- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
Flash-WAM accelerates world-action models through modality-aware consistency distillation. It retains the LCM parameterization for video while using a clean-sample parameterization for actions to reduce low-noise gradient attenuation. Experiments on LingBot-VA and Motus, simulation benchmarks, and a real robot demonstrate substantial inference acceleration while retaining much of the teacher’s control performance.
Critical strengths
1,The method addresses a practical bottleneck with a simple modification that requires no architectural changes. 2,The reported speed–accuracy trade-off is promising, reaching 23.3× acceleration on LingBot-VA. 3,Evaluation across two WAM architectures, two simulation benchmarks, and real hardware supports practical relevance.
Critical weaknesses
1,The mechanism is not fully isolated. Proposition 1 characterizes a scalar coefficient, rather than the complete optimization dynamics. Shared linear parameterization and noise-dependent loss reweighting are important missing controls.
2,Baseline fairness needs clarification. DMD2 uses four-step training rollouts and updates its student every five iterations, raising questions about convergence and alignment with one-/two-step evaluation.
3,The revision would benefit from discussing the following complementary approaches:From Articulated Kinematics to Routed Visual Control for Action-Conditioned Surgical Video Generation. Its modality routing and budgeted execution offer a relevant perspective on efficient controllable generation. Please discuss how reducing computation within a denoising step relates to Flash-WAM’s reduction in denoising steps, and whether the approaches could be combined. ORV: 4D Occupancy-centric Robot Video Generation. This provides useful context for evaluating whether Flash-WAM preserves control alignment and useful visual predictions after distillation.
4, Qualitative examples alone do not establish that accelerated generation retains temporal consistency and agreement with predicted actions.
5,Confidence intervals are missing, despite only 20 real-world trials per task and relatively small gains over some stronger baselines, such as video-only LCM with regularization at 1v/2a.
Questions for authors
1,Can the authors compare the proposed design against using the linear parameterization for both modalities and against noise-reweighted LCM? Gradient norms and prediction errors across noise levels would help substantiate the proposed explanation.
2,Does the DMD2 training budget of 2,000 steps count critic iterations or student updates? Please clarify the effective optimization budget and evaluate training rollouts matched to the target inference steps.
3,Please report quantitative video fidelity and action–video consistency, together with end-to-end robot latency, including observation processing and action-chunk scheduling.
4,Please reconcile the teacher results in Tables 1 and 4: 91.64/90.86 versus 92.93/91.55 on Clean/Randomized splits. The 1v/2a naive joint LCM Randomized result also differs between these tables: 22.07 versus 20.08.
7 comments
W2 + Q2: DMD2 training
We thank the reviewer for raising these points and address each of them below.
Rollout steps in training versus inference. To align the training rollout exactly with one-step inference, we implemented DMD2 with a one-step rollout, so that the student is trained at exactly the noise level used for one-step sampling. All other settings are unchanged, including the flow-matching loss on the action stream, and we report it after 2,000, 4,000 and 6,000 steps (400, 800 and 1,200 student updates). Even with this exact alignment, DMD2 does not close the gap and stays below Flash-WAM on both splits at every checkpoint. Success rates on the 10-task subset (50 trials per task) are below.
| Method | Training steps | Clean 1v/1a | Randomized 1v/1a |
|---|---|---|---|
| DMD2 baseline with one-step rollout | 2,000 | 71.0 | 60.8 |
| DMD2 baseline with one-step rollout | 4,000 | 70.2 | 61.4 |
| DMD2 baseline with one-step rollout | 6,000 | 65.6 | 59.0 |
| Flash-WAM | 2,000 | 81.4 | 70.8 |
Longer training does not narrow the gap either, since the baseline gains at most 0.6 points from 2,000 to 4,000 steps and falls below its 2,000-step result at 6,000 steps, which shows the gap comes from the distillation objective, not from the rollout length or the training budget.
Training budget and convergence. Each training step updates the critic, and the student is updated at every fifth step, so 2,000 steps correspond to 2,000 critic updates and 400 student updates. The number of student updates is not directly comparable between DMD and consistency distillation, since the two methods use entirely different training signals and update rules. To check whether DMD2 had converged, we continued training the DMD2 baseline of the paper to 6,000 steps. As shown in the above table, further training did not improve the result.
Updating the student every five iterations. DMD training is generally unstable, because the critic must keep track of the student's distribution for the distribution-matching gradient to remain informative. In our initial runs with a 1:1 update ratio, the student moved ahead of the critic within the first iterations and the DMD loss signal collapsed. We therefore followed the DMD hyperparameters of Helios [1], which update the student once every five critic updates. With this ratio, the student and the critic learned in step and training converged stably.
[1] Helios: Real Real-Time Long Video Generation Model, Yuan et. al.
W3: related work
We thank the reviewer for suggesting these two papers. KVLR (Li et al., 2026) reduces the computation within each denoising step by routing control signals and executing under a compute budget, whereas Flash-WAM reduces the number of denoising steps. The two are complementary and can be combined. Savings within a step also become relatively more important once inference uses only one or two steps, because these forward passes and observation processing then make up most of the latency per chunk (W4). ORV (Yang et al., 2026) generates robot videos conditioned on 4D occupancy aligned with actions. Its focus on control alignment relates directly to the action–video consistency we now report under W4 response. In the revision, we discuss both papers in the Appendix, next to the video fidelity and action–video consistency results reported under W4.
We thank the reviewer for the detailed review and the constructive suggestions, which we address below.
W1 + Q1: isolating the mechanism
We agree that the shared linear parameterization and the noise-dependent loss reweighting are informative controls, and we thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We therefore added both controls, together with direct measurements of the gradient each stream receives and of its prediction error across noise levels. In short, Flash-WAM outperforms both controls, and reweighting the loss recovers almost none of the gap.
Controls. All variants use the same recipe and training budget (2,000 steps) and differ only in the consistency functions. We evaluated them on a 10-task RoboTwin subset.
Reweighting the standard function's action loss so that its gradient matches ours at every noise level does not recover performance. Reweighting changes how strongly each noise level is fit, but not what the network is fit to. Under the standard function, the learned velocity does not yield the clean-sample estimate that the few-step sampler uses at inference, as the prediction errors below show. The action function must therefore both scale linearly near zero noise and coincide with the clean-sample estimate. The shared linear parameterization also satisfies both conditions on the action stream and recovers most of the gap. Keeping the standard function for the video stream, as Flash-WAM does, performs better still at both budgets.
Gradient norms across noise levels. We set every frame of one stream to noise level σ, build the consistency target exactly as in training, and measure the norm of the gradient of that stream's loss with respect to the model parameters. The table below reports the action stream at the start of distillation, where both functions share the same weights.
The gradient of the standard function vanishes quadratically as σ→0 and is 58× smaller than ours at σ=0.01, while ours decreases only linearly. The video stream is trained mostly at high noise, where the standard function already provides a large gradient.
Prediction errors across noise levels. Per the reviewer's request, we also measure the mean distance between the model's clean action estimate and the distillation target at each noise level, before and after distillation.
Under the standard function, the action estimate at low noise drifts 10–40× away from the target during distillation, while ours stays at its initial accuracy.