- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the timely problem of watermark robustness against generative image editing. From an information bottleneck perspective, the authors propose WaterVIB, a plug-in module that reduces dependence on host-image information while preserving watermark messages. Experiments across multiple watermarking frameworks demonstrate encouraging improvements.
Critical strengths
Clear motivation and insightful analysis. The authors identify an important problem through well-designed empirical analyses and provide a principled information-theoretic formulation.
Practical significance and applicability. Robustness against generative editing is increasingly important. The proposed plug-in module is easy to integrate into existing watermarking frameworks and demonstrates promising improvements.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper argues that host-image dependence weakens watermark robustness (Section 3), but does not directly examine whether WaterVIB also reduces host dependence in watermark embedding. A useful experiment would be to embed the same message into two different host images, extract their watermark residuals, and swap these residuals between the two hosts. The authors should compare decoding performance before and after swapping, both with and without generative editing, using the original backbone and WaterVIB. If WaterVIB also reduces embedding-level host dependence, it should exhibit better cross-host transferability. This would help clarify the scope of the proposed mechanism.
-
Table 1 analyzes only HiDDeN and EditGuard, with HiDDeN being a relatively early watermarking framework. Although Table 3 evaluates five backbones, the proposed mechanism may behave differently on more recent architectures. Additional experiments on CIN [1], Lightweight-Mark [2], and VideoSeal [3] would strengthen the plug-and-play claim.
-
Diffusion-based editing introduces distortions through both VAE reconstruction and the diffusion noising-denoising process. However, the main global purification experiments use an extremely low strength of 0.002 (Appendix G.1). Table 3 also reports nearly identical BER under SD1.5 purification (48.983%) and VAE reconstruction (48.979%) for EditGuard. This raises concerns that the improvements primarily reflect VAE reconstruction robustness rather than robustness to diffusion denoising. Appendix G.3 further shows that the gains become substantially smaller under stronger purification.
-
Despite focusing on generative-editing robustness, the paper lacks direct comparisons with specialized diffusion-erasure-robust watermarking methods, such as DERO [4]. Such comparisons are necessary to better establish the competitiveness of WaterVIB.
[1] Ma et al. "Towards Blind Watermarking: Combining Invertible and Non-invertible Mechanisms" (CIN). 2022. https://arxiv.org/abs/2212.12678
[2] Qiu et al. "Lightweight-Mark: Rethinking Deep Learning-Based Watermarking." ICML, 2025. https://proceedings.mlr.press/v267/qiu25b.html
[3] Fernandez et al. "Video Seal: Open and Efficient Video Watermarking." 2024. https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.09492
[4] Fang et al. "DERO: Diffusion-Model-Erasure Robust Watermarking." ACM Multimedia, 2024. https://doi.org/10.1145/3664647.3681220
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.
Response to Reviewer SWhn
Thank you for recognizing the practical motivation and modular design. Following your suggestion, we swapped watermarks between images to test how much an embedded watermark depends on its original image.
Q1/W1 Swapping watermarks across images
Both models read a watermark more accurately on the image it was written into. After VAE reconstruction, WaterVIB recovers more complete messages on that image; after a swap, neither model consistently recovers more. Holding the watermark fixed isolates the effect of texture: amplifying texture causes a smaller BER increase with WaterVIB.
Table 1. 32 pairs, same 100-bit message within each pair, residuals swapped both ways, editing noise fixed. Each cell: BER (%) / exact messages out of 64.
Table 1b. Texture intervention with the watermark fixed. A positive difference means a smaller BER penalty for WaterVIB.
Q2/W2 CIN and VideoSeal
With the same decoder, adding KL lets CIN recover more complete messages after VAE reconstruction and milder diffusion. VideoSeal also makes fewer bit errors and detects more registered watermarks.
Table 2. Released CIN (30 bits) and VideoSeal (256 bits). Control: same Gaussian head with KL off. BER and exact recovery are three-seed means (%) ± sample variances (pp²). VideoSeal uses the same detection threshold for both arms.
Q3/W3 VAE reconstruction and diffusion denoising
At the original strength of 0.002, the image change comes mainly from VAE reconstruction. WaterVIB also lowers BER on both backbones at all three multistep SD1.5 strengths and under CtrlRegen+. Under CtrlRegen, BER falls on VINE-R and rises slightly on EditGuard.
Table 3. Frozen original and submitted systems read their own 100-bit messages. 128 images per backbone, embedding MSE matched per image. Submitted strength: 0.002. The three SD1.5 settings below use 8, 16 and 26 denoiser calls.
Q4/W4 Comparison with DERO
We could not find an official release of DERO’s code or model weights, so we did not include a direct comparison.