = 0.0079). Human review further separates acceptance correctness from execution success.
Setup. AppWorld, the paper's 417 tasks plus 168 new tasks, 585 in total; with the same candidates and budget we compare strict semantic verification and structure-only verification.
| Metric | Original 417 | Additional 168 | Combined 585 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strict verification success | 96/417 (23.0%) | 68/168 (40.5%) | 164/585 (28.0%) |
| Structure-only success | 100/417 (24.0%) | 46/168 (27.4%) | 146/585 (25.0%) |
| Strict − structure-only | −1.0 pp | +13.1 pp | +3.1 pp |
| Paired wins/losses (strict vs. structure-only) | 2/6 | 28/6 | 30/12 |
| Exact McNemar p | 0.289 | 0.00020 | 0.0079 |
For the 100 disputed contracts accepted by the original verifier and rejected by the independent auditor, a three-expert majority judges 98/100 acceptable and 2/100 unacceptable (unanimous on 97/100; Fleiss' κ = 0.66). Of the 48 candidates additionally admitted by structure-only checks on the original 417 tasks, humans judge 40 unacceptable and 8 acceptable. The two samples analyze, respectively, the auditor disagreement and the filtering effect of semantic checks on structurally valid candidates.
Q6 — Distinguishing organizational barriers from missing or incorrect knowledge
Response. We first determine whether the Skill's knowledge is correct and sufficient for the task. If execution improves when the knowledge content is fixed and only the organization of dependencies changes, this supports an organizational-barrier explanation; if a necessary fact is missing or a rule is incorrect, the failure is attributed to knowledge; when evidence is insufficient, the cause is marked undetermined.
Setup. 64 closed-graph tasks; with knowledge and token count held fixed, we compare shuffled and dependency-ordered relations, and simulate missing knowledge by deleting a key fact.
| Condition | Success |
|---|---|
| Shuffled relations | 19/64 (29.7%) |
| Dependency-ordered | 29/64 (45.3%) |
| Gain from organizational repair | +15.63 pp (95% CI [+4.69, +26.56]) |
A symbolic solver confirms that deleting the terminal fact makes the answer non-unique, separating organizational barriers from missing knowledge in this construction.
Looking Forward to Your Feedback (Reviewer 92nF)
Dear Reviewer 92nF, thank you again for your suggestions on the implementation of SCS and VSR, the diagnostic validity of SCS on natural skills, and the roles of runtime guidance and semantic verification. We would be grateful for your thoughts on whether our additional experiments and clarifications answer your questions. If you feel we have addressed your concerns, we would greatly appreciate it if you would consider raising your rating accordingly. We look forward to hearing from you.
W1 — How are SCS/VSR implemented, and how do the stages pass information?
Response. The pipeline is LLM semantic extraction → deterministic SCS scoring → typed repair → verified deployment.
Type mapping: Relevance → evidence selection; Dependency → producer–consumer links; Grounding → parameter binding; Progress → observation-driven progress. The paper reports that 269/269 matched-type dispatches pass and 807/807 wrong-type dispatches are rejected (Appendix G.4).
W2 — Does SCS diagnosis and selective repair actually help?
Response. With shared candidate repairs, SCS exceeds a length heuristic by 6.56 pp (95% CI [+0.26, +12.79]); it is 2.25 pp below Always, while reducing harmful interventions by 27% and candidate-compilation tokens by about 27.1%. Its value is mainly an accuracy–risk–cost trade-off.
Setup. MedCalc under the paper's protocol, with 1,600 new cases (40 calculators); candidates are fixed, comparing No repair, Always, a length heuristic, and the SCS Router.
MedCalc: Qwen3.5-4B, Full source, 1,600 cases
Full/Selected mixture: 1,600 cases × 2 representations = 3,200 inputs per model.