- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes RELAY, which predicts cellular perturbation responses from related control–perturbed population pairs rather than explicit perturbation, cell-type, or donor values. The method is evaluated on chemical, genetic, and cytokine datasets under unseen-combination and unseen-variable-value settings.
Critical strengths
RELAY uses measured control–perturbed responses as inference-time context and predicts target-cell expression changes through cross-attention, yielding an architecture that is well aligned with the task. The results are broadly consistent across four datasets, and the ablations of relation embeddings, state embeddings, and context composition support that the model uses the shared relations between context and target conditions.
Critical weaknesses
1.The novelty of relational modeling is not fully clear. Prior context-based methods also transfer information from observed control–perturbed pairs. RELAY adds shared-variable relation embeddings to these pairs, but its benefit beyond standard context conditioning or a simple match-mask embedding is not isolated.
2.The comparison lacks an explicit residual-effect baseline. Except for STATE, the other learned baselines are generative or transport-based. A matched deterministic residual predictor, such as GEARS on the genetic benchmark, would help determine whether RELAY’s gains arise from relational context or from predicting perturbation effects as residuals.
Questions for authors
1.Equations (6)–(8) add shared-variable-type embeddings to context tokens. How does this differ from standard variable-type or segment embeddings? A simpler matched conditional-encoding baseline using the same shared-variable mask would help establish the value of the relational design.
2.The role of the paired-population encoder is unclear. Since control and perturbed cells are unpaired, why does jointly encoding their population summaries represent a perturbation-induced transition rather than a generic joint representation?
3.Could the authors clarify how context is obtained and introduced in Setting 2, and whether all context-based baselines use the same context and information budget?
4.Could the authors add matched Setting 2 ablations across multiple datasets, such as removing relation embeddings, state embeddings, or using a generic context encoder?
5.Figure 4 shows diminishing but still positive gains as increases. Is the maximum context size constrained by the number of available conditions? Could the authors explicitly compare different allocations under a fixed total context budget?